Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-v9fdk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T07:51:18.542Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

When Garibaldi went to Azerbaijan: A Study of British Perceptions of the Iranian Constitutional Revolution, Part I, 1906–07

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2022

Savka Andic
Savka Andic*
Affiliation:
Modern Middle Eastern Studies, St. Antony's College, University of Oxford
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In the early years of the twentieth century, a wave of constitutional revolutions swept over the developing world, attracting the attention of European observers. One of these was the Iranian Constitutional Revolution of 1906–11. British perceptions of this “brave new world” in Iran were more nuanced and diverse than one would expect for this era, commonly portrayed as a time of jingoism and rampant “Orientalist” racism. This study identifies four broad perspectives which shaped British perceptions: the imperialist, Europeanist, liberal idealist and local pragmatist. Within the context of these perspectives, British perceptions were further shaped by different understandings of Iran—influenced by a specifically Iranian-flavored literary Orientalism, Aryanism and history—and by understandings of what constituted an authentic reform or revolutionary movement.

Type
Articles
Information
Iranian Studies , Volume 45 , Issue 5 , September 2012 , pp. 597 - 618
Copyright
Copyright © The International Society for Iranian Studies 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

In October 2012, Dr Mansour Bonakdarian brought charges of academic misconduct against the author of this article. For full details of the report into these allegations by the Ad Hoc Committee of the International Society for Iranian Studies, and a response to the report by Savka Andic, see http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00210862.2013.780803.

References

1 Sohrabi, Nader, “Historicizing Revolutions: Constitutional Revolutions in the Ottoman Empire, Iran and Russia, 1905–1908,” American Journal of Sociology, 100, no. 6 (May 1995): 1383–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 I have delimited the time period to be examined in this study from January 1906 to July 1909, which corresponds roughly to the beginning of the first major agitations in late 1905 which culminated in the demand for constitutional government and the abdication of Muhammad ᶜAli Shah in July 1909.

3 Afary, Janet, The Iranian Constitutional Revolution, 1906–11: Grassroots Democracy, Social Democracy and the Origins of Feminism (New York, 1996), 133Google Scholar.

4 McLean, David, Britain and her Buffer State: The Collapse of the Persian Empire, 1890–1914 (London, 1979), 37–50Google Scholar.

5 Members of the Liberal Party, which was in power from 1906 to 1910.

6 Support for liberal nationalism around the globe flourished during the Edwardian era among many British Liberal and “new” Left (Labour, Socialist) foreign policy critics. See Gott, Richard, “Little Englanders,” Patriotism: the Making and Unmaking of British National Identity. Vol. 1, History and Politics (New York, 1989), 90–102Google Scholar.

7 Said, Edward W., Orientalism: Western Conceptions of the Orient (London, 1978), 206–08Google Scholar.

8 Javadi, Hasan, Persian Literary Influence on English Literature: with Special Reference to the Nineteenth Century (Costa Mesa, CA, 2005), 129–30Google Scholar.

9 Edmund Bosworth, C. “Edward Granville Browne: 1862–1926,” A Century of British Orientalists, 1902–2001 (Oxford, 2001), 76Google Scholar.

10 Javadi, Persian Literary Influence, 184.

11 Ballantyne, Tony, Orientalism and Race: Aryanism in the British Empire (New York, 2002), 27–30, 48CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Browne, E.G., A Year Amongst the Persians: Impressions as to the Life, Character and Thought of the People of Persia (London, 1950; originally published 1893), 133–34Google Scholar.

13 Curzon, G.N., Persia and the Persian Question, 2 vols. (London, 1892), 7Google Scholar.

14 Keddie, Nikki, Iran: Religion, Politics and Society (London, 1980), 53Google Scholar.

15 Denis Wright, “Grant Duff, Sir Evelyn Mountstuart,” Encyclopaedia Iranica Online Edition, 15 December 2002, http://www.iranica.com/articles/grant-duff.

16 MSS.EUR.F234/25, Grant Duff to his father, 31 January 1904.

17 FO 881/8730, Grant Duff to Grey, 28 February 1906.

18 FO 881/8775, Grant Duff to Grey, 13 June 1905.

19 FO 881/8775, Grant Duff to Grey, 18 June 1906.

20 FO 881/8730, Grant Duff to Grey, 27 February 1906.

21 Browne, E.G., The Persian Revolution of 1905–1909, new ed. (Washington DC, 1995), 192Google Scholar.

22 Klein, Ira, “British Intervention in the Persian Revolution, 1905–1909,” Historical Journal, 15, no. 4 (1972): 735Google Scholar.

23 FO 881/8775 and 8802, Grant Duff to Grey, 21 June and 25 July 1906.

24 Viscount of Fallodon (Sir Edward) Grey, Twenty-Five Years 1892–1916, vol. 1 ( London, 1925), 267.

25 FO 881/8802, Grant Duff to Grey, 1 August 1906.

26 FO 881/8802, Grey to Grant Duff, 21 September 1906.

27 FO 881/8802, Grey to Grant Duff, 3 August 1906.

28 Times of London, 18 February 1903.

29 FO 881/8802, Nicolson to Grey, 23 September 1906.

30 Grey, Twenty-Five Years, 246.

31 FO 881/8802, Grant Duff to Grey, 13 August 1906.

32 Burton, David H., Cecil Spring-Rice: A Diplomat's Life (London, 1990), 20Google Scholar.

33 Burton, Cecil Spring-Rice, 35, 115.

34 Burton, Cecil Spring-Rice, 138.

35 Gwynn, Stephen, ed., The Letters and Friendships of Sir Cecil Spring-Rice: A Record, 2 vols. (Boston and New York, 1929), 81Google Scholar.

36 Gwynn, The Letters, 88.

37 FO 881/9078, Spring-Rice to Grey, 23 May 1907.

38 FO 881/9078, Spring-Rice to Grey, 18 June 1907.

39 FO 881/9296, Spring-Rice to Grey, 13 September 1907.

40 Gwynn, The Letters, 88.

41 FO 800/70, Spring-Rice to Grey, 3 January 1907.

42 Gwynn, The Letters, 98.

43 FO 881/9039, Spring-Rice to Grey, 27 February 1907.

44 Browne, Persian Revolution, 123.

45 Gwynn, The Letters, 96.

46 Gwynn, The Letters, 98.

47 FO 800/70, Spring-Rice to Grey, 28 March 1907.

48 FO 800/70, Spring-Rice to Grey, 28 March 1907.

49 McLean, Britain and her Buffer State, 2.

50 Gwynn, The Letters, 99.

51 Hereafter referred to as the Guardian.

52 Times, 17 December 1906.

53 Times, 13 August 1906.

54 Guardian, 24 December 1906.

55 Times, 10 September 1907.

56 Guardian, 10 January 1907.

57 Guardian, 19 September 1906.

58 Times, 11 March 1907.

59 Lord Lansdowne, HL Deb 6 February 1908, Hansard, vol. 183, cols. 999–1047.

60 Times, 13 August 1906.

61 Times, 10 September 1906.

62 Guardian, 10 January 1907.

63 Guardian, 10 January 1907.

66 Times, 3 September 1907.

64 Guardian, 5 June 1907.

65 Times, 3 September 1907.

66 Times, 3 September 1907.

67 Weinroth, Howard, “Radicalism and Nationalism: An Increasingly Unstable Equation,” Edwardian Radicalism 1900–1914 (London and Boston, 1974), 221Google Scholar.

68 Weinroth, “Radicalism and Nationalism,” 220.

69 Bonakdarian, Mansour, Britain and the Iranian Constitutional Revolution of 1906–11: Foreign Policy, Imperialism and Dissent (Syracuse, NY, 2006), 93Google Scholar.

70 Browne, Persian Revolution, xiii.

71 Browne, Persian Revolution, xii.

72 Browne, Persian Revolution, xx.

73 Browne, Persian Revolution, xix.

74 Brailsford, H.N., The Fruits of our Russian Alliance (London, 1912), 40Google Scholar.

75 Brailsford, The Fruits, 41.

76 Gordon, T.E., The Reform Movement in Persia (London, 1907)Google Scholar.

77 Hart-Davies, Reform Movement in Persia.

78 Tyrrell, F.H., “Popular Government among Musalman Peoples,” Imperial and Asiatic Quarterly Review (April 1908): 291Google Scholar.

79 Tyrrell, “Popular Government,” 286–87.

80 Tyrrell, “Popular Government,” 292.

81 Fraser, David, Persia and Turkey in Revolt (Edinburgh and London, 1910)Google Scholar, front matter.

82 Fraser, Persia and Turkey in Revolt, 17–18.

83 Fraser, Persia and Turkey in Revolt, 20.

84 Constitution.

85 Fraser, Persia and Turkey in Revolt, 22.

86 Fraser, Persia and Turkey in Revolt, 2.

87 Lord Curzon quipped that Thomas Moore's “descriptions of Persia are about as much like the original as the Alhambra of Leicester Square is like the exquisite palace of Boabdil.” Curzon, Persian Question, 5.