Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-vdxz6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T01:06:32.809Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Decision Analysis to Evaluate Control Strategies for Crested Wheatgrass (Agropyron cristatum) in Grasslands National Park of Canada

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

Leonardo Frid  and
John F. Wilmshurst
Leonardo Frid*
Affiliation:
ESSA Technologies Ltd., 1765 West 8th Avenue, Suite 300, Vancouver, BC, Canada V6J 5C6
John F. Wilmshurst
Affiliation:
Parks Canada, Western and Northern Service Centre, 145 McDermot Ave., Winnipeg, MB, Canada, R3B 0R9
*
Corresponding author's E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Protected area managers often face uncertainty when managing invasive plants at the landscape scale. Crested wheatgrass, a popular forage crop in the Great Plains since the 1930s, is an aggressive invader of native grassland and a problem for land managers in protected areas where seeded roadsides and abandoned fields encroach into the native mixed-grass prairie. Given limited resources, land managers need to determine the best strategy for reducing the cover of crested wheatgrass. However, there is a high degree of uncertainty associated with the dynamics of crested wheatgrass spread and control. To compare alternative management strategies for crested wheatgrass in the face of uncertainty, we conducted a decision analysis based on information from Grasslands National Park. Our analysis involves the use of a spatially explicit model that incorporates alternative management strategies and hypotheses about crested wheatgrass spread and control dynamics. Using a decision tree and assigning probabilities to our alternative hypotheses, we calculated the expected outcome of each management alternative and ranked these alternatives. Because the probabilities assigned to alternative hypotheses are also uncertain, we conducted a sensitivity analysis of the full probability space. Our results show that under current funding levels it is always best to prioritize the early detection and control of new infestations. Monitoring the effectiveness of control is paramount to long-term success, emphasising the need for adaptive approaches to invasive plant management. This type of decision analysis approach could be applied to other invasive plants where there is a need to find management strategies that are robust to uncertainty in the current understanding of how these plants are best managed.

Keywords

Crested wheatgrass, Agropyron cristatum (L.) GaertnDecision analysissimulation modelingalien plant invasions
Type
Research
Information
Invasive Plant Science and Management , Volume 2 , Issue 4 , October 2009 , pp. 324 - 336
Copyright
Copyright © Weed Science Society of America 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Literature Cited

Alexander, C. A. D., Peters, C. N., Marmorek, D. R., and Higgins, P. 2006. A decision analysis of flow management experiments for Columbia River mountain whitefish (Prosopium williamsoni) management. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci 63:1142–1156.Google Scholar
Ambrose, L. G. and Wilson, S. D. 2003. Emergence of the introduced grass Agropyron cristatum and the native grass Bouteloua gracilis in a mixed-grass prairie restoration. Restor. Ecol 11:110–115.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Andersen, M. C., Adams, H., Hope, B., and Powell, M. 2004. Risk assessment for invasive species. Risk Anal 24:787–793.Google Scholar
Anonymous 2009. LANDFIRE. http://www.landfire.gov/reference_models.php. Accessed: May 6, 2009.Google Scholar
Arbaugh, M., Schilling, S., Merzenich, J., and van Wagtendon, J. W. 2000. A test of the strategic fuels management model VDDT using historical data from Yosemite National Park. Pages 85–89. In Neuenschwander, L. F. and Ryan, K. C. Joint Fire Science Conference and Workshop. Volume 2. Boise, ID University of Idaho and International Association of Wildland Fire.Google Scholar
Bakker, J. D., Christian, J., Wilson, S. D., and Waddington, J. 1997. Seeding blue grama in old crested wheatgrass fields in southwestern Saskatchewan. J. Range. Manage 50:156–159.Google Scholar
Bakker, J. and Wilson, S. 2001. Competitive abilities of introduced and native grasses. Plant Ecol 157:117–125.Google Scholar
Bakker, J. D. and Wilson, S. D. 2004. Using ecological restoration to constrain biological invasion. J. Appl. Ecol 41:1058–1064.Google Scholar
Beukema, S. J., Kurz, W. A., Klenner, W., Merzenich, J., and Arbaugh, M. 2003. Applying TELSA to assess alternative management scenarios. Pages 145–154. In Arthaud, G. J. and Barrett, T. M. Systems Analysis in Forest Resources. Snowmass, CO Kluwer Academic Publishers.Google Scholar
Byers, J. E., Reichard, S., Randall, J. M., Parker, I. M., Smith, C. S., Lonsdale, W. M., Atkinson, I. A. E., Seastedt, T. R., Williamson, M., Chornesky, E., and Hayes, D. 2002. Directing research to reduce the impacts of nonindigenous species. Conserv. Biol 16:630–640.Google Scholar
Christian, J. M. and Wilson, S. D. 1999. Long-term ecosystem impacts of an introduced grass in the northern Great Plains. Ecology 80:2397–2407.Google Scholar
Clark, J. S. and Fastie, C. 1998. Reid's paradox of rapid plant migration. Bioscience 48:13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clemen, R. T. 1996. Making Hard Decisions: An Introduction to Decision Analysis. 2nd ed. Belmont, CA Duxbury Press, Wadsworth Publishing. 664 p.Google Scholar
Cook, C. W., Stoddart, L. A., and Kinsinger, F. E. 1958. Responses of crested wheatgrass to various clipping treatments. Ecol. Monogr 28:237–273.Google Scholar
Dillman, A. C. 1946. The beginnings of crested wheatgrass in North America. J. Am. Soc. Agron 38:237–250.Google Scholar
Drechsler, M. and Burgman, M. A. 2004. Combining population viability analysis with decision analysis. Biodivers. Conserv 13:115–139.Google Scholar
Eiswerth, M. E. and Johnson, W. S. 2002. Managing nonindigenous invasive species: insights from dynamic analysis. Environ. Resour. Econ 23:319–342.Google Scholar
Ellison, A. M. 1996. An introduction to Bayesian inference for ecological research and environmental decision-making. Ecol. Appl 6:1036–1046.Google Scholar
ESSA Technologies Ltd 2005a. TELSA: Tool for Exploratory Landscape Scenario Analyses, Model Description. Version 3.3. Vancouver, Canada ESSA Technologies Ltd. 50 p.Google Scholar
ESSA Technologies Ltd 2005b. Vegetation Dynamics Development Tool User Guide. Version 5.1. Vancouver, Canada ESSA Technologies Ltd. 188 p.Google Scholar
Forbis, T. A., Provencher, L., Frid, L., and Medlyn, G. 2006. Great Basin land management planning using ecological modeling. Environ. Manage 38:62–83.Google Scholar
Hansen, M. J. 2006. Prediction and management of an invasive grass (Agropyron cristatum). Ph.D. dissertation. Regina, Canada Biology Department, University of Regina. 205 p.Google Scholar
Hansen, M. J. 2007. Evaluating management strategies and recovery of an invasive grass (Agropyron cristatum) using matrix population models. Biol. Conserv 140:91–99.Google Scholar
Hansen, M. J. and Wilson, S. D. 2006. Is management of an invasive grass Agropyron cristatum contingent on environmental variation? J. Appl. Ecol 43:269–280.Google Scholar
Heidinga, L. and Wilson, S. D. 2002. The impact of an invading alien grass (Agropyron cristatum) on species turnover in native prairie. Divers. Distrib 8:249–258.Google Scholar
Hemstrom, M. A., Korol, J. J., and Hann, W. J. 2001. Trends in terrestrial plant communities and landscape health indicate the effects of alternative management strategies in the interior Columbia River basin. For. Ecol. Manage 153:105–125.Google Scholar
Henderson, D. C. 2005. Ecology and Management of Crested Wheatgrass Invasion. Ph.D. dissertation. Edmonton, Canada Department of Renewable Resources, University of Alberta. 149 p.Google Scholar
Higgins, S. I., Richardson, D. M., and Cowling, R. M. 2000a. A dynamic spatial model for managing alien plant invasions at the landscape extent. Ecol. Appl 10:1833–1848.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Higgins, S. I., Richardson, D. M., and Cowling, R. M. 2000b. Using a dynamic landscape model for planning the management of alien plant invasions. Ecol. Appl 10:1833–1848.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hull, A. C. J. and Klomp, G. J. 1967. Thickening and spreading of crested wheatgrass stands on southern Idaho ranges. J. Range. Manage 20:222–227.Google Scholar
Kurz, W. A., Beukema, S. J., Klenner, W., Greenough, J. A., Robinson, D. C. E., Sharpe, A. D., and Webb, T. M. 2000. TELSA: The tool for exploratory landscape scenario analyses. Comput. Electron. Agric 27:227–242.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leung, B., Lodge, D. M., Finnoff, D., Shogren, J. F., Lewis, M. A., and Lamberti, G. 2002. An ounce of prevention or a pound of cure: bioeconomic risk analysis of invasive species. Proc. R. Soc. Lond., Ser. B: Biol. Sci 269:2407–2413.Google Scholar
Loveridge, D. M. and Potyondi, B. 1983. From Wood Mountain to the Whitemud: A Historical Survey of the Grasslands National Park Area. History and Archaeology 67. Ottawa, Canada National Historic Parks and Sites Branch, Parks Canada, Environment Canada. 349 p.Google Scholar
Maguire, L. A. 2004. What can decision analysis do for invasive species management? Risk Anal 24:859–868.Google Scholar
Marlette, G. M. and Anderson, J. E. 1986. Seed banks and propagule dispersal in crested-wheatgrass stands. J. Appl. Ecol 23:161–175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merzenich, J. and Frid, L. 2005. Projecting landscape conditions in southern Utah using VDDT. Pages 157–163. In Bevers, M. and Barrett, T. M. Systems Analysis in Forest Resources: Proceedings of the 2003 Symposium. General Technical Report PNW-GTR-656. Portland, OR U.S. Stevenson, WA, U.S.A.: Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station.Google Scholar
Merzenich, J., Kurz, W. A., Beukema, S. J., Arbaugh, M., and Schilling, S. 1999. Long-range modelling of stochastic disturbances and management treatments using VDDT and TELSA. Society of American Foresters National Convention: Landscape Analysis Session. Portland, Oregon Society of American Foresters.Google Scholar
Michalsky, S. J. and Ellis, R. A. 1994. Vegetation of Grasslands National Park. Calgary, Canada D.A. Westworth and Associates. 111 p.Google Scholar
Moody, M. E. and Mack, R. N. 1988. Controlling the spread of plant invasions: the importance of nascent foci. J. Appl. Ecol 25:1009–1021.Google Scholar
Mooney, H. A. 2005. Invasive alien species: The nature of the problem. Pages 1–15. In Neville, L. E., Shei, P. J., Waage, J. K., Mooney, H. A., Mack, R. N., and McNeely, J. A. Invasive Alien Species: A New Synthesis. Washington, DC Island Press.Google Scholar
Parks Canada Agency 2002. Grasslands National Park Management Plan. Ottawa, Canada Department of Heritage, Government of Canada. 79 p.Google Scholar
Perrings, C., Dalmazzone, S., and Williamson, M. 2005. The economics of biological invasions. Pages 16–35. In Neville, L. E., Shei, P. J., Waage, J. K., Mooney, H. A., Mack, R. N., and McNeely, J. A. Invasive Alien Species: A New Synthesis. Washington, DC Island Press.Google Scholar
Peterman, R. M. and Anderson, J. 1999. Decision analysis: a method for taking uncertainties into account in risk based decision making. Hum. Ecol. Risk Assess 5:231–244.Google Scholar
Peterman, R. M. and Peters, C. N. 1998. Decision analysis: taking uncertainties into account in forest resource management. Pages 105–127. In Sit, V. and Taylor, B. Statistical Methods for Adaptive Management Studies. Victoria, BC British Columbia Ministry of Forests Research Branch.Google Scholar
Peters, C. N. and Marmorek, D. R. 2001. Application of decision analysis to evaluate recovery actions for threatened Snake River spring and summer chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha). Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci 58:2431–2446.Google Scholar
Peters, C. N., Marmorek, D. R., and Deriso, R. B. 2006. Application of decision analysis to evaluate recovery actions for threatened Snake River fall chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha). Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci 58:2247–2458.Google Scholar
Pimentel, D., Lach, L., Zuniga, R., and Morrison, D. 2000. Environmental and economic costs of nonindigenous species in the United States. Bioscience 50:53–65.Google Scholar
Pyke, D. A. 1990. Comparative demography of co-occurring introduced and native tussock grasses: persistence and potential expansion. Oecologia 82:537–543.Google Scholar
Rejmanek, M., Richardson, D. M., Higgins, S. I., Pitcairn, M. J., and Grotkopp, E. 2005. Ecology of invasive plants: state of the art. Pages 104–161. In Neville, L. E., Shei, P. J., Waage, J. K., Mooney, H. A., Mack, R. N., and McNeely, J. A. Invasive Aliens Species: A New Synthesis. Washington, DC Island Press.Google Scholar
Rinella, M. J. and Sheley, R. L. 2005. A model for predicting invasive weed and grass dynamics. II. Accuracy evaluation. Weed Sci 53:605–614.Google Scholar
Rogler, G. A. 1954. Seed size and seedling vigor in crested wheatgrass. Agron. J 46:216–220.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rogler, G. A. and Lorenz, R. J. 1983. Crested wheatgrass—early history in the United States Agropyron cristatum, Agropyron desertorum and related taxa. J. Range. Manage 36:91–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shea, K. and Chesson, P. 2002. Community ecology theory as a framework for biological invasions. Trends Ecol. Evol 17:170–176.Google Scholar
Shea, K. and Kelley, D. 2004. Modeling for management of invasive species: Musk thistle (Carduus nutans) in New Zealand. Weed Technol 18:1338–1341.Google Scholar
Shea, K., Possingham, H. P., Murdoch, W. M., and Roush, R. 2002. Active adaptive management in insect pest and weed control: intervention with a plan for learning. Ecol. Appl 12:927–936.Google Scholar
Shirtliffe, S. J., Kenkel, N. C., and Entz, M. H. 2002. Fractal analysis of seed dispersal and spatial pattern in wild oats. Community Ecol 3:101–107.Google Scholar
Simberloff, D. 2003. How much information on population biology is needed to manage introduced species? Conserv. Biol 17:83–92.Google Scholar
Sturch, A. 2000. Revegetation Action Plan for Grasslands National Park of Canada. Unpublished Internal Report. Val Marie, Canada Parks Canada. 14 p.Google Scholar
Sturch, A. 2005. Facilitating prairie restoration through the management of crested wheatgrass (Agropyron cristatum) in Grasslands National Park of Canada (Saskatchewan). MSc. Victoria, British Columbia, Canada: Technology and Environment Division, Royal Roads University.Google Scholar
Taylor, C. M. and Hastings, A. 2004. Finding optimal control strategies for invasive species: a density-structured model for Spartina alterniflora . J. Appl. Ecol 41:1049–1057.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wadsworth, R. A., Clooingham, Y. C., Willis, S. G., Huntley, B., and Hulme, P. E. 2000. Simulating the spread and management of alien riparian weeds: are they out of control? J. Appl. Ecol 37:28–38.Google Scholar
Wilson, S. D., Bakker, E. S., Christian, J., Li, X., Ambrose, L. G., and Waddington, J. 2004. Semiarid old-field restoration: is neighbor control needed? Ecol. Appl 14:476–485.Google Scholar
Wilson, S. D. and Gerry, A. K. 1995. Strategies for mixed-grass prairie restoration: herbicide, tilling and nitrogen manipulation. Restor. Ecol 3:290–298.Google Scholar
Wilson, S. D. and Pärtel, M. 2003. Extirpation or coexistence? Management of a persistent introduced grass in a prairie restoration. Restor. Ecol 11:410–416.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: PDF

Frid and Wilmshurst supplementary material

Appendix

Download Frid and Wilmshurst supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 40.4 KB