Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-s22k5 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-13T23:16:14.348Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Reconceiving Surrogacy: Toward a Reproductive Justice Account of Indian Surrogacy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 March 2020

Alison Bailey
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

My project here is to argue for situating moral judgments about Indian surrogacy in the context of Reproductive Justice. I begin by crafting the best picture of Indian surrogacy available to me while marking some worries I have about discursive colonialism and epistemic honesty. Western feminists' responses to contract pregnancy fall loosely into two interrelated moments: post‐Baby M discussions that focus on the morality of surrogacy work in Western contexts, and feminist biomedical ethnographies that focus on the lived dimensions of reproductive technologies and how they are embodied and negotiated in specific cultural contexts. Both approaches have their shortcomings. Uncritically extending Western moral frameworks (for example, liberal feminist political values) to Indian surrogacy work raises the specter of discursive colonialism; with it, worries arise about how Western normative traditions can distort, erase, or misread non‐Western subjects' lived experiences. Feminist biomedical ethnographic approaches correct this, but raise the specter of a weak moral absenteeism; with it, concerns arise about under‐theorizing the structural harms and injustices shaping surrogacy worker's lives. I suggest that we might reduce these shortcomings by framing normative and ethnographic engagement with global surrogacy as questions of reproductive justice.

Type
Responsibility and Identity in Global Justice
Information
Hypatia , Volume 26 , Issue 4: Special Issue: 2nd FEAST Special Issue , Fall 2011 , pp. 715 - 741
Copyright
Copyright © 2011 by Hypatia, Inc.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

ACRJ. 2006. A new vision for advancing our movement for reproductive health, reproductive rights, and reproductive justice. http://www.reproductivejustice.org/download/ACRJ_A_New_Vision.pdf (accessed March 30, 2008).Google Scholar
Ali, Lorraine, and Kelley, Raina. 2008. The curious lives of surrogates. Newsweek, March 29.Google Scholar
Amnesty International. 2010. Deadly delivery: The maternal health care crisis in the USA: Summary. http://www.amnestyusa.org/demand‐dignity/maternal‐health‐is‐a‐human‐right/the‐united‐states/page.do?id=1351091 (accessed September 2, 2010).Google Scholar
Bharadwaj, Aditya. 2002. Conception politics: Medical egos, media spotlights, and the contest over test‐tube firsts in India. In Infertility around the globe: New thinking on childlessness, gender, and reproductive technologies, ed. Inhorn, Marcia C. and Van Balen, Frank. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Burton, Antoinette. 1994. Burdens of history: British feminists, Indian women, and imperial culture, 1865–1915. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Chandran, Rina. 2009. As crisis bites: Indian women turn to surrogacy. Reuters. http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE53705T20090408 (accessed April 7, 2010).Google Scholar
Chopara, Anuj. 2006. Childless couples look to India for surrogate mothers. The Christian Science Monitor, April 3. http://www.csmonitor.com/2006/0403/p01s04‐wosc.html (accessed April 17, 2010).Google Scholar
Cohen, Margot. 2009. A search for a surrogate leads to India. The Wall Street Journal, October 9.Google Scholar
Corea, Gena. 1985. The mother machine: Reproductive technologies from artificial insemination to artificial wombs. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
CRR. 2008. Maternal mortality in India: Using international and constitutional law to promote accountability and change. http://reproductiverights.org/en/document/maternal‐mortality‐in‐india‐using‐international‐and‐constitutional‐law‐to‐promote‐accountab. (accessed November 11, 2009).Google Scholar
Cussins, Charis. 1998. Ontological choreography: Agency for women patients in an infertility clinic. In Differences in medicine: Unraveling practices, techniques, and bodies, ed. Berg, Marc and Mol, Anne Marie. Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Dillaway, Heather E. 2008. Mothers for others: A race, class and gender analysis of surrogacy. International Journal of Sociology of the Family 34(2): 301–26.Google Scholar
Doezema, Jo. 2001. Western feminists' “wounded attachment” to the “third world prostitute.” Feminist Review 67 (Spring): 16–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dolnick, Sam. 2007. Giving birth becomes latest job outsourced to India. USA Today, December 30. http://www.usatoday.com/news/health/2007‐12‐30‐surrogacy_N.htm (accessed April 5, 2010).Google Scholar
Eager, Paige Whaley. 2004. Global population policy: From population control to reproductive rights. Burlington, Vt.: Ashgate Publishing Company.Google Scholar
Farquhar, Dion. 1996. The other machine: Discourses and reproductive technologies. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Franklin, Sarah, and Ragoné, Helena. 1998. Reproducing reproduction: Kinship, power, and technological innovation. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
Gentleman, Amelia. 2005. India's effort to stop child marriage hits a wall. The New York Times, June 2. http://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/01/world/asia/01iht‐india.html (accessed November 9, 2010).Google Scholar
Gentleman, Amelia. 2008. India nurtures business of surrogate motherhood. The New York Times, March 10.Google Scholar
Ghosh, Aditya. 2006. Cradle of the world. Hindustan Times, December 23.Google Scholar
Ginsberg, Faye D., and Rapp, Ranya, eds. 1995. Conceiving the new world order: The global politics of reproduction. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Goslinga‐Roy, Gillian. 2000. Body boundaries, fiction of the female self: An ethnographic perspective on power, feminism, and the reproductive technologies. Feminist Studies 26(1): 113–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harding, Sandra. 1991. Whose science? Whose knowledge?: Thinking from women's lives. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Haworth, Abigail. 2007. Surrogate mothers: Wombs for rent. Marie Claire. http://www.marieclaire.com/world‐reports/news/international/surrogate‐mothers‐india (accessed January 16, 2009).Google Scholar
ICRW. 2001. Reproductive rights and choice: The role of abortion in India. Washington, D.C.: ICRW.Google Scholar
Ikemoto, Lisa. 1999. Lesson from the Titanic: Start with the people in steerage, women and children first. In Mother troubles: Rethinking contemporary maternal dilemmas, ed. Hanigsberg, Julia E. and Ruddick, Sara. Boston, Mass.: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
Inhorn, Marcia C., ed. 2003. Local babies, global science: Gender, religion, and in vitro fertilization in Egypt. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Inhorn, Marcia C. 2007. Reproductive disruptions: Gender, technology and biopolitics in the new millennium. New York: Berghahn Books.Google Scholar
Inhorn, Marcia C., and Van Balen, Frank, eds. 2002. Infertility around the globe: New thinking on childlessness, gender, and reproductive technologies. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Jaggar, Alison. 1983. Feminist politics and human nature. Totowa, N.J.: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Kannan, Shilpa. 2009. Regulators eye India's surrogacy sector. BBC News, March 19. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/7935768.stm (accessed April 17, 2010).Google Scholar
Lee, Wendy L. 2010. Contemporary feminist theory and activism: Six global issues. Buffalo, N.Y.: Broadview Press.Google Scholar
Maclean's, ed. 2007. Outsourcing life itself: What India teaches us. Maclean's 120(25): 4. http://www.macleans.ca/canada/opinions/article.jsp?content=20070702_107034_107034&page=1 (accessed April 10, 2010).Google Scholar
Medical Tourism Corporation. 2009. Interview with Dr. Gautam Allahbadia—surrogacy expert India. http://www.medicaltourismco.com/assisted‐reproduction‐fertility/dr‐Gautam‐Allahbadia‐India‐Surrogacy‐Expert.php (accessed May 27, 2009).Google Scholar
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (India). 2005/2006. Fact sheets by state http://www.nfhsindia.org/index.shtml (accessed November 9, 2010).Google Scholar
Mohanty, Chandra Talpade. 1988. Under western eyes: Feminist scholarship and colonial discourses. Feminist Review 30 (Autumn): 61–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mohanty, Chandra Talpade. 2003. Under Western eyes revisited: Feminist solidarity through anticapitalist struggles. Signs 28(2): 499–535.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murray, Anne Firth. 2008. Surrogate motherhood in India: Understanding and evaluating the effects of gestational surrogacy on women's health and rights. Stanford University. http://www.stanford.edu/group/womenscourage/Surrogacy/index.html (accessed April 10, 2010).Google Scholar
National Family Health Survey, India. 2006. NFHS 3. http://www.nfhsindia.org/nfhs3.shtml (accessed April 4, 2010).Google Scholar
Niazi, Shuriah. 2007. Surrogacy boom. http://Boloji.com, October 14. http://www.boloji.com/wfs6/wfs1027.htm (accessed March 23, 2009).Google Scholar
Pande, Amrita. 2008. Commercial gestational surrogacy in India: Nine months of labor? In A quest for alternative sociology, ed. Kosaka, Kenji and Ogino, Masahiro. Nishinomiya, Japan: Trans Pacific Press.Google Scholar
Pande, Amrita. 2009a. It may be her eggs, but it's my blood: Surrogates and everyday forms of kinship in India. Qualitative Sociology 32(4): 379–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pande, Amrita. 2009b. Not an “angel,” not a “whore.” Indian Journal of Gender Studies 16(2): 141–73.Google Scholar
Pande, Amrita. 2010. Commercial surrogacy in India: Manufacturing the perfect mother‐worker. Signs 35(4): 969–92.10.1086/651043CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peachey, Paul. 2006. Doctor hails ‘reproductive tourism as Indians make outsourced babies’. Middle East Times [March 29, 2006].Google Scholar
Ragoné, Helena. 2000. Of likeness and difference: How race is being transfigured by gestational surrogacy. In Ideologies and technologies of motherhood, ed. Ragoné, Helena and Twine, France Winddance. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Roberts, Dorothy. 1999. Killing the black body: Race, reproduction, and the meaning of liberty. New York: Vintage.Google Scholar
Ross, Loretta J. 2006. Understanding reproductive justice. SisterSong: Women of Color Reproductive Health Collective. http://www.sistersong.net/publications_and_articles/Understanding_RJ.pdf (accessed April 10, 2010).Google Scholar
Ross, Loretta J. 2007. Understanding reproductive justice: Transforming the pro‐choice movement. Off Our Backs 36(4): 16–20.Google Scholar
Rotunda Hospital. 2010. Low‐cost surrogacy: FAQ and procedure overview. http://www.medicaltourismco.com/assisted‐reproduction‐fertility/low‐cost‐surrogacy‐india.php (accessed November 9, 2010).Google Scholar
Roy, Sujit. 2008. Surrogate motherhood: Should it be allowed? http://Merinews.com, June 30. http://www.merinews.com/article/surrogate‐motherhood‐should‐it‐be‐allowed/136765.shtml (accessed November 11, 2009).Google Scholar
Ruparelia, Rakhi. 2007. Giving away the “gift of life”: Surrogacy and the Canadian assisted human reproduction act. Canadian Journal of Family Law 23(1): 11–54.Google Scholar
Sama. 2006. ARTs and women: Assistance in reproduction or subjugation? New Delhi: Sama Resource Group for Women's Health.Google Scholar
Sama. 2008. Comments and suggestions on the assisted reproductive technology (regulation) bill and rules‐2008 (draft), to the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and ICMR. [Dec. 4, 2008]. http://www.samawomenshealth.org/adv_art.html (accessed November 9, 2010).Google Scholar
Sama. 2009a. Assisted reproductive technologies: For whose benefit? Economic and Political Weekly 46(18): 25–31.Google Scholar
Sama. 2009b. Unraveling the fertility industry: Challenges and strategies for movement building. http://samawomenshealth.wordpress.com/2009/11/27/unraveling‐the‐fertility‐industry‐challenges‐and‐strategies‐for‐movement‐building/ (accessed April 17, 2010).Google Scholar
Schultz, Sandra. 2008. In India, surrogacy has become a global business. Der Spiegel Online. Translated by Christopher Sultan. http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,580209,00.html (accessed March 23 2008).Google Scholar
Scott, Amy. 2007. “Wombs for rent” grows in India. Marketplace on NPR December 27. http://marketplace.publicradio.org/display/web/2007/12/27/surrogate_mothers/ [MP3 file] (accessed November 9, 2010).Google Scholar
Shanthi, K. 2004. Feminist bioethics and reproductive rights in India: Myth and reality. In Linking visions, ed. Tong, Rosemary, Donchin, Anne, and Dodds, Susan. Oxford: Roman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Smerdon, Usha Rengachary. 2008. Crossing bodies, crossing borders: International surrogacy between the United States and India. Cumberland Law Review 39(1): 15–85.Google Scholar
Solinger, Rickie. 2001. Beggars and choosers: How the politics of choice shapes adoption, abortion, and welfare in the United States. New York: Hill and Wang.Google Scholar
Solinger, Rickie. 2005. Pregnancy and power: A short history of reproductive politics in America. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Stacy, Meg, ed. 1992. Changing human reproduction: Social science perspectives. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Subramanian, Sarmishta. 2007. Wombs for rent: Is paying the poor to have children wrong when both sides reap such benefits? Maclean's, July 2.Google Scholar
Teman, Elly. 2010. Birthing a mother: The surrogate self and the pregnant self. Berkeley: University of California Press.10.1525/california/9780520259638.001.0001CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thompson, Charis M. 2002. Fertile ground: Feminists theorize infertility. In Infertility around the globe: New thinking on childlessness, gender, and reproductive technologies, ed. Inhorn, Marcia C. and Van Balen, Frank. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Thompson, Charis M. 2005. Making parents: The ontological choreography of reproductive technologies. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Tong, Rosemarie. 2005. Surrogate motherhood. In A companion to applied ethics, ed. Frey, R. G. and Wellman, Christopher H.Malden, Mass.: Wiley‐Blackwell.Google Scholar
UNICEF. 2008. Monitoring the situation of children and women. http://www.childinfo.org/marriage.html (accessed September 30, 2009).Google Scholar
UNICEF. 2009. State of the world's children: Maternal and newborn health. http://www.unicef.org/sowc09/ (accessed April 3, 2010).Google Scholar
Vora, Kalindi. 2009. Indian transnational surrogacy and the commodification of vital energy. Subjectivity 28:266–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wade, Matt. 2009. Take away baby boom. The Brisbane Times. http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/news/world/the‐takeaway‐baby‐boom/2009/01/30/1232818725697.html (accessed April 10, 2010).Google Scholar
Washington, Harriet. 2007. Medical apartheid: The dark history of medical experimentation on black Americans from colonial times to the present. New York: Anchor Books.Google Scholar
WHO. 2005. Maternal mortality in 2005: Estimates. http://www.who.int/reproductive‐health/publications/maternal_mortality_2005/mme_2005.pdf (accessed November 9, 2010).Google Scholar
Wolf, Susan. 1999. Erasing difference: Race, ethnicity, and gender in bioethics. In Embodying bioethics, ed. Donchin, Ann and Purdy, Laura. Oxford: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar