Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-08T02:20:33.318Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Women Teachers in Western Australian “Bush” Schools, 1900-1939: Passive Victims of Oppressive Structures?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

Janina Trotman
Janina Trotman*
Affiliation:
Graduate School of Education, The University of Western Australia
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Demography, distance, and die expansion of settlements created problems for the State Department of Education in Western Australia and other Australian states in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Educational administration in Canada and parts of the United States faced similar issues with regard to the provision of schools. A common response was the establishment of one-teacher rural schools, frequently run by young, and sometimes unclassified, female teachers. In the United States locally elected school boards were the primary source of regulation, but in late nineteenth-century Western Australia such local boards had been stripped of their powers and were answerable to the newly established, highly centralized Education Department. Formal regulated teachers. The masculinized system of the Department and its inspectorate. All the same, however, the local community still exerted informal controls over the lives of teachers working and living in small settlements.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 46 , Issue 2 , Summer 2006 , pp. 248 - 273
Copyright
Copyright © 2006 by the History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Alison Prentice and Marjorie Theobald, “The Historiography of Women Teachers: A Retrospect,” in Women who Taught, eds. Alison Prentice and Marjorie Theobald, (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1991), 9.Google Scholar

2 The State Education Department was not responsible for providing schooling for Aboriginal children, which was seen to be the brief of the Aborigines Department. However, in some country towns Aboriginal children did attend the local school, but there were often protests from the white parents-mainly about hygiene. Successive ministers of education found these protests to be reasonable, and fearing that the white children would be withdrawn from the schools authorised the exclusion of the Aboriginal children. Education Department briefing to Minister, November 1917. Cited in, ed. Marion Aveling, Westralian Voices: Documents in Western Australian Social History, (Perth: University of Western Australia Press, for the Education Committee of the 150th Anniversary Celebrations, 1979), 195.Google Scholar

3 Mossenson, David, A History of Teacher Training in Western Australia, (Melbourne: Australian Council for Education Research, 1955), 13.Google Scholar

4 McKenzie, John, Old Bush Schools: Life and Education in the Small Schools of Western Australia, 1893 to 1961 (Perth: Western Australian College of Advanced Education, n.d.), 9.Google Scholar

5 Banjo Patterson (1864-1941) was one of Australia's most renowned ‘bush’ poets. The Man from Snowy River, one of his other famous works, was the basis of the movie of the same name.Google Scholar

6 Dettman, Hany W., “Review and Prospect,” in Education in Western Australia, ed. Wally Neal, D., (Perth: University of Western Australia Press for the Education Committee of the 150th Anniversary Celebrations, 1979), 296.Google Scholar

7 Mossenson, A History of Teacher Training in Western Australia, 123.Google Scholar

8 Percival Cole, ed. The Rural School in Australia, Educational Research Series No. 49, (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1937), 11. This publication was the result of a “systematic and scientific examination of rural education in Australia” (p. 11) as well as a “revelation of the experience and theories of a number of our leading educationists” (p. 12). The editor, Percival Cole, a distinguished scholar and educationist, was Vice-Principal of Sydney Teachers’ College, and a lecturer at Sydney University. From 1936 to 1937, he served as Carnegie Professor of International Relations in America, and was one of the founders of the Australian Council for Educational Research. Contributors to The Rural School in Australia were all notable educationists, academics and administrators, such as R.G. Cameron, Professor of Education at the University of Western Australia and Principal of Claremont Teachers’ College; Frank Tate, former Director of Education of the State of Victoria; Tas Lovell, Professor of Psychology at Sydney University and Christopher McRae, Senior Lecturer at Sydney Teachers’ College, later appointed as Principal.Google Scholar

9 Meadmore, Peter, “Hard Times, Expedient Measures: Women Teachers and Queensland Rural Schools, 1920-1950”, History of Education 28 (4) (December 1999): 435–447.Google Scholar

10 Hunt, Lynne and Trotman, Janina, Claremont Cameos Archive, (Perth, Western Australia: Edith Cowan University, 1990). The archive is located in the Edith Cowan University Archives. The initial step in the creation of the archive was generated by our indignation at the lack of acknowledgement of women teachers in an official ceremony held when Claremont ceased teacher training in 1989. Echoing our feelings, Alison White, herself a Claremont graduate, wrote a letter of protest to the local newspaper in which she pointed out the following: “Despite the fact that there have been more women trained as teachers during the College's history, and that women are the dominant sex in the teaching profession, not one woman was invited to speak!” (Claremont-Nedlands POST, 15 (46) 14 November 1989), 2. A small grant from the West Australian Women's Trust enabled us to start the project, which received further funding from Edith Cowan University. There are forty-seven interviews conducted by Hunt and Trotman with the assistance of thirty-two volunteer interviewers, all of whom were trained in oral history interview procedures. The interviewees, ranging in age from ninety-eight to forty-five, were not a representative sample of the women graduates. Some of them had responded to a newspaper advertisement we placed, others were nominated by people who thought the women's stories were important to record. We eventually had to close the interviewing stage because of time and financial constraints, but we were always finding ourselves being approached by people who would urge us to interview yet another particular teacher because they had been ‘so special.’ Making selections from the oral histories to publish in our book was very difficult. We did not want to focus solely on the women who had been high achievers—and there were many—because we wanted to acknowledge the backbone of the State's teaching profession, the “ordinary” classroom teacher. Seven of the interviewees had completed the Short Course for rural schools, but twelve had taught in bush schools. This article is based on thirteen of the oral histories in the archive. See also, Lynne Hunt and Janina Trotman, Claremont Cameos: Women Teachers and the Building of Social Capital in Australia, (Perth, Western Australia: Edith Cowan University, 2002).Google Scholar

11 McKenzie, John, Old Bush Schools: Life and Education in the Small Schools of Western Australia, 1893 to 1961, (Perth: Western Australian College of Advanced Education, n.d.)Google Scholar

12 There is considerable amount of scholarly work which addresses these questions. See, for example, Susan S. Friedman, “Making History: Reflections on Feminism, Narrative, and Desire,” in The Postmodern History Reader, ed. Keith Jenkins, (London: Routledge, 1997), 231–236; Marjorie Theobald, “Teachers, Memory and Oral History,” in Telling Women's Lives: Narrative Inquiries in the History of Women's Education, in eds. Kathleen Weiler and Sue Middleton (Buckingham: Open University Press, 1999), 9–24; Joan Sangster, “Telling our Stories: Feminist Debates and the Use of Oral History” in, The Oral History Reader, eds. Robert Perks and Alistair Thomson, (London: Routledge, 1998), 87–100. For an elaboration of the methodological and interpretive positions we took, see Janina Trotman and Lynne Hunt, “Whose Story is This? Claremont Cameos and the Dilemmas of Working Within a Feminist Framework,” From all Quarters (Journal of the Oral History Association of Australia) 25 (2003): 37–43.Google Scholar

13 Altenbaugh, Richard, “Oral History, American Teachers and a Social History of Teaching: An Emerging Agenda.” Cambridge Journal of Education 27: 3 (September 1997): 313–330.Google Scholar

14 Rankin, Donald H., The History of the Development of Education in Western Australia: 1829-1923 (Perth: Carrolls Ltd. Publishers, 1926).Google Scholar

15 Mossenson, David, State Education in Western Australia: 1829-1960 (Perth: University of Western Australia Press, 1972).Google Scholar

16 Sangster, “Telling our Stories,” 87.Google Scholar

17 See Alison Holbrook's schematic representation of the interview as event and process in “Methodological Developments in Oral History: A Multi-layered Approach,” Australian Educational Researcher 22: 3 (December 1995): 37.Google Scholar

18 Damousi, Joy, “Marching to Different Drums: Women's Mobilisation, 1914-1939”, in Gender Relations in Australia: Domination and Negotiation, eds. Kay Saunders and Raymond Evans (Sydney: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1992), 362; Connell, R. Bob, Masculinities (St. Leonards, New South Wales: Allen and Unwin, 1995), 84.Google Scholar

19 Blackmore, Jill, Making Educational History: A Feminist Perspective (Geelong: Deakin University Press, 1992), 33.Google Scholar

20 Holmes, Katie, “‘Diamonds of the Dustheap'?: Women's Diary Writing Between the Wars,” in Wallflowers and Witches: Women and Culture in Australia 1910-1945 ed. Maryanne Dever (St Lucia: Queensland University Press, 1994), 43. The early decades of the twentieth century witnessed a cultural reconstruction of femininity. This was the Jazz Age during which several factors combined to “create a notion of what the modern, feminine woman was, what she did, and what she looked like…. [she] had to be attractive to men: her appeal was sexual and sensual, she was young and mil of life, slightly daring, and ready to embark on the adventure of romance.” But as Katie Holmes concludes, the end result was still marriage.Google Scholar

21 McKenzie, Old Bush Schools, 9.Google Scholar

22 ibid., 16–17. Unclassified teachers had passed an entrance exam, and had satisfied an inspector of their ability to teach a small number of children: “A very elementary test of their knowledge and teaching capacity”.Google Scholar

23 See, for example, Sari Knopp Biklen, Schoolwork: Gender and the Cultural Construction of Teaching (New York: Teachers’ College Press, 1995); Weiler, Kathleen, Country Schoolwomen: Teaching in Rural California, 1850-1950 (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1998); Carolyn Steedman, “Prisonhouses,” in Teachers: The Culture and Politics of Work eds. Martin Lawn and Gerald Grace (London: Falmer Press, 1987), 117–129; Rosemary Deem, Women and Schooling (London: Routledge, 1978).Google Scholar

24 Western Australian Education Department, Annual Report 1912 (Perth, Western Australia: Government Print), 82.Google Scholar

25 Oral history interview with Gladys York (nee Tobias) (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Jessie Hardy. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archive, 4.Google Scholar

26 Oral history with Jean Cairns (nee Hughan) (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Joan Moss. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archive, 3.Google Scholar

27 Walkerdine, Valerie, “Post-structuralist Theory and Everyday Practices: The Family and the School,” in Feminist Social Psychology: Developing Theory and Practice ed. Sue Wilkinson (Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1986), 72: “In many cases, the power of girls in the classroom is given precisely through their operation as sub-teachers [they] are displaying the requirements necessary to join the caring professions.”Google Scholar

28 Clifford, Geraldine Jonçich, “‘Lady teachers’ and the politics of teaching in the United States, 1850-1930” in Lawn and Grace, eds., Teachers: The Culture and Politics of Work, 10.Google Scholar

29 Oral history interview with Evelyn Parker (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Hilary Rumley. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archives, 3.Google Scholar

30 Oral history interview with Jess Gray (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Alison Sutherland. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archives, p.6Google Scholar

31 The first Short Course for rural schools was six months duration. In 1919 it was extended to a year.Google Scholar

32 Oral history interview with Jess Gray, 2–6.Google Scholar

33 ibid., 7.Google Scholar

34 Oral history interview with May Knowles (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewers, Avril O'Brien and Janina Trotman. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameo Archives, 8–9. Google Scholar

35 Ibid., 9Google Scholar

36 Oral history interview with Muriel Rose (nee Seddon) (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Alison Sutherland. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameo Archives, 8–9.Google Scholar

37 Angela Brazil was arguably the most successful early twentieth-century English writer of schoolgirl fiction. Her stories of the boarding school adventures of middle-class girls became the model for the content of the burgeoning market for girls’ magazines in the early decades of the last century. Deborah Gorham, “The Ideology of Femininity and Reading for Girls, 1850-1914, in Lessons for Life: The Schooling of Girls and Women, 1850-1950 ed. Felicity Hunt (Oxford: Blackwells 1987), 39–59.Google Scholar

38 A small holiday island a few miles off the coast of Perth. Very popular with families, but also known as a place of fairly unrestricted social and romantic activities for students.Google Scholar

39 Oral history interview with Rica Erickson (nee Sandilands) (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Shirley Leahy. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archive, 17–18.Google Scholar

40 Oral history interview with Mabel Guy (nee Harris) (Safety Bay, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Gail Thomas. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archive, 12–13.Google Scholar

41 Ibid., 13Google Scholar

42 Ibid., 25Google Scholar

43 Ibid., p. 9Google Scholar

44 By 1906 Andrews had established Schools of Instruction in country centers where Inspectors assembled groups of country teachers for advice and assistance. A Model Rural School was established at Gosnells, a rural settlement some 20 miles from Perth. In 1908 and 1909 a three-month course was held for country teachers at Claremont during the summer break in the academic year. Mossenson, A History of Teacher Training in Western Australia, 125.Google Scholar

45 McKenzie, Old Bush Schools, 22.Google Scholar

46 Williamson, Noeline, “The Employment of Female Teachers in the Small Bush Schools of New South Wales, 1880-1890: A Case of Stay Bushed or Stay Home,” Labour History 43 (November 1982): 1–12.Google Scholar

47 The one-year course did not survive the Depression. In 1931 the College was closed as part of the Government's stringency measures, and when it re-opened in 1934, the Short Course was reduced to six months.Google Scholar

48 Mossenson, A History of Teacher Training in Western Australia, 28.Google Scholar

49 Oral History interview with Hilda Hearne (nee Chate) (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Lekkie Hopkins. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archive, p.25Google Scholar

50 Oral history interview with Evelyn Parker (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Hilary Rumley. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archive, p.4Google Scholar

51 Oral history interview with Rica Erickson, p. 25Google Scholar

52 Trotman, Janina, “Jobs for the girls: Family Ideology and the Employment of Women in Education,” Australian Journal of Education 28: 2 (August 1984): 132–144.Google Scholar

53 Weiler, Country Schoolwomen, 41.Google Scholar

54 Collins, J. Maxwell, “Structural Changes in the Australian Teaching Workforce - a Female Takeover Bid?” Australian Journal of Education 17: 1 (April 1973): 18–24. Cited in Noeline Kyle, “Women's ‘Natural Mission’ but Man's Real Domain: The Masculinisation of the State Elementary Teaching Service in New South Wales” in Battlers and Bluestockings: Women's Place in Australian Education eds. Sandra Taylor and Miriam Henry (Deakin, Australian Capital Territory Australian College of Education, 1988), 26.Google Scholar

55 Kennedy, Sally, “ ‘Useful and Expendable': Women Teachers in Western Australia in the 1920s and 1930s”, Labour History 44 (May 1983): 20.Google Scholar

56 Oral history interview with Biddy (Blanche) McMullen (nee Rohan) (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Barbara Campbell. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archives, 9.Google Scholar

57 Oral history interview with Edith Moore (nee Atkinson) (Manjimup, Western Australia, Interviewer, Margaret Roeterdink. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archives, p.5.Google Scholar

58 Oral history interview with Evelyn Parker, p.4Google Scholar

59 Oral history interview with Jean Cairns, p.4Google Scholar

60 Oral history interview with Evelyn Parker p. 5Google Scholar

61 Oral history interview with Edith Moore, p.6Google Scholar

62 George Romans, ed. The Handbook of Western Australia: An Official Handbook for the Information of Commercial Men, Tourists and Immigrants (Perth, Western Australia: Government Printer, 1912), 103.Google Scholar

63 Oral history interview with Hilda Hearne. p.9Google Scholar

64 Oral history interview with Evelyn Parker, p 7.Google Scholar

65 Originally a New Zealand term, in this sense it means keeping house for oneself with little or no prior experience. Arthur Delbridge, John Bernard, R., David Blair, Susan Buder, Pamela Peters & Colin Yallop, eds. The Macquarie Dictionary (Sydney, New South Wales: The Macquarie Library Pty Ltd, 1997, 3rd edn), 146.Google Scholar

66 Oral history interview with Muriel Rose. p. 12Google Scholar

67 Ibid.,Google Scholar

68 McKenzie, Old Bush Schools, 47.Google Scholar

69 Oral history interview with Gladys York. p.20Google Scholar

70 Oral history interview with Rica Erickson. p. 15Google Scholar

71 Oral history interview with Nennie Harken, (Perth, Western Australia, 1990). Interviewer, Dale Twycross. In Hunt and Trotman, Claremont Cameos Archive,Google Scholar

72 Oral history interview with Nennie Harken, p. 11Google Scholar

73 Cunningham, K.S., “Buildings and equipment”, in The Rural School in Australia, ed Cole, 143.Google Scholar

74 McKenzie, Old Bush Schools, 30.Google Scholar

75 Ibid., 31Google Scholar

76 Oral history interview with Hilda Hearne. p. 15Google Scholar

77 This heading is a deliberate “re-gendering” of a title of one of McKenzie's chapters, “The bush chalkie and his school”. In Australia, “chalkie” is a slang term for teacher. McKenzie, Old Bush Schools, 27.Google Scholar

78 McKenzie, , Old Bush Schools, 21.Google Scholar

79 Cole ed., The Rural School in Australia, 165–210.Google Scholar

80 Braithwaite, J.M., and C. R., McRae. “The Time-table and Other Special Problems.” In, The Rural School in Australia, ed. Cole, 171.Google Scholar

81 Braithwaite, and McRae, , in The Rural School in Australia, ed. Cole, 172 (emphasis added).Google Scholar

82 Oral history interview with Gladys York. p. 23Google Scholar

83 Oral history with Nennie Harken, p. 13Google Scholar

84 Weiler, , Country Schoolwomen, 194.Google Scholar

85 Tate, Frank, “Rural School Administration” in The Rural School in Australia, ed. Cole, 91.Google Scholar

86 Ibid, 91.Google Scholar

87 Oral history interview with Nennie Harken, p.13Google Scholar

88 Oral history interview with Muriel Rose, p.21Google Scholar

89 Oral history interview with Evelyn Parker, p.32Google Scholar

90 Ibid. 9.Google Scholar

91 Ibid. 5.Google Scholar

92 Cole ed., The Rural School in Australia. Google Scholar

93 Meadmore, “Hard Times, Expedient Measures”, 447.Google Scholar

94 Foucault, Michel, “The Subject and Power,” in Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics eds. Harold Dreyfus and Paul Rabinow (Brighton: Harvester Press, 1982), 101.Google Scholar

95 Damousi, Joy, “Marching to Different Drums” 362.Google Scholar

96 Gouldner, Alvin W., The Future of Intellectuals and the Rise of the New Middle Class (New York: Continuum, 1979).Google Scholar

97 Theobald, Knowing Women, 192.Google Scholar