Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-kw2vx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-23T22:18:50.692Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Radical Youth: Generational Conflict in the Anfang Movement, 1912–January 1914

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

Philip Lee Utley
Philip Lee Utley*
Affiliation:
Theodore Reik Consultation Center, New York
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Anfang movement, centered in Vienna and Berlin from 1912 to 1914, was the twentieth century's first left-wing political youth movement whose main concern was youthful independence from adult authority. The movement took its name from its journal Der Anfang (“The Beginning”). The 3000 members were Austrians and Germans born between 1890 and 1899. Most were urban state secondary school pupils and university students from middle-class families, many of which were artistic, academic and intellectual. A third of the members were Jewish; in Vienna 90% were Jewish. In June 1914 the journal reached a high point of 1000 subscribers.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 19 , Issue 2 , Summer 1979 , pp. 207 - 228
Copyright
Copyright © 1979 by History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

My thanks to Richard Dougherty for advice concerning this article; and to Lily Bernfeld Stross, Rosemarie Bernfeld Ostwald, Ruth Bernfeld Goldberg, Peter Paret and Rudolf Ekstein for interviews about the movement; to Marek Web for access to the YIVO Institute Archive; to Agnes Peterson for access to the Hoover Institution Archive; to Hans Wolf for access to the German Jugendbewegung Archive, Burg Ludwigstein.

1 Bernfeld, Siegfried, Die Schulgemeinde und ihre Funktion im Klassenkampf (Berlin, 1928), 16–25, 110–116.Google Scholar

2 YIYO Institute Archive, Bernfeld Collection, Files 3890–3960 (cited hereafter as YIVO with file number); Hoover Institution, Bernfeld Collection.Google Scholar

3 Der Anfang: Zeitschrift der Jugend 1: 1–32 (the first issue; Vol. 1, No. 1–12, appeared May 1913–April 1914; Vol. 2, No. 1, 2, 3, 4, appeared May–July 1914); YIVO 3940. On Barbizon see Barbizon, Georges, in Der neue Anfang, Vol. 1, No. 4 (February 15, 1919); Gustav Wyneken, Interview with Mosse, George L., October 7, 1961 (transcript at Jugendbewegung archive, Burg Ludwigstein).Google Scholar

4 On Wyneken's editing, Anfang, 1: 1–32; YIVO 3940. On Benjamin, Benjamin, Walter, Briefe , ed. Adorno, Theodor and Scholem, Gershom (Frankfurt, 1966), 530–531; on Benjamin's importance, Arendt, Hannah. ed., in Benjamin, , illuminations , tr. Zohn, Harry (New York, 1969), 14.Google Scholar

5 Barbizon, in Anfang 1: 1–32; Bernfeld, , “Ziele,” Die freie Schulgemeinde 3 (1913): 54–58.Google Scholar

6 Wyneken, in Anfang 1: 1–32; YIVO 3940.Google Scholar

7 Anfang 1: 1–32.Google Scholar

8 Anfang 1: 343–345; 178–179.Google Scholar

9 Anfang 1: 1–32, 351–352.Google Scholar

10 Anfang 1: 148–149, 108–110.Google Scholar

11 Anfang 1: 148–149.Google Scholar

12 Anfang 1: 23–26.Google Scholar

13 See e.g. Anfang 1: 261–265, 200–209, 316–317; Anfang 2: 58–61.Google Scholar

14 Ekstein, Rudolf, in Psychoanalytic Pioneers, ed. Alexander, Franz et. al. (New York, 1966), 416–417; Stross, Lily Bernfeld, Interview with Utley, Philip, November 23, 1975.Google Scholar

15 McGrath, William J., Dionysian Art and Populist Politics in Austria (New Haven, 1974), 1–119; Anfang 1: 386; Bronnen, Arnolt, Arnolt Bronnen gibt zu Protokoll (Hamburg, 1954), 27.Google Scholar

16 Anfang 1: 328–337.Google Scholar

17 Anfang 1: 200–209, 227–235.Google Scholar

18 Kollwitz, Hans, ed., in Käthe Kollwitz, The Diary and Letters, tr. R. and Winston, C. (Chicago, 1955), 4–18: hectographed Anfang, Hoover Institution Bernfeld Collection.Google Scholar

19 Benjamin, , Berliner Chronik (Frankfurt, 1970), 45; Herzfelde, Wieland, Unterwegs: Blätter aus funfzig Jahren (Berlin, 1961), 278; Gumpert, Martin, Hölle im Paradies (Stockholm, 1939), 54; Stross, Interview.Google Scholar

20 Anfang 1: 338.Google Scholar

21 Panter, Ulrich, Gustav Wyneken: Leben und Werk (Weinheim, 1960), 1–2, 69–75, 98–100; Anfang 1: 27–28.Google Scholar

22 Wyneken, Gustav, Kampf für die Jugend (Jena, 1919), 5–40, 112–121, 244–262.Google Scholar

23 Ibid. Scholarly thoroughness compels mentioning the probable connection between Wyneken's idealization of youth and his homosexuality, of which the Anfang movement was unaware; see YIVO 9505.Google Scholar

24 Bernfeld, , Schulgemeinde, 17, 19.Google Scholar

25 Wyneken, , Kampf, 112–121.Google Scholar

26 Benjamin, , Briefe, 55.Google Scholar

27 Anfang 1: 27–28; Bernfeld, , Die neue Jugend und die Frauen (Vienna, 1914), 1–71.Google Scholar

28 Bernfeld, , Schulgemeinde, 16–23.Google Scholar

29 Anfang 1: 27–28; Bernfeld, , “Die Arbeiten des akademischen Comitées für Schulreform,” in Die erste studentisch-padagoische Tagung, Breslau 1913 (Leipzig, 1913), 31–32.Google Scholar

30 Anfang 1: “Umschau,” each No.Google Scholar

31 Bernfeld, , “Die Arbeiten,” 31–32; Stross, , Interview; Benjamin, , Berliner Chronik, 34–35.Google Scholar

32 Bernfeld, , “Das akademische Comitée für Schulreform,” Münchener akademische Rundschau (1914), 221–223; Bernfeld, , “Die Arbeiten,” 33–34; Anfang 1: 385; YIVO 3944.Google Scholar

33 Bernfeld, , Schulgemeinde, 16–23.Google Scholar

34 Ibid.: Anfang 1: 27–28.Google Scholar

35 Laqueur, Walter, Young Germany: A History of the German Youth Movement (New York, 1962), 32–38, 52–55; Anfang 1: 1–32.Google Scholar

36 Anfang 1: 12–15.Google Scholar

37 Laqueur, , 32–36; Pross, Harry, Jugend Eros Politik: Die Geschichte der deutschen Jugendverbande (Bern, 1964), 130–136, 160–168; Anfang 1:129–131, 161–163, 193–197; 2: 93–103.Google Scholar

38 Anfang 1: 161–163, 193–197, 286–287.Google Scholar

39 Anfang 1: 27–28.Google Scholar

40 Benjamin, , Briefe, 48–85.Google Scholar

41 Anfang 1: 60–61; 2: 88–90.Google Scholar

42 Anfang 1: 251–252; Benjamin, , Briefe, 85–86.Google Scholar

43 Benjamin, , Briefe, 54, 75, 868; Anfang 1: 60–61; YIVO 3930.Google Scholar

44 Benjamin, , Berliner Chronik, 34–35; Benjamin, , Briefe, 93–117, 531.Google Scholar

45 Anfang 1: 386; Bernfeld, , Schulgemeinde, 20; Stross, , Interview.Google Scholar

46 Anfang 1: 337.Google Scholar

47 Anfang 1: 200–209, 356–357; 2: 120–122.Google Scholar

48 Bernfeld, , “Praktische Arbeit,” Studentische Monatshefte vom Oberrhein (typed) (1914), No. 5.Google Scholar

49 Anfang 2: 120–123.Google Scholar

50 Freud, Anna, Letter to Utley, Philip, July 19, 1969.Google Scholar

51 See Hoffer, Willi, “Siegfried Bernfeld and ‘Jerubbaal’: An Episode in the Jewish Youth Movement,” Leo Baeck Institute Yearbook 10 (1965): 151–167.Google Scholar

52 Bernfeld, , “Die Arbeiten.” 31–34; Anfang 2: 51–58.Google Scholar

53 Anfang 2: 75–77; Bernfeld, , Schulgemeinde, 18–23.Google Scholar

54 Anfang 1: 328–337; 2: 92; Ahlborn, Knud et al, Die freideutsche Jugend im Bayrischen Landtag (Hamburg, 1914), 3–47.Google Scholar

55 Anfang 1: 386; Bronnen, , 27, dates the lecture a year early; YIVO 3944.Google Scholar

56 Anfang 2: 1–12, 93–109.Google Scholar

57 Borkenau, Franz (pseud., Jungmann, Fritz), “Autorität and Sexualmoral in der freien bürgerlichen Jugendbewegung,” Studien uber Autoritat und Familie (Paris, 1936), 669–705.Google Scholar

58 Laquer, , 3–83.Google Scholar

59 Pross, , 11–168.Google Scholar

60 Bernfeld, , Neue Jugend, 1–71.Google Scholar

61 Anfang 1: 100.Google Scholar

62 Bernfeld, , “Psychoanalyse in der Jugendbewegung,” Imago 5 (1919): 283–289.Google Scholar

63 Freud, Anna, The Ego and the Mechanisms of Defense (New York, 1946), 157–189.Google Scholar

64 Ibid. ; Bernfeld, , “Psychoanalyse,” 283–289; see Bernfeld, , “Eine typische Form der männlichen Pubertät,” Imago 9 (1923): 169–188; Blos, Peter, On Adolescence (New York, 1962).Google Scholar

65 On character disorders, Kernberg, Otto, Borderline Conditions and Pathological Narcissism (New York, 1975).Google Scholar

66 Anfang 1: 148–149.Google Scholar

67 See e.g. Anfang 1: 166–169.Google Scholar

68 Bronnen, , 25–29; see Brockhaus Enzyklopädie, 16th ed., s.v. “Bronnen, Arnolt.” Google Scholar

69 Bernfeld, , Schulgemeinde, 113–114; YIVO 3944.Google Scholar

70 On the importance of early childhood, Freud, Sigmund, “Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality,” Standard Edition (London, 1953–1974) 7: 135–243; for one view on the relation between child-rearing and character, DeMause, Lloyd, ed., The History of Childhood (New York, 1974), 1–73.Google Scholar

71 Stross, , Interview.Google Scholar

72 Bernfeld, , “Brief an einem Quartaner,” Die Weltbuhne 23 (1927): 595–596.Google Scholar

73 Stross, , Interview.Google Scholar

74 Arendt, , 24–27.Google Scholar

75 Benjamin, , Berliner Chronik, 41, 96–98.Google Scholar

76 Arendt, , 24–27; Benjamin, , Briefe, 532–535.Google Scholar

77 Kollwitz, Hans, loc. cit.; Kollwitz, Käthe, Diary and Letters, 51–130, 179–180. Google Scholar

78 Fischer, Ernst, Uberlegungen zur Situation der Kunst (Zurich, 1971), 77–121; Stross, , Interview; YIVO 3921, 3944; Brockhaus Enzyklopadie, 16th ed., and Encyclopaedia Judaica (1971–1972), s. v. “Fischer, Ruth,” “Eisler, Hanns,” “Eisler, Gerhart.” Google Scholar

79 Borkenau, , 687.Google Scholar

80 Bernfeld, , Neue Jugend, 1–71.Google Scholar

81 Anfang 1: 216–218.Google Scholar

82 Bernfeld, , “Ziele,” 54–56.Google Scholar

83 Bernfeld, , Schulgemeinde, 24.Google Scholar

84 Anfang 1:1.Google Scholar