Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-04T19:24:57.002Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“One Can't Live on Air”: Sarah McComb and the Problem of Old-Age Income for Single Women Teachers, 1870s–1930s

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

Linda Van Ingen
Linda Van Ingen*
Affiliation:
University of Nebraska-Kearney; e-mail: [email protected]
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Alone in her last phase of life, Sarah McComb copied a poem onto the back of a postcard that read, “And now… what wait I for? No home, no welcome, nobody who needs me; no love, to which in my loneliness I can turn. And now… what wait I for?” She died in January 1937, not long after she “fell and broke her thigh” the previous December. She was ninety-one years old. Her hospital bills and funeral invoice, like most of her expenses, were sent to her brother's daughter. Her old-age dependency on extended kin, however, was not inevitable. As a single, childless, white middle-class woman, Sarah had supported her independence through itinerant teaching, traveling the American west including Alaska, with additional adventures to Guatemala and Cuba. As she approached her sixties, she pursued alternative strategies for income, intensifying her efforts to earn a profit through business ventures while continuing to teach for as long as she could. Despite her determination, Sarah faced old age without savings of her own; she would not be able to finance her independence once she stopped teaching. When that time finally came, she was seventy-six years old and had to turn to her brother for help. Securing his support, however, was a proposition fraught with familial tension and personal anxiety. Although women like Sarah valued their independence, they struggled to carry this independence into old age.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 54 , Issue 2 , May 2014 , pp. 172 - 196
Copyright
Copyright © 2014 History of Education Society 

References

1 McComb, Sarah, Diary, , February 1926, in author's possession.Google Scholar

2 Hospital bills, December 1936 and January 1937; Funeral Director's Invoice, 2 February 1937; file 79, carton 2, Keyes-McIntire-Voorheis-Clark Family Papers, Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley (hereafter Keyes papers).Google Scholar

3 Carter, Susan B., Gartner, Scott Sigmund, Haines, Michael R., Olmstead, Alan L., Sutch, Richard, Wright, Gavin, eds., Historical Statistics of the United States: Earliest Times to the Present, Volume 1: Population (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2006), 78–79.Google Scholar

4 Single women of the same generation as Sarah McComb (1845–1937), such as Addams, Jane (1860–1935), Florence Kelley (1859–1932), and Anna Howard Shaw (1847–1919), collectively mark a new generation of female independence. Susan B. Anthony (1820–1906), also a single woman, belonged to an older generation of women leaders who mostly followed traditional patterns of marriage and children. Cemetery card, file 79, carton 2, Keyes papers; James, Edward T., James, Janet Wilson, Boyer, Paul S., eds., Notable American Women: A Biographical Dictionary (Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press, 1971).Google Scholar

5 The National American Woman Suffrage Association raised $30,000 to provide Shaw an annual retirement income of $3,200 ($267 per month) beginning in 1916 when she was sixty-eight years old. Harper, Ida H., ed., History of Woman Suffrage, Volume 5: 1900–1920 (New York: Arno Press, 1969), 458; Trisha Franzen, “Singular Leadership: Anna Howard Shaw, Single Women and the US Woman Suffrage Movement,” Women's History Review 17, no. 3 (July 2008): 421.Google Scholar

6 Riley, Glenda, Inventing the American Woman: A Perspective on Women's History (Arlington Heights, IL: Harlan Davidson Press, 1987), 167. The pay differential between female and male teachers varied by region and position, with high school teachers, principals, and superintendents—male-dominated positions—earning higher salaries than elementary teachers. See Joel Perlmann and Robert Margo, Women's Work? American Schoolteachers, 1650–1920 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2001).Google Scholar

7 Blount, Jackie M., Destined to Rule the Schools: Women and the Superintendency, 1873–1995 (New York: State University of New York Press, 1998), 92.Google Scholar

8 Ogren, Christine, The American State Normal School: “An Instrument of Great Good” (New York: Palgrave, 2005), 193; Barbara Miller Solomon, In the Company of Educated Women (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1985), 31–32, 119–20; Kathleen Underwood, “The Pace of Their Own Lives: Teacher Training and the Life Course of Western Women,” Pacific Historical Review 55 (November 1986): 513–30.Google Scholar

9 Blount, , Destined to Rule the Schools; Cordier, Mary Hurlbut, Schoolwomen of the Prairies and Plains: Personal Narratives from Iowa, Kansas, and Nebraska, 1860s–1920s (Albuquerque, NM: University of New Mexico Press, 1992), 49; Polly Welts Kaufman, Women Teachers on the Frontier (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1984); Ogren, The American State Normal School; Sklar, Kathryn Kish, Catherine Beecher: A Study in American Domesticity (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1973); Solomon, In the Company of Educated Women; Underwood, “The Pace of Their Own Lives;” Kathleen Weiler, Country Schoolwomen: Teaching in Rural California, 1850–1950 (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1998).Google Scholar

10 Weiler, , Country Schoolwomen, 18.Google Scholar

11 Kathleen Underwood finds over two-thirds of Colorado State Normal School female graduates in the 1890s came from small towns of less than 5,000 people. Most graduates remained in Colorado, with one-third returning to their small hometowns to teach. She also concludes that teaching gave these women the opportunity to postpone or forego marriage altogether. Underwood, “The Pace of Their Own Lives,” 519–21.Google Scholar

12 Søland, Birgitte, “Ages of Women: Age as a Category of Analysis in Women's History, Special Issue,” Journal of Women's History 12, no. 4 (Winter 2001): 6–10; Smith, Hilda L., “Cultural Constructions of Age and Aging: ‘Age': A Problematic Concept for Women,” Journal of Women's History 12, no. 4 (Winter 2001): 77–86.Google Scholar

13 Whitehead, Kay and Thorpe, Stephen, “The Function of Age and the History of Women's Work: The Career of an Australian Teacher, 1907–1947,” Gender & History 16, no. 1 (April 2004): 686–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

14 According to Whitehead, by the late nineteenth century in Australia, “the term ‘new woman’ had been coined to describe this cohort of well-educated, socially and economically independent single women.” Kay Whitehead, The New Women Teachers Come Along: Transforming Teaching in the Nineteenth Century (Sydney: Australian and New Zealand History of Education Society Monograph Series, 2003), 71.Google Scholar

15 Leroux, Karen, “‘Unpensioned Veterans': Women Teachers and the Politics of Public Service in the Late-Nineteenth-Century United States,” Journal of Women's History 21, no. 1 (Spring 2009): 34–62. For more on women's pensions and the emerging welfare state, see Theda Skocpol, Protecting Soldiers and Mothers: The Political Origins of Social Policy in the United States (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1992); Linda Gordon, Pitied But Not Entitled: Single Mothers and the History of Welfare, 1890–1935 (New York: The Free Press, 1994).Google Scholar

16 Epstein, Abraham, Facing Old Age: A Study of Old Age Dependency in the United States and Old Age Pensions (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1922, 1972), 183–9.Google Scholar

17 Kaufman, , Women Teachers on the Frontier, 39–40, Appendix D, 230–53.Google Scholar

18 Weiler, , Country Schoolwomen, 147–8.Google Scholar

19 Ibid., 127.Google Scholar

20 Drawing on Alice Kessler-Harris's insight about the role of biography in history, this article views Sarah's life “not as a subject to be studied for its own sake, but as evidence that could provide a different path into the past.” Jean Quataert and Leigh Ann Wheeler describe Kessler-Harris's observation of “‘see[ing] through” an individual life as a window on larger historical questions. David Nasaw similarly reminds historians that biography “is no longer restricted to the lives of the rich, powerful, famous, and infamous,” but can also focus on the “unknown” whose stories offer a “fruitful approach to re-examining, and perhaps reconfiguring,” categories of analysis “as they interact at the level of the individual.” Alice Kessler-Harris, “AHR Roundtable: Why Biography?” American Historical Review 114, no. 3 (June 2009): 626; Jean Quataert and Leigh Ann Wheeler, eds., “Editorial Note: Individual Lives: Windows on Women's History,” Journal of Women's History 24, no. 3 (Fall 2012): 7; Nasaw, David, “AHR Roundtable: Historians and Biography—Introduction,” American Historical Review 114, no. 3 (June 2009): 576.Google Scholar

21 In historicizing the ideas of economic fairness and documenting how these ideas changed over time, Kessler-Harris argues that the social and legal constructs of workplace fairness limited women's access to full citizenship. She identifies the need for economic citizenship, which she defines as the “achievement of an independent and relatively autonomous status that marks self-respect and provides access to the full play of power and influence that defines participation in a democratic society.” Women may have had access to work and the ability to support themselves, but economic citizenship “does not end there.” It also requires “customary and legal acknowledgment of person-hood” with “all that implies” for the “distribution of resources.” Alice Kessler-Harris, In Pursuit of Equity: Women, Men, and the Quest for Economic Citizenship in 20th Century America (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001), 12–13.Google Scholar

22 Cemetery card, file 79, carton 2, Keyes papers. Years and locations of teaching positions from Sarah McComb, “Record of Teaching,” file 95, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

23 Ogren, The American State Normal School, 195–8.Google Scholar

24 Although there is no indication that McComb followed the path of a missionary teacher, there is a history of women missionaries going abroad to teach. Ogren, The American State Normal School, 198.Google Scholar

25 Sarah noted in her diary on board the Granada that Jack “gave me a copy of ‘Burn's poems” and that she had spent “most of the time” with him while at sea. Many poems and letters from Jack also attest to an egalitarian spirit of endearment and passion typical of a companionate union. Sarah McComb, Diary, 18 April 1880, in author's possession; McComb, Jack to Sarah Voorheis, 18 August 1880, file 35, carton 1; Jack McComb to Sarah Voorheis McComb, 7 January 1883, carton 1; Marriage license, 30 January 1882, Alameda county, California, file 96, carton 2, Keyes Papers. See also Davis, Rebecca L., “‘No Marriage at All, but Simple Harlotry': The Companionate Marriage Controversy,” Journal of American History 94, no. 4 (March 2008): 1137–63.Google Scholar

26 McComb, , “Record of Teaching.”Google Scholar

27 The University of Michigan admitted women in 1870 and although many studied in professions such as medicine, dentistry, and pharmacy, “the vast majority of trained women” became teachers. Ruth Bordin, Women at Michigan: The “Dangerous Experiment,” 1870s to the Present (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1999), 21.Google Scholar

28 It is not clear how Sarah financed her education, but she likely benefited from her proximity to family in her home state and she also taught school in several Michigan towns during that time. Certificates of graduation and high school credits, file 114; McComb, “Record of Teaching;” Keyes papers.Google Scholar

29 At the time of Sarah's enrollment at the University of Michigan, the state had one state normal school in Ypsilanti, founded in 1853. It became a state normal college in 1899, five years after Sarah's graduation from the University of Michigan. Ypsilanti was unique for its courses in modern languages, in addition to preparatory courses typical of a normal school. The University of Michigan, however, had a champion for women in higher education in its president, James Angell, which may have contributed to Sarah's decision to enroll there, at the university level, instead of the normal school. Ogren, The American State Normal School, 88, 221; Bordin, Women at Michigan, 20.Google Scholar

30 Weiler, , Country Schoolwomen, 51.Google Scholar

31 “University of Michigan Teachers Certificate,” file 87, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

32 Nancy Beadie, “Toward a History of Education Markets in the United States: An Introduction,” Social Science History 32, no. 1 (2008): 47–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

33 Wyoming Territory also enacted a pay equity law but this did not necessarily ensure equal pay. Also, since the profession was increasingly dominated by women, wages for both women and men remained low. Glenda Riley, The Female Frontier: A Comparative View of Women on the Prairie and the Plains (Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 1988), 122–3; Weiler, Country Schoolwomen, 39, 153; Rankin, Charles E., “Teaching: Opportunity and Limitation for Wyoming Women,” Western Historical Quarterly 21, no. 2 (May 1990): 153, 158.Google Scholar

34 Jones, A. W., Principal of Public Schools, letter of reference, 1896, file 94, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

35 Smith, J. W., Co. Supt., Letter of Reference, 1908, file 94, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

36 Voorheis, Mrs. (mother) to Sarah Voorheis McComb, 14 May 1899, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

37 “Who's Who in ‘94,” University of Michigan Alumni, n.d., circa 1920s, file 113, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

38 Scott, Elva, Jewel on the Yukon: Eagle City (Eagle City, AK: Eagle Historical Society and Museums, 1997), 73; Scott, Elva, Historic Eagle and If's[sic] People (Eagle City, AK: Eagle Historical Society and Museums, 1993), 114–5.Google Scholar

39 The School Board also allocated $15 per month for a school janitor, no small gesture to Sarah's middle-class status. Her successor for the 1904–1905 school year, Miss Lois Adams, was listed in Eagle City records as “teacher and janitor” for the same pay they had allocated to Sarah. Elva Scott, Eagle Schools Eighty Years, 1901–1981: Alaska Educational Systems in Action at Eagle, Alaska (Eagle City, AK: Eagle Historical Society and Museums, 1981), 18–24.Google Scholar

40 McComb, Sarah to Voorheis, Jennie (sister) and Mother, Eagle, Alaska, 20 December 1900, file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

41 Alaska established a dual system of education by 1900 whereby white children attended “Territorial schools,” while “native” children attended underfunded schools run by the U.S. Bureau of Education. Frank Golder was a white man who spent three years teaching Aleuts in Unga, Alaska, at about the same time Sarah taught in Eagle City. Elva Scott, Eagle Schools Eighty Years, 13; Allen Wachhold, “Frank Golder as an Alaskan Teacher: 1899–1902,” Alaska Journal 9 (1979): 38–42.Google Scholar

42 Scott, , Jewel on the Yukon, 16.Google Scholar

43 The U.S. Army established a presence in Alaska following the purchase of the territory from Russia in 1867. Gold discoveries in the 1890s intensified the military's presence in the Alaskan interior. Army posts included Fort Egbert in Eagle City, completed in 1899 shortly before Sarah's arrival. Scott, Jewel on the Yukon. Google Scholar

44 McComb, Sarah to Voorheis, Jennie (sister) and Mother, Eagle, Alaska, 20 December 1900, file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

45 Letters of reference from Hinsdale, B. A., Professor, University of Michigan, 3 April 1894, file 94; Jones, A. W., Principal of Public Schools, Newaygo, Michigan, 1896, file 94; Common Schools of the State of Washington, Stevens County, 14 October 1912, file 88; School Board, Eagle, Alaska, 22 June 1903, file 94; carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

46 Ransom, Roger and Sutch, Richard, “The Labor of Older Americans: Retirement of Men On and Off the Job, 1870–1937,” Journal of Economic History 46, no. 1 (March 1986): 1–30; Ransom, Roger and Sutch, Richard, “The Impact of Aging on the Employment of Men in American Working-Class Communities at the End of the Nineteenth Century,” in Aging in the Past: Demography, Society, and Old Age, eds. Kertzer, David I. and Laslett, Peter (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1995), 303–5; Smith, Daniel Scott, “Life Course, Norms, and the Family System of Older Americans in 1900,” Journal of Family History 4, no. 2 (Fall 1979): 285–98.Google Scholar

47 Teaching positions were located in Sonoma, Lake, Shasta, Mariposa, Modesto, Ruth, and Colusa counties. McComb, “Record of Teaching.” A printed calling card identified Sarah as a teacher of “High School Branches” and “Modern Languages.” n.d., file 106, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

48 McComb, , “Record of Teaching.”Google Scholar

49 Epstein, , Facing Old Age, 189.Google Scholar

50 “An act to provide for the payment of retirement salaries to public school teachers of this state,” Statutes of California 1913, Chapter 694: Fortieth Session of the California Legislature (Sacramento: Chief Clerk of the Assembly, 1913), 1427.Google Scholar

51 Weiler, , Country Schoolwomen, 39, 49, 22, 153, 56.Google Scholar

52 McComb, , “Record of Teaching.”Google Scholar

53 California State Department of Education, 1927 Edition of Circular of Information Regarding Teachers’ Retirement Salary Law, file 77, carton 2, Keyes Papers.Google Scholar

54 The cost of shipping textbooks to Eagle City from the contiguous states, for example, involved paying a local businessman a “warrant of $150” to purchase and ship the goods while on a business trip “outside.” Scott, Historic Eagle, 114–5.Google Scholar

55 Cordier, , Schoolwomen of the Prairies and Plains, 183; Chris Enss, Frontier Teachers: Stories of Heroic Women of the Old West (Guilford, CT: Globe Pequot Press, 2008).Google Scholar

56 McComb, Sarah to Voorheis, Jennie (sister) and Mother, Eagle, Alaska, 20 December 1900, file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

57 Ibid.Google Scholar

58 Bargo, Michael identifies the laundry business as one of many entrepreneurial efforts by women in the West. Michael Bargo, “Women's Occupations in the West in 1870,” Journal of the West 32, no. 1 (January 1993): 30–45.Google Scholar

59 McComb, Sarah to Voorheis, Jennie (sister) and Mother, Eagle City, Alaska, 20 December 1900, file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

60 Ibid.Google Scholar

61 Ibid.Google Scholar

62 It is not clear why Sarah gave up her laundry business, but she may not have fully accounted for the hard labor and the costs involved, including two other employees. She also likely faced stiff competition from other proprietors, such as Anna Malm, a Finnish immigrant recorded in a local history as the owner of “Arctic Laundry,” which she operated soon after her arrival in Eagle in 1898. Scott, Jewel on the Yukon, 46.Google Scholar

63 McComb, Sarah to Voorheis, Jennie (sister), en route to Cuba, 20 December 1903, file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

64 For more on the Cuban land market, see Carmen Diana Deere, “Here Come the Yankees! The Rise and Decline of United States Colonies in Cuba, 1898–1930,” The Hispanic American Historical Review, 78, no. 4 (November 1998): 686–94; Santamarina, Juan C., “The Cuba Company and the Expansion of American Business in Cuba, 1898–1915,” The Business History Review, 74, no. 1 (Spring 2000): 41–83.Google Scholar

65 McComb, Sarah to Jennie Voorheis (sister), en route to Cuba, 20 December 1903, file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

66 Ibid.Google Scholar

67 Although many American investors anticipated U.S. military protection for their investments in Cuba, they never saw it materialize as such. Santamarina, “The Cuba Company.”Google Scholar

68 Deere, , “Here Come the Yankees!” 729–65.Google Scholar

69 McComb, Sarah to Voorheis, Jennie (sister), Cuba, 25 December 1903, file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

70 Ibid.Google Scholar

71 McComb, Sarah to Voorheis, Jennie (sister), Cuba, 13 January [circa 1904], file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

72 Ibid.Google Scholar

73 Contract for Deed, 3 March 1917, file 79, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

74 Reply from Mr. Harris, Monterey, written on letter Sarah McComb wrote to him in 1932, file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

75 It is not clear how or when Sarah acquired this property. “Last Will and Testament of Sarah E.V. McComb,” 17 February 1928, file 93, carton 2, Keyes papers; Booklet from Central National Bank, Oakland, file 78, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

76 Hareven, Tamara K. and Uhlenberg, Peter, “Transition to Widowhood and Family Support Systems in the Twentieth Century, Northeastern United States,” in Aging in the Past: Demography, Society, and Old Age, 273–299.Google Scholar

77 Obituary, Amador Ledger, 7 May 1925; Gibbons, Mary Clark, granddaughter of Edward Voorheis, interview by author, San Francisco, 16 February 1992.Google Scholar

78 Edward, C. Voorheis to Voorheis, Jennie, 10 August 1908; 7 November 1908; 24 November 1910. Edward, C. Voorheis to Aunt Mary, n.d.; carton 7, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

79 McComb, Sarah to Voorheis, Jennie (sister), Cuba, 13 January [circa 1904]; Sarah McComb to Jennie Voorheis (sister), on letterhead “Santa Clara Fruit and Cotton Co. Plantation, Santa Domingo, Cuba,” n.d. [circa 1904], file 36, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

80 Frances Voorheis to Sarah McComb, 31 January 1919, carton 1, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

81 Ibid.Google Scholar

82 Teaching experience in California listed in “Affidavit of Applicant for Life Diploma,” 8 September 1924, file 84, carton 2, Keyes Papers.Google Scholar

83 For discussion about a woman teacher's challenge to traditional patriarchal constructs, see Jackie Blount, “Spinsters, Bachelors, and Other Gender Transgressors in School Employment, 1850–1990,” Review of Educational Research 70, no. 1 (Spring 2000): 83–101; White, The New Women Teachers Come Along, 68–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

84 Gibbons, , interview by author. Edward may have resented the fact that Sarah's husband had not provided for his widow, that Sarah had married for love not economic security, that she had pursued individual interests and travel outside the norms of traditional womanhood, or some combination of these challenges to traditional patriarchal order.Google Scholar

85 McComb, Sarah, savings account books, circa 1915–1929, files 76, 78, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

86 Edward died in 1925, leaving property to his daughter who continued to support his many female dependents. Obituary, Amador Ledger, 7 May 1925; Memo “Enclosed please find check to your order for $50” from Baylies Clark (husband to Edward's daughter), 1929 to 1936, carton 1, Keyes Papers.Google Scholar

87 McComb, , Diary (poems written in handwriting of her old age on scraps of paper, inserted in Diary, undated), in author's possession.Google Scholar

88 Letter of certification from Westminster Presbyterian Church, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 30 August 1882, carton 1; Horoscope chart from the “Rathill's Academy of Occult Sciences,” New York, addressed to Mrs. Sarah E. V. McComb, Eagle, Alaska, file 91, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

89 Little Notebook, n.d. [circa 1936], file 97, carton 2, Keyes papers.Google Scholar

90 McComb, , Diary, in author's possession.Google Scholar

91 Gratton, Brian, “The Poverty of Impoverishment Theory: The Economic Weil-Being of the Elderly, 1890–1950,” Journal of Economic History 56, no. 1 (March 1996): 57–58; Haber, Carole and Gratton, Brian, Old Age and the Search for Security: An American Social History (Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1994).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

92 Abelson, Elaine S., “‘Women Who Have No Men to Work for Them': Gender and Homelessness in the Great Depression, 1930–1934,” Feminist Studies 29, no. 1 (Spring 2003): 686–94.Google Scholar