Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T19:52:00.288Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Winston Churchill and the Soviet Union during the Second World War

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Martin Kitchen
Martin Kitchen
Affiliation:
Simon Fraser University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

When thinking of Churchill's attitude towards the Soviet Union one automatically thinks of him as the most outspoken of the advocates of armed intervention during the civil war, or as the author of the speech in Fulton, Missouri, which many people regard as the opening salvo in the Cold War. During the war, however, when the Soviet Union became a great ally without whose help the war in Europe could never have been won, his attitude was bound to be quite different. Even before the Germans launched ‘Operation Barbarossa’ thus forcing the Soviets into the Allied camp, Churchill had been thinking of the Russians as possible partners in the struggle against Nazi Germany, for however much he detested the Soviet regime, his passionate determination to destroy Nazism was a far more powerful emotion, and, as he put it, if Hitler were to invade Hell he would promptly sign a pact with the Devil.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 30 , Issue 2 , June 1987 , pp. 415 - 436
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1987

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Gilbert, Martin, Finest hour. Winston S. Churchill 1939–1941 (London, 1983), p. 44Google Scholar.

2 Ibid. p. 50.

3 Maisky, Ivan, Memoirs of a Soviet ambassador (London, 1967), p. 32Google Scholar.

4 CAB 65–2, 85–10, 16 Oct. 1939.

5 CAB 65–5, 22–5, 24 Jan. 1940.

6 CAB 65–12, 68–4, 14 Mar.1940.

7 British Library, Harvey diaries, 14 Mar. 1940.

8 CAB 84–9, Ministry of supply to foreign office 31 Oct. 1939; CAB 65–6, 76–6, 27 Mar. 1940.

9 F.O. 371, 24840, 12 June 1940.

10 Hinsley, F. H., British intelligence in the second world war, (London, 1979), 1, 432Google Scholar.

11 PREM 3, 395–16, 22 Feb. 1941.

12 SirWoodward, Llewellyn, British foreign policy in the second world war, 1, 611Google Scholar.

13 F.O. 371, 29479.

14 Gilbert, , Finest hour, p. 1051Google Scholar.

15 CAB 65–8, 61–7, 19 June 1941.

16 Churchill, Winston S., The grand alliance (New York, 1962), pp. 314–15Google Scholar.

17 Gilbert, , Finest hour, p. 1122Google Scholar.

18 CAB 65–18, 62–4, 23 June 1941. For further discussion of policy towards the Soviet Union at this time see: Lawlor, Sheila ‘Britain and the Russian entry into the war’, in Langhorne, Richard (ed.), Diplomacy and intelligence during the second world war (Cambridge, 1985), pp. 168–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Ismay, H., The memoirs of General Lord Ismay (London, 1960), pp. 223, 225Google Scholar.

20 London School of Economics, D. N. Pritt Memoirs, p. 525.

21 Gilbert, Finest hour, p. 1133Google Scholar.

22 F.O. 371, 29467.

23 CAB 65–19, 67–1, 9 July 1941.

24 PREM 3, 395–16, Churchill 10 July 1941.

25 Ibid.

26 Woodward, , British foreign policy, 11, 16–18Google Scholar.

27 F.O. 371–29471.

28 Woodward, , British foreign policy, 11, 18Google Scholar.

29 Gilbert, , Finest hour, p. 1143Google Scholar.

30 CAB 65–19, 84, 19 Aug. 1941; F.O. 371, 29569. Kimball, Warren F., Churchill and Roosevelt: the complete correspondence, vol. I, The alliance emerging, October 1933–November 1942, (Princeton, 1984) p. 227Google Scholar, argues persuasively that aid to Russia was the ‘most concrete achievement of the RIVIERA conference.’

31 Churchill, , The grand alliance, p. 386Google Scholar.

32 Gilbert, , Finest hour, pp. 1182–4Google Scholar.

33 F.O. 371, 29489, 13 Sept. 1941.

34 F.O. 29471, Cripps 13 Nov. 1941.

35 CAB 65–24, fo. 33, Eden to Cripps 17 Nov. 1941.

36 F.O. 371, 29472.

37 CAB 65–24, 120–5, 27 Nov. 1941.

38 CAB 64–24, 133–8.

39 CAB 65–29, 17–5.

40 Taylor, A. J. P., Beaverbrook (New York, 1972), p. 511Google Scholar.

41 F.O. 371, 32877.

42 CAB 65–30, 68–2, 26 May 1942.

43 CAB 65–30, 73, 11 June 1942.

44 PREM 3, 392–2, Churchill to Roosevelt 27 July 1942. Roosevelt to Churchill, 29 July 1942.

45 F.O. 800, 300.

46 CAB 65–31, 118–2, 25 Aug. 1942.

47 CAB 65–31, fo. 123.

48 CAB 65–32, 135–1, 7 Oct. 1942, draft telegram to Stalin.

49 PREM 3, 392–3.

50 CAB 65–28, 162.

51 Woodward, , British foreign policy, 11, 547Google Scholar.

52 F.O. 954, 26 part 1.

53 F.O. 800, 301, Warner to Clark Kerr 16 Mar. 1943.

54 PREM 4, 30–2.

55 PREM 3, 354–8.

56 CAB 65–34, 56–5 19 Apr. 1943.

57 PREM 3, 354–8.

58 Ibid.

59 PREM 3, 354–9, Churchill to Eden 10 May 1943.

60 PREM 3, 237–11, Churchill to Clark Kerr 16 June 1943.

61 F.O. 371, 37033.

62 Harvey diaries, 27 Oct. 1943.

63 PREM 3, 355–4, Churchill to Eden 6 Oct. 1943.

64 PREM 3, 76–12, Churchill to C.O.S. 21 Nov. 1943.

65 PREM 3, 355–7.

66 Ibid. Churchill to Eden 7 Jan. 1944.

67 PREM 3, 399–6, Churchill to Eden 16 Jan. 1944.

68 Bryant, Arthur, Triumph in the west (London, 1959), p. 140Google Scholar.

69 CAB 65–45, 11–1, 25 Jan. 1944.

70 PREM 3, 355–8, Churchill 15 Feb. 1944.

71 PREM 3, 396–14.

72 F.O. 371, 48928.

73 F.O. 371, 43636, Roosevelt to Churchill 11 June 1944; Churchill to Roosevelt 11 June 1944; Roosevelt to Churchill 22 June 1944; Churchill to Roosevelt 23 June 1944.

74 CAB 21–1614.

75 Dalton diaries, 9 June 1944.

76 PREM 3, 355–12, Stalin to Churchill 23 July 1944; Churchill to Roosevelt 26 July 1944; Churchill to Stalin 27 July 1944; Stalin to Churchill 28 July 1944; Churchill to Roosevelt 29 July 1944.

77 Ibid.

78 F.O. 800, 414 for a record of Churchill's visit to Moscow.

79 PREM 3, 66–7 for the original of this famous document. See also: Resis, Albert, ‘The Churchill-Stalin secret “percentage” agreement on the Balkans, Moscow October 1944’. American Historical Review, LXXXIII, (04 1978)Google Scholar.

80 PREM 3, 66–7.

81 PREM 3, 397–3, Churchill to Attlee 18 Oct. 1944 quoting Horace, , Odes, 111, 40Google Scholar.

82 CAB 65–48, 157, 27 Nov. 1944.

83 CAB 21–1614, Churchill to Eden 25 Nov. 1944.

84 CAB 65–51, 7–4, 22 Jan. 1945.

85 CAB 65–51, 10–1, 26 Jan. 1945.

86 Churchill College, Cambridge, Cadogan papers, diary 11 Feb. 1945.

87 CAB 65–21, 22–1, 19 Feb. 1945.

88 Dalton diary, 23 Feb. 1945.

89 F.O. 371, 47585, Churchill to Stalin 31 Mar. 1945.

90 CAB 65–52, 40, 5 Apr. 1945. Smith, Bradley F. and Agarossi, Elena, Operation Sunrise (New York, 1979)Google Scholar.

91 PREM 3, 350–9, Churchill to Roosevelt 8 Mar. 1945.

92 PREM 3, 396–12.

93 F.O. 371 47076.

94 Bryant, , Triumph in the west, p. 478Google Scholar.

95 Ibid, p. 469.