Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-08T07:26:44.606Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

WARTIME AND POST-WAR RAPE IN FRANCO'S SPAIN

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 February 2021

ÁNGEL ALCALDE Open the ORCID record for ÁNGEL ALCALDE [Opens in a new window]
ÁNGEL ALCALDE*
Affiliation:
University of Melbourne
*
School of Historical and Philosophical Studies, The University of Melbourne, Victoria3010, Australia[email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

By examining the experience of rape in Spain in the 1930s and 1940s, this article explains how the Spanish Civil War and Franco's dictatorship dramatically increased the likelihood of women becoming victims of sexual assault. Contrary to what historians often assume, this phenomenon was not the result of rape being deliberately used as a ‘weapon of war’ or as a blunt method of political repression against women. The upsurge in sexual violence was a by-product of structural transformations in the wartime and dictatorial contexts, and it was the direct consequence, rather than the instrument, of the violent imposition of a fascist-inspired regime. Using archival evidence from numerous Spanish archives, the article historicizes rape in a wider cultural, legal, and social context and reveals the essential albeit ambiguous political nature of both wartime and post-war rape. The experience of rape was mostly shaped not by repression but structural factors such as ruralization and social hierarchization, demographic upheavals, exacerbation of violent masculinity models, the proliferation of weapons, and the influence of fascist and national-Catholic ideologies. Rape became an expression of the nature of power and social and gender relations in Franco's regime.

Type
Article
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 64 , Issue 4 , September 2021 , pp. 1060 - 1082
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

For their research assistance and/or their comments on drafts of this article, the author wishes to thank the following historians: Ángela Cenarro, Miguel Alonso Ibarra, Helena Andrés, Una McIlvenna, Holly Wilson, Miguel Palou, José María García Márquez, Juan Carlos Collado, Mercedes Peñalba. This research was partially supported by the project PGC2018–097232-B-C21 (MCIU/AEI/FEDER, UE).

References

1 Archivo Histórico Provincial de Zaragoza (AHPZ), Audiencia, 4074. This case was not exceptional; see Archivo de la Universidad de Navarra (AUN), Fal Conde, 133/187, 6 Huelva, ‘Higuera de la Sierra’.

2 Richards, Michael, A time of silence: Civil War and the culture of repression in Franco's Spain, 1936–1945 (Cambridge, 1998)Google Scholar.

3 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4074; Archivo Municipal de Sos, 014, Libros de Actas; Archivo General de la Administración (AGA), 44/2534; Cenarro, Ángela, Cruzados y camisas azules: los orígenes del franquismo en Aragón, 1936–1945 (Zaragoza, 1997)Google Scholar.

4 For a literary account, see Zabildea, Víctor, El delito sexual en España, 1944–1974 (Madrid, 1975)Google Scholar.

5 Brownmiller, Susan, Against our will: men, women and rape (London, 1975)Google Scholar; Vigarello, Georges, Histoire du viol (XVIe–XXe siècles) (Paris, 1998)Google Scholar; Bourke, Joanna, Rape: a history from 1860 to the present day (London, 2007)Google Scholar; eadem, ‘A global history of sexual violence’, in Louise Edwards, Nigel Penn, and Jay Winter, eds., The Cambridge world history of violence, iv: 1800 to the present (Cambridge, 2020), pp. 147–67.

6 Mullins, Christopher W., ‘Sexual violence during armed conflict’, in McGarry, Ross and Walklate, Sandra, eds., The Palgrave handbook of criminology and war (London, 2016), pp. 117–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Meger, Sara, Rape loot pillage: the political economy of sexual violence in armed conflict (New York, NY, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Herzog, Dagmar, ed., Brutality and desire: war and sexuality in Europe's twentieth century (Basingstoke, 2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hedgepeth, Sonja M. and Saidel, Rochelle G., eds., Sexual violence against Jewish women during the Holocaust (Waltham, MA, 2010)Google Scholar; Mary Louise Roberts, What soldiers do: sex and the American GI in World War II France (Chicago, IL, 2013); Zipfel, Gaby, Mühlhäuser, Regina, and Campbell, Kirsten, eds., In plain sight: sexual violence in armed conflict (New Delhi, 2019)Google Scholar.

8 Egido, Ángeles and Montes, Jorge J., eds., Mujer, franquismo y represión: una deuda histórica (Madrid, 2018)Google Scholar; Preston, Paul, The Spanish Holocaust: inquisition and extermination in twentieth-century Spain (New York, NY, 2012)Google Scholar; Graham, Helen, The war and its shadow: Spain's Civil War in Europe's long twentieth century (Eastbourne, 2012), pp. 35–6, 114–15Google Scholar.

9 Anuario estadístico de España (Madrid, 1946–7), pp. 1180–1. In the early 1940s, official statistics recorded some 2,400 ‘crimes against decency’ (including rape) annually in the entire country, yet these figures represented an extremely small portion of the reality of sexual violence.

10 Burgess-Jackson, Keith, Rape: a philosophical investigation (Aldershot, 1996), pp. 43–64Google Scholar.

11 Navarrete, Miguel Polaino, Introducción a los delitos contra la honestidad (Seville, 1975)Google Scholar.

12 José Caballero, ed., Diccionario general de la lengua castellana (Madrid, 1855), ad nomen.

13 Casañ, V. Suarez, Conocimientos para la vida privada (Barcelona, 1903), i, pp. 205–6Google Scholar. See also Bates, Victoria, ‘Forensic medicine and female victimhood in Victorian and Edwardian England’, Past & Present, 245 (2019), pp. 117–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 Cualla, Guillermo Uribe, Los delitos sexuales ante la Medicina Legal (Bogotá, 1944), pp. 5–8Google Scholar; Iwan Bloch, La vida sexual contemporánea (Madrid, Berlin, and Buenos Aires, 1924), p. xi.

15 Mario, José Ibáñez, Violación supuesta: defensa de un capitán acusado de tal delito leída ante el Consejo de Guerra de Oficiales Generales (Madrid, 1900)Google Scholar.

16 El Sol (Madrid), 13 Jan. 1928; Heraldo de Madrid (Madrid), 17 Mar. 1928.

17 Soller (Mallorca), 22 Nov. 1913.

18 Bourke, Rape, pp. 21–49; Mateo Orfila y Rotger, Tratado de medicina legal (Madrid, 1847), i, pp. 150–1.

19 The second part of the history of the valorous and witty knight-errant, Don Quixote of the Mancha (London, 1620), p. 299.

20 José García Rico, El médico forense: compendio de medicina legal, toxicología, frenopatía y antropología (Allende, 1923), pp. 52–3; Sydney Smith, Medicina forense (Barcelona, 1926), pp. 272–90; numerous books by the author Martín de Lucenay, including titles on ‘how to fake virginity’, popularized flawed sexual knowledge in the early 1930s; see de Lucenay, Ángel Martín, Cómo se imita la virginidad (Madrid, 1933)Google Scholar.

21 Revista Técnica de la Guardia Civil, 225 (1928), p. 591.

22 AGA, Justicia, 41/761, sumario 90.

23 Elisa Garrido et al., Historia de las mujeres en España (Madrid, 1997), pp. 417ff; Nash, Mary, Defying male civilization: women in the Spanish Civil War (Denver, CO, 1995), pp. 7–42Google Scholar.

24 Aresti, Nerea, Médicos, donjuanes y mujeres modernas: los ideales de feminidad y masculinidad en el primer tercio del siglo XX (Bilbao, 2001)Google Scholar; eadem, Masculinidades en tela de juicio (Valencia, 2010).

25 Ana Aguado and Teresa María Ortega, eds., Feminismos y antifeminismos: culturas políticas e identidades de género en la España del siglo XX (Valencia, 2011); Richmond, Kathleen, Women and Spanish fascism: the Women's Section of the Falange, 1934–1959 (New York, NY, 2003)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 Fernández, Daniel Macías, Franco ‘nació en África’: los africanistas y las campañas de Marruecos (Madrid, 2019), pp. 317–52Google Scholar.

27 Preston, Spanish Holocaust, pp. 82–90.

28 Timothy Rees, ‘Women on the land: household and work in the southern countryside, 1875–1939’, in Victoria Lorée Enders and Pamela Beth Radcliff, eds., Constructing Spanish womanhood: female identity in modern Spain (New York, NY, 1999), pp. 173–94.

29 Miguel Plou, Historia de Letux (Letux, 1989), p. 285.

30 Ángel Martín de Lucenay, Los delitos sexuales (Madrid, 1934), p. 32.

31 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4529.

32 Arxiu Històric de Lleida, Govern civil, Ordre public, 673, exp. 66.

33 Archivo Histórico Provincial de Sevilla (AHPS), Sala 2 Penal, L-3120 (1937). A similar case in 1940 in Archivo Histórico del Tribunal Militar Territorial Segundo de Sevilla (AHTMTSS), legajo 101, no. 1807.

34 AHPZ, Audiencia, 5162.

35 Ibid., 4904.

36 Archivo del Juzgado Togado Militar 32 de Zaragoza (AJTMZ), 2580/21.

37 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4448.

38 Archivo Histórico Provincial de Huesca (AHPHU), J2599, Libro de sentencias 1936–41, Sentencia 9.

39 AHPHU, J2601, Libro de sentencias 1943–4, Sentencia 18.

40 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4894.

41 AGA, Justicia, 41/1018, legajo 764, sumario 1133.

42 Eider de Dios Fernández, Sirvienta, empleada, trabajadora de hogar: género, clase e identidad en el franquismo y la transición a través del servicio doméstico (1939–1995) (Malaga, 2018).

43 AHPS, Audiencia, Sala 2 Penal, L-3131 (1944), Sentencia 238; AHPZ, Audiencia, 4863.

44 AHTMTSS, legajo 241, no. 4023.

45 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4473.

46 AHTMTSS, legajo 41, no. 2044; AHTMTSS, legajo 132, no. 4629.

47 AJTMZ, 1820.

48 AHPHU, J2600, Libro de sentencias (1942), Sentencia 8.

49 An example in AHTMTSS, legajo 527, no. 7704; see also AHTMTSS, legajo 33, no. 1695, and legajo 122, no. 2234.

50 Guereña, Jean-Louis, La prostitución en la España contemporánea (Madrid, 2003), pp. 317–19Google Scholar; Araujo, Jesús Mirás, ‘Rasgos básicos y transformaciones en el servicio doméstico en una ciudad periférica. A Coruña, 1900–1960’, Cuadernos de historia contemporánea, 27 (2005), pp. 197–221Google Scholar, at pp. 207–9.

51 Carlos Barciela, ed., Autarquía y mercado negro: el fracaso económico del primer franquismo, 1939–1959 (Barcelona, 2003).

52 AHPZ, Audiencia Penal, Inventarios 181 to 183.

53 Paul Preston, ‘The psychopathology of an assassin: General Gonzalo Queipo de Llano’, in Peter Anderson and Miguel Ángel del Arco Blanco, eds., Mass killings and violence in Spain, 1936–1952 (New York, NY, 2015), pp. 23–58.

54 Gibson, Ian, Sevilla, verano de 1936 (con las charlas radiofónicas completas) (Barcelona, 1986)Google Scholar; ABC (Seville), 30 Aug. 1936.

55 Koestler, Arthur, Spanish testament (London, 1937), p. 31Google Scholar; Cabanellas, Guillermo, La guerra de los mil días (Mexico, 1973), pp. 399–401Google Scholar; Gibson, Sevilla, pp. 84–5.

56 ABC, 23 Jul. 1936; see also El Sol, 24 Jul. 1936.

57 García, Hugo, ‘Seis y media docena: propaganda de atrocidades y opinión británica durante la Guerra Civil Española’, Hispania, 226 (2017), pp. 671–92Google Scholar.

58 Tuma, Ali Al, Guns, culture and moors: racial perceptions, cultural impact and the Moroccan participation in the Spanish Civil War (1936–1939) (London, 2018), pp. 110–16CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Francisco Sánchez Ruano, Islam y Guerra Civil Española (Madrid, 2004); Maud Joly, ‘The practices of war, terror and imagination: moor troops and rapes during the Spanish Civil War’, in Raphaëlle Branche and Fabrice Virgilli, eds., Rape in wartime (Basingstoke, 2012), pp. 103–14.

59 Sebastian Balfour, Deadly embrace: Morocco and the road to the Spanish Civil War (Oxford, 2002).

60 Ferreira, F. E. Rodrigues, ‘Os barranquenhos e a memória da Guerra Civil’, História, 18 (1996), pp. 40–51Google Scholar, at p. 48.

61 Cunha, Luis, Memória social em Campo Maior (Lisbon, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

62 La Voz, 9 Sept. 1936.

63 Preston, Spanish Holocaust, pp. 333–4.

64 Juan Carlos Collado Jiménez, La Guerra Civil en El Casar de Escalona: del paseo militar a la resistencia planificada (1936) (Toledo, 2008), p. 55; El Luchador (Alicante), 3 Jul. 1937.

65 According to Meger, Rape loot pillage, pp. 54–71, wartime opportunistic rape for ‘recreation’ purposes should be distinguished from the use of rape as a ‘weapon of war’. For a dissenting view, see Regina Mühlhäuser, ‘“You have to anticipate what eludes calculation”: reconceptualizing sexual violence as weapon and strategy of war’, in Zipfel, Mühlhäuser, and Campbell, eds., In plain sight, pp. 3–29.

66 Maestre, Francisco Espinosa, La columna de la muerte: el avance del ejército franquista de Sevilla a Badajoz (Barcelona, 2017)Google Scholar; Pura Sánchez, Individuas de dudosa moral: la represión de las mujeres en Andalucía (1936–1958) (Barcelona, 2009).

67 Muñoz-Encinar, Laura, ‘Unearthing gendered repression: an analysis of the violence suffered by women during the Civil War and Franco's dictatorship in southwestern Spain’, World Archaeology, 51 (2019), pp. 759–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

68 AHTMTSS, legajo 170, no. 7385.

69 Enrique González Duro, Las rapadas: el franquismo contra la mujer (Madrid, 2012); Julio Prada Rodríguez, ‘Escarmentar a algunas y disciplinar a las demás: mujer, violencia y represión sexuada en la retaguardia sublevada’, Historia Social, 87 (2017), pp. 67–83.

70 AHTMTSS, legajo 162, no. 6590 (8000).

71 Ibid., legajo 109, no. 3122.

72 Ibid., legajo 108, no. 3109.

73 AUN, Fal Conde, 133/187, 5.

74 AHTMTSS, legajo 134, no. 4724.

75 More examples in Francisco Espinosa Maestre, La justicia de Queipo: violencia selectiva y terror fascista en la II División en 1936 (Barcelona, 2000), pp. 223–6; AUN, Fal Conde, 133/187 and 133/188; Enesida García Suárez, Mi infancia en el franquismo: Tiraña, Asturies, 1938 (Oviedo, 2018).

76 Román Molada, ‘Mis recuerdos: historia de Bronchales’ (Castellón, 1990).

77 Archivo General Militar de Ávila (AGMAV), C. 2161, 4.

78 AHTMTSS, legajo 203, no. 9367 (8000).

79 Guereña, La prostitución, pp. 410–14. For a transnational discussion on soldiers’ sexual behaviour as a mode of dominance, see the Book Forum introduced by Surkis, Judith, ‘Introduction: what gender historians do’, Journal of Women's History, 26 (2014), pp. 129–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar, on Roberts, What soldiers do.

80 AGMAV, C. 1562, 62; C. 1563, 17; C. 1748, 7.

81 AJTMZ, 2569/10.

82 Ibid., 1956/16.

83 Ibid., 2580/21.

84 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4052.

85 Julián Casanova, ‘Del terror “caliente” al terror “legal”’, in Santos Juliá, ed., Víctimas de la Guerra Civil (Madrid, 1999), pp. 159–77.

86 AHTMTSS, legajo 184, no. 8136.

87 Ibid., legajo 199, no. 3471.

88 Ibid., legajo 112, no. 3286.

89 O'Neill, Carlota, Trapped in Spain (Toronto, ON, 1978), pp. 42–3, 49Google Scholar; Villalba, Juan Ortiz, Del golpe militar a la Guerra Civil: Sevilla 1936 (Seville, 2006), pp. 312–13Google Scholar.

90 AHTMTSS, legajo 104, no. 1869.

91 Ibid., legajo 187, no. 8354.

92 Preston, Spanish Holocaust, p. 450.

93 AJTMZ, 1401/1.

94 Archivo Histórico Provincial de Teruel (AHPT), Gobierno Civil, 2159/73.

95 Preston, Spanish Holocaust, p. xix; Ruiz, Julius, The ‘red terror’ and the Spanish Civil War: revolutionary violence in Madrid (New York, NY, 2012), p. 139Google Scholar.

96 Sola, Adriana Cases, ‘La violencia sexual en la retaguardia republicana durante la Guerra Civil Española’, Historia Actual Online, 34 (2014), pp. 69–80Google Scholar; Archivo Histórico Nacional (AHN), Causa General (CG), 1341, exp. 6.

97 AHN, CG, 199, exp. 46.

98 Centro Documental de la Memoria Histórica, PS Santander, Tribunal Popular de Euzkadi, 16, exp. 5.

99 AHN, CG, 200, exp. 1.

100 Ana Aguado and Vicenta Verdugo, ‘Represión franquista sobre las mujeres: cárceles y tribunales de responsabilidades políticas’, Hispania Nova, 10 (2012).

101 Archivo Intermedio Militar Noroeste (Ferrol) (AIMNO), Asturias, Caja 347(ii), 340/39; Marco, Jorge and Yusta, Mercedes, ‘Irregular war, local community and intimate violence in Spain (1939–1952)’, European History Quarterly, 49 (2019), pp. 231–49CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

102 España democrática (Montevideo), 18 Dec. 1940; España popular (México), 15 Aug. and 23 Nov. 1940, 6 Mar. and 23 Oct. 1942.

103 Ángeles Egido, ed., Cárceles de mujeres: la prisión femenina en la posguerra (Madrid, 2017); Núñez, Mirta, Mujeres caídas: prostitutas legales y clandestinas en el franquismo (Madrid, 2003)Google Scholar.

104 Molinero, Carme, ‘Mujer, franquismo, fascismo: la clausura forzada en un “mundo pequeño”’, Historia Social, 30 (1998), pp. 97–117Google Scholar.

105 Cuevas, Tomasa, Prison of women: testimonies of war and resistance in Spain, 1939–1975 (Albany, NY, 1998), p. 21Google Scholar.

106 AHPHU, J1548, no. 10.

107 Francisco Alia Miranda et al., ‘Mujeres solas en la posguerra española (1939–1949): estrategias frente al hambre y la represión’, Revista de historiografía, 26 (2017), pp. 213–36.

108 Jaume Morey Sureda, Artá: llarg camí cap el desastre (Palma, 2016), i, p. 401. On sexual bartering as a reflection of power mechanisms, see Anna Hájková, ‘Sexual barter in times of genocide: negotiating the sexual economy of the Theresienstadt Ghetto’, Signs, 38 (2013), pp. 503–33.

109 AGA, Justicia, 41/871, legajo 657, sumario 317.

110 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4053.

111 Archivo Real y General de Navarra (AGN), Juzgado Tudela, exp. 39 (1939). On Francoist veterans’ post-war masculinity, see Alcalde, Ángel, ‘El descanso del guerrero: la transformación de la masculinidad excombatiente franquista (1939–1965)’, Historia y Política, 37 (2017), pp. 177–208Google Scholar.

112 AHTMTSS, legajo 5, no. 227.

113 AGA, Justicia, 41/322, legajo 255, sumario 426. A similar case from 1942 in AHTMTSS, legajo 231, no. 3886.

114 AJTMZ, 1820.

115 AHPZ, Audiencia, 5156.

116 AIMNO, Asturias, Caja 406, 201/42.

117 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4778.

118 AHTMTSS, legajo 790, no. 11226.

119 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4889.

120 AGA, Justicia, 41/1012.

121 Mir, Conxita, Vivir es sobrevivir: justicia, orden y marginación en la Cataluña rural de posguerra (Lleida, 2000)Google Scholar. In 1939, the rate of proceedings for ‘crimes against decency’ as a proportion of population was up to six times higher in regions that had been in the hands of the rebels since 1936, such as Galicia, Canary Islands, Balearic Islands, and Western Andalousia than in Republican areas such as Catalonia and Valencia. See Anuario estadístico de España (Madrid, 1943), p. 1073.

122 AHN, Tribunal Supremo, Criminal, 7, exp. 1027.

123 AGA, Justicia, 41/1117, legajo 829, sumario 53; Archivo Histórico de Defensa (Madrid), 6018, legajo 3743.

124 AHPZ, Audiencia, 5162.

125 AHPT, Audiencia, 667/3.

126 AJTMZ, 1030/7.

127 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4914.

128 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4052.

129 AHTMTSS, legajo 255, no. 4203.

130 AHPZ, Audiencia, 4457.

131 Carmona, Álvaro Soto, ‘Huelgas en el franquismo: causas laborales – consecuencias políticas’, Historia Social, 30 (1998), pp. 39–61Google Scholar.