Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T08:12:29.789Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

VI. The Irish Question and Liberal Politics, 1886–1894

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

D. A. Hamer
D. A. Hamer
Affiliation:
University of Lancaster
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Between 1867 and the end of the nineteenth century the Irish question was one of the major issues in British politics. Between 1880 and 1893 in particular it achieved the status of the predominating issue, the great and abiding preoccupation of politicians. There would appear to be little difficulty for the historian in explaining why this was so. There were obviously abundant reasons in the Irish situation itself why politicians should have devoted so much of their time and effort to dealing with it—the urgent nature of Ireland's social problems, especially in relation to land-holding; the growth of Irish agrarian agitation so much better organized and supported than had hitherto been the case that it had to be met by a large and extremely time-consuming amount of coercion or land reform or a combination of both; the growing hold in Ireland of nationalism and of the demand for home rule; the new strength and cohesion of the Irish parliamentary party and its impact on British politics, both within the House of Commons and through the mobilisation of the votes of Irishmen in the non-Irish constituencies. Ireland clearly needed, and had the means of exacting, a very considerable amount of attention to its problems. The nature of the preoccupation with Ireland seems equally clear. The issues of land and local government reform, home rule, and coercion predominate in the thought and action of politicians with regard to the Irish question.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 12 , Issue 3 , September 1969 , pp. 511 - 532
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1969

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Young, K., Arthur James Balfour: The Happy Life of the Politician Prime Minister Statesman and Philosopher, 1848–1930 (1963), p. 128.Google Scholar

2 Irish Nationalism and British Democracy, (1951), pp. 184–5.

3 The Times, 22 Sept. 1891.

4 Brien, C.C.O', Parnell and His Party 1880–90 (Oxford, 1957), p. 210.Google ScholarCurtis, L.P. Jr., Coercion and Conciliation in Ireland, 1880–1892: A Study in Conservative Unionism (Princeton and London, 1963), p. 431.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

5 For a full account of these origins see Hoskin, D.G., ‘The genesis and significance of the 1886 “Home Rule” split in the Liberal Party’, CambridgePh.D. thesis, 1964.Google Scholar

6 Hanham, H.J., Elections and Party Management: Politics in the Time of Disraeli and Gladstone (1959),Google Scholar chapter 6.

7 Chamberlain, , ‘The Next Page of the Liberal Programme’, The Fortnightly Review, no. 94 (10. 1874), 413.Google Scholar

8 Morley, J., The Life of William Eviart Gladstone (1903), II, 502–3.Google Scholar For examples of sectionalism, cf. Dale, A.W.W., The Life of R. W. Dale of Birmingham (1898), pp. 281,Google Scholar 285–6 and , J.L. and Hammond, B., James Stansfeld: A Victorian Champion of Sex Equality (1932), p. 177.Google Scholar

9 Garvin, J.L., The Life of Joseph Chamberlain (1932), I, 161.Google Scholar

10 G. W. E. Russell (ed.), Letters of Matthew Arnold, 1848–1888 (1901), II, 129.

11 Cf. Briggs, A., Victorian Cities (1963), pp. 188–227.Google Scholar For the sources of this mystique, cf. Tholfsen, T.R., ‘ The Origins of the Birmingham Caucus’, The Historical Journal, II, no. 2 (1959), 161–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

12 Hanham, op. cit., chapter 7. R. S. Watson, The National Liberal Federation from Its Commencement to the General Election of 1906, 1907, esp. pp. 8, 15, 19, 20, 24. M. Ostrogorski, Democracy and the Organization of Political Parties, (1902), 1, 175, 183. P. Fraser, Joseph Chamberlain Radicalism and Empire, 1868–1914 (1966), pp. 29–32. J. Chamberlain, ‘A New Political Organization’, The Fortnightly Review, no. 127 (July 1877), 127–9; ‘ T h e Caucus’, The Fortnightly Review, no. 143 (Nov. 1878), 726–7, 730, 734, 737.

13 Gladstone to Russell, 20 June 1866, Russell Papers, P.R.O. 30/22/16, quoted in Smith, F.B., The Making of the Second Reform Bill (Cambridge, 1966), p. 114.Google Scholar

14 As reported in Gladstone to Granville, 22 Jan. 1885, Ramm, A. (ed.), The Political Correspondence of Mr Gladstone and Lord Granville 1876–1886, II (Oxford, 1962), 326.Google Scholar For Harrington in 1875 see Holland, B., The Life of Spencer Compton, Eighth Duke of Devonshire, (1911), I, 141–4.Google Scholar

15 Bear, W.E., ‘The Liberal Party and the Farmers’, The Fortnightly Review, no. 147 (03. 1879), 443.Google Scholar

16 For 1873–4, cf. Morley, op. cit. II, 480–2. For the ‘act of hara-kiri’ in 1885, cf. Curtis op. cit. pp. 19–23.

17 Chamberlain, ‘The Next Page of the Liberal Programme’ loc. cit. pp. 413, 418.

18 Lord Houghton, quoted in Hammond, J.L., Gladstone and the Irish Nation (1938), p. 164.Google Scholar

19 For Morley, cf. his correspondence with Chamberlain in Aug. 1873 in the Chamberlain MSS., Birmingham University Library, and in Garvin, op. cit. I, esp. pp. 146, 161. V. also Morley, , The Life of Richard Cobden, I (1881), 203.Google Scholar For Fowler, cf. Fowler, E.H., The Life of Henry Hartley Fowler, First Viscount Wolverhampton, G.S.C.I. (1912), pp. 230–40.Google Scholar

20 Fowler, op. cit. p. 384. Morley to Chamberlain, 18 Aug. 1873, and in a speech reported in The Times, 10 Dec. 1889.

21 Cf. Chamberlain, ‘A New Political Organization’, loc. cit. pp. 127, 130; and Gladstone's recollection of the quarrel in F. E. Hamer (ed.), The Personal Papers of Lord Rendel (1931), P. 93.

22 Ostrogorski, op. cit. I, 218.

23 Fowler, op. cit. pp. 239–40. Hamer, D.A., John Morley: Liberal Intellectual in Politics (1968), pp. 94–5.Google Scholar

24 Cf. Morley, Life of Cobden, I, 126–7, 142, 203–4; II, pp. 38–41, 112–13, 121, 384.

25 McCord, N., The Anti-Corn Law League, 1838–1846 (1958), pp. 16–17,Google Scholar 19–20, 41–3, 77–80, 111–12.

26 Morley, Life of Gladstone, II, 457, 498, 502–3.

27 Cf. his attitude to Leonard Courtney as reported in Gooch, G.P., Life of Lord Courtney (1920), p. 250.Google Scholar

28 Morley, Life of Gladstone, I, 479.

29 Ramm, op. cit. I, 40, 42.

30 Holland, op. cit. I, 149, 176.

31 Morley, Life of Gladstone, III, 248.

32 Chamberlain to Labouchere, 20 Oct. 1885, Thorold, A.L., The Life of Henry Labouchere (1913), p. 239.Google Scholar Gladstone to Chamberlain, 25 Oct. 1885, C. H. D. Howard (ed.), A Political Memoir 1880–92 by Joseph Chamberlain (1953), p. 132.

33 Childers, S., The Life and Correspondence of the Right Hon. Hugh C. E. Childers (1901), II, 234.Google Scholar

34 Gladstone to Granville, 12 Apr. 1878, Ramm. op. cit. 1, 70. On this preference for questions involving ‘higher interests’, see Shannon, R.T., Gladstone and the Bulgarian Agitation 1876 (1963), pp. 96–7.Google Scholar

35 The Times, 12 Nov. 1885.

36 The Times, 12 Jan. 1887. Russell, G.W.E., ‘The New Liberalism: A Response’, The Nineteenth Century, 09 1889, p. 494.Google Scholar

37 Watson, op. cit. p. 89.

38 The Times, 13 Dec, 21 June 1888.

39 Ibid., 20 Oct. 1886, 28 Apr., 21, 23 May, 18 Aug. 1887, 10 Oct. 1888. James, R.R., Lord Randolph Churchill (1959), p. 322.Google Scholar

40 The Times, 9 Aug. 1886. Cf. Gladstone, Herbert, ‘Ireland Blocks the Way’, The Nineteenth Century, 06 1892, pp 899 ffGoogle Scholar

41 The Times, 18 Mar. 1887.

42 Ibid. 27 Apr. 1887.

43 Cf. Morley, The Times, 12 Feb. 1887

44 Ibid. 25 Mar. 1890.

45 Ibid. 18 Mar., 20 Oct. 1887. Hamer, op. cit., pp. 203–5.

46 J. Newton, W. S. Caine, M.P.: A Biography (1907), pp. 167–8, 179–82. Askwith, Lord, Lord James of Hereford (1930), p. 190.Google Scholar

47 James, R.R., Rosebery: A Biography of Archibald Philip, Fifth Earl of Rosebery (1963), p. 191.Google Scholar

48 The Times, 23 May 1888, 18 Mar. 1887.

49 Gladstone, W.E., ‘Electoral Facts’, The Nineteenth Century, 11. 1878,Google Scholar Oct. 1887, Dec. 1889, Sept. 1891.

50 Rosebery to Gladstone, 11 Aug. 1889, Rosebery MSS., National Library of Scotland, Box 19

51 The Times, 19 Oct. 1887.

52 Ibid. 21 May 1887.

53 Collings to H. H. Fowler, 27 Dec. 1886, quoted in Fowler, op. cit. p. 219.

54 The Times, 7 Dec. 1887 (Arnold Morley), 5 May, 6 July 1892 (John Morley). Rogers, J. Guinness, ‘The Middle Class and the New Liberalism’, The Nineteenth Century, 10. 1889, p. 712.Google Scholar Hamer, op. cit., pp. 192–3.

55 Haldane, , ‘The Liberal Party and its Prospects’, The Contemporary Review, 01. 1888,Google Scholar pp. 145 ff.; ‘The Liberal Creed’, ibid., Oct. 1888, pp. 461 ff.

56 Cf. Spender, J.A., Sir Robert Hudson A Memoir (1930), pp. 21–2.Google Scholar

57 For a good example of the attitudes of Gladstonian ‘loyalists’, see A. J. Mundella to Gladstone, 15 Dec. 1885, Gladstone Papers, B.M. Add. MSS. 44258, fos. 211–15.

58 Morley, Life of Gladstone, III, 355.

59 Ibid. III, 225–6. Ramm, op. cit. II, 405.

60 Cf. Haldane's comments on this, Contemporary Review, Jan. 1888, p. 148; Oct. 1888, p. 474.

61 Ostrogorski, op. cit. I, 132–3. Hamer, op.cit., pp. 269–70.

62 Trevelyan, G.M., The Life of John Bright (1913), p. 443.Google Scholar

63 Hirst, F.W., In the Golden Days (1947), p. 169.Google ScholarAmery, J., The Life of Joseph Chamberlain, (1951), IV, 511–12.Google Scholar

64 Garvin, op. cit. (1933), II, 292.

65 Loc. cit. p. 903.

66 Poirier, P.P., The Advent of the Labour Party (1958), p. 32.Google Scholar

67 Webb, S.,‘The Moral of the Elections’, The Contemporary Review, 08. 1892, pp. 282–3.Google Scholar

68 The Times, 8 Feb. 1888, 24 Oct. 1889. Hamer, op. cit., pp. 228–30.

69 Morgan, K.O., Wales in British Politics 1868–1922 (Cardiff, 1963), pp. 90–1,Google Scholar 122–3, 139.

70 Arnold Morley to Gladstone, 24 Sept. 1890, Gladstone Papers, B.M. Add. MSS. 44254, fos. 34–5.

71 Arnold Morley to Gladstone, 30 Dec. 1890, 1 Jan. 1891, B.M. Add. MSS. 44254, fos. 65, 67. Harcourt to John Morley, 19 Dec. 1890, 6 Jan. 1891, Harcourt Papers, Stanton Harcourt, Oxfordshire. John Morley to Gladstone, 31 Dec. 1890, B.M. Add. MSS. 44256, fo. 104. Hamer, op. cit., chapter 17.

72 Wolf, L., Life of the First Marquess of Ripon, (1921), II, 196–200.Google Scholar

73 Ibid. Morley, Life of Gladstone, III, 457. Lyons, F.S.L., The Fall of Parnell 1891–91 (1960), p. 219.Google Scholar Memo, by J. Morley, enclosed in A. Morley to Harcourt, 30 Dec. 1890, Harcourt Papers. A. Morley to Gladstone, 30 Dec. 1890, B.M. Add. MSS. 44254, fos. 63–4. J. Morley to Gladstone, 31 Dec. 1890, 2 Jan. 1891, B.M. Add. MSS. 44256, fos. 103–4, 107.

74 Harcourt to Gladstone, 3 Jan. 1891, B.M. Add. MSS. 44202, fos. 48–9.

75 Gladstone to Harcourt, 14, 18, 22 July 1892, B.M. Add. MSS. 44202, fos. 157–8, 166–7, 176.

76 Charming, F.A., Memories of Midland Politics 1885–1910 (1918), pp. 129, 147.Google Scholar

77 Wolf, op. cit. II, 200–1.

78 Haldane to Sir A. West, 8 Aug. 1892, Haldane MSS. 5903, fo. 205, National Library of Scotland, Edinburgh.

79 Labouchere to Harcourt, 9 Aug. [1892], Harcourt Papers; Labouchere to H. Gladstone, 27 Aug. [1892], Viscount Gladstone Papers, B.M. Add. MSS. 46016, fos. 156–8.

80 Cf. above, note 75.

81 Spender, J.A., The Life of the Right Hon. Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman, G.C.B., I (1923), 124Google Scholar

82 Rogers, J. Guinness, ‘The Position of the Liberal Party’, The Nineteenth Century, 02. 1894, pp. 191–2.Google Scholar

83 The Times, 22 May 1894.

84 Cf., for example, Rosebery, Lord, The Pressing Question for the Liberal Party (speech at Eighty Club), [1895];Google ScholarThe Speaker, 17 Oct. 1896, editorial on ‘Party Discipline’.

85 Fowler, op. cit. pp. 384, 441–2.

86 The Pressing Question for the Liberal Party, pp. 9–11

87 Ibid. pp. 12–13. Lord Rosebery's Speeches (1874–1896) (1896), pp. 268–96, 347.

88 See, for instance, the editorials in The Speaker during 1894, and also the reports of Liberal and N.L.F. activity in The Liberal Magazine, II (1894), e.g. pp. 46–7,Google Scholar 50, 166, 204–17.

89 Cf. the complaints in editorials in The Speaker during the early part of 1895, e.g. 11 May and 6 July

90 Mallet, C., Herbert Gladstone: A Memoir (1932), p. 156Google Scholar

91 Rosebery to Canon Holland, 21 Aug. 1895, Rosbery MSS., Box 89.

92 Culminating in his ‘clean slate’ speech at Chesterfield, 16 Dec. 1901.

93 Cf. his memo, of 25 Aug. 1896, quoted in Crewe, , Lord Rosebery (1931), II, 522–3.Google Scholar

94 This theme can be found first enunciated in his speech at the City Liberal Club, 24 Apr. 1894. See The Liberal Magazine, II, 114.

95 The Times, 5 Feb. 1896.

96 ‘The Liberal Creed’, loc. cit. pp. 464–5, 474.