Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-30T16:56:45.313Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

VI. Lord Bryce and the First World War

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 December 2010

Keith G. Robbins
Keith G. Robbins
Affiliation:
University of York
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

James Bryce considered that 1914 would be a satisfying year. He had just been created a viscount and, at the age of seventy-six, could look back on a career of distinction in university life, politics and diplomacy. He could continue to write books and indulge in correspondence with his friends. In fact, the books were not written and his correspondence became very practical. The tension in Europe in the summer of 1914 caused many people to ask him for advice on the best course of action. What, in particular, were Liberals to do? Some M.P.s were talking of peace demonstrations to keep Britain out of European war, but Bryce hesitated. On the evening of 31 July, the matter was discussed with J. A. Spender who noted that ‘… Bryce … strongly advised not to join this demonstration. He agreed that violation of Belgium would be casus belli.’ When Belgium was violated, Bryce was committed to the war but his commitment was reluctant, hesitant and with foreboding. The consequences of his decision are the subject of this article.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 10 , Issue 2 , 1967 , pp. 255 - 278
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1967

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Lord Bryce to J. A. Spender, 31 July 1914, Spender MSS., British Museum Add. MSS. 46392.

2 Fisher, H. A. L., James Bryce (London, 1927), 11, 126.Google ScholarRichter, M., The Politics of Conscience. T. H. Green and his Age (London, 1964), p. 90Google Scholar.

3 Bryce, J., Impressions of South Africa (London, 1899 ed.), p. 477.Google Scholar

4 Lord Bryce to J. Burns, 5 Aug. 1914, Burns MSS., British Museum Add. MSS. 46303.

5 A picture of the Bryce mission is given in Percy, E., Some Memories (London, 1958), pp. 23 ffGoogle Scholar.

6 Bryce, Lord, Essays and Addresses in War Time (London, 1918), p. 5.Google Scholar

7 Ibid. p. 16.

8 Fisher, H. A. L., op. cit. p. 130.Google Scholar

9 C. P. Trevelyan to Lord Bryce, 2 Sept. 1914, MS. Bryce, Bodleian Library, Oxford. This collection of Bryce MS. is as yet uncatalogued. For the U.D.C. see Hanak, H., ‘The Union of Democratic Control during the First World War,’ Bulletin of the Institute of Historical Research (11, 1963)Google Scholar.

10 C. P. Trevelyan to Lord Bryce, 28 Sept. 1914, MS. Bryce.

11 Dickinson's approach can be seen in Forster, E. M., Goldsworthy Lowes Dickinson (London, 1962 ed.)Google Scholar.

12 G. Lowes Dickinson to Lord Bryce, 20 Oct. 1914, MS. Bryce.

13 Richard Cross acted as secretary of the group (Wilkinson, M., E. Richard Cross (London, 1917). PP. 39–42)Google Scholar.

14 Winkler, H. R., The League of Nations Movement in Great Britain, 1914-19 (New Brunswick, New Jersey 1952);Google Scholar a useful study based on printed materials.

15 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 17 Sept. 1914, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2, Bodleian Library, Oxford.

16 Lord Bryce to N. M. Butler, 1 Oct. 1914, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23, Bodleian Library, Oxford.

17 Fisher, H. A. L., op. cit. p. 132.Google Scholar

18 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 9 February 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. a.

19 Ibid. 1 Dec. 1914, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

20 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 15 Jan. 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

21 Ibid.

22 Lord Bryce to A. L. Lowell, 28 Feb. 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

23 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 15 April 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

24 Fisher, H. A. L., op. cit. p. 135.Google Scholar

25 Osgood, R. E., Ideals and Self-interest in America's foreign relations (Chicago, 1953), p. 229.Google Scholar

26 It is not the purpose of this article to examine in detail the various forms and theories of a League of Nations. Material on the detailed discussions of the Bryce Group does, however, exist in the Bryce Collection.

27 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 22 Oct. 1914, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

28 Lord Bryce to N. M. Butler, 24 March 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

29 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 1 July 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

30 Lord Bryce to A. B. Holt, 29 March 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

31 Lord Bryce to Noel Buxton, n.d. (early 1915), MS. Roden Buxton. Seen by permission of Miss Eglantyne Buxton.

32 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 8 Aug. 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

33 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 11 May 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

34 Lord Bryce to C. P. Scott, 4 March 1915, Scott MSS., British Museum Add. MSS. 50908.

35 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 16 Sept. 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

36 Lord Bryce to C. P. Scott, 26 May 1915, Add. MSS. 50908.

37 Lord Bryce to W. A. White, 7 July 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

38 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 23 Sept. 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

39 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 8 Aug. 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

40 C. R. Buxton to Lord Bryce, 11 June 1915, MS. Bryce.

41 Lord Bryce to C. R. Buxton, 25 lune 1915 (letter in author's possession).

42 Lord Bryce to E. M. House, 26 Nov. 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

43 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 4 Nov. 1915, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

44 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 29 Jan. 1916, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

45 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 7 March 1916, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

46 Lord Bryce to N. M. Butler, 27 April 1916, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

47 A. L. Lowell to G. Lowes Dickinson, 17 Aug. 1915, W. H. Dickinson MS., MSS. Eng. Hist. c. 402, Bodleian Library, Oxford.

48 Lord Bryce to E. M. House, 26 Aug. 1916, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

49 Lord Bryce to E. M. House, 27 Dec. 1916, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

50 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 7 Sept. 1916, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

51 Lord Bryce to C. P. Scott, 31 Aug. 1916, Add. MSS. 50909.

52 Lord Bryce to C. P. Scott, 3 Sept. 1916, Add. MSS. 50909.

53 Lord Bryce to C. P. Scott, 17 Dec. 1916, Add. MSS. 50909.

54 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 1 Jan. 1917, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

55 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 24 Jan. 1917, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

56 Lord Bryce to E. M. House, 24 Jan. 1917, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

57 Lord Bryce to B. Henry, 5 April 1917, Fisher, H. A. L., op. cit. pp. 159–60Google Scholar.

58 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 30 Jan. 1917, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

59 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 25 June 1915, Fisher, H. A. L., op. cit. p. 155Google Scholar.

60 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 19 Sept. 1917, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

61 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 16 July 1917, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

62 Lord Bryce to E. Root, 15 Sept. 1917, Fisher, H.A L., op. cit. pp. 173–4Google Scholar.

63 Lord Bryce to T. Roosevelt, 25 Oct. 1917, Fisher, H.A.L., op. cit. p. 176Google Scholar.

64 G. Lowes Dickinson to G. Murray, 20 Dec. 1916, MS. Murray. Bodleian Library, Oxford.

65 Lord Bryce to A. L. Lowell, 14 Feb. 1917, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

66 Lord Bryce to W. H. Dickinson, 21 April 1917, MSS. Eng. Hist. c. 403.

67 Sir R. Borden to Lord Bryce, 28 April 1917, MSS. Eng. Hist. c. 403.

68 Lord Bryce to A. L. Lowell, 20 July 1917, Fisher, H. A. L., op. cit. p. 166Google Scholar.

69 Bryce, Lord and , others, Proposals for the prevention of future wars (London, 1917).Google Scholar

70 Lord Bryce to W. H. Dickinson, 17 May 1917, MSS. Eng. Hist. c. 403.

71 Fisher, H. A. L., op. cit. p. 137.Google Scholar

72 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 14 Nov. 1917, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

73 Lord Courtney of Penwith to Lord Bryce, 29 Nov. 1917, MS. Bryce.

74 Lord Courtney of Penwith to Lord Bryce, 3 Dec. 1917, MS. Bryce.

75 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 8 Feb. 1918, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

76 Lord Bryce to A. L. Lowell, 8 Feb. 1918, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

77 Lord Bryce to A. L. Lowell, 1 March 1918, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

78 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 15 March 1918, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

79 Lord Bryce to A. L. Lowell, 5 June 1918, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

80 Lord Bryce to A. L. Lowell, 30 Oct. 1918, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

81 Lord Bryce to Anon. 18 Oct. 1918, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

82 Lord Bryce to J. A. Spender, 24 Nov. 1918, Spender MSS., Add. MSS. 46392.

83 Lord Bryce to J. A. Spender, 15 Dec. 1918, Add. MSS. 46392.

84 Lord Bryce to J. F. Rhodes, 20 Feb. 1919, H.A.L. Fisher, op. cit. pp. 213-14.

85 Lord Bryce to M. Storey, ao Feb. 1919, Fisher, H. A. L., op. cit. p. 212Google Scholar.

86 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 26 March 1919, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

87 Lord Bryce to C. P. Scott, 27 March 1919, Add. MSS. 50909.

88 Lord Bryce to C. P. Scott, 2 June 1919, Add. MSS. 50909.

89 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 4 June 1919, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

90 Lord Bryce to C. P. Scott, 14 June 1919, Add. MSS. 50909.

91 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 20 July 1919, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

92 Lord Bryce to A. L. Lowell, 18 July 1919, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 23.

93 Lord Bryce to C. W. Eliot, 20 July 1919, MS. Bryce U.S.A. 2.

94 Lord Bryce to M. Storey, 27 Nov. 1919, Fisher, H. A. L., op.cit. p. 232Google Scholar.

95 Lord Bryce to J. F. Rhodes, 6 Dec. 1919, Fisher, H. A. L., op.cit. p. 234Google Scholar.

96 Lord Bryce to Lord Gladstone, 19 Nov. 1919, Viscount Gladstone MSS., British Museum Add. MSS. 46019.