Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-03T01:19:50.078Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Legitimist Opposition to the Revolution of 1830 in the French Provinces*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Roger Price
Roger Price
Affiliation:
University of East Anglia
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The purpose of this paper is to examine the extent and character of the early legitimist opposition to the Orleanist regime. It seeks to demonstrate the secondary importance of their political loyalties for most of those with a significant material stake and status in the existing society. The basic theme is thus one of the effective formation of a conservative alliance pursuing the politics of selfinterest and prepared to sacrifice its ideals to do so. The cause of the legitimate monarch after 1830 could only have succeeded, and only came close to succeeding, if and when it promised to serve as the most efficient guarantor of social order. It failed because it appeared too concerned with ideology and ideals and not sufficiently with compromise, conservative unity and material progress. Its weakness was evident in 1830 in the manner in which its potential supporters reacted to the change of government.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 17 , Issue 4 , December 1974 , pp. 755 - 778
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1974

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Cf. Gonnet, Paul ‘Esquisse de la crise économique en France de 1827 á 1832’ Revue d'histoire économique et sociale 1955, p. 33.Google Scholar

2 Prentout, H. ‘Caen en 1830’ in 1830: Études sur les mouvements libiraux et nationaux de 1830 (Paris, 1931), pp. 49–54.Google Scholar

3 Contamine, H., ‘La Révolution de 1830 en Metz’Google Scholar, Ibid. pp. 56–63.

4 Villat, Louis, ‘Besançon en 1830’Google Scholar, Ibid. pp. 92–96.

5 Weill, Georges, ‘La Révolution de Juillet dans les Provinces’,Google ScholarIbid. p. 143; Rude, F., L'insurrection lyonnaise de novembre 1831 (Paris, 1969), p. 117 S.Google Scholar

6 Cf. reports of procureur-général (P.G.) at Angers of 30 July and of prefect of Haute-Vienne of 19 July in A.N. BB 18 1186.

7 Giraud-Mangin, M., ‘Nantes en 1830 et les journées de Juillet’ in 1830: Etudes …, pp. 116–17.Google Scholar

8 E.g. proclamation of the Municipal Commission of Orleans of 11 August in Archives historiques de la guerre [A.H.G.] E 5 1.

9 See a report of the P.G. at Rennes of 29 October 1830 in A.N. BB 1 1319–1320, and Girard, Louis, La Garde nationale 1814–1871 (Paris, 1964), p. 174.Google Scholar

10 Report of General Hulet d'osery, commanding in depts. of Calvados, Orne, and Manches, of 10 Aug. 1830 in A.H.G. E 5 1.

11 Report of the P.G. at Rennes of 29 Oct. 1830, loc. cit.

12 Reports of the P.G. at Grenoble of 18 Sept. 1830 in A.N. BB 1 1188 and of Marechal de Camp Laffitte from the Ariège, 10 Aug. in A.H.G. E 5 1.

13 In A.N. BB 18 1186.

14 Lt.-General Guyot report of 15 Aug. in A.H.G. E 5 1.

15 In. A.N. BB 18 1186.

16 Lt.-Gen. Delort in A.H.G. E 5 1.

17 Pouthas, C. H., ‘La réorganisation du ministere de l'intérieur et la réconstitution de 1'administration préiectorale par Guizot en 1830’ in Revue d'histoire modeme et corttemporaine 9 (1962), 243.Google Scholar Cf. Tudesq, A. J., ‘Les influences locales dans l'administration centrale en France sous la Monarchic de Juillet’ in Annali delta Fondazione italiana par la storia amministrativa (1967), p. 368.Google Scholar

18 Pouthas, , op. cit. p. 253.Google Scholar

19 Rousselet, M., La Magistrature sous la Monarchic de Juillet (Paris, 1937), pp. 73, 93–94.Google Scholar

20 Contamine, , op. cit. p. 60Google Scholar; Vidalenc, J., Le departement de I'Eure sous la monarchic constitutionnelle (Paris, 1957), p. 283.Google Scholar

21 Report of the P.G. at Aix of 10 Dec. 1830 in A.N. BB 18 1188.

22 Reports of the minister of the interior to the minister of justice, 20 Feb. 1831 in BB l s 1319–20 and of Gén. Roguet commanding the 7th and 9th military divisions from Lyon to Périer, M. Casimir, President of the Council of 21 Apr. 1831 in A.H.G. E 5 146.Google Scholar

23 Perreux, G., ‘L'esprit public dans les départements au lendemain de la Révolution de 1830’ in Révolution de 1848, XXI (1924), 24.Google Scholar

24 Higgs, David, Ultra-Royalism in Toulouse (London, 1973), pp. 89, 92.Google Scholar

25 Vidalenc, , p. 283.Google Scholar

26 Ibid. p. 284 and Pouthas op. cit. p. 258.

27 Report on the assizes held in the Charente during the 4th trimestre of 1830 in BB 20 50.

28 Vidalenc, , p. 254Google Scholar and Contamine, , p. 61.Google Scholar

29 Report of the P.G. at Rennes of 29 Oct. 1830 in BB 18 1319–1320.

30 Ibid.

31 Report of the P.G. at Angers of 3 Sept. 1830 in A.N. BB 18 1186.

32 Report of a commissaire in the dépt. of the Orne to the minister of war of 10 Aug. 1830 in A.H.G. E 5 1; cf. Girard, La Garde nationale, p. 179.Google Scholar

33 Report of Gen. Remond, 11 Aug. 1830, Ibid.

3 Cf. Tudesq, A. J., Les grands notables en France 1840–1849 (Paris, 1964), p. 185Google Scholar; Higgs, D., ‘Politics and Landownership among the French Nobility after the Revolution’, European Studies Review, 1 (1971), III.CrossRefGoogle ScholarDupeux, Georges, La Société Française, 1789–1960 (Paris, 1964), p. 107.Google ScholarBergeron, Louis, L'episode napoleonien (Paris, 1972), p. 137.Google Scholar

35 Gautier, E., Un siecle d'indigence (Paris, 1950), pp. 56, 68, 98.Google Scholar

36 Tudesq, A. J., Les grands notables, p. 134Google Scholar ff. This section owes much to his discussion on legitimacy, cf. Bois, P., Paysans de Vouest (Le Mans, 1960), p. 10.Google Scholar

37 See Tilly, Charles, The VendSt (New York, 1967), pp. 60–1, 80.Google Scholar For an appreciation of the complexity of the relationship between habitat and social consciousness see Meyer, Jean, ‘L'Evolurion des idées, sur le bocage en Betagne’ in La Pensée geographique francaise contemporaine, Mélanges offerts á André Meynier (Saint-Brieuc, 1972), p. 462.Google Scholar

38 See Tudesq, , Les grands notables, pp. 146–55Google Scholar and Armengaud, A., Les Populations de I'esti-Aquitain au début de I'époque contemporaine (Paris, 1961), pp. 340–4.Google Scholar

39 Ibid. p. 156.

40 Ibid. p. 185.

41 Cr. Marcilhacy, Ch., he diocèse d'Orléans au milieu du 19e siècle (Paris, 1964), pp. 249–50, 259Google Scholar, and Maurain, Jean, La Politique ecclisiastique du Second Empire (Paris, 1930), pp. 240–1, 323.Google Scholar

42 Tudesq, ., Les grands notables, pp. 188, 437.Google Scholar

43 Bois, P., op. cit. pp. 23–4Google Scholar - cf. Tudesq, , p. 143.Google Scholar

44 Becanuer, Jean, ‘Noblesse et représentation parlementaire (1871–1968)’ in Revue française de Science Politique, XXIII (1973), 581.Google Scholar

45 Cf. Faucheux, M. ‘La Vendee’ in Girard, L. (ed.), Les flections de 1869 (Paris, 1960), p. 151.Google Scholar

46 Bécanuer, op. cit. p. 979Google Scholar ff.; Bois, op. cit. pp. 13–16, 152Google Scholar, and Siegfried, André, Tableau politique de la France de I'Ouest sous la 111e République (Paris, 1910), p. 422.Google Scholar

47 See ‘Note sur les événements politiques survenus dans les années 1831 et 1832’ in A.H.G. E 5 135, Dubreuil, Léon, Histoire des insurrections de I'Ouest, 11 (Paris, 1930), pp. 323–37, 329–36,Google Scholar and Thureau-Dangin, Paul, Histoire de la Monarchic de juillet, III (Paris, 1888), 155–7.Google Scholar

48 Report of 4 Oct. in A.N. BB 18 1188.

49 See e.g. a report of the sous-préfet at Ploërmel (Morbihan) of 19 Aug. 1830 in A.H.G. E 5 1, and Thureau-Dangin, 1, 149.

50 e.g. report of Colonel de la Brun commanding the 4th legion of gendarmerie of 10 Aug. 1830, same loc.

51 Circular in A.N. F-1 cl 32.

52 See a letter from F. de Bertier to the duchesse de Berry of 16 Nov. 1830, in de Sauvigny, G. de BercierLa Conspiration des legitimistes et de la Duchesse de Berry contre Louis-Philippe 1830–1832 (Correspondances et documents inédites, Paris, 1950).Google Scholar

53 Report of the officer temporarily in command of the fourth military division of 9 Aug. 1830 in A.H.G. E 5 1. See also Blanchard, René, ‘Le 10e léger et la Révolution de Juillet 1830 à Nantes’ in Revue de Bretagne (1903) passim.Google Scholar

54 ‘Rapport du baron de Bordigné sur les dispositions des provinces de 1'Ouest et du Sud-Ouest’ of Oct.-Nov. 1830 in Bertier de Sauvigny, La Conspiration.

55 On the behaviour of the army see Richard Holroyd ‘The Bourbon Army, 1815–1830’ in Historical Journal, XIV, 5 (1971), p. 530Google Scholar ff.; Price, R. D., ‘The French Army and the Révolution of 1830’ in European Studies Review, III (1973).Google Scholar

56 Report of 19 Aug. in A.H.G. E 5 1.

57 Tudesq, A. J., Annali della Fondazione italiana per la storia amministrativa (1967), pp. 379–80, Higgs, op. cit. p. 99.Google Scholar

58 Leblanc, M., report of 19 Aug. in A.H.G. E 5 1.Google Scholar

59 Reports of the Rennes, P.G. of 10 Jan. and of the minister of war to the minister of the interior of 11 Jan. 1831, both in A.N. BB 18 1319–20.Google Scholar

60 See the Bertier correspondence.

61 Undated report, but Dec., in A.N. BB 18 1310–20.

62 Report of 24 Jan. 1831, same loc.

63 Report of 3 Dec. 1830, same loc.

64 Aguet, J. P., ‘Les Procès intentés aux Gazettes légitimistes en France au début de la monarchie de Juillet’ in Etudes de hettres (1961), pp. 67, 72, 87.Google Scholar

65 Cf. Price, R. D., ‘Popular Disturbances in the French Provinces after the July Révolution of 1830’, in European Studies Review, 1, 345.Google Scholar

66 General report of the 29 Oct. 1830, in A.N. BB 18 1319–20.

67 Minister of war to minister of the interior, 2 Dec. 1830, same loc.

68 Same loc.

69 Reports of Lt.-Gen. Boyer commanding at Tours of 9 Aug. and 10 Aug. 1830 in A.H.G. E5 1.

70 Report of the Maréchal de Camp commanding the Dépt. of 30 Aug. 1830, same loc.

71 Report of recruiting captain in the Deux-Sèvres of 27 Mar. 1831 in A.H.G. E 5 135.

72 In a letter to the duchesse de Berry of 16 Nov. 1830. See also the report of the baron de Bordigné, loc. cit.

73 In an undated letter of F. de Bertier.

74 See e.g. the general report of the P.G. at Rennes of 29 Oct. 1830.

75 Report of General Lamarque of 24 Nov. and minister of war to minister of the interior of 2 Dec. 1830 in A.N. BB 18 1319–20.

76 Epp, Rene, ‘L'évêque de Strasbourg, le Pappe de Trevern (1827–41) et la Révolution de 1830 ou l'episcopat français de la Restauration devant la monarchic de Juillet’, in Revue des sciences religieuses, 1971, pp. 349, 350, 355–7Google Scholar, and Pinkney, David H., The French Révolution of 1830 (Princeton, 1972), p. 311.Google Scholar

77 Report of the P.G. at Rennes of 24 Oct. 1830, A.N. BB 18 1319–20.

78 Ibid.

79 Ibid.

80 Report of the prefect of the Morbihan of 30 Nov. 1830 in A.N. F 1 CI 32.

81 Report of the P.G. at Rennes of 29 Oct. 1830, A.N. BB 18 1319–20.

82 Report of 14 Jan., same loc.

83 Ibid.

84 Reports of the P.G. at Rennes of 28 and 29 Jan. 1831, same loc.

85 Report of the captain commanding the gendarmerie at Vitre of 16 Apr. 1831 in A.H.G. E 5 135.

86 Reports of 12 and 14 Jan. 1831 in A.N. BB 18 1318–20.

87 Ibid.

88 Letter of the mayor of Vitré to the minister of the interior of 12 Jan. 1831, same loc.

89 Report of 7 Mar. 1831 in A.H.G. E 5 135.

90 Report of 18 Mar. 1831.

91 Report of the prefect of Deux-Sè;vres to the minister of war of 1 Apr. 1831, same loc.

92 The Baron de Bordigné in his report loc. cit.

93 Report of the officer commanding the 5th legion of gendarmerie from Vitré, 14 Apr. 1831, A.H.G. E 5 135.

94 Undated report of the gendarmes concerned in A.N. BB 18 1319–20.

95 Minister of war to minister of the interior, 2 Dec. 1830, same loc.

96 Ibid.

97 Report of recruiting captain of 27 Mar. 1831 in A.H.G. E 5 135.

98 Copy of letter with ministry of interior memo, of 16 Apr. 1831, same loc.

99 See e.g. Lewis, Gwynn, ‘The White Terror of 1815 in the Department of the Gard: Counter- Révolution, Continuity and the Individual’, Past and Present (1973), p. 134 ff.Google Scholar

100 Report of the P.G. at Aix of 10 Dec. 1830 in A.N. BB 18 1188.

101 Same loc.

102 Cf. Higgs, David, op. cit. pp. 72–5, 173Google Scholar and Jardin, & Tudesq, , La France des notables, vol. 2 (Paris, 1973), pp. 36–8.Google Scholar

103 A.H.G. E 5 1.

104 Report of the prefect of the Vaucluse, 3 Dec. 1830 in A.N. BB 18 1188.

105 Reports of the P.G. at Grenoble of 25 Sept., Aix of 10 Dec., Toulouse of 16 Nov. 1830, same loc.

106 Report of the P.G. at Nîmes of 20 Nov. 1830 in A.N. BB 1S 1315; Perreux, G., ‘L'esprit public dans les départements au lendemain de la Révolution de 1830’ in Révolution de 1848, xx (1927), p. 255–8Google Scholar, and especially Posener, S., ‘La Révolution de Juillet et le départment du Gard’, in Mercure de France, vol. 22 (1930) passim.Google Scholar

107 Report of the P.G. at Toulouse of 16 Nov. 1830, loc. cit.

108 Contained with report of the P.G. at Aix of 29 Nov. 1830, same loc.

109 Report of 15 Nov. ibid.

110 Report of the P.G. at To.ilouse of 17 Nov. 1830 in A.N. BB 18 1190.

111 Ibid.

112 Report of 30 Jan. 1831 in A.N. BB 18 1319–20.

113 Report in A.N. BB 18 1188.

114 Report of 11 Oct., same loc.

115 Report of 14 Jan. 1831 in A.N. BB 18 1319–20. See also report of Gen. Roquet, commanding at Lyon, of 2 Mar. 1830 in A.H.G. E 5 146.

116 Report of the P.G. at Toulouse of 16 Nov. 1830 in A.N. BB 18 1188.

117 See Forster, Robert, ‘The Survival of the Nobility during the French Révolution’, Past and Present (1967), p. 72.Google Scholar

118 Anon, I Sept. 1830 in A.N. BB 18 1186.

119 Report of the brigadier of gendarmerie at Longwy of 18 Aug. 1830, in A.H.G. E 5 1.

120 See a report of the P.G. at Aix of 10 Dec. 1830 in A.N. BB l s 1188.

121 Reports of the P.G. at Riom, Bordeaux and Limoges of 3 Oct. and 14 and 19 Aug. 1830 in A.N. BB 18 1186.

122 Reports of the P.G. and of the avocat-général at Poitiers of 7 and 29 Sept. 1830 in A.N. 1 BB 18 1186.

123 See Price, R. D.‘Popular Disturbances in the French Provinces…’, European Studies J Review, 1, 323 f.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

124 Report on the assizes held in the Corrèze during the fourth trimestre of 1830 in A.N. BB 20 51.

125 Reports of the P.G. at Nancy of 28 Aug. 1830, at Orleans of 6 Sept. 1830, Paris of 19 and 28 Aug. in A.N. BB l8 1106.

126 Same loc.

127 Letter to the duchesse de Berry of 16 Nov. 1831, loc. cit.

128 Op. cit. p. 123.Google Scholar

129 Cf. Gossez, Remi, ‘Critique des sources’, in Girard, L. (ed.) Les Conseilleurs Généraux en 1870 (Paris, 1967), p. 19.Google Scholar

130 Cf. Tudesq, A. J., ‘Les influences locales dans l'administration centrale’, p. 376 and also ‘L'administration municipale dans le Sud-Ouest sous le monarchic de Juillet’ in Annales dti Midi (1972) pp. 483, 489, 490.Google Scholar

131 See Dangin, Thureau, 1, 93.Google Scholar

132 Quoted by Tudesq, , p. 145.Google Scholar

133 See Chef d'escadron Peytier, ‘Répartition des troupes dans la 13e division militaire’ in ‘Memoire …’, of 21 Mar. 1848, in A.H.G. MR 1239.

134 See Price, R. D., The Trench Second Republic (London, 1972), ch. II.Google Scholar