Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-tf8b9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T22:19:57.989Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

FATHERHOOD, PROVIDING, AND ATTACHMENT IN LATE VICTORIAN AND EDWARDIAN WORKING-CLASS FAMILIES*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 November 2012

JULIE-MARIE STRANGE
JULIE-MARIE STRANGE*
Affiliation:
University of Manchester
*
School of Arts, Histories and Cultures, Samuel Alexander Building, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL[email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Histories of the late Victorian working-class family focus overwhelmingly on mothers. When men feature in family dynamics, it is within the context of their obligation to provide. Despite the familiarity of this model of family life, it is problematic, not least because it is partial. Written from a women's history perspective, such analyses have inevitably, and understandably, focused on the ‘dark side’ of breadwinning and privileged women's experiences as wives and mothers. Further, they have tended to make husbands synonymous with fathers. Drawing on working-class autobiography, this article revisits the cliché of the ‘good provider’ to suggest that children could invest the normative paternal obligation to provide with intimate and individual meaning, reimagining breadwinning as an act of devotion that distinguished particular father–child relationships within a context of more general working-class values. It does not suggest that women were not oppressed by the breadwinner ideal, or that attachment to mothers and fathers was the same. Rather, it calls for recognition of the fluidity of a sexual division of affective labour whereby, in memory at least, fathers' obligation to provide could be deeply embedded within an understanding of the emotional dynamics of everyday life.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 55 , Issue 4 , December 2012 , pp. 1007 - 1027
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I am grateful to Megan Doolittle, Daniel Miller, Michael Sanders, members of the Institute of Historical Research ‘Life Cycles’ seminar, and anonymous readers for the Historical Journal for feedback on verbal or written versions of this article. Financial support was provided by the Arts and Humanities Research Council (grant ref: AH/I001875/1).

References

1 The literature on breadwinning is vast. See Seccombe, W., ‘Patriarchy stabilized: the construction of the male breadwinner wage norm in nineteenth-century Britain’, Social History, 11 (1986), pp. 53–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Horrell, S. and Humphries, J., ‘The origins and expansion of the male breadwinner family: the case of nineteenth-century Britain’, International Review of Social History, 42 (1997), pp. 25–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Creighton, Colin, ‘The rise of the male breadwinner family: a reappraisal’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 38 (1996), pp. 310–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Creighton, C., ‘The rise and decline of the “male breadwinner family” in Britain’, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 23 (1999), pp. 519–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Janssens, A., ‘The rise and decline of the male breadwinner family? An overview of the debate’, International Review of Social History, 42 (1997), pp. 1–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lewis, J., ‘The decline of the male breadwinner model: the implications for work and care’, Social Politics, 8 (2001), pp. 152–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For breadwinning and marriage, see Joanna Bourke's lively account of women's imaginative navigation of power dynamics within the family, Bourke, Joanna, Working-class cultures in Britain, 1890–1960: gender, class and ethnicity (London, 1993), pp. 67–71Google Scholar. Ellen Ross's insightful analysis of working-class marriage notes that ‘good men’ were common but focuses on women's difficulties and resentments towards the ‘family’ wage, Ross, Ellen, Love and toil: motherhood in outcast London, 1870–1918 (Oxford, 1993), pp. 72–6Google Scholar. See also Roberts, Elizabeth, A woman's place: an oral history of working-class women, 1890–1940 (Oxford, 1995)Google Scholar; Chinn, Carl, They worked all their lives: women of the urban poor, 1880–1939 (Manchester, 1988)Google Scholar; August, Andrew, Poor women's lives: gender, work and poverty in late-Victorian London (London and Cranbury, 1999)Google Scholar; Honeyman, Katrina and Goodman, Jordan, ‘Women's work, gender conflict and labour markets in Europe, 1500–1900’, Economic History Review, 44 (1991), pp. 608–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Megan Doolittle, ‘Fatherhood and family shame: masculinity, welfare and the workhouse in late-nineteenth-century England’, in L. Delap, B. Griffin and A. Wills, eds., The politics of domestic authority in Britain since 1800 (Basingstoke and New York, NY, 2009), pp. 84–108.

2 See C. Pateman, ‘The patriarchal welfare state’, in C. Pateman, ed., The disorder of women: democracy, feminism and political theory (Cambridge, 1989), pp. 179–209; Clark, Anna, ‘The New Poor Law and the breadwinner wage: contrasting assumptions’, Journal of Social History, 34 (2000), pp. 261–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Levine-Clark, M., ‘The gendered economy of family liability: intergenerational relationships and poor law relief in England's Black Country, 1871–1911’, Journal of British Studies, 45 (2006), pp. 72–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Warren, Tracey, ‘Conceptualising breadwinning work’, Work, Employment and Society, 21 (2007), pp. 317–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Pioneers in the field of the history of emotion call for an integration of emotion into existing fields of study. See Plamper, Jan, ‘The history of emotions: an interview with William Reddy, Barbara Rosenwein, and Peter Stearns’, History and Theory, 49 (2010), pp. 237–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For introduction to the history of emotion see Reddy, William, The navigation of feeling: a framework for the history of emotions (Cambridge, 2001)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bourke, Joanna, ‘Fear and anxiety: writing about emotion in modern history’, History Workshop Journal, 55 (2003), pp. 111–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Roper, Michael, ‘Slipping out of view: subjectivity and emotion in gender history’, History Workshop Journal, 59 (2005), pp. 57–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Tosh, John, ‘What should historians do with masculinity? Reflection on nineteenth-century Britain’, History Workshop Journal, 38 (1994), pp. 179–202CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Tosh, J., A man's place: masculinity and the middle-class home in Victorian England (New York, NY, and London, 1999)Google Scholar; Gordon, Eleanor and Nair, Gwyneth, ‘Domestic fathers and the Victorian parental role’, Women's History Review, 15 (2006), pp. 551–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sanders, Valerie, The tragi-comedy of Victorian fatherhood (Cambridge, 2009)Google Scholar; Olsen, S., ‘The authority of motherhood in question: fatherhood and the moral education of children in England’, Women's History Review, 18 (2009), pp. 765–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bailey, Joanne, ‘A very sensible man: imagining fatherhood in England, 1750–1830’, History, 95 (2010), pp. 267–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Francis, Martin, ‘Tears, tantrums and bared teeth: the emotional economy of three Conservative prime ministers, 1951–1963’, Journal of British Studies, 41 (2002), pp. 354–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Gillis, John, A world of their own making: myth, ritual and the quest for family values (Cambridge, 1996), p. 179Google Scholar. There are a few exceptions, mostly focused on the twentieth century. See Fisher, Tim, ‘Fatherhood and the British Fathercraft Movement, 1919–1939’, Gender and History, 17 (2005), pp. 441–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and King, Laura, ‘Hidden fathers? The significance of fatherhood in mid-twentieth-century Britain’, Contemporary British History, 26 (2012), 25–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 This is the classic social history line on family and household economy. See Roberts, A woman's place; Bourke, Working-class cultures; Davies, A., Leisure, gender and poverty: working-class culture in Salford and Manchester, 1900–1939 (Milton Keynes, 1992)Google Scholar; Ittmann, Karl, Work, gender and family in Victorian England (London, 1994)Google Scholar; Seccombe, W., Weathering the storm: working-class families from the industrial revolution to the fertility decline (London, 1993)Google Scholar.

8 Andrew Walker also makes this point, noting that Chinn's index entry for ‘father’ takes readers to pages on men's general role in households. A. Walker, ‘Father's pride? Fatherhood in industrialising communities’, in T. Broughton and H. Rogers, eds., Gender and fatherhood in the nineteenth century (Basingstoke, 2007), pp. 113–25.

9 For use of autobiography as empirical evidence of childhood see Humphries, Jane, Childhood and child labour in the British industrial revolution (Cambridge, 2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Ross, Love and toil, pp. 3–10.

11 See for instance, Bryson, Elizabeth, Look back in wonder (Dundee, 1966), p. 29Google Scholar, and Foakes, Grace, Four meals for fourpence: a heart-warming tale of family life in London's old East End (London, 2011), pp. 15–25Google Scholar, 37–52.

12 See, for example, Foley, Alice, A Bolton childhood (Manchester, 1973), pp. 3–4Google Scholar, 8; Woodward, Kathleen, Jipping Street (London, 1983), pp. 6–7Google Scholar; and Lawson, Jack, A man's life (London, 1932), pp. 14–16Google Scholar.

13 Vincent, D., Bread, knowledge and freedom: a study of nineteenth-century working-class autobiography (London and New York, NY, 1981), pp. 62–86Google Scholar.

14 To the workers of the world: an appeal for personal religion by eight members of parliament (London, 1913), p. 34.

15 Hackett, Nan, ‘A different form of self: narrative style in British nineteenth-century working-class autobiography’, Biography, 12 (1989), pp. 208–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Gagnier, Regenia, Subjectivities: a history of self-representation, 1832–1920 (Oxford, 1991)Google Scholar, p. 139.

16 Morrison, Herbert, An autobiography (London, 1960), pp. 11–12Google Scholar, 16–17.

17 Foakes, Four meals, pp. 26–36.

18 See Miller, Daniel, A theory of shopping (London, 1998)Google Scholar.

19 Taylor, Lord, Uphill all the way: a miner's struggle (London, 1972)Google Scholar, p. 4.

20 Aldred, Guy, No traitor's gate! The autobiography of Guy A. Aldred (London, 1955)Google Scholar, pp. 13, 22.

21 Lawson, Man's life, pp. 9–11.

22 Roper, Michael, The secret battle: emotional survival in the Great War (Manchester, 2009)Google Scholar, p. 23.

23 Taylor, Uphill all the way, p. 4.

24 See Candace Clark, ‘Emotions and micro-politics in everyday life: some patterns and paradoxes of “place”’, in T. Kemper, ed., Research agendas in the sociology of emotions (Albany, NY, 1990), pp. 305–34.

25 Gagnier, Subjectivities, p. 144.

26 Lawson, Man's life, p. 13.

27 Ibid., pp. 9–10.

28 Gagnier, Subjectivities, p. 161.

29 Walter Benjamin, ‘Theses on the philosophy of history’, xii. See Eagleton, T., Walter Benjamin, or towards a revolutionary criticism (London, 1981)Google Scholar, p. 147.

30 Jackson, T. A., Solo trumpet (London, 1953)Google Scholar, p. 38.

31 See Gosling, Harry, Up and down stream (London, 1927), pp. 6–20Google Scholar; Christie, A. V., Brass tacks and a fiddle: reminiscences (Kilmarnock, 1943)Google Scholar, p. 14.

32 Grossek, Mark, First movement (London, 1937), pp. 119–21Google Scholar.

33 See especially Andrews, Elizabeth, A woman's work is never done (Dinas Powys, 2006; orig. publ. 1967), pp. 8–14Google Scholar.

34 A prime example is the pathetic music hall song, ‘Don't go down the mine, Dad’, printed on Bamforth postcards and performed in magic lantern shows. See, for instance, Slater, Lilian, Think on! Said Mam: a childhood in Bradford, Manchester, 1911–1919 (Manchester, 1984)Google Scholar, p. 47; Screening the poor, 1888–1914, curated by Martin Loiperdinger and Ludwig Vogl-Bienek (DVD-ROM, Edition Filmmuseum, 2011); and British Library sound recording at http://sounds.bl.uk/World-and-traditional-music/Traditional-music-in-England/025M-C1023X0014XX-1400V0 (accessed 10 May 2012).

35 Edwards, Wil, From the valley I came: reminiscences of the author's life up to 1926, with special reference to his mother (London, 1956), pp. 4–8Google Scholar, 34.

36 Taylor, Uphill all the way, p. 4.

37 Muir, Edwin, An autobiography (London, 1954), pp. 90–3Google Scholar.

38 Strange, Julie-Marie, ‘Fatherhood, furniture and the interpersonal dynamics of working-class homes, c. 1870–1914’, Urban History, forthcomingGoogle Scholar.

39 Kirkwood, David, My life of revolt (London, 1935), pp. 52–3Google Scholar.

40 See Clark, Candace, Misery and company: sympathy in everyday life (Chicago, IL, and London, 1997), pp. 229–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

41 Kirkwood, Life of revolt, pp. 52–3.

42 For discussion of the plurality of emotional communities, see Rosenwein, Barbara, Emotional communities in the middle ages (New York, NY, and London, 2006)Google Scholar, and Rosenwein's discussion of ‘emotional communities’ (as distinct from William Reddy's ‘emotional regimes’) in Plamper, ‘The history of emotions’, at pp. 252–4.

43 Dermott, Esther, Intimate fatherhood: a sociological analysis (London, 2008), pp. 25–42Google Scholar.

44 Bryson, Look back in wonder, p. 89.

45 Llewellyn, Michael, Sand in the glass (London, 1943), p. 84Google Scholar.

46 Southgate, Walter, That's the way it was (Oxford, 1982), p. 12Google Scholar.

47 This tension was played on by a conservative press who portrayed men as selfish and starving their children. See Croll, A. J., ‘Starving strikers and the limits of the “humanitarian discovery of hunger” in late-Victorian Britain’, International Review of Social History, 561 (2011), pp. 103–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

48 Jones, Jack, Unfinished journey (New York, NY, 1937), pp. 65–9, 72Google Scholar.

49 Ibid., pp. 64–77.

50 For example, Baldry, George, The rabbit skin cap: a tale of a Norfolk countryman's youth (Ipswich, 1974), p. 57Google Scholar; Stamper, Joseph, So long ago (London, 1960), pp. 21, 107–8Google Scholar; Harris, Harry, Under oars: reminiscences of a Thames lighterman, 1894–1909 (London, 1978)Google Scholar, p. 39; Citrine, Walter, Men and work: an autobiography (London, 1964), pp. 13–18Google Scholar.

51 Loane, M., From their point of view (London, 1908), pp. 155–6Google Scholar.

52 Jones, Lewis, Cwmardy: the story of a Welsh mining valley (Cardigan, 2006; orig. publ. 1937), pp. 137–66Google Scholar.

53 Britten, Barnabas, Woodyard to palace: reminiscences (Bradford, 1958), pp. 191–2Google Scholar.

54 Lax, W. M., His book: the autobiography of Lax of Poplar (London, 1937), p. 89Google Scholar.

55 Kirkwood, Life of revolt, p. 24.

56 See for instance, Campion, Sidney, Sunlight on the foothills (London, 1941), pp. 29–38Google Scholar; Ratcliffe, George, Sixty years of it: being the story of my life and public career (London, 1935), pp. 5, 35Google Scholar.

57 Eldred, John, I love the Brooks: reminiscences (London, 1955), pp. 86–8Google Scholar.

58 A notable exception is Armstrong, Chester, Pilgramage from Nenthead: an autobiography (London, 1938)Google Scholar.

59 For feckless dads as motors to ‘good’ fathering, see Royce, James, I stand nude (London, 1937)Google Scholar, and Shaw, Sam, Guttersnipe: an autobiography (London, 1946)Google Scholar. Other writers' contrasted their father's faults with their peers' fathers to suggest a blueprint for fathering. See Garrett, V., A man in the street (London, 1939), p. 72Google Scholar, and Roberts, Robert, A classic slum: Salford life in the first quarter of the century (London, 1971), p. 117Google Scholar.

60 Jones, Unfinished journey, pp. 127–35.

61 Dayus, Kathleen, Her people (London, 1982), pp. 11–13Google Scholar.

62 Aldred, No traitor's gait, p. 13.

63 Eldred, I love the Brooks, pp. 162–3.

64 Steedman, Carolyn, Past tenses: articles on writing, autobiography and history (London, 1992), pp. 21–40Google Scholar.

65 Ross, Love and toil, pp. 166–94.

66 Eldred, I love the Brooks, pp. 161–5.

67 Gillis, A world of their own, p. 196.

68 Indeed, anthropological research into post-Soviet Cuba demonstrates how female breadwinners appropriate state ideologies of ‘struggle’ to express individual agency, claim personal virtues, and narrate a particular sense of self. See Anna Pertierra, ‘Creating order through struggle in revolutionary Cuba’, in Daniel Miller, ed., Anthropology and the individual: a material culture perspective (Oxford, 2009), pp. 145–58.

69 See for instance, Keating, Joseph, My struggle for life (London, 1916)Google Scholar.