Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dk4vv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T13:23:19.980Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Auctions and the Making of the Nabob in Late Eighteenth-Century Calcutta and London

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 April 2021

Patrick D. Rasico*
Affiliation:
Department of History and Political Science, Fisk University, Nashville, TN, USA

Abstract

This article examines the meanings and controversies surrounding sales by public auction in British colonial Calcutta and in London during the last decades of the eighteenth century. For Britons living in Calcutta's European sector, auctions were essential for acquiring imported European items that granted a sense of gentility and Britishness abroad. Public sales in Calcutta provided Britons with goods that instilled the fantasy of living in a British geography in India. However, by the last quarter of the century, ‘sales by hammer’ throughout the colonial world carried association with corruption, cruelty, and orientalization in the metropolitan imagination. In Britain, textual and visual accounts circulated of Europeans transforming into debauched ‘nabobs’, of the horrors of American slave auctions, and of the British East India Company's use of public sales to defraud and abuse prominent Indians. For some metropolitan observers, sales by hammer were a deceitful means of seizing property and status from the traditional landed elite of India and Britain. British critics feared that colonial auction practices could become common in Britain and could lead to the upending of social hierarchization and the normalization of slavery in the metropolis.

Type
Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Anonymous, ‘To be sold by auction by Mr. Bonfield’, Calcutta Gazette (Calcutta, India), 3 Mar. 1785; Anonymous, ‘To be sold by Messrs. Williams and Lee at the Old Court House’, Calcutta Gazette, 21 Apr. 1785.

2 ‘Europe shops’ were retailers of recently imported goods from Europe. Williamson, Thomas, The East India vade-mecum; or, complete guide to gentlemen (2 vols., London, 1810), II, pp. 169–70Google Scholar; Anonymous, ‘Inventories: household goods of Warren Hastings at Daylesford’, British Library (BL) Add MS 41609.

3 Anonymous, ‘Account sale of sundries sold at public outcry…on account of the estate of Lt. Colonel John Green’, 20–5 July 1784, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/6.

4 This article employs the contemporary usage of the term ‘Anglo-Indian’ as specifying a Briton who spent considerable time in South Asian geographies, climates, and cultural milieus. Since there was not a singular, coherent definition of Britishness, Anglo-Indians used this term and the word ‘British’ to self-identify.

5 Swati Chattopadhyay claims that although Calcutta residents used the terms ‘black town’ and ‘white town’ when referring to certain regions of the city, there was not a clear separation of these geographies and social spheres. Chattopadhyay, Swati, ‘Blurring boundaries: the limits of “white town” in colonial Calcutta’, Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, 59 (2000), pp. 154–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Wall, Cynthia, ‘The English auction: narratives of dismantlings’, Eighteenth-Century Studies, 31 (1997), pp. 125CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 The term ‘nabob’ had its origins in the Persian word ‘nawab’, meaning governor or deputy.

8 Burke, Edmund, ‘Speech on opening of impeachment’, in Marshall, P. J., ed., The writings and speeches of Edmund Burke (9 vols., Oxford, 1991–2015), VI, p. 382Google Scholar.

9 Colson, Percy, A story of Christies (London, 1950)Google Scholar; Faith, Nicholas, Sold: the rise and fall of the house of Sotheby (New York, NY, 1985)Google Scholar; Herrman, Frank, Sotheby's: portrait of an auction house (London, 1980)Google Scholar; Lacey, Robert, Sotheby's: bidding for class (Boston, MA, 1998)Google Scholar.

10 The audience bid on a lot until one inch of a candle had burned. The Company sold imports in London by this method throughout the eighteenth century. Anonymous, The London guide, describing public and private buildings of London, Westminster, & Southward (London, 1782), p. 91.

11 Pears, Iain, The discovery of painting: the growth of interest in the arts in England, 1680–1768 (New Haven, CT, 1988), pp. 5767Google Scholar.

12 McKendrick, Neil, Brewer, John, and Plumb, J. H., The birth of a consumer society: the commercialization of eighteenth-century England (Bloomington, IN, 1982), pp. 933Google Scholar.

13 Wall, ‘The English auction’, pp. 1–7. Auctions were popular spectacles and fashionable gatherings, but they could also be traumatic for persons as death and bankruptcy forced possessions to cross the auction block.

14 Richter, Anne Nellis, ‘Spectacle, exoticism, and display in the gentleman's house: the Fonthill auction of 1822’, Eighteenth-Century Studies, 41 (2008), pp. 555–6Google Scholar.

15 Altick, Richard, The shows of London (Cambridge, MA, 1978)Google Scholar; Cooper, Jeremy, Under the hammer: the auctions and auctioneers of London (London, 1977)Google Scholar; Wall, ‘The English auction’.

16 Ralph, James, The taste of the town; or, a guide to all publick diversions (London, 1731), p. 233Google Scholar.

17 Ohashi, Satomi, ‘The Auction Duty Act of 1777: the beginning of institutionalization of auctions in Britain’, in Warren, Jeremy and Turpin, Adriana, eds., Auctions, agents, and dealers: the mechanisms of the art market, 1660–1830 (Oxford, 2008), pp. 21–3Google Scholar.

18 Some disreputable auctioneers paid ‘puffers’ to place fake bids. Anonymous, Town and Country Magazine, 4 (London, 1772), p. 192; John Bowle to James Granger, 12 Jan. 1774, in J. P. Malcolm, ed., Letters between the Rev. James Granger, rector of Shiplake, and many of the most eminent literary men of his time (London, 1805), p. 45.

19 Ralph, The taste of the town, pp. 231–2.

20 The term ‘Ishmaelite’ referred to persons of the Arabian Peninsula. Bathurst, Lord Henry, The ruinous tendency of auctioneering (London, 1812, 1848), pp. 7, 35–9Google Scholar.

21 Sharp, Granville, A representation of the injustice and dangerous tendency of tolerating slavery (London, 1769), p. 89Google Scholar.

22 White, Daniel E., From Little London to Little Bengal: religion, print, modernity in early British India, 1793–1835 (Baltimore, MD, 2013), pp. 36Google Scholar; Eaton, Natasha, ‘Excess in the city? The consumption of imported prints in colonial Calcutta, c. 1780–c. 1795’, in Jay, Martin and Ramaswamy, Sumathi, eds., Empires of vision (Durham, NC, 2014), pp. 168–9Google Scholar; Rasico, Patrick D., ‘Calcutta “in these degenerate days”: the Daniells’ visions of life, death, and nabobery in late eighteenth-century British India’, Journal for Eighteenth-Century Studies, 42 (2019), pp. 2747CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

23 Chattopadhyay, Swati, Representing Calcutta: modernity, nationalism, and the colonial uncanny (London, 2005), p. 84CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Wilson, Kathleen, ‘The lure of the other: Sheridan, identity and performance in Kingston and Calcutta’, Eighteenth-Century Fiction, 27 (2015), p. 510CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Russell, Gillian, The theatres of war: performance, politics, and society, 1793–1815 (Oxford, 1995)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

25 Burke, ‘Speech on opening of impeachment’, p. 382.

26 Bayly, C. A., Indian society and the making of the British empire (Cambridge, 1988), pp. 4855CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Marshall, P. J., East Indian fortunes: the British in Bengal in the eighteenth century (Oxford, 1976), pp. 110–18, 204–8Google Scholar.

28 Nechtman, Tillman, Nabobs: empire and identity in eighteenth-century Britain (Cambridge, 2010), pp. 1215Google Scholar.

29 Advertisers, merchants, and consumers applied the term ‘Europe goods’ to items imported from Britain or continental Europe. Eaton, ‘Excess in the city?’, pp. 169, 173–5.

30 Williamson, The East India vade-mecum, II, p. 230.

31 Nechtman, Nabobs, pp. 192–3, 132–5; Ghosh, Suresh Chandra, The British in Bengal: a study of the British society and life in the late eighteenth century (New Delhi, 1998), pp. 58–9Google Scholar.

32 Marshall, P. J., ‘The white town of Calcutta under the rule of the East India Company’, Modern Asian Studies, 34 (2000), pp. 309, 323–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

33 W. S. Seton-Karr, Selections from the Calcutta Gazette of the years 1784, 1785, 1786, 1787, and 1788 (3 vols., Calcutta, 1864–8), I, pp. 117–18.

34 Anonymous, ‘Inventory & sales of all & sundry the goods, chattels, belongings of John Hinlock’, 1789, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/11.

35 Quoted in Douglas Dewar, Bygone days in India (London, 1922), p. 181.

36 Anonymous, ‘Account sale of the following effects sold by us by public auction on account of the estate of Joseph Bourdieu’, 17 Nov. 1791, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/13.

37 Hickey, William, Memoirs of William Hickey, 1790–1809, ed. Spencer, Alfred (4 vols., New York, NY, 1919–25), IV, pp. 184–5Google Scholar.

38 Quoted in Carey, W. H., The good old days of Honorable John Company (2 vols., Shimla, 1882), I, p. 122Google Scholar.

39 Seton-Karr, Selections from the Calcutta Gazette, I, pp. 34, 48–9, 110–11, 168, 216, 240.

40 Ibid., II, p. 99.

41 BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/1–23.

42 Eaton, Natasha, Mimesis across empires: artworks and networks in India, 1765–1860 (Durham, NC, 2013), pp. 8990Google Scholar.

43 Quoted in Carey, The good old days of Honorable John Company, I, p. 162, II, p. 66.

44 Williamson, The East India vade-mecum, II, pp. 169–70.

45 Frykenberg, Robert, ‘Christian Missions and the Raj’, in Etherington, Norman, ed., Missions and empire (Oxford, 2005), p. 109Google Scholar.

46 Andrew Fuller to William Carey, 6 Sept. 1797, Home Office correspondence, Baptist Missionary Society Archives (BMSA), BMS missionary correspondence, Southern Baptist Historical Library and Archive (SBHLA), Nashville, TN, microfilm collection (MC) #5350, reel 20, vol. 2; Anonymous, Periodical accounts relative to the Baptist Missionary Society (6 vols., London, 1800–19), I, p. 487.

47 J. C. Gotch to William Burls, 6 Aug. 1817, BMSA, BMS correspondence, box H/4, SBHLA MC #5350, reel 21.

48 Anonymous, ‘Account sale of household furniture belonging to the estate of Petruse Isaac…sold by public auction at the deceased dwelling house’, 14 Mar. 1786, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/11.

49 Anonymous, ‘An account sales of sundry effects belonging to the estate of the late Mr. John Moore…sold at public outcry by Kirparam Doss’, 12 July 1781, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/2.

50 Quoted in Carey, The good old days of Honorable John Company, I, pp. 138, 147.

51 Anonymous, ‘Account sales of the goods & effects of Messrs. Redpath & Simon in partnership’, 1788, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/11.

52 BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/1–17.

53 Williamson, The East India vade-mecum, II, pp. 168–9.

54 Quoted in Carey, The good old days of Honorable John Company, I, p. 165.

55 Anonymous, ‘Account sale of the house and effects belonging to the estate of John Baptiste Mandezer’, 21 May 1781, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/2; Anonymous, ‘Account sales of sundries sold at public sale…on account of the estate of C. L. Playdell’, 23–5 June 1779, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/1.

56 Eacott, Jonathan, Selling empire: India in the making of Britain and America, 1600–1830 (Chapel Hill, NC, 2016), pp. 291–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

57 William Hickey, ‘Article on unpublished portions of Hickey's memoirs vol. IV’, BL MSS Eur F82/15.

58 BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/1–23; Eacott, Selling empire, pp. 296–8.

59 Jasanoff, Maya, Edge of empire: lives, cultures, and conquest in the East, 1750–1850 (New York, NY, 2005), pp. 67Google Scholar.

60 See, for example, Anonymous, ‘An inventory of the effects of the late John Knott of Calcutta…sold by public auction’, 25 May 1792, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/14.

61 Eaton, Mimesis across empires, pp. 8–14.

62 Anonymous, ‘Account sales of sundries belonging to the estate of Mr. Heatley, Esq…sold by us by public auction’, 30 Sept. 1794, BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/17.

63 Jasanoff, Edge of empire, pp. 48, 81–4.

64 Horace Walpole to Lady Hertford, 11 Mar. 1764, in W. S. Lewis, ed., Walpole correspondence (48 vols., New Haven, CT, 1937–83), XXXVIII, pp. 344–5.

65 Smylitopoulos, Christina, ‘Portrait of a nabob: graphic satire, portraiture, and the Anglo-Indian in the late eighteenth century’, RACAR: revue d'art canadienne/Canadian Art Review, 37 (2012), pp. 1315Google Scholar.

66 ‘A.B.C.D.’, Town and Country Magazine, 2 (London, 1770), p. 587; ‘Socrates’, Town and Country Magazine, 5 (London, 1773), p. 411.

67 Nechtman, Nabobs, pp. 12–16, 80–91.

68 Archenholz, Johann, A picture of England: containing a description of the laws, customs, and manners of England (London, 1789), p. 22Google Scholar; Rasico, ‘Calcutta “in these degenerate days”’, p. 31.

69 Brian Learmount, A history of the auction (Iver, 1985), pp. 29–31.

70 Nechtman, Nabobs, pp. 156–7; Daily Gazetteer, 2 Nov. 1767, quoted in Wilson, Kathleen, The sense of the people: politics, culture, and imperialism in England, 1715–1785 (Cambridge, 1995), p. 275Google Scholar.

71 ‘Bashaw’ or pasha was a term for a Turkish official. Sharp, A representation of the injustice and dangerous tendency of tolerating slavery, p. 82.

72 Eacott, Selling empire, pp. 202, 209.

73 Cooper, Thomas, Letters on the slave trade (Manchester, 1787), p. 16Google Scholar; Clarkson, Thomas, The substance of the evidence of sundry persons on the slave-trade (London, 1789), pp. 16, 54Google Scholar.

74 Bailyn, Bernard, Voyagers to the west: a passage in the peopling of America on the eve of the Revolution (New York, NY, 1986), pp. 174, 324–5Google Scholar.

75 American auctioneers attracted audiences by selling land, buildings, artworks, furnishings, and enslaved individuals at a single ‘vendu’. Breen, T. H., The marketplace of revolution: how consumer politics shaped American independence (Oxford, 2004), pp. 141–3Google Scholar; Roach, Joseph, Cities of the dead: circum-Atlantic performance (New York, NY, 1996), pp. 211–15Google Scholar.

76 Sharp, A representation of the injustice and dangerous tendency of tolerating slavery, pp. 89–90, 104–5.

77 BL IOR/L/AG/34/27/1–23; H. E. Busteed, Echoes from old Calcutta (London, 1908), pp. 134–5.

78 Middlesex Journal, 13–15 Oct. 1773.

79 Satirical prints identified nabobs and imperial geographies as unlike peoples and spaces of Britain. Smylitopoulos, ‘Portrait of a nabob’, pp. 11–12.

80 George, Mary Dorothy, Catalogue of political and personal satires preserved in the Department of Prints and Drawings in the British Museum (12 vols., London, 1870–1954), VI, pp. 336–7Google Scholar.

81 Tim Fulford, ‘Getting and spending: the orientalization of satire in Romantic London’, in Steven E. Jones, ed., The satiric eye: forms of satire in the Romantic period (London, 2003), p. 16; John C. Leffel, ‘“Where woman, lovely woman, for wealth and grandeur comes from afar”: representations of the colonial marriage market in Gillray, Topham, Starke, and Austen’, in Monika Class and Terry F. Robinson, eds., Transnational England: home and abroad, 1780–1860 (Newcastle, 2009), pp. 211–16; Wilson, Kathleen, The island race: Englishness, empire, and gender in the eighteenth century (London, 2003), p. 98Google Scholar.

82 O'Quinn, Daniel, Staging governance: theatrical imperialism in London, 1770–1800 (Baltimore, MD, 2005), pp. 291–2Google Scholar; Worrall, David, ‘Chinese Indians: a James Gillray print, Covent Garden's The loves of Bengal, and the eighteenth-century Asian economic ascendancy’, European Romantic Review, 19 (2008), pp. 105–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

83 Molineux, Catherine, ‘Making the middle passage: maritime dimensions of abolitionist debate’, in Shammas, Carole and Mancall, Peter, eds., Governing the sea in the early modern era (San Marino, CA, 2015), pp. 275–81Google Scholar.

84 Worrall, ‘Chinese Indians’, p. 107.

85 ‘Lack’ is a play on words. In South Asian numbering systems, ‘lakh’ means 100,000.

86 Fulford, ‘Getting and spending’, pp. 14–16.

87 Chattopadhyay, Amal Kumar, Slavery in the Bengal presidency, 1772–1843 (London, 1977), pp. 22–3, 157–9Google Scholar.

88 Schmidt, Benjamin, ‘Collecting global icons: the case of the exotic parasol’, in Bleichmar, Daniela and Mancall, Peter, eds., Collecting across cultures: material exchanges in the early modern Atlantic world (Philadelphia, PA, 2011), pp. 3157CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

89 Richard Godfrey, James Gillray: the art of caricature (London, 2001), p. 66.

90 George, Catalogue of political and personal satires, VI, p. 337.

91 Nechtman, Nabobs, pp. 165–6.

92 Horace Walpole to Horace Mann, 17 Nov. 1771, in Lewis, ed., Walpole correspondence, XXIII, p. 350.

93 Walpole to Mann, 9 Apr. 1772, in Lewis, ed., Walpole correspondence, XXIII, p. 400.

94 ‘To the editor of the coffee house’, Town and Country Magazine, 16 (London, 1784), pp. 124–5.

95 Cowley, Hannah, The belle's stratagem (London, 1782), p. 13Google Scholar, quoted in Bhattacharya, Nandini, Slavery, colonialism and connoisseurship: gender and eighteenth-century literary transnationalism (Burlington, VT, 2006), p. 100Google Scholar.

96 Edmund Burke, ‘The opening of impeachment, 18 February, 1788’, in Marshall, ed., The writings and speeches of Edmund Burke, VI, p. 191.

97 Horace Mann to Horace Walpole, 29 Oct. 1767, in Lewis, ed., Walpole correspondence, XXII, p. 561.

98 Mark Bence-Jones, Clive of India (London, 1974), pp. 187–9, 265; Jasanoff, Edge of empire, pp. 36–7.

99 Henry Strachey to Robert Clive, 23 May, 1771, BL MSS Eur G37/61/4, fos. 38–9.

100 Bénédicte Miyamoto, ‘“Making pictures marketable”: expertise and the Georgian art market’, in Charlotte Gould and Sophie Mesplède, eds., Marketing art in the British Isles, 1700 to the present: a cultural history (Burlington, VT, 2012), pp. 227–9.

101 Christie, James, A catalogue of the superb…pictures collected abroad this year with great speculation and vast expense by Mr. Robert Ansell (London, 1771), pp. 38Google Scholar. Prices and buyers in master copy at Christie's Archive, London.

102 Horace Walpole, Book of materials, in Lewis, ed., Walpole correspondence, XXIII, p. 299.

103 James Christie, A catalogue of a capital and elegant collection of pictures selected from the Roman, Florentine, Lombard, and other schools (London, 1771), pp. 1, 6. Prices and buyers in Christie's master copy.

104 Robert Clive to Henry Strachey, 15 May 1771, BL MSS Eur F128/93, fos. 55–6; Jasanoff, Edge of empire, pp. 36–7.

105 Lawson, Philip and Phillips, Jim, ‘“Our execrable banditti”: perceptions of nabobs in mid-eighteenth century Britain’, Albion: A Quarterly Journal Concerned with British Studies, 16 (1984), pp. 227–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

106 Gilbert Elliot to Lady Elliot, 3 Mar. 1787, The life and letters of Sir Gilbert Elliot, 1st earl of Minto, 1750–1806, edited by the countess of Minto (3 vols., London, 1874), I, p. 131.

107 Richter, ‘Spectacle, exoticism, and display in the gentleman's house’, p. 556.

108 Christie, James, Particulars and conditions of sale of a valuable freehold estate, consisting of the manors of Worcester and Goldbeaters (London, 1787), pp. 1, 315Google Scholar.

109 William Pitt, 22 Jan. 1770, in William Taylor and John Pringle, eds., The correspondence of William Pitt, earl of Chatham (4 vols., London, 1838–40), III, p. 405.

110 ‘Anti-nabob’, ‘Memoirs of a nabob’, Town and Country Magazine, 3 (London, 1771), p. 70; ‘Sir George Crusty and Sir William Pliant, Esq’, Town and Country Magazine, 8 (London, 1776), p. 613.

111 Ahmed, Siraj, The stillbirth of capital: Enlightenment writing and colonial India (Stanford, CA, 2011), pp. 143–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

112 Edmund Burke, ‘Speech on Fox's India Bill’, in Marshall, ed., The writings and speeches of Edmund Burke, V, p. 426.

113 Marshall, P. J., The impeachment of Warren Hastings (Oxford, 1965), pp. xivxvGoogle Scholar.

114 Bayly, Indian society and the making of the British empire, p. 53.

115 Travers, Robert, Ideology and empire in eighteenth-century India: the British in Bengal (Cambridge, 2007), pp. 71–2CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

116 Philip Francis, ‘Extract of a minute from General Clayering, Colonel Monson, and Mr. Francis’, 20 Jan. 1776, in Romesh C. Dutt, ed., Sir Philip Francis's minutes on the subject of a permanent settlement (Calcutta, 1901), pp. 8–9.

117 Williamson, The East India vade-mecum, II, pp. 488–9.

118 Burke, Edmund, ‘The trial of Warren Hastings’, in The trial of Warren Hastings, Esq. late governor-general of Bengal (London, 1788), pp. 67Google Scholar.

119 Edmund Burke, ‘Articles of impeachment’, in Marshall, ed., The writings and speeches of Edmund Burke, V, p. 191.

120 Burke, ‘Speech on Fox's India Bill’, p. 426.

121 Burke, ‘Speech on opening of impeachment’, p. 382.

122 Burke, ‘Speech on Fox's India Bill’, pp. 410–11.

123 Broome, Ralph, An elucidation of the articles of impeachment preferred by the last parliament against Warren Hastings (London, 1790), p. 141Google Scholar.

124 Anonymous, ‘Committee of the whole house on the articles of charge of high crimes and misdemeanors, presented to the house against Warren Hastings’, in India courier extraordinary: proceedings of parliament relating to W. Hastings (9 vols., London, 1786–7), II, p. 140–1.

125 Peters, Julie Stone, ‘Theatricality, legalism, and the scenography of suffering: the trial of Warren Hastings and Richard Brinsley Sheridan's Pizarro’, Law and Literature, 18 (2006), pp. 21–2Google Scholar.

126 Richard Sheridan, ‘Speech of R. B. Sheridan, Esq. on summoning up the evidence on the second, or Begum charge’, in The trial of Warren Hastings, Esq. late governor-general of Bengal, p. 100.

127 Richard Sheridan, ‘Proceedings against Mr. Hastings, Feb. 7, 1787’, in Henry Bohn, ed., The speeches of the Right Honourable Richard Brinsley Sheridan (3 vols., London, 1842), I, p. 235.

128 James Christie, A catalogue of a valuable collection of pictures…of the esteemed and excellent artist, Mr. Gainsborough Dupont…also a grand selection of views of India by the ingenious artist Mr. Hodges – portraits by Kettle, &c, the property of Warren Hastings (London, 1797), pp. 6–10. Prices in Christie's master copy.

129 Anonymous, True Briton (London), 14 Apr. 1797.

130 Quoted in Lawson, Charles, The private life of Warren Hastings: the first governor general of India (London, 1895), p. 140Google Scholar.

131 Rabin, Dana, Britain and its internal others, 1750–1800: under rule of law (Manchester, 2017), pp. 46CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Travers, Ideology and empire in eighteenth-century India, p. 25.

132 Eaton, Natasha, ‘The art of colonial despotism: trafficking art and sovereignty in South India, 1765–1795’, Cultural Critique, 70 (2008), pp. 63–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.