Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-l7hp2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-01T00:43:33.495Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Patriotism, History and the Left in Twentieth-Century Britain

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Miles Taylor
Miles Taylor
Affiliation:
Girton College, Cambridge
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

An abstract is not available for this content so a preview has been provided. Please use the Get access link above for information on how to access this content.
Image of the first page of this content. For PDF version, please use the ‘Save PDF’ preceeding this image.'
Type
Historiographical Reviews
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 33 , Issue 4 , December 1990 , pp. 971 - 987
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1990

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 ‘The language of patriotism, 1750–1914’, History Workshop Journal, XII (1981)Google Scholar.

2 Formations editorial collective, Formations of nation and people (1984); Colls, Robert & Dodd, Philip (eds.), Englishness: politics and culture, 1880–1920 (1986)Google Scholar.

3 Anderson, Benedict, Imagined communities: reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism (1983)Google Scholar; Wright, Patrick, On living in an old country: the national past in contemporary Britain (1985)Google Scholar; Gilroy, Paul, ‘There ain't no black in the Union Jack’: the cultural politics of race and nation (1987)Google Scholar.

4 Williams, Gwyn, The Welsh in their history (1982)Google Scholar; Curtis, Tony (ed.), Wales: the imagined nation. Essays in cultural and national identity (Bridgend, 1986)Google Scholar; Howell, David, A lost left. Three studies in socialism and nationalism (Manchester, 1986)Google Scholar; McCrone, David et al. , The making of Scotland: nation, culture and social change (British Sociological Association, Edinburgh, 1989)Google Scholar.

5 Edited by Samuel, Raphael and published by Routledge, the three volumes are: 1. History and politics, 2. Minorities and outsiders and 3. National fictions (1989)Google Scholar.

6 Colley, Linda, ‘The apotheosis of George III: loyalty, royalty and the British nation, 1760–1820’, Past and Present, CII (1984), 94–129CrossRefGoogle Scholar; MacKenzie, John M., Propaganda and empire. The manipulation of British public opinion, 1880–1960 (1984), p. 7Google Scholar.

7 Christie, Clive, ‘The British left and the Falklands war’, Political Quarterly, LV (1984), 288–307CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Guardian (editorial), 21 May 1987, p. 5; Benton, Sarah, ‘The triumph of the spirit of war’, New Statesman, 29 05 1987, pp. 12–14Google Scholar; Guardian (editorial), 21 September 1988, p. 18.

8 Barker, M., The new racism. Conservatives and the ideology of the tribe (1981), ch. 3Google Scholar; Seidel, Gill, ‘Culture, nation and race in the British and French new right’ in Le vitas, Ruth, The ideology of the new right (1986), pp. 107–35Google Scholar; Parekh, Bhiku, ‘The new right and the politics of nationhood’, in Cohen, Gerald et al. , The new right. Image and reality (1986), pp. 33–44Google Scholar.

9 Barnett, Anthony, Iron Britannia (1982), p. 88Google Scholar; Hobsbawm, Eric, ‘Falklands fallout’, Marxism Today, (01 1983), 13–19Google Scholar; cf. idem, ‘Another forward march halted’, ibid. (October 1989), 14–19; Hall, Stuart, ‘The empire strikes back’ (1982)Google Scholar, reprinted in his The hard road to renewal. Thatcherism and the crisis of the left (1988), pp. 73–4.

10 Yeo, Stephen, ‘Socialism, the state and some oppositional Englishness’, in Colls, and Dodd, (eds.) Englishness, pp. 308–69Google Scholar; Hall, Stuart, ‘The toad in the garden: Thatcherism among the theorists’, in Nelson, Cary and Grossberg, Lawrence (eds.), Marxism and the interpretation of culture (Urbana, Illinois, 1988), pp. 64–7Google Scholar.

11 Williams, Raymond, Towards 2000 (1983), pp. 180–2, 196–9Google Scholar; Wright, On living in an old country, ch. 3; cf. Stephen Howe, ‘Labour patriotism, 1939–83’, Barnett, Anthony, ‘After nationalism’, in Samuel, (ed.), Patriotism, vol. 1Google Scholar, Beatrix Campbell, ‘Orwell revisited’, in ibid, vol. 3.

12 Cunningham, ‘Language of patriotism’, Colley, ‘Radical patriotism in eighteenth-century England’, cf. Cottrell, Stella, ‘The devil on two sticks: franco-phobia in 1803’ all in Samuel, (ed.), Patriotism, vol. 1Google Scholar.

13 Preben Kaarsholm, ‘Pro-Boers’, Richard Gott, ‘Little Englanders’, Logie Barrow, ‘White solidarity in 1914’, all in ibid. vol. 1.

14 Christopher Hill, ‘History and patriotism’, Samuel, ‘Continuous national history’, Alan Howkins, ‘A defence of national history’, Carolyn Steedman, ‘True romances’, all in ibid. vol. I, reprinted from History Today (1984); cf. Kaye, Harvey J., ‘The use and abuse of the past: the new right and the crisis of history’;, Socialist Register, XXIII (1987), 332–64Google Scholar.

15 See, in particular: Mary Chamberlain, ‘Growing up Catholic’, Dave Douglass, ‘C stream on Tyneside’, Thom, Deborah, ‘Tommy's sister: women at Woolwich in world war I’ all in vol. 2Google Scholar; Worpole, Ken, ‘Village school or blackboard jungle’ in vol. 3Google Scholar.

16 See, in particular, Jeannine Surel, ‘John Bull’, Raphael Samuel and Gareth Stedman Jones, ‘Pearly kings and queens’, Nairn, Tom, ‘Britain's royal romance’, all in Samuel, (ed.), Patriotism, vol. 3Google Scholar.

17 Jones, Gareth Stedman, ‘Class expression versus social control? A critique of recent trends in the history of “leisure”’ (1977)Google Scholar, reprinted in his Languages of class: Studies in English working-class history, 1832–1982 (Cambridge, 1983), pp. 76–89.

18 Letter to the Times Literary Supplement, 19–25 01, 1990, p. 63Google Scholar.

19 Hill, Christopher, ‘The Norman yoke’, in Saville, John (ed.), Democracy and the labour movement. Essays in honour of Dona Torr (1954), pp. 11–66Google Scholar; Thompson, E. P., The making of the English working class (1963), ch. 4Google Scholar.

20 Hoggart, Richard, The uses of literacy. Aspects of working-class life with special reference to publications and entertainments (1957), pp. 102–12Google Scholar.

21 Hobsbawm, Eric and Ranger, Terence (eds.), The invention of tradition (Cambridge, 1983)Google Scholar.

22 Shannon, R. T., Gladstone and the Bulgarian agitation, 1876 (1963)Google Scholar; Cunningham, Hugh, ‘Jingoism in 1877–8’, Victorian Studies, XIV (1971), 429–53Google Scholar.

23 Hobson, J. A., Imperialism. A study (1902), pp. 153–8Google Scholar.

24 Clarke, Peter, Liberals and Social Democrats (Cambridge, 1978), pp. 90–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar; ‘Hobson, free-trade and imperialism’, Economic History Review, 2nd series, XXXIV (1981), 308–12Google Scholar. See also the overviews of Hobson's critique of jingoism in Mitchell, Harvey, ‘Hobson revisited’, Journal of the History of Ideas, XXVI (1965), 397–416CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Allett, John, New Liberalism: The political economy of J. A. Hobson (1981), pp. 157–64Google Scholar; Freeden, Michael (ed.), ‘Introduction’ to J. A. Hobson: a reader (1988), pp. 19–21Google Scholar.

25 Hobson, J. A., ‘Capitalism and imperialism in South Africa’, Contemporary Review, LXXXVII (01, 1900), 1–17Google Scholar; cf. idem, The war in South Africa. Its causes and effects (1900), pp. 206–28.

26 Hobson, , The psychology of Jingoism (1901), pp. 6–13Google Scholar.

27 Hobson, , Imperialism, p. 150Google Scholar; cf. Hobhouse, L. T., Democracy and reaction (1904)Google Scholar reprinted with an introduction and notes by Peter Clarke (1972), chs. 1–2.

28 Jones, Raymond A., ‘Peace, retrenchment and reform: the British radicals before 1914’, Parliaments, estates and representations, IV (1984), 75–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Swartz, M., The union of democratic control in British politics (Oxford, 1971)Google Scholar; Young, Nigel, ‘War resistance and the British peace movement since 1914’, in Taylor, Richard and Young, Nigel (eds.), Campaigns for peace: British peace movements in the twentieth century (Manchester, 1987), pp. 23–48Google Scholar.

29 Lane, Ralph, pseud. (Norman Angell), Patriotism under three flags. A plea for rationalism in politics (1903), pp. 14, 24–31Google Scholar; cf. idem, The great illusion. A study of the relation of military power in nations to the economic and social advantage (1910), pp. 117–18. On Angell, see Miller, J. D. B., Norman Angell and the futility of war; peace and the public mind (1986)Google Scholar; Navari, Cornelia, ‘The great illusion revisited: the international theory of Norman Angell’, Review of International Studies, XV (1989), 341–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

30 Hobson, J. A., Democracy after the war (1917), p. 104Google Scholar; idem, ‘Why the war came as a surprise’, Political Science Quarterly, XXV (September 1920), 337–59.

31 Morley, John, The life of Richard Cobden, 2 vols (1881)Google Scholar; Trevelyan, George Macaulay, The life of John Bright (1913)Google Scholar; Hobson, J. A., Richard Cobden. The international man (1920)Google Scholar; Edward, and Garnett, Richard, The life of W. J. Fox (1910)Google Scholar; Hobhouse, Stephen, Joseph Sturge (1918)Google Scholar.

32 Winkler, Henry R., ‘J. L. Hammond’, in Schmitt, Hans A. (ed.), Historians of Modern Europe (Baton Rouge, Louisiana, 1971), pp. 95–119Google Scholar.

33 For Norman Angell's influence on the I.L.P., see: Weinroth, Howard, ‘Norman Angell and The great illusion: an episode in pre-1914 pacifism’, Historical Journal, XVII (1974), 551–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For the post war Liberal legacy in general, see: Winkler, Henry R., ‘The emergence of a Labor foreign policy in Great Britain, 1918–1929’, Journal of Modern History, XXVIII (1956), 247–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Dowse, R. E., Left in the centre. The Independent Labour Party, 1983–1940 (1962), pp. 24–6Google Scholar; Cline, C. A., Recruits to Lobour (Syracuse, N.Y., 1963)Google Scholar.

34 Strachey, John, The coming struggle for power (1932), ch. 21Google Scholar.

35 Brinton, Harry (ed.), Does capitalism cause war? (New Statesman & Nation 1935)Google Scholar; Foot, Michael et al. , Young Oxford and war (1934), pp. 63–6Google Scholar.

36 Laski, Harold J., Nationalism and the future of civilisation (Conway Memorial lecture, 1932), pp. 22–3, 34, 39Google Scholar; Cripps, Stafford, The struggle for peace (1932), pp. 14–16Google Scholar; Dickinson, G. Lowes, The international anarchy, 1904–1914 (1926), pp. 37–46Google Scholar.

37 , R.P.D., ‘The British school of Marxism’, Labour Monthly, II (06 1922), pp. 429–31Google Scholar; idem, ‘More British Marxism’, ibid., IV (February 1923), 124–8; cf. League, Plebs, An outline of modern imperialism (1922)Google Scholar; Arnot, R. P., ‘1914 and 1934’, Labour Monthly, XVI (08 1934), 488–96Google Scholar. For an extended discussion of British communist attitudes towards imperialism in the 1920s and early 1930s, see: MacIntyre, Stuart, ‘The Marxist theory of imperialism and the British labour movement’, Our History, LXIV (1975)Google Scholar.

38 Martin, Kingsley, The triumph of Lord Palmerston (1924)Google Scholar.

39 Postgate, Raymond and Vallance, Aylmer, Those foreigners. The English people's opinion on foreign affairs as reflected in their newspapers since Waterloo (1937)Google Scholar.

40 Fox, Ralph, The class struggle in Britain in the epoch of imperialism. Part II. 1914–1923 (1933), pp. 11–13Google Scholar; idem, The colonial policy of British imperialism (1933), pp. 108–9.

41 Maclntyre, Stuart, Proletarian science. Marxism in Britain, 1917–33 (1979), ch. 9Google Scholar; cf. Morton, Vivien and Maclntyre, Stuart, ‘T. A. Jackson – revolutionary and working class intellectual: centenary appreciation, 1879–1979’, Our History, LXXIII (1979), pp. 20–1Google Scholar.

42 Johnson, Richard, ‘Culture and the historians’, in Clarke, J. et al. (eds.), Working class culture: Studies in history and theory (1979), pp. 41–71Google Scholar; Mulhearn, Francis, ‘The Marxist aesthetics of Christopher Caudwell’, New Left Review, LXXXV (1974), 37–58Google Scholar. For Caudwell's list of bourgeois neuroses, including patriotism, see Studies in a dying culture (1938), p. 156.

43 Dare, Robert, ‘Instinct and organisation: intellectuals and British Labour after 1931’, Historical Journal, XXVI (1983), 677–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Coombes, John, ‘British intellectuals and the popular front’, in Gloversmith, Frank (ed.), Class, culture and social change. A new view of the 1930s (Brighton, 1980), pp. 84–7Google Scholar; Wood, Neal, Communism and British intellectuals (New York, N.Y., 1959), pp. 168–71Google Scholar.

44 Klugmann, James, ‘Introduction: the crisis in the thirties: a view from the Left’, in Clark, Jon et al. (eds.), Culture and crisis in Britain in the thirties (1979), pp. 13–36Google Scholar; Samuel, Raphael, ‘British Marxist historians, 1880–1980: Part one’, New Left Review, CXX (1980), 21–96Google Scholar; Heinemann, Margot, ‘The people's front and the intellectuals’, in Fyrth, Jim (ed.), Britain, Fascism and the Popular Front (1985), pp. 157–86Google Scholar. For a more critical view, see: Schwarz, Bill, ‘“The people” in history: the Communist Party Historians' Group, 1946–56’, in Johnson, Richard et al. , Making histories. Studies in history-writing and politics (1982), pp. 54–5Google Scholar.

45 White, R. M., ‘Some features of the development of Fascism in Britain’, Communist International, 1 10 1933, pp. 640–6Google Scholar.

46 Fyfe, Hamilton, ‘The press and mass hysteria’, Left Review, 1 (02 1935), 169–72Google Scholar; Jackson, T. A., The Jubilee – and how (1935)Google Scholar; Kerrigan, P. et al. , ‘The C.P.G.B. and the Jubilee’, Communist International, XX, 07 1935, pp. 692–7Google Scholar; Daily Worker 1 May 1937, p. 4 (R. P. Dutt), 12 May 1937, p. 1 (Harry Pollitt).

47 Martin, Kingsley, The magic of monarchy (1937), pp. 102–3Google Scholar.

48 Jackson, T. A., ‘The monarchy fetish’, Labour Monthly, XIX (05 1937), 283–7Google Scholar; cf. Cole, Margaret, ‘The new economic revolution’, Fact, 1 (04 1937), 38Google Scholar; ‘Crown and classes’ (editorial), Left Review, 3, (06 1937), 258–9Google Scholar.

49 Cole, G. D. H., The People's Front (1937), ch. 3Google Scholar; cf. Wright, A. W., G. D. H. Cole and socialist democracy (Oxford, 1979), pp. 120–1Google Scholar.

50 Madge, Charles, ‘Magic and materialism’, Left Review, III (02 1937), 31–5Google Scholar; Madge, Charles and Harrisson, Tom, Mass-observation (1937), pp. 18–20Google Scholar. Particularly useful on the political background to the ‘Mass Observation’ movement are: Jeffery, Tom, Mass observation. A short history (Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies, Occasional paper, no. 55, 1978)Google Scholar; Mellor, David, ‘Mass Observation: the intellectual climate’, Camerawork, XI (09 1978), 4–5Google Scholar.

51 Madge, Charles and Harrisson, Tom (arr.), Britain by mass observation (1939), pp. 25, 109, 234–5Google Scholar.

52 Harrisson, Tom, ‘What is public opinion?’, Political Quarterly, XI (1940), 368–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

53 Samuels, Stuart, ‘The Left Book Club’, Journal of Contemporary History, I (1966), 65–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lewis, John, The Left Book Club: a historical record (1970)Google Scholar.

54 Cole, Margaret, ‘Europe and the servile state’, Fact, XXXVII (06 1939), 7–53Google Scholar.

55 Orwell, George, The lion and the unicorn (1982 edn), p. 39Google Scholar.

56 Williams, Raymond, Orwell (1971), ch. 2Google Scholar; Cultural History Group, ‘Out of the people: the politics of containment, 1935–45’, in Working Papers in Cultural Studies, IX (Spring 1976), 29–50Google Scholar. For a more sympathetic account, see: Lutman, Stephen, ‘Orwell's patriotism’, Journal of Contemporary History, II (1967), 149–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Claeys, Gregory, ‘The lion and the unicorn, patriotism and Orwell's politics’, Review of Politics, XLVII (1985), 186–211CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

57 Orwell, , Lion and the unicorn, p. 39Google Scholar; cf. his account of George V's jubilee in ‘Our opportunity’, The Left News (January 1941), 1608–12 and his ‘Culture and democracy’, in Cole, G. D. H. et al. , Victory or vested interest (1942), pp. 88–9Google Scholar.

58 e.g. Laski, Harold, The rights of man (Macmillan War pamphlets, no. 8, 1940)Google Scholar.

59 Orwell, George, ‘The Home Guard and you’, Tribune, XX (12 1940), pp. 8–9Google Scholar; idem, ‘Don't let Colonel Blimp ruin the Home Guard’, Evening Standard, 8 January 1941, p. 5; idem, ‘Patriots and revolutionaries’ in Victor Gollancz (ed.), The betrayal of the left: an examination and refutation of Communist policy, from October 1939 to January 1941: with suggestions for an alternative and an epilogue on political morality (1941), p. 242; Wintringham, Tom, Armies of freemen (1940), pp. 179–81Google Scholar; idem, The politics of victory (1941), pp. 52–3. On Wintringham, see Fernbach, David, ‘Tom Wintringham and socialist defence strategy’, History Workshop Journal, XIV (1982), 63–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

60 Childs, David, ‘The British Communist Party and the war, 1939–41: old slogans revived’, Journal of Contemporary History, XII, (1977), 237–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Shaw, Martin, ‘War, peace and British marxism, 1895–1945’, in Taylor, & Young, (eds.), Campaigns for peace, p. 64Google Scholar.

61 Rickword, Edgell, ‘Introduction on English freedom’ to A handbook of freedom. A record of English democracy through twelve centuries (1939)Google Scholar, chosen by Jack Lindsay and Edgell Rickword.

62 Jackson, T. A., Trials of British freedom. Being some studies in the history of the fight for democratic freedom in Britain (1940), pp. xix–xxGoogle Scholar.

63 Foot, Michael and Bruce, Donald, Who are the patriots? (1949)Google Scholar.

64 Thompson, E. P., ‘Outside the whale’ (1960)Google Scholar, reprinted in The poverty of theory and other essays (1978), pp. 1–33; cf. Rodden, John, The politics of literary reputation: The making and claiming of ‘St George’ Orwell (Oxford, 1989), pp. 188–200Google Scholar.

65 Hilton, Rodney, Communism and liberty (1950), pp. 7Google Scholar, 12–14. For the history of the group, see Hobsbawm, Eric, ‘The Historians' Group of the Communist Party’, in Cornforth, Maurice (ed.), Rebels and their causes: essays in honour of A. L. Morton (1978), pp. 21–47Google Scholar; Schwarz, ‘“The people ” in history’; Kaye, Harvey J., The British Marxist historians. An introductory analysis (1984), pp. 9–18Google Scholar.

66 Hill, Christopher, ‘The English revolution and the state’, Modern Quarterly, IV (1949), 110–28Google Scholar; Eric Hobsbawm, ‘The taming of parliamentary democracy’, ibid. VI (1951), 319–39.

67 Quoted in Schwarz, , ‘“The people” in history’, p. 72Google Scholar.

68 Thompson, E. P., ‘William Morris and the moral issues today’, Arena, II (1951), 25–30Google Scholar; cf. idem, The struggle for afree press (1952).

69 Thompson, E. P., ‘Winter wheat in Omsk’, World News, XXX (06 1956), 408–9Google Scholar; idem, ‘Reply to George Matthews’, Reasoner, I (July 1956), 11–15; cf. Wood, , Communism and British intellectuals, pp. 194–200Google Scholar; Holden, David R., ‘The first new left in Britain, 1956–1962’ (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Wisconsin, Madison, 1976), p. 95Google Scholar.

70 Thompson, E. P., ‘Commitment in polities’, Universities and Left Review, VI (Spring 1959), 50–5Google Scholar; idem, ‘The new left’, New Reasoner, IX (Summer 1959), 1–17; idem, ‘A Psessay in Ephology’, ibid. X (Autumn 1959), 1–8; idem, ‘The segregation of dissent’ (1961) reprinted in his Writing by candlelight (1980), pp. 1–10; cf. Taylor, Richard, Against the bomb: the British peace movement, 1958–1965 (Oxford, 1988), pp. 331–8Google Scholar.

71 Cf. Russell, Bertrand in Peace News, 15 09 1961, p. 7Google Scholar.

72 Thompson, E. P., ‘The freeborn Englishman’, New Left Review, XV (1962), 43–57Google Scholar.

73 For two divergent accounts of ‘positive neutralism’, see: Brown, Michael Barratt, ‘Positive neutralism then and now’, in Archer, Robin et al. (eds.), Out of apathy. Voices of the New Left thirty years on (1989), pp. 81–7Google Scholar; Hinton, James, Protests and visions: peace politics in 20th century Britain (1989), ch. 14Google Scholar. For a useful overview, see: Howe, , ‘Labour patriotism’, in Samuel, , Patriotism, vol. IGoogle Scholar.

74 Williams, Raymond (ed.), May Day manifesto 1968 (Harmondsworth, 1968), p. 66Google Scholar.

75 Lin, C., ‘The British New Left, 1957–1977’ (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Cambridge, 1989), pp. 119, 186Google Scholar.

76 Nairn, Tom, ‘Patriotism’, 7 Days, 24 11 1971, p. 17Google Scholar; idem, ‘British nationalism and the E.E.C.’, New Left Review, LXIX (1971), 3–28; cf. Kiernan, Victor, Marxism and imperialism (1974), pp. 55–6Google Scholar; idem, ‘Working class and nation in nineteenth-century Britain’, in Cornforth (ed.), Rebels and their causes, pp. 123–40.

77 Jones, Gareth Stedman, ‘Working-class culture and working-class politics in London, 1870–1900: notes on the remaking of a working class’ (1974)Google Scholar, reprinted in his Languages of class, pp. 179–238.

78 Hobsbawm, Eric, ‘Mass-producing traditions: Europe, 1870–1914’ in Hobsbawm, and Ranger, (eds.), The invention of tradition, pp. 268–9Google Scholar; cf. idem, The age of empire, 1875–1914 (1987), pp. 105, 148–9; cf. Nairn, Tom, The enchanted glass: Britain and its monarchy (1988), pp. 281–2Google Scholar.

79 E. P. Thompson, Writing by candlelight, passim; idem, The heavy dancers (1985), pp. 1–11.

80 Hall, Stuart, The young Englanders (1968)Google Scholar; Kiernan, Victor, ‘After empire’, New Edinburgh Review, XXXVII (1977), 23–35Google Scholar.

81 Dietz, Mary, ‘Patriotism’, in Ball, T. et al. (eds.), Political innovation and conceptual change (Cambridge 1989), pp. 177–93Google Scholar.