Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dlnhk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-30T12:44:53.742Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Competing Research Traditions in American Industry: Uncertain Alliances between Engineering and Science at Westinghouse Electric, 1886–1935

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 February 2015

Ronald R. Kline  and
Thomas C. Lassman
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Westinghouse Electric opened a new research laboratory near the company’s main factory in East Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in 1916. Located in the suburban borough of Forest Hills, the laboratory was set up to provide scientific knowledge for the older materials testing and product development laboratories at the factory. Unlike its industrial counterparts, however, the Forest Hills laboratory was dominated by a strong engineering research tradition that disrupted efforts undertaken in the 1920s and again in the 1930s to build and sustain a diversified fundamental research program. Whereas Eastman Kodak, DuPont, AT&T, and General Electric had successfully integrated fundamental research into their corporate laboratories, the Forest Hills laboratory remained the site of recurring tensions between two cultures of innovation—one based on fundamental science, the other on engineering research. Although such tensions often resulted in competing research strategies, managerial conflicts, and mismatched corporate priorities, the long-standing culture of engineering research contributed far more to Westinghouse’s strategic growth than even the most advanced fundamental research. More generally, the interactions between the cultures of engineering and science that characterize the early history of industrial research at Westinghouse highlight the evolving and sometimes conflicting patterns of technological innovation and organizational change in American industry before World War II.

Type
Articles
Information
Enterprise & Society , Volume 6 , Issue 4 , December 2005 , pp. 601 - 645
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2005. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Business History Conference. All rights reserved.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bibliography of Works Cited

Books

Aitken, Hugh G. J. The Continuous Wave: Technology and American Radio, 1900–1932. Princeton, N.J., 1985.Google Scholar
American Society for Testing Materials. Yearbooks. Philadelphia, 1910–15.Google Scholar
Barron, L. D., Jr. Westinghouse Centennial: Baltimore Divisions and Contracts Management—A History. Baltimore, Md., 1985.Google Scholar
Bright, Arthur A. The Electric-Lamp Industry: Technological Change and Economic Development from 1800 to 1947. New York, 1949.Google Scholar
Brittain, James E. Alexanderson: Pioneer in American Electrical Engineering. Baltimore, Md., 1992.Google Scholar
Bush, Vannevar. Science—The Endless Frontier: A Report to the President on a Program for Postwar Scientific Research. Washington, D.C., 1945 Google Scholar
Carlson, W. Bernard. Innovation as a Social Process: Elihu Thomson and the Rise of General Electric, 1870–1900. Cambridge, U.K., 1991.Google Scholar
Douglas, Susan J. Inventing American Broadcasting, 1899–1922. Baltimore, Md., 1987.Google Scholar
Fleming, A. P. M. Industrial Research in the United States of America. London, 1917.Google Scholar
Fleming, John A. The Alternate-Current Transformer in Theory and Practice. 2 vols. London, 1889–92.Google Scholar
Friedel, Robert, and Paul Israel. Edison’s Electric Light: Biography of an Invention. New Brunswick, N.J., 1986.Google Scholar
Graham, Margaret B. W., and Pruitt, Bettye H.. R&D for Industry: A Century of Technical Innovation at Alcoa. Cambridge, U.K., 1990 Google Scholar
Graham, Margaret B. W., and Shuldiner, Alec T.. Corning and the Craft of Innovation. Oxford, U.K., 2001 Google Scholar
Hounshell, David A., and John Kenly Smith, Jr. Science and Corporate Strategy: DuPont R&D, 1902–1980. Cambridge, U.K., 1988.Google Scholar
Hughes, Thomas P. Networks of Power: Electrification in Western Society, 1880–1930. Baltimore, Md., 1983.Google Scholar
Israel, Paul. From Machine Shop to Industrial Laboratory: Telegraphy and the Changing Context of American Invention, 1830–1920. Baltimore, Md., 1992.Google Scholar
Jenkins, Reese V. Images and Enterprise: Technology and the American Photographic Industry, 1839 to 1925. Baltimore, Md., 1975.Google Scholar
Johnston, Marjorie, ed. The Cosmos of Arthur Holly Compton. New York, 1967 Google Scholar
Kevles, Daniel J. The Physicists: The History of a Scientific Community in Modern America. New York, 1978 Google Scholar
Kline, Ronald R. Steinmetz: Engineer and Socialist. Baltimore, Md., 1992.Google Scholar
Lamme, Benjamin Garver. Benjamin Garver Lamme, Electrical Engineer: An Autobiography. New York, 1926 Google Scholar
Mees, C. Kenneth, E. The Organization of Industrial Scientific Research. New York, 1920.Google Scholar
National Cyclopedia of American Biography. New York, 1934, 1953–54.Google Scholar
Passer, Harold C. The Electrical Manufacturers, 1875–1900: A Study in Competition, Entrepreneurship, Technical Change, and Economic Growth. Cambridge, Mass., 1953.Google Scholar
Reich, Leonard S. The Making of American Industrial Research: Science and Business at GE and Bell, 1876–1926. Cambridge, U.K., 1985.Google Scholar
Shankland, Robert S., ed. Scientific Papers of Arthur Holly Compton: X-Rays and Other Studies. Chicago, 1973 Google Scholar
Stokes, John W. 70 Years of Radio Tubes and Valves: A Guide for Electronic Engineers, Historians, and Collectors. New York, 1982 Google Scholar
Stuewer, Roger H. The Compton Effect: Turning Point in Physics. New York, 1975 Google Scholar
Usselman, Steven W. Regulating Railroad Innovation: Business, Technology, and Politics in America, 1840–1920. Cambridge, U.K., 2002.Google Scholar
Wise, George. Willis R. Whitney, General Electric, and the Origins of U.S. Industrial Research. New York, 1985 Google Scholar
Wright, Helen. Explorer of the Universe: A Biography of George Ellery Hale. New York, 1966 Google Scholar

Articles and Essays

Bartlett, Howard. “The Development of Industrial Research in the United States.” In Research—A National Resource, ed. National Research Council. 3 vols. Washington, D.C., 1941, 2: 19–77.Google Scholar
Coltman, John W. “The Westinghouse Atom Smasher: An IEEE Historical Milestone.” IEEE Transactions on Education E-30 (1987): 37–42.Google Scholar
Davis, H. P. “The Early History of Broadcasting in the United States.” In The Radio Industry: The Story of Its Development as Told by Leaders of the Industry. Chicago and New York, 1928, pp. 189–225.Google Scholar
Dennis, Michael Aaron. “Accounting for Research: New Histories of Corporate Laboratories and the Social History of American Science.” Social Studies of Science 17 (1987): 479–518.Google Scholar
Drew, Bernard A., and Gerard Chapman. “William Stanley.” Berkshire History 6 (1985): 1–40.Google Scholar
Faulkner, Wendy. “Conceptualizing Knowledge Used in Innovation: A Second Look at the Science-Technology Distinction and Industrial Innovation.” Science, Technology, and Human Values 19 (1994): 425–58.Google Scholar
Flinn, Alfred D. “Research Laboratories in Industrial Establishments of the United States of America: A Classified List with Some Information about Staff, Work, and Equipment.” Bulletin [No. 2] of the National Research Council, vol. 1, part 2. Washington, D.C., March 1920 Google Scholar
Galambos, Louis. “Theodore N. Vail and the Role of Innovation in the Modern Bell System.” Business History Review 66 (1992): 95–126.Google Scholar
Hoddeson, Lillian. “The Emergence of Basic Research in the Bell Telephone System, 1875–1915.” Technology and Culture 22 (1981): 512–44.Google Scholar
Hounshell, David A. “The Evolution of Industrial Research in the United States.” In Engines of Innovation: U.S. Industrial Research at the End of an Era, ed. Rosenbloom, Richard S. and Spencer, William J.. Boston, 1996, pp. 13–85.Google Scholar
Kargon, Robert H. “The New Era: Science and American Individualism in the 1920s.” In The Maturing of American Science: A Portrait of Science in Public Life Drawn from the Presidential Addresses of the American Association of the Advancement of Science, 1927–1970, ed. Kargon, Robert H.. Washington, D.C., 1974, pp. 1–29.Google Scholar
Kargon, Robert H. “Temple to Science: Cooperative Research and the Birth of the California Institute of Technology.” Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences 8 (1977): 3–31.Google Scholar
Kevles, Daniel J. “George Ellery Hale, the First World War, and the Advancement of Science in America.” Isis 59 (1968): 427–37.Google Scholar
Kline, Ronald R. “Construing ‘Technology’ as ‘Applied Science’: Public Rhetoric of Scientists and Engineers in the United States, 1880–1945.” Isis 86 (1995): 194–221.Google Scholar
Kline, Ronald R. “Science and Engineering Theory in the Invention and Development of the Induction Motor, 1880–1900.” Technology and Culture 28 (1987): 283–313.Google Scholar
Lassman, Thomas C. “Industrial Research Transformed: Edward Condon at the Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Company, 1935” Technology and Culture 44 (2003): 306–39.Google Scholar
Layton, Edwin T. Jr. “American Ideologies of Science and Engineering.” Technology and Culture 17 (1976): 688–701.Google Scholar
Layton, Edwin T. Jr. “Scientific Technology, 1845: The Hydraulic Turbine and the Origins of American Industrial Research.” Technology and Culture 20 (1979): 64–89.Google Scholar
Leslie, Stuart W. “Blue Collar Science: Bringing the Transistor to Life in the Lehigh Valley.” Historical Studies in the Physical and Biological Sciences 32 (2001): 71–113.Google Scholar
Lipartito, Kenneth. “Culture and the Practice of Business History.” Business and Economic History 24 (1995): 1–41.Google Scholar
Lipartito, Kenneth. “Review of Business History and Business Culture, ed., Andrew Godley and Oliver M. Westall.” Business History Review 73 (1999): 126–28.Google Scholar
Mowery, David C. “The Development of Industrial Research in U.S. Manufacturing” American Economic Review 80 (1990): 345–49.Google Scholar
Reich, Leonard S. “Lighting the Path to Profit: GE’s Control of the Electric Lamp Industry, 1892” Business History Review 66 (1992): 305–34.Google Scholar
Schatzberg, Eric. “Symbolic Culture and Technological Change: The Cultural History of Aluminum as an Industrial Material.” Enterprise & Society 4 (2003): 226–71.Google Scholar
Skinner, Charles E. “What’s Wrong with It.” In Industrial Explorers, ed. Maurice Holland. New York, 1928, pp. 265–81.Google Scholar
Smith, John Kenly, Jr. “The Scientific Tradition in American Industrial Research.” Technology and Culture 31 (1990): 121–31.Google Scholar
Tweedale, Geoffrey. “Metallurgy and Technological Change: A Case Study of Sheffield Specialty Steels and America, 1830–1930.” Technology and Culture 27 (1986): 189–222.Google Scholar
Usselman, Steven W. “From Novelty to Utility: George Westinghouse and the Business of Innovation during the Age of Edison.” Business History Review 66 (1992): 251–304.Google Scholar

Journals, Magazines, and Newspapers

“C. E. Skinner.” Electrical Engineer 53 (1934): 839.Google Scholar
“Changes in Personnel.” Westinghouse Electric News 6 (1920): 19.Google Scholar
Chemical Abstracts. 1907–16.Google Scholar
Davis, H. P. “Munition Work in Pittsburgh.” Electric Journal 16 (1919): 7.Google Scholar
Electrical World 26 (1895): 14–16; and 78 (1921): 690.Google Scholar
Flinn, Alfred D. “The Relation of the Technical School to Industrial Research.” Science 54 (1921): 508–10.Google Scholar
Hale, George E. “Industrial Research and National Welfare.” Science 48 (1918): 505–7.Google Scholar
Herr, Edwin M. “The Organization of the [Westinghouse] Electric Company.” Electric Journal 3 (1906): 682–85.Google Scholar
Jewett, F. B. “Industrial Research with Some Notes Concerning Its Scope in the Bell Telephone System.” Transactions of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers 36 (1917): 841–55.Google Scholar
Lamme, Benjamin G. “The Story of the Induction Motor.” Journal of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers 40 (1921): 203–23.Google Scholar
Lynch, Tillman D. “Manufacture of Six Inch High Explosive Shells for the United States Army.” Electric Journal 16 (1919): 17–25.Google Scholar
Mees, C. Kenneth, E. “The Organization of Industrial Scientific Research.” Science 43 (1916): 763–73.Google Scholar
Mees, C. Kenneth, E. “The Production of Scientific Knowledge.” Science 46 (1917): 519–28.Google Scholar
“Micarta Propellers on Liberty Motors.” Westinghouse Electric News 6 (1920): 10–11.Google Scholar
Millikan, Robert A. “The New Opportunity in Science.” Science 50 (1919): 285–97.Google Scholar
Moore, R. W. E. “Properties and Uses of Bakelite Micarta.” Electric Journal 10 (1913): 645–50.Google Scholar
New York Times. 24 July 1916, 4 Jan. 1918, 25 Aug. 1918.Google Scholar
Nutting, Perley G. “The Application of Organized Knowledge to National Welfare.” Scientific Monthly 6 (1918): 406–16.Google Scholar
Nutting, Perley G. “Industrial Research Has Become a Distinct Profession.” American Gas Engineering Journal 107 (1917): 111–12.Google Scholar
Nutting, Perley G. “Institutes of Applied Science.” Journal of the Franklin Institute 187 (1919): 489–93.Google Scholar
Nutting, Perley G. “Organized Knowledge and National Welfare.” Science 46 (1917): 247–52.Google Scholar
Nutting, Perley G. “Research and the Industries.” Scientific Monthly 7 (1918): 149–57.Google Scholar
Pilling, Norman B. “The Quenching Behavior of Liquids.” Physical Review 14 (1919): 222–27.Google Scholar
Pilling, Norman B. “Vapor Pressure of Metallic Calcium.” Physical Review 18 (1921): 362–68.Google Scholar
Pope, F. L. “The Westinghouse Alternating System of Electric Lighting.” Electrician and Electrical Engineer 6 (1887): 332–42.Google Scholar
Science Abstracts. 1908, 1915–21.Google Scholar
“Scientific Notes and News.” Science 53 (1921): 303–4.Google Scholar
Scott, Charles F. “Exhibit of Tesla Polyphase System at the World’s Fair.” Proceedings of the International Electrical Congress (1893), 417–22.Google Scholar
Shrader, James E. “Conductivity of Insulating Materials Near the Breakdown Voltage.” Physical Review 17 (1921): 502–7.Google Scholar
Shrader, James E. “A Modification of the Braun Electrostatic Voltmeter.” Physical Review 15 (1920): 533–35.Google Scholar
Shrader, James E. “Residual Gases and Vapors in Highly Exhausted Glass Bulbs.” Physical Review 13 (1919): 434–37.Google Scholar
Shrader, James E. and Ryder, Harry M.. “An Optical Lever Manometer.” Physical Review 13 (1919): 321–25.Google Scholar
Shrader, James E. and Sherwood, R. G. “Production and Measurement of High Vacua.” Physical Review 12 (1918): 70–80.Google Scholar
Skinner, Charles E. “Benjamin G. Lamme—An Appreciation.” Electric Journal 12 (1915): 496–97.Google Scholar
Skinner, Charles E. “Commercial Research.” Electric Journal 5 (1908): 185–203.Google Scholar
Skinner, Charles E. “Industrial Research and Its Relation to University and Governmental Research.” Transactions of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers 36 (1917): 871–82.Google Scholar
Skinner, Charles E. “The Opportunity for Industrial Research.” Journal of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers 40 (1918): 23–24.Google Scholar
Skinner, Charles E. “Selling Research.” Journal of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers 41 (1922): 307–9.Google Scholar
Skinner, Charles E. and Chubb, Lewis W.. “The Electrolytic Insulation of Aluminum.” Electric Journal 12 (1915): 78–80.Google Scholar
Skinner, Charles E. and Chubb, Lewis W.. “Electropercusive Welding.” Electric Journal 11 (1914): 640–44.Google Scholar
Skinner, Charles E. and Moore, R. W. E. “The New Westinghouse Research Building.” Electrical World 71 (1918): 1132–33.Google Scholar
Stanley, William Jr. “The Alternating System of Electrical Distribution.” Electrician and Electrical Engineer 6 (1887): 358–60.Google Scholar
Stanley, William Jr. “The Inventor and the Trust.” Electrical World and Engineer 41 (1903): 519–20.Google Scholar
Westinghouse Electric News 7 (1921): 12–15; and 7 (Sept. 1921): 14–15.Google Scholar
Yensen, Trygve D. “Magnetic and Electrical Properties of the Ternary Alloys Fe-Si-C.” Journal of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers 43 (1924): 558–67.Google Scholar

Unpublished Sources

“Annual Report of the Board of Directors of the Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Company to Its Stockholders, 1916, 1917.” Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Lassman, Thomas C. “From Quantum Revolution to Institutional Transformation: Condon, Edward U. and the Dynamics of Pure Science in America, 1925–1951.” Ph.D. diss., Johns Hopkins University, 2000.Google Scholar
Morris, Susan W. “Resource Networks: Industrial Research in Small Enterprises, 1860–1930.” Ph.D. diss., Johns Hopkins University, 2003.Google Scholar
Sturchio, Jeffrey. “Experimenting with Research: Kenneth Mees, Eastman Kodak, and the Challenge of Diversification.” Paper presented at the Hagley R&D Pioneers Conference, Hagley Museum and Library, Wilmington, Del., Oct. 1985 Google Scholar

Archival Sources

Arthur Holly Compton Papers. Washington University Archives, St. Louis, Mo.Google Scholar
Charles, E. Skinner Papers. Preserved in the Records of the Westinghouse Electric Corporation, Library and Archives Division, Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh, Pa.Google Scholar
Frank, B. Jewett Collection. AT&T Archives, Warren, N.J.Google Scholar
Minutes of the Rochester Section, Optical Society of America, 1915. Niels Bohr Library, Center for History of Physics, American Institute of Physics, College Park, Md.Google Scholar
Records of the Directors of Industrial Research. Accession Number 1851, Hagley Museum and Library, Wilmington, Del.Google Scholar
Records of the Westinghouse Electric Corporation. Library and Archives Division, Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh, Pa.Google Scholar
Millikan, Robert A. Papers. California Institute of Technology Archives, Pasadena, Calif.Google Scholar
William Stanley, Jr. Papers. Schaffer Library, Union College, Schenectady, N.Y.Google Scholar