No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
“Child of Koevoet”: Counterinsurgency, Crisis, and the Rise of Private Security in South Africa
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 17 October 2024
Abstract
Scholars of various backgrounds have noted how societies across the globe have come to rely on more and more policing and incarceration since the late 1970s. To date, however, detailed analyses of the causes and consequences of this “punitive turn” have been limited to the Global North, with the vast majority of studies focused on the expansion of states’ capacity for violence. This article offers a corrective to the global study of the punitive turn by tracing the rise of South Africa’s private security industry from its inception in the late apartheid period to its current position as one of the largest of its kind in the world. Using newspaper reports, archival material from the apartheid state’s security apparatus, and ethnographic interviews of former and current members of the security industry, it shows how counterinsurgency doctrine, civil war, and deindustrialization shaped South Africa’s punitive turn, precipitating a process where violence was devolved from the state to private actors, including local militias, vigilante groups, and private security firms. This process, it is argued, is far from anomalous, and should be seen as a paradigm for the way the post-1970s punitive turn has unfolded in the majority of the world.
Keywords
- Type
- Prose of Counterinsurgency
- Information
- Copyright
- © The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Society for the Comparative Study of Society and History
References
1 Gilmore, Ruth Wilson, “What Is to Be Done?” American Quarterly 63, 2 (2011): 245–65, 247.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
2 All names are pseudonyms unless noted otherwise. Some biographical details have been altered to preserve participants’ anonymity.
3 At the time, present-day Namibia was ruled by South Africa, which referred to the territory as “South West Africa.” In 1966, the United Nations declared South Africa’s occupation illegal and “South West Africa” to be an independent state—”Namibia.” Thus, I use “Namibia” to describe the country after 1966.
4 Joseph Tshilongo, interview with author, Johannesburg, 3 May 2022.
5 Comparisons of this kind are difficult due to the lack of reliable data and confounded by differing measures of size. As a matter of total licensed officers, South Africa (557,000) ranks sixth behind countries with larger populations: India (seven million), China (five million), the United States (two million), Russia (800,000), and Brazil (570,000). In terms of total licensed officers per capita, South Africa (935 per hundred thousand people) ranks fifth behind countries with much smaller populations: Bulgaria (1,714), Latvia (1,068), Estonia (1,006), and Guatemala (945). Nicolas Florquin, “A Booming Business: Private Security and Small Arms,” Small Arms Survey (Geneva: Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, 2011); and Confederation of European Security Services, “Private Security in Europe—2015” (Wemmel, Belgium, Jan. 2017).
6 “PSIRA Annual Report 2020/2021” (Centurion, PSIRA, 2020), 63, 66.
7 Statistics South Africa, “Revised Annual Financial Survey 2019,” AFS (Pretoria: Statistics South Africa, 2019); Guy Martin, “Government Private Security Spend Amounts to Billions,” DefenceWeb, 21 Dec. 2021.
8 Stuart Hall et al., Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the State and Law & Order (Houndmills: Palgrave, 2013).
9 Gilmore, Ruth Wilson, Golden Gulag: Prisons, Surplus, Crisis, and Opposition in Globalizing California (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2007).Google Scholar
10 See Lebrón, Marisol, Policing Life and Death: Race, Violence, and Resistance in Puerto Rico (Oakland: University of California Press, 2019), 5–6 Google Scholar; Camp, Jordan T. and Heatherton, Christina, Policing the Planet: Why the Policing Crisis Led to Black Lives Matter (New York: Verso, 2016), 2–3 Google Scholar. A notable exception is Caldeira, Teresa, City of Walls: Crime, Segregation, and Citizenship in São Paulo (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2000).Google Scholar
11 Garland, David, The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2001)Google Scholar; Simon, Jonathan, Governing through Crime: How the War on Crime Transformed American Democracy and Created a Culture of Fear (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
12 For a sample of this work, see Muhammad, Khalil Gibran, The Condemnation of Blackness: Race, Crime, and the Making of Modern Urban America (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2011)Google Scholar; Murakawa, Naomi, The First Civil Right: How Liberals Built Prison America (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014)Google Scholar; Hinton, Elizabeth K., From the War on Poverty to the War on Crime: The Making of Mass Incarceration in America (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2016)Google Scholar; Hernandez, Kelly Lytle, City of Inmates: Conquest, Rebellion, and the Rise of Human Caging in Los Angeles (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2017).Google Scholar
13 Wacquant, Loïc, Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity (Durham: Duke University Press, 2009)Google Scholar; Seigel, Micol, Violence Workers: State Power and the Limits of the Police (Durham: Duke University Press, 2018)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Schrader, Stuart, Badges without Borders: How Global Counterinsurgency Transformed American Policing (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2019).Google Scholar
14 Go, Julian, Policing Empires: Militarization, Race, and the ‘Imperial Boomerang’ in Britain and the US (New York: Oxford University Press, 2023)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Schrader, Badges.
15 See also Camp and Heatherton, Policing the Planet; Didier Fassin, Enforcing Order: An Ethnography of Urban Policing (Cambridge: Polity, 2013); Loïc Wacquant, Punishing the Poor.
16 Marisol Lebrón, Policing Life and Death, 5–6.
17 P. W. Singer, Corporate Warriors: The Rise of the Privatized Military Industry (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2003), 49; see also O’Brien, Kevin, “Private Military Companies and African Security 1990–98,” in Musah, Abdel-Fatau and Fayemi, J. Kayode, eds., Mercenaries: An African Security Dilemma (London: Pluto Press, 2000)Google Scholar; Lock, Peter, “Africa, Military Downsizing, and the Growth of the Security Industry,” in Cillier, Jakkie K. and Mason, Peggy, eds., Peace, Profit or Plunder? The Privatisation of Security in War-Torn African Societies (Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies, 1999).Google Scholar
18 Final Report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (henceforth Final Report), vol. 3, 38.
19 “State Security Hearings,” in the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) Collection, AL 2924, A2.1–5, South African Historical Archive (SAHA); “The State v. Botha and Appeal,” TRC AL3060, vol. 33.
20 Khalili, Laleh, Time in the Shadows: Confinement in Counterinsurgency (Redwood City: Stanford University Press, 2012)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Schrader, Badges.
21 “Gen. Fraser Talks on the Terror War,” Rand Daily Mail, 23 May 1973: 22.
22 Lieutenant General C. A. Fraser, Revolutionary Warfare: Basic Principles of Counter-Insurgency (4 Survey and Printing Regiment, 1968), 1–3.
23 Ibid., 6.
24 Thompson, Robert, “Foreword,” in McCuen, John J., The Art of Counter-Revolutionary War: A Psycho-Politico-Military Strategy of Counter-Insurgency (Harrisburg: Stackpole Books, 1966), 16.Google Scholar
25 Stapleton, Timothy, A Military History of South Africa: From the Dutch-Khoi Wars to the End of Apartheid (Santa Barbara: Praeger, 2010), 163 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
26 Herbstein, Denis and Evenson, John, The Devils Are among Us: The War for Namibia (London: Zed Books, 1989), 27 Google Scholar; Minutes of State Security Council Meeting, 26 Nov. 1979, SAHA TRC, The State v. P. W. Botha & Appeal Collection (AL3060), vol. 22, doc 0; Dreyer, Ronald, Namibia and Southern Africa: Regional Dynamics of Decolonization, 1945–90 (London: Routledge, 1994), 83 Google Scholar; Giliomee, Hermann, The Afrikaners: Biography of a People (Cape Town: University of Virginia Press, 2010), 571.Google Scholar
27 Stapleton, Military History, 157; Dreyer, Namibia, 54.
28 Stapleton, Military History, 157–58; Brewer, John, Black and Blue: Policing in South Africa (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994), 244, 276–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
29 Author’s fieldnotes, 12 May 2022; Aaron Branch, interview with author, Krugersdorp, 24 Jan. 2022.
30 Franklin Makoni, interview with author, Krugersdorp, 30 Nov. 2021.
31 See “Aid to the Portuguese,” South African Department of Defence Archive (SADF), Charles Alan Fraser Collection, box 10, vols. 6–8; “Counter-Insurgency Operations Manual,” Apr. 1974, Aliança Contra as Rebeliões em Africa (ALCORA) Collection, SADF Archive; Timothy J. Stapleton, Warfare and Tracking in Africa, 1952–1990 (London: Routledge, 2016), 110.
32 Posel, Deborah, The Making of Apartheid, 1948–1961: Conflict and Compromise (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1991), 81.Google Scholar
33 Hofmeyr, John, “Black Wages: The Post-War Experience,” in Nattrass, Nicoli and Ardington, Elisabeth, eds., The Political Economy of South Africa (Cape Town: Oxford University Press, 1990), 133 Google Scholar; Seekings, Jeremy and Nattrass, Nicoli, Class, , Race, and Inequality in South Africa (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2005), 167–77Google Scholar; Simkins, Charles, “Agricultural Production in the African Reserves of South Africa, 1918–1969,” Journal of Southern African Studies 7, 2 (1981): 256–83, 271.Google Scholar
34 Nattrass, Nicoli, “Economic Power and Profits in Post-War Manufacturing” in The Political Economy of South Africa, by Nicoli Nattrass and Elisabeth Ardington (Cape Town: Oxford University Press, 1990), 108.Google Scholar
35 Simkins, Charles, “The Political Economy of South Africa in the 1970s,” South African Journal of Economic History 14, 1–2 (1999): 11–36, 12–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
36 Hofmeyr, “Black Wages,” 131; Lodge, Tom, “Resistance and Reform, 1973–1994,” in Ross, Robert, Mager, Anne Kelk, and Nasson, Bill, eds., The Cambridge History of South Africa, vol. 2 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011), 412.Google Scholar
37 Dreyer, Namibia, 72–75.
38 Steve Biko, “Black Workers,” 1972 Black Review (1973), republished in New Frame, 6 June 2019: n.p.
39 Lodge, “Resistance and Reform,” 415.
40 Friedman, Steven, Building Tomorrow Today: African Workers in Trade Unions, 1970–1984 (Cape Town: Ravan Press, 1987), 40.Google Scholar
41 For an eyewitness account, see Testimony of Murphy Morobe, “Human Rights Violation Hearings,” before the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, 23 July 1996, South African Broadcasting Corporation, TRC Special Report Series.
42 Final Report, vol. 2, 14 & 24; and vol. 3, 568–71.
43 Kahn, Brian, “The Crisis and South Africa’s Balance of Payments,” in Gelb, Stephen, ed., South Africa’s Economic Crisis (Cape Town: Zed Books, 1991), 66.Google Scholar
44 Lodge, Tom, Black Politics in South Africa since 1945 (London: Longman, 1983), 340–41.Google Scholar
45 Seekings and Nattrass, Class, Race, and Inequality, 95.
46 Lodge, “Resistance and Reform,” 420.
47 Kahn, “Crisis,” 82–83.
48 Feinstein, C. H., An Economic History of South Africa: Conquest, Discrimination and Development (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005), 204–6.Google Scholar
49 Bell, Trevor and Padayachee, Vishnu, “Unemployment in South Africa: Trends, Causes and Cures,” Development Southern Africa (Sandton, South Africa) 1, 3–4 (1984): 426–38, 433CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Feinstein, Economic History, 222.
50 Webb, Arthur, “South African Agriculture in the 1970s: A Decade of Transformation?” South African Journal of Economic History 15, 1–2 (2000): 159–79, 170Google Scholar; Kirsten, J. F., Van Zyl, J., and Van Rooyen, J., “South African Agriculture in the 1980s,” South African Journal of Economic History 9, 2 (1994): 19–48, 47.Google Scholar
51 Seekings and Nattrass, Class, Race, and Inequality, 176.
52 Rand Daily Mail, 6 Mar. 1973: 24; 7 Aug. 1973: 12; 15 July 1974.
53 Ibid., 24 Oct. 1973: 24.
54 Ibid., 15 May 1973: 10.
55 Ibid., 5 Dec. 1974: 3, 11.
56 Author’s fieldnotes, 13 Jan. 2022.
57 Aaron Branch, interview with author, Krugersdorp, 24 Jan. 2022.
58 Author’s fieldnotes, 15 Mar. and 23 May 2022.
59 Stapleton, Warfare and Tracking, 105.
60 Stapleton, Military History, 170.
61 Rand Daily Mail, 28 July 1975: 4; 30 July 1975: 2; 4 Oct. 1977.
62 Giliomee, Afrikaners, 575, 601.
63 Rand Daily Mail, 9 Sept. 1976: 7.
64 Ibid., 14 Sept. 1976.
65 Ibid., 14–16 Sept. 1976.
66 Ibid., 15 Sept. 1976.
67 Ibid., 15 Dec. 1977: 2.
68 Ibid., 13 June 1978: 1; 26 Mar. 1982: 28; 11 Jan. 1978: 3.
69 Ibid., 11 Mar. 1982: 5.
70 Ibid., 13 Oct. 1977: 3.
71 Ibid., 7 Jan. 1978: 5; 19 Jan. 1980: 2; 12 Dec. 1981: 2; 3 Mar. 1982: 4; 26 Apr. 1982: 9; 15 Feb. 1982: 2.
72 Ibid., 30 Sept. 1978: 16; 26 Mar. 1982: 28.
73 Ibid., 13 Oct. 1977.
74 Ibid., 16 Sept. 1976: 16.
75 Ibid., 1 Mar. 1969: 1.
76 Mr. Gumbi requested that his real name be used so his experiences might be broadly understood and recognized.
77 Author’s fieldnotes, 25 Jan. 2022.
78 Mafika Gumbi, interview with author, Krugersdorp, 25 Nov. 2021.
79 Rand Daily Mail, 1 June 1977: 1.
80 Philip, Kate, “The Private Sector and the Security Establishment,” in Cock, Jacklyn and Nathan, Laurie, eds., Society at War: The Militarisation of South Africa (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1989), 213 Google Scholar.
81 Diphoorn, Tessa G., Twilight Policing: Private Security and Violence in Urban South Africa (Oakland: University of California Press, 2016), 37–38 Google Scholar; Brogden, Michael and Shearing, Clifford, Policing for a New South Africa (New York: Routledge, 1993), 71–72.Google Scholar
82 National Key Points Act 102 of 1980, Gazette no. 7134, notice no. 1515, 25 July 1980, Section 3 (1).
83 P. W. Botha, “White Paper on Defence,” 1977, SADF, Annual White Papers, 15.
84 Ibid., 4.
85 The secondary literature often claims that the “total national strategy” originated from the French counterinsurgency expert André Beaufre. But in fact it was Fraser who combined Beaufre’s work with American counterinsurgency ideas of “national strategy” to create the neologism that Botha used. See C. A. Fraser, “Strategy and Strategic Action,” SADF Archive, Charles Alan Fraser Collection, box 4, GOC 32 and 39, and box 5, GOC 23.
86 Fraser, Revolutionary Warfare, 6.
87 Von Schnitzler, Antina, “Disciplining Freedom: Apartheid, Counterinsurgency, and the Political Histories of Neoliberalism,” in Slobodian, Quinn and Plehwe, Dieter, eds., Market Civilizations: Neoliberals East and South (Brooklyn: Zone Books, 2022), 175.Google Scholar
88 Testimony of Magnus Malan, “State Security Hearings,” 4 and 5 Dec. 1997, SAHA TRC AL2924, A2.4, 270–71.
89 Quoted in Swilling, Mark and Phillips, Mark, “State Power in the 1980s: From ‘Total Strategy’ to ‘Counter-Revolutionary Warfare,’” in Cock, Jacklyn and Nathan, Laurie, eds., Society at War: The Militarisation of South Africa (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1989), 163 Google Scholar; Testimony of Malan, 207.
90 My translation of: “om die opkoms van ’n Swart middelklas en die vestiging van ’n kapitalistiese bestel, veral onder die stedelike Swartes,” Secretariaat van die Staatsveiligheidsraad, “Konsep Nasionale Strategie Teen Die Rewolusionêre Oorlog Teen Die RSA: NR 44,” 27 Nov. 1986, TRC, AL3060, vol. 20.
91 Rand Daily Mail, 23 Nov. 1979: 4; 26 Oct. 1979: 13.
92 See “Nasionale Fisiese Ontwikkelingsplan,” 27 May 1980, in J. F. Huyser Collection, box 11, vol. 40, SADF Archive.
93 Aaron Branch, interview with author, Krugersdorp, 24 Jan. 2022; author’s fieldnotes, 17 and 22 Nov. 2021.
94 See, for example, Super, Gail, Governing through Crime in South Africa: The Politics of Race and Class in Neoliberalizing Regimes (Farnham: Ashgate, 2013)Google Scholar; Singh, Anne-Marie, Policing and Crime Control in Post-Apartheid South Africa (Farnham: Ashgate, 2008).Google Scholar
95 Rueedi, Franziska, The Vaal Uprising of 1984 & the Struggle for Freedom in South Africa (Woodbridge: James Currey, 2021), 55, 65.Google Scholar
96 Pottinger, Brian, The Imperial Presidency: P. W. Botha, the First 10 Years (Johannesburg: Southern Book Publishers, 1988), 272; Kahn, “Crisis,” 66.Google Scholar
97 My translation of “Het die rewolusionêres reeds daarin geslaag om ‘bevryde gebiede’ in sekere Swart gemeenskape te vestig,” Secretariaat van die Staatsveiligheidsraad, “NR 44,” SAHA TRC, AL3060, vol. 20.
98 “NR 44,” SAHA TRC AL3060, vol. 20.
99 Fraser, Revolutionary Warfare, 21.
100 Joseph Tshilongo, interview with author, 3 May 2022; Stapleton, Warfare and Tracking, 108; Pottinger, Imperial Presidency, 46.
101 Stapleton, Warfare and Tracking, 111.
102 Brewer, Black and Blue, 273, 283–87; Stapleton, Military History, 186–87, 157.
103 “The Apparatus of State-Orchestrated Violence in Apartheid South Africa,” SAHA TRC, Jane Argall Collection (AL 3115), C2.
104 Kamongo, Sisingi and Bezuidenhout, Leon, Shadows in the Sand: A Koevoet Tracker’s Story of an Insurgency War (Pinetown: 30 Degrees South Publishers, 2011), 37–38.Google Scholar
105 Final Report, vol. 2, 73.
106 Ibid., 69; Herbstein and Evenson, Devils Are among Us, 64.
107 See, for example, McCuen, John J., The Art of Counter-Revolutionary War: A Psycho-Politico-Military Strategy of Counter-Insurgency (Harrisburg: Stackpole Books, 1966), 107–13.Google Scholar
108 Brewer, Black and Blue, 306–7.
109 Final Report, vol. 3, 384–86.
110 Brewer, Black and Blue, 306–7.
111 Author’s fieldnotes, 15 Mar. 2022.
112 Ibid.
113 Walter Felgate, “Challenges to Be Faced in the Transition to Democracy,” Speech to South African Institute of Race Relations, 8 Oct. 1997, SAHA TRC, Walter Felgate Security Papers (AL3456).
114 Testimony of Brian Gcina, TRC Special Hearing on Caprivi, 4 Aug. 1997, South African Broadcasting Corporation, TRC Special Report.
115 For example, during the 1990 massacre known as the “Seven Days’ War,” police, according to witnesses, supplied Inkatha militants with “buckets of ammunition.” Final Report, vol. 2, 626; Testimony of Daluxolo Dlamini, TRC Special Hearing on Caprivi, 5 Aug. 1997, South African Broadcasting Corporation, TRC Special Report.
116 Rand Daily Mail, 6 Oct. 1983: 14.
117 Final Report, vol. 5, 463–67.
118 Haysom, Nicolas, “Vigilantes and the Militarisation of South Africa,” in Cock, Jacklyn and Nathan, Laurie, eds., Society at War: The Militarisation of South Africa (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1989), 189.Google Scholar
119 Final Report, vol. 3, 347.
120 Ibid., vol. 2, 389.
121 See, for example, Testimony of Michael Adriaan van Den Berg, Section 29 Hearing of the TRC, 3 Oct. 1997, SAHA, Freedom of Information Programme Collection (AL2878), B01.5.75.02.26, 40.
122 Testimony of Van Den Berg, SAHA AL2878 B01.5.75.02.26, 472.
123 Testimony of Walter Felgate, Section 29 Hearing of the TRC, 7 July 1996, SAHA TRC AL3456.
124 Final Report, vol. 3, 725–26.
125 Ibid., vol. 2, 373.
126 Ibid., vol. 3, 725–26.
127 Shaw, Mark, Crime and Policing in Post-Apartheid South Africa: Transforming under Fire (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2002), 72.Google Scholar
128 Kynoch, Gary, “Crime, Conflict and Politics in Transition-Era South Africa,” African Affairs (London) 104, 416 (2005): 493–514.Google Scholar
129 Final Report, vol. 2, 160–63.
130 Ibid., 612, 700–1.
131 Independent Board of Inquiry, “Special Report Bisho: Ciskei shootings, September 7, 1992,” Wits Historical Papers (ZA HPRA), Independent Board of Inquiry Records, AG2543-A-A16; Final Report, vol. 2, 414, 427, 433.
132 Sara Blecher, “Safety in Security? A Report on the Private Security Industry and Its Involvement in Violence,” Mar. 1996, Wits Historical Papers (ZA HPRA), Independent Board of Inquiry Records, AG2543-A-A16.
133 For details on the destruction of security documents, see Harris, Verne, “‘They Should Have Destroyed More’: The Destruction of Public Records by the South African State in the Final Years of Apartheid 1990–1994,” in Cox, Richard J. and Wallace, David A., eds., Archives and the Public Good: Accountability and Records in Modern Society (Westport: Quorum Books, 2002).Google Scholar
134 BBC, 18 Mar. 1985; Toronto Star, 28 Aug. 1987; Reuters, 13 Aug. 1987; Rand Daily Mail, 27 May 1981; 3 July 1982: 3; 9 Dec. 1982: 1; 18 Nov. 1982: 9; 23 Feb. 1984: 1; 24 Feb. 1984: 2; 5 Mar. 1983: 3; 4 July 1983: 1; 7 June 1982: 4.
135 Rand Daily Mail, 14 Jan. 1982; 19 Apr. 1985: 2.
136 Ibid., 23 Feb. 1982: 14.
137 Ibid., 18 Oct. 1984: 4.
138 Financial Times, 6 June 1986.
139 Financial Mail, 8 Aug. 1986.
140 See Reuters, 22 July 2003; Financial Times, 4 Oct. 2001.
141 Reuters, 3 Mar. 1999.
142 Financial Times, 4 Oct. 2001; Nordic Business Review, 3 Sept. 2001.
143 Johannesburg Stock Exchange Interim Report, 24 Feb. 1999; Reuters, 15 Sept. 2000.
144 Financial Times, 4 Oct. 2001.
145 Business Day, 22 Dec. 2010.
146 See also Bollinger, Lennart, Apartheid’s Black Soldiers: Un-National Wars and Militaries in Southern Africa (Athens: Ohio University Press, 2021), 152.Google Scholar
147 Joseph Tshilongo, interview with author, Johannesburg, 3 May 2022.
148 Alexander, Neville, An Ordinary Country: Issues in the Transition from Apartheid to Democracy in South Africa (New York: Berghahn Books, 2003).Google Scholar