Hostname: page-component-6bf8c574d5-t27h7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-02-14T10:36:50.376Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Stakes of Inclusion: Chinese Canadian Head Tax Redress

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 March 2008

Stephen Winter
Stephen Winter
Affiliation:
University of Auckland
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Abstract. Between 1885 and 1923 Canada imposed a discriminatory head-tax on Chinese immigrants. In 2006 Canada implemented a material redress program intended to resolve this historical injustice, but aspects of this program have been subjected to vigorous criticism by those seeking greater inclusivity. Paying particular attention to the program's intergenerational aspects, this study explores how the current program's conceptualization of a valid redress claim is situated with respect to both its critics and to domestic and international precedents. Recognizing the dynamic potentiality of redress, the study explores aspects of why and how Canada's understandings of historical redress are politically implicated.

Résumé. Entre 1885 et 1923 le Canada a imposé un impôt discriminatoire aux immigrés chinois. En 2006, le Canada a mis en oeuvre un programme de réparation afin de redresser cette injustice historique, mais certains aspects de ce programme sont vivement critiqués par les partisans d'une plus grande inclusivité. Se concentrant en particulier sur les aspects intergénérationnels du programme, cette étude analyse la manière dont le programme actuel situe la conceptualisation d'une demande légitime de réparation en fonction à la fois de ses détracteurs et de précédents nationaux et internationaux. Prenant en compte le potentiel dynamique de la réparation, cette étude analyse les implications politiques de la démarche canadienne de redressement historique.

Type
Research Article
Information
Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique , Volume 41 , Issue 1 , March 2008 , pp. 119 - 141
Copyright
© 2008 Canadian Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Armstrong, A. 2006. “The Role of Civil Society Actors in Reparations Legislation.” In Redressing Injustices through Mass Claims Processes, ed. The International Bureau of the Permanent Court of Arbitration. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
Aubry, J. 2007. “Ottawa Drops ‘No Apology, No Compensation’ Hard Line.” Vancouver Sun. June 3, http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/story.html?id=74eecb25-f944-463b-958a-1a7937c606c5 (December 10, 2007).
Authers, J. 2006. “Making Good Again: German Compensation for Forced and Slave Laborers.” In The Handbook of Reparations, ed. P. De Greiff. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
Barkan, E. 2000. The Guilt of Nations: Restitution and Negotiating Historical Injustices. Baltimore and London: John Hopkins University Press.
Boxill, B. R. 2003. “A Lockean Argument for Black Reparations.” The Journal of Ethics 7: 63–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
British Columbia Ministry of Education. 2006. Social Studies 10: Integrated Resource Package 2006. http://www.bced.gov.bc.ca (July 23, 2007).
Brooks, R., ed. 1999. When Sorry Isn't Enough: The Controversy over Apologies and Reparations for Human Injustice. New York and London: New York University Press.
Brophy, A. 2003. “Some Conceptual and Legal Problems in Reparations for Slavery.” New York University Annual Survey of American Law 58 (4): 497–554.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Butt, D. 2004. “Principles of Compensation and Restitution in International Justice.” Doctoral dissertation. Oxford University, Oxford.
Canada. Canadian Heritage. 2006a. “Applicant's Guide: Application for Ex-Gratia Symbolic Payments to Living Chinese Head Tax Payers.” http://www.canadianheritage.gc.ca/ (July 23, 2007).
Canada. Canadian Heritage. 2006b. “Guide and Application Form: For an ex-gratia payment to a person who was in a conjugal relationship with a now deceased Chinese Head Tax Payer.” http://www.canadianheritage.gc.ca/ (July 23, 2007).
Canada. Canadian Heritage. 2006c. Head Tax FAQ. http://www.canadianheritage.gc.ca/ (July 23, 2007).
Canada. Canadian Heritage. Corporate Review Branch. 1988. Redress Agreement—Terms of Agreement between the Government of Canada and the National Association of Japanese Canadians, appendix A. http://www.pch.gc.ca (December 10, 2007).
Canada. Service Canada 2007 “Common Experience Payment: Application for Personal Representative or Estate” http://www.hrsdc.gc.ca. (September 20, 2007).
Canadian Jewish Congress. 2006. “CJC Commends Prime Minister for Chinese Canadian Redress.” News release, June 22. http://www.cjc.ca/template.php?action=news&story=811 (June 20, 2007).
Cane, P. 2001. Responsibility in Law and Morality. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
Chinese Canadian National Council. 2006a. “Canada Day Finally Has Special Meaning.” Press release, July 1. http://www.ccnc.ca/ (Feb. 23, 2007).
Chinese Canadian National Council. 2006b. “CCNC to Attend June 22nd Apology and Ceremony.” Press release, June 20. http://www.ccnc.ca/ (Feb. 23, 2007).
Chinese Canadian National Council. 2006c. “Redress Application Process Announced for Head Tax Payers.” Press release, Aug. 29. http://www.ccnc.ca/ (Feb. 23, 2007).
Chinese Canadian National Council. 2007a. “Inclusive Head Tax Redress Raised at United Nations.” Press release, Feb. 21. http://www.ccnc.ca/ (Feb. 23, 2007).
Chinese Canadian National Council. 2007b. Chinese Head Tax and Exclusion Act: CCNC and the Redress Campaign. www.ccnc.ca/ (June 19, 2007).
Chinese Canadian National Council. 2007c. “Chinese Canadians Mark One-Year Anniversary of Chinese Head Tax Parliamentary Apology—220 Redress Payments Issued in One Year.” Press release, June 22. http://www.ccnc.ca (July 27, 2007).
Coleman, J. L. 2003. “Theories of Tort Law.” The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy Winter.
Cook, K. Assistant Curator of the History Division in the Canadian Museum of Civilization. 2007. Personal Communication. March 3.
De Greiff, P., ed. 2006. The Handbook of Reparations. New York: Oxford University Press.
Dyzenhaus, D. and M. Moran. 2005. “Mack v. Canada (Attorney General): Equality, History, and Reparation.” In Calling Power to Account: Law, Reparations, and the Chinese Canadian Head Tax Case, ed. D. Dyzenhaus and M. Moran. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Falk, R. 2006. “Reparations, International Law, and Global Justice.” In The Handbook of Reparations, ed. P. De Greiff. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
Farrier, K. Acting Manager of the Department of Canadian Heritage's Chinese Head Tax Head Unit 2007. Personal Communication September 28.
Feinberg, J. 1984. Harm to Others. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Go, A. 2005. “Litigating Injustice.” In Calling Power to Account: Law, Reparations, and the Chinese Canadian Head Tax Case, ed. D. Dyzenhaus and M. Moran. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Hammond, L. Curator of History at the Royal British Columbia Museum. 2007. Personal Communication. February 27.
Harper, S. 2006. Address by the Prime Minister on the Chinese Head Tax Redress. www.pm.gc.ca (Feb. 22, 2007).
Harper, S. 2007. “Prime Minister Stephen Harper Speaks at Chinese Lunar New Year Festival.” Audio recording. www.pm.gc.ca (Feb. 28, 2007).
Howard-Hassmann, R. E. 2004. “Getting to Reparations: Japanese Americans and African Americans.” Social Policy 83 (2): 823–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ivison, D. 2006. “Historical Injustice.” In The Oxford Handbook to Political Theory, ed. John S. Dryzek, Bonnie Honig and Anne Philips. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
James, M. 2004. “Recognition, Redistribution and Redress: The Case of the ‘Chinese Head Tax.’” Canadian Journal of Political Science 37: 883–902.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
James, M. 2006. “Do Campaigns for Historical Redress Erode the Canadian Welfare State?” In Multiculturalism and the Welfare State: Recognition and Redistribution in Contemporary Democracies, ed. K. Banting and W. Kymlicka. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
Japanese Canadian Redress Secretariat (Canada). 1988. Redress for Japanese Canadians: Eligibility and Application Information. Ottawa: Government of Canada, Japanese Canadian Redress Secretariat.
Kobayashi, A. 1992. “The Japanese-Canadian redress settlement and its implications for ‘race relations.’” Canadian Ethnic Studies 24: 1–19.Google Scholar
Lessing, H., R. Rebernick and N. Spitzy. 2006. “The Austrian General Settlement Fund: An Overview.” In Redressing Injustices through Mass Claims Processes: Innovative Responses to Unique Challenges, ed. The International Bureau of the Permanent Court of Arbitration. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
Matsuda, M. J. 1987. “Looking to the Bottom: Critical Legal Studies and Reparations.” Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review 22: 323–99.Google Scholar
McGregor, J. 2006. “Does the Use of Human Subjects in Research in Developing Nations Violate Their Human Rights? If So, Are Reparations an Appropriate Response?” The Journal of Social Philosophy 37: 441–63.Google Scholar
Miller, D. 2004. “Inheriting Responsibilities (second draft).” http://www.trinitinture.com/documents/miller.pdf (Apr. 16, 2006).
Miller, J. and R. Kumar, eds. 2007. Reparations: Interdisciplinary Inquiries. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
National Anti-Racism Council of Canada. 2006. “NARCC Applauds Head Tax Apology to Chinese Canadians.” Press release, June 28, 2006. http://action.web.ca/home/narcc/issues.shtml?x=91822 (Mar. 12, 2007).
National Anti-Racism Council of Canada. 2007. Racial Discrimination in Canada. Submissions to the Committee on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination on the Occasion of the Review of Canada's Seventeenth and Eighteenth Reports on the United Nations under the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination. Toronto. www.narcc.ca (December 10, 2007).
O'Neil, P. 2007. “Government warned of legal problems from head tax.” Vancouver Sun (Vancouver), February 12. www.canada.com (Mar. 5, 2007).
Posner, E. A. and A. Vermeule. 2003. “Reparations for slavery and other historical injustices.” Columbia Law Review 103: 689–747.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pross, C. 1998. Paying for the past: The struggle over reparations for surviving victims of the Nazi terror. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
Province of Newfoundland and Labrador. 2006a. “Province apologizes for Chinese Head Tax.” News release, June 28, 2006. http://www.releases.gov.nl.ca/releases/2006/exec/0628n06.htm (Mar.1, 2007).
Province of Newfoundland and Labrador. 2006b. “Statement by Premier Danny Williams” News release, March 23, 2006. http://www.releases.gov.nl.ca/releases/2006/exec/0323n03.htm (June 20, 2007).
Province of Ontario. 2006 (amended). Succession Law Reform Act. R.S.O. 1990, chapter S.26 http://www.e-laws.gov.on.ca/DBLaws/Statutes/English/90s26_e.htm#BK21 (June 22, 2007).
Province of Saskatchewan. 2004 (amended). The Survival of Actions Act. http://www.qp.gov.sk.ca/documents/English/Statutes/Statutes/S66-1.pdf (December 10, 2007).
Ridge, M. 2003. “Giving the Dead their Due.” Ethics 114: 38–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sebok, A. 2005. “A Brief History of Mass Restitution Litigation in the United States.” In Calling Power to Account, ed. D. Dyzenhaus and M. Moran. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Siddiqui, T. 2007. “Ottawa urged to expand head-tax redress.” The Globe and Mail (Toronto), February 20, 2007.
Simmons, A. J. 2001. “Historical Rights and Fair Shares.” In Justification and Legitimacy: Essays on Rights and Obligations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Thompson, J. 2001. “Historical injustice and reparation: Justifying claims of descendants.” Ethics 112: 114–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thompson, J. 2002. Taking Responsibility for the Past: Reparation and Historical Injustice. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Tilly, C. 2002. Stories, Identities, and Political Change. Lanham MD: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers.
Torpey, J. 2001. “Making whole what has been smashed: Reflections on reparations.” Journal of Modern History 73: 333–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Torpey, J. 2006. Making Whole What Has Been Smashed: On Reparations Politics. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Treasury Board of Canada. 2006. Canada's Performance 2006: The Government of Canada's Contribution. http://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/report/govrev/06/cp-rc07_e.asp (Feb. 23, 2007).
Tully, J. 1988. “The Pen is a Mighty Sword: Quentin Skinner's Analysis of Politics.” In Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics. Cambridge: Polity Press.
United States of America. Judicial Administration. 1988. Part 74, Payment in the case of a deceased eligible individual, Civil Liberties Act Redress Provision. http://www.access.gpo.gov/nara/cfr/waisidx_01/28cfr74_01.html (Apr. 12, 2005).
Veteran Affairs Canada. 2004. “Chemical Testing” Announcement of Special Benefit, February. http://www.vac-acc.gc.ca/clients/sub.cfm?source=Services/chemical/QsandAs (June 20, 2007).
Waldron, J. 1992. “Superseding Historic Injustice.” Ethics 103: 4–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Winbush, R. 2003. Should America Pay? Slavery and the Raging Debate over Reparations. New York: Amistad Press.
Winter, S. 2006. “Uncertain Justice: History and Reparations.” The Journal of Social Philosophy 37: 342–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Winter, S. 2007. “What's So Bad About Slavery? Assessing the Grounds for Reparations.” Patterns of Prejudice 41: 373–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar