Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dk4vv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T21:19:38.579Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The rise and fall of Porsoniasm

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 February 2013

Christopher Stray
Christopher Stray
Affiliation:
University of Wales Swansea
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In 1903, in the preface to the first volume of his edition of Manilius, Housman wrote:

… we now witness in Germany pretty much what happened in England after 1825, when our own great age of scholarship, begun in 1691 by Bentley's Epistola ad Millium, was ended by the successive strokes of doom which consigned Dobree and Elmsley to the grave and Blomfield to the bishopric of Chester. England disappeared from the fellowship of nations for the next forty years.

(Housman (1903) xlii)

The name which lurks unspoken behind this paragraph is that of Richard Porson, and Dobree, Elmsley and Blomfield, whose names are spoken, were all in different ways his disciples. Although Porson had no pupils and gave no lectures, in the generation just after his death he had a number of followers who cultivated his memory and emulated his style, at least before they were removed to higher spheres by death or preferment to bishoprics. If the cultivation of his scholarly style can be called Porsonianism, it was the cult of Porson himself after his death in 1808, centred on Trinity College, Cambridge, for which three years later the Oxford scholar Peter Elmsley coined the name ‘Porsoniasm’. As one might expect, the name-giver was an outsider. Yet as his inclusion in Housman's sketch indicates, Elmsley could be called a Porsonian, and indeed in 1911, in his inaugural lecture as Professor of Latin at Cambridge, Housman remarked that ‘scholarship meant to Elmsley what it meant to Dobree’ (Housman (1969) 25). But though Elmsley was a Porsonian, he was not (if I may venture a hapax of my own) a Porsoniast.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Cambridge Classical Journal , Volume 53 , 2007 , pp. 40 - 71
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s). Published online by Cambridge University Press 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Aarsleff, H. (1967) The study of language in England, 1780–1860, Princeton.Google Scholar
Abbott, E. and Campbell, L. (1897) Life and letters of Benjamin Jowett, 2 vols., London.Google Scholar
Ackerman, R. A. (1969) ‘The Cambridge Group and the origins of myth criticism’, PhD, Columbia University.Google Scholar
Ackerman, R. A. (1971) ‘Some letters of the Cambridge Ritualists’, Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies 12, 113–36.Google Scholar
Ackerman, R. A. (2007) ‘The Cambridge Ritualists’, ODNB, online release.Google Scholar
Anderson, W. D. (1975) ‘Arnold and the classics’, in Allott, K. (ed.) Matthew Arnold, London, 259–85.Google Scholar
Anon. (1843) ‘Kenrick's Egypt of Herodotus’, Eclectic Review n.s. 14, 431–43.Google Scholar
Anon. (1850) ‘University reform – Cambridge’, Fraser's Magazine 41, 617–29.Google Scholar
[Appleyard, E. S.] (1828) Letters from Cambridge, illustrative of the studies, habits and peculiarities of the university, London.Google Scholar
Bainbridge, B. (1985) Watson's apology, London.Google Scholar
Barker, E. H. (1820) Aristarchus anti-Blomfieldianus, London.Google Scholar
Barker, E. H. (1852) Literary anecdotes and contemporary reminiscences of Professor Porson and others, London.Google Scholar
Barton, R. (2006) ‘The X Club (active 1864–92)’, ODNB, online release.Google Scholar
Beard, W. M. (2000) Inventing Jane Harrison, Cambridge MA.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beard, W. M. (2005) ‘“While RIDGEWAY lives, Research can ne'er be dull”’, in Stray, C. A. (ed.) The owl of Minerva: the Cambridge praelections of 1906, Cambridge Philological Society, supp. vol. 28, 111–41.Google Scholar
Beverley, R. M. (1833) A letter to His Royal Highness the Duke of Gloucester, Chancellor, on the present corrupt state of the University of Cambridge, London.Google Scholar
Blomfield, C. J. [‘BJC’] (1807–8) ‘On the dancing of the ancients’, Athenaeum 2, 597–601; 3, 511–14.Google Scholar
Blomfield, C. J. (1809–1810) ‘The Cambridge edition of Aeschylus’, Edinburgh Review 15, 152–63, 315–22.Google Scholar
Blomfield, C. J. (1816) ‘Monk's Alcestis’, Quarterly Review 15, 112–25.Google Scholar
[Blomfield, C. J.] (1820) ‘Stephens's Thesaurus’, Quarterly Review 22, 302–48.Google Scholar
Brink, C. O. (1986) English classical scholarship, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Brock, M. G. (1997) ‘The Oxford of Peel and Gladstone, 1800–1833’, in id. and Curthoys, M. C. (eds.) The history of the University of Oxford, vol. 6: Nineteenth-century Oxford, part 1, Oxford, 7–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
[Burges, G.] (1838–1839) ‘English scholarship, its rise, progress and decline’, Church of England Quarterly Review 4 (1838) 91–125; 5 (1839) 145–75, 399–426.Google Scholar
[Burges, G.] (1840) ‘The living lamps of learning’, Church of England Quarterly Review 7, 84–106.Google Scholar
Burns, A. and Stray, C. A. (2008) ‘The Greek play bishops’, ODNB, online release.Google Scholar
Burrow, J. W. (1967) ‘The uses of philology in Victorian England’, in Robson, R. (ed.) Ideas and institutions of Victorian Britain, London, 180–204.Google Scholar
Butler, S. (1810) A letter to the Rev. C. J. Blomfield … containing remarks on the Edinburgh Review of the Cambridge Aeschylus …, Shrewsbury.Google Scholar
Butler, S. (1896) The life and letters of Dr. Samuel Butler, London.Google Scholar
Clark, W. (2006) Academic charisma and the rise of the research university, Chicago.Google Scholar
Clarke, M. L. (1937) Richard Porson: a biographical essay, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Clarke, M. L. (1945) Greek studies in England 1700–1830, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Clarke, M. L. (1959) Classical education in Great Britain 1500–1900, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Coates, V. C. G. and Seydl, J. L. (eds.) (2007) Antiquity recovered: the legacy of Pompeii and Herculaneum, New York.Google Scholar
Collard, C. (2004) ‘George Burges’, in Todd, R. B. (ed.) Dictionary of British classicists, Bristol, 119–20.Google Scholar
Copleston, E. (1810) Reply to the calumnies of the Edinburgh Review against Oxford, Oxford.Google Scholar
Davy, H. (1821) ‘Some observations and experiments on the papyri found in the ruins of Herculaneum’, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 111, 191–208.Google Scholar
Dobree, P. P. (ed.) (1820) Ricardi Porsoni notae in Aristophanem, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Dobree, P. P. (ed.) (1822) Photiou tou patriarchou lexeon synagoge: e codice Galeano descripsit Ricardus Porsonus, Cambridge.Google Scholar
[Donaldson, J. W.] (1840) ‘Richard Porson’, Penny Cyclopaedia 18, 420.Google Scholar
Dowling, L. (1986) Language and decadence in the Victorian fin de siècle, Princeton.Google Scholar
Drake, B. (ed.) (1853) Aeschyli Eumenides; the Greek text with English notes critical and explanatory; and English verse translation; and an introduction, containing an analysis of the dissertations of C. O. Müller, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Drury, H. (ed.) (1841) Arundines Cami, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Elmsley, P. (1810) ‘Blomfield's Prometheus vinctus’, Edinburgh Review 17, 211–42, 491.Google Scholar
Elmsley, P. (1812a) ‘Markland's Euripidis Supplices’, Quarterly Review 7, 441–64.Google Scholar
Elmsley, P. (1812b) ‘Monk's Euripidis Hippolytus’, Quarterly Review 8, 215–30.Google Scholar
Engel, A. J. (1983) From clergyman to don: the rise of the academic profession in nineteenth-century Oxford, Oxford.Google Scholar
Finglass, P. J. (2007) ‘A newly-discovered edition of Sophocles by Peter Elmsley’, GRBS 47, 1–16.Google Scholar
Fleck, L. (1935/1979) Genesis and development of a scientific fact, Chicago (originally published in German in 1935).Google Scholar
Gascoigne, J. (1989) Cambridge in the Age of the Enlightenment: science, religion and politics from the Restoration to the French Revolution, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Grafton, A. T. (1983) ‘Polyhistor into Philolog: notes on the transformation of German classical scholarship, 1780–1850’, History of Universities, vol. 3, 153–92.Google Scholar
Gunning, H. (1855) Reminiscences of Cambridge, 2 vols., London.Google Scholar
Hardie, W. R. (1920) Res metrica: an introduction to the study of Greek and Roman versification, Oxford.Google Scholar
H[are], J. C. (1832) ‘Dobree's Adversaria’, Philological Museum 1, 204–8.Google Scholar
Harrison, J. E. (1912) Themis: a study of the social origins of Greek religion, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Henderson, J. G. W. (1998) Juvenal's Mayor: the professor who lived on 2d a day, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Henderson, J. G. W. (2006) ‘Oxford Reds’: classic commentaries on Latin classics, London.Google Scholar
Henderson, J. G. W. (2007) ‘The “Euripides Reds” series: well-laid plans at OUP’, in Stray, C. A. (ed.) Classical books: scholarship and publishing in Britain since 1800, London.Google Scholar
Hewlett, J. T. J. (1843) College life, or The proctor's notebook, 3 vols., London.Google Scholar
Hillard, G. S. (ed.) (1876) Life, letters and journals of George Ticknor (2nd edn.), Boston.Google Scholar
Horsfall, N. M. (1974) ‘Classical studies in England, 1810–1825’, GRBS 15, 449–77.Google Scholar
Horsfall, N. M. (1987) Review of Brink (1986), CR 37, 122–3.Google Scholar
Housman, A. E. (ed.), (1903) M. Manilii Astronomicon liber primus, London.Google Scholar
Housman, A. E. (1969) The confines of criticism: the Cambridge inaugural 1911, ed. Carter, J., Cambridge.Google Scholar
Kidd, T. (ed.) (1815) Tracts and miscellaneous criticisms of the late Richard Porson, London.Google Scholar
Kuhn, T. S. (1966) The structure of scientific revolutions, Chicago.Google Scholar
Lloyd-Jones, H. (1982) Blood for the ghosts: classical influences in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, London.Google Scholar
Lehnus, L. (1997) ‘“Some Oxford scholars”. Una conferenza inedita di J. U. Powell’, Eikasmos 8, 245–82.Google Scholar
Luard, H. R. (1857) ‘Richard Porson’, in Cambridge essays 1857, London, 125–71.Google Scholar
Luard, H. R. (ed.) (1867) The correspondence of Richard Porson, M.A., formerly Regius Professor of Greek in the University of Cambridge, Cambridge.Google Scholar
McKitterick, D. J. (1998) A history of Cambridge University Press, vol. 2: scholarship and commerce 1698–1872, Cambridge.Google Scholar
McKitterick, D. J. (2007) ‘Publishing and perishing in classics: E. H. Barker and the early nineteenth-century English book trades’, in Stray, C. A. (ed.) Classical books: scholarship and publishing in Britain since 1800, London.Google Scholar
McManus, B. F. (2007) ‘“Macte nova virtute, puer!”: Gilbert Murray as mentor and friend to J. A. K. Thomson’, in Stray, C. A. (ed.) Gilbert Murray reassessed, Oxford, 181–200.Google Scholar
Major, J. R. (1826) The Hecuba of Euripides, from the text, and with a translation of the notes, preface, and supplement of Porson …, London.Google Scholar
Major, J. R. (1827) Questions adapted to Mitford's History of Greece …, London.Google Scholar
Major, J. E. B. (ed.) (1869) Baker, T., History of the College of St John the Evangelist, Cambridge, 2 vols., Cambridge.Google Scholar
Monk, J. H. and Blomfield, C. J. (eds.) (1812) Adversaria: nota et emendationes in poetas Grœcos quas ex schedis manuscriptis Porsoni deprompserunt et ordinarunt nee non indicibus instruxerunt Jacobus Henricus Monk A.M., Carolus Jacobus Blomfield A.M., Cambridge.Google Scholar
Murray, G. G. A. (1889) The place of Greek in education, Glasgow.Google Scholar
Nuttall, A. D. (2003) Dead from the waist down. Scholars and scholarship in the popular imagination. New Haven.Google Scholar
Ogilvie, R. M. (1964) Latin and Greek: a history of the influence of the classics on English life from 1600 to 1918, London.Google Scholar
Page, D. L. (1960) ‘Richard Porson (1759–1808)’, Proceedings of the British Academy 45, 221–36.Google Scholar
Parr, S. (1828) Works, with memoirs of his life and writings, and a selection from his correspondence, ed. Johnstone, J., 8 vols., London.Google Scholar
Pelikan, J. (1999) ‘Foreword’, in Fitzgerald, A. D. (ed.) Augustine through the ages: an encyclopedia, Grand Rapids MI, xiv.Google Scholar
Pinney, T. (ed.) (1974) Letters of Thomas Babington Macaulay, vol. I, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Pinney, T. (1981) Letters of Thomas Babington Macaulay, vol. 6, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Preyer, R.O. (1985) ‘The romantic tide reaches Trinity: notes on the transmission and diffusion of new approaches to traditional studies at Cambridge, 1820–1840’, in Paradis, J. and Postlewait, T. (eds.) Victorian science and Victorian values: literary perspectives, New Brunswick NJ, 39–68.Google Scholar
Rouse, J. (1987) Knowledge and power: towards a political philosophy of science, Ithaca NY.Google Scholar
Rudwick, M. J. S. (2005) Bursting the limits of time: the reconstruction of geohistory in the age of revolution, Chicago.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schaffer, S. (1991) ‘The history and geography of the intellectual world: Whewell's politics of language’. in Fisch, M. and Schaffer, S. (eds.) William Whewell: a composite portrait, Oxford, 201–32.Google Scholar
Schaffer, S. (2007) ‘Newton on the beach: a genealogy of testimony and solitude’: unpublished paper, Dept. of History and Philosophy of Science, University of Cambridge. (Accessible via the author: )Google Scholar
Sedgwick, A. (1833) A discourse on the studies of the university, Cambridge and London (reprinted in 1969, eds. Ashby, E. and Anderson, M., Leicester).Google Scholar
Short, T. V. (1829) A letter on the state of the public examinations in the University of Oxford… reprinted with an appendix, Oxford.Google Scholar
Smith, G. H. (1834) A manual of Grecian antiquities. Compiled for the use of schools and private students, London.Google Scholar
Smith, J. (2001) ‘Trinity College annual examinations in the nineteenth century’, in Smith, and Stray, , 122–38.Google Scholar
Smith, J. and Stray, C. A. (eds.) (2001) Teaching and learning in nineteenth-century Cambridge, Woodbridge.Google Scholar
Stray, C. A. (1988) ‘England, culture and the 19th century’, Liverpool Classical Monthly 13.6, 85–90.Google Scholar
Stray, C. A. (1997) ‘“Thucydides or Grote?” Classical disputes and disputed classics in 19th-century Cambridge’. TAPA 127, 363–71.Google Scholar
Stray, C. A. (2001a) ‘A parochial anomaly: the classical tripos 1822–1900’, in Smith, and Stray, , 31–44.Google Scholar
Stray, C. A. (2001b) ‘Curriculum and style in the collegiate university: classics in nineteenth-century Oxbridge’, History of Universities, 16.2, 183–218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stray, C. A. (2004a) ‘John Selby Watson’, in Todd, R. B. (ed.), Dictionary of British classicists, Bristol, 1034–5.Google Scholar
Stray, C. A. (2004b) ‘From one Museum to another: the Museum Criticum (1813–26) and the Philological Museum (1831–3)’, Victorian Periodicals Review 37.3, 289–314.Google Scholar
Stray, C. A. (2005) ‘Flying at dusk: the 1906 preelections’, in Stray, (ed.), The owl of Minerva: the Cambridge praelections of 1906, Cambridge Philological Society, supp. vol. 28, 1–12.Google Scholar
Stray, C. A. (2007a) ‘Politics, culture and scholarship: classics in the Quarterly Review’, in Cutmore, J. (ed.), John Murray's gentlemen: the Quarterly Review 1809–24, London.Google Scholar
Stray, C. A. (2007b) ‘Sir William Smith and his dictionaries: a study in scarlet and black’, in id. (ed.) Classical books: scholarship and publishing in Britain since 1800, London.Google Scholar
Tilley, A. A. (1884) ‘The development of classical learning’, National Review 3, 163–76.Google Scholar
Traweek, S. (1988) Beamtimes and lifetimes: the world of high energy physicists, Cambridge MA.Google Scholar
Tyrrell, R. Y. (1888) ‘The old school of classics and the new. A dialogue of the dead’, Fortnightly Review 49, 42–59.Google Scholar
Walker, W. S. (1852) The poetical remains of William Sidney Walker, edited with a memoir by Revd J. Moultrie, London.Google Scholar
Warwick, A. (2003) Masters of theory: Cambridge and the rise of mathematical physics, Chicago.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Warwick, A. and Kaiser, D. (2005) ‘Kuhn, Foucault, and the power of pedagogy’, in Kaiser, D. (ed.) Pedagogy and the practice of science, Cambridge MA, 393–409.Google Scholar
Watson, J. S. (1861) The life of Richard Porson, M.A., Professor of Greek in the University of Cambridge from 1792 to 1808, London.Google Scholar
Wilson, A. T. and Wilson, J. S. (eds.) (1933) James M. Wilson: an autobiography, London.Google Scholar
Winstanley, D. A. (1940) Early Victorian Cambridge, Cambridge.Google Scholar
[Wright, J. M. F.] (1827) Alma mater, or, Seven years at the University of Cambridge, by a Trinity-man, 2 vols., London.Google Scholar