Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T21:07:11.053Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The paintings on the Hermes tomb under San Sebastiano: a new Interpretation

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 February 2013

Alastair H. B. Logan
Alastair H. B. Logan
Affiliation:
University of Exeter
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

How early did Christians make their presence felt in the ancient cemetery under the present church of San Sebastiano in Rome? In this present article I will argue that enigmatic paintings on the attic of a second-century tomb, the tomb of Clodius Hermes, whose subject-matter and provenance is much disputed, are best interpreted as Christian and as representing three Lukan parables from chapters 14–15 (the Lost Sheep, the Great Supper and the Prodigal Son). I will suggest they were the work of a Christian slave or freedman of the household, perhaps a member of the titulus Byzantis on the Clivus Scauri, seeking to win over those coming to honour their dead relatives in the cemetery. It was such a community that was responsible for choosing the site for the joint cult of Peter and Paul in 258. My methodology will be, in the light of scholarly disagreement over the interpretation of the paintings as Christian, (a) to demonstrate the logic of the three scenes as representing linked parables, the likely identity of their author(s) and their apologetic function, with literary support from Tertullian; (b) to show the lack of obvious pagan parallels and argue for the plausibility of parables in the light of their occurrence and function elsewhere; (c) to suggest that such evidence of a Christian presence makes more comprehensible the later choice of the site for the joint cult.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Cambridge Classical Journal , Volume 53 , 2007 , pp. 180 - 201
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s). Published online by Cambridge University Press 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Bendinelli, G. (1922) ‘Il monumento scpolcrale degli Aureli al viale Manzoni in Roma’, Monumenti Antichi 28, 290–520.Google Scholar
Bovini, G. (1958) Mosaici di S. Apollinare Nuovo di Ravenna: il ciclo cristologico, Florence.Google Scholar
Brandenburg, H. (1979) Roms frühchristliche Basiliken des 4 Jahrhunderts, Munich.Google Scholar
Brandenburg, H. (1992) ‘Die konstantinischen Kirchen in Rom: Staatsragender Kult und Herrscherkult zwischen Tradition und Neuerung’, in Brehm, O. and Klie, S. (eds.) MOUSIKOS ANER. Festschrift für Max Wegner zum 90. Geburtstag, Bonn, 25–58.Google Scholar
Brent, A. (1994) Hippolytus and the Roman Church in the third century, Leiden.Google Scholar
Buchheit, V. (1974) ‘Tertullian und die Anfänge der christlichen Kunst’, Römische Quartalschrift 69, 133–42.Google Scholar
Calza, G. (1944) La necropoli del porto di Roma nell'Isola Sacra, Rome.Google Scholar
Carcopino, J. (1956) De Pythagore aux Apôtres, Paris.Google Scholar
Carletti, C. (1981) ‘Pagani e cristiani nel sepolcreto della “piazzola” sotto la Basilica Apostolorum a Roma’, Vetera Christianorum 18, 287–307.Google Scholar
Cecchelli, C. (1944) Monumenti cristiano-eretici di Roma, Rome.Google Scholar
Chadwick, H. (1957) ‘St. Peter and St. Paul in Rome: the problem of the Memoria Apostolorum ad Catacumbas’, JTS n.s. 8, 31–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Colini, A. M. (1944) ‘Storia e tipografia del Celio nell'antichità’, Atti della pontificia Accademia romanadi Archeologia, Serie 3, Memorie 7.Google Scholar
Curran, J. (2000) Pagan city and Christian capital: Rome in the fourth century, Oxford.Google Scholar
de Bruyne, L. (1958) ‘Refrigerium Interim’, RAC 34, 87–118.Google Scholar
Deckers, J. G., Seeliger, H. R., Mietke, G. (eds.) (1987) Die Katakombe ‘Santi Marcellino e Pietro’, Repertorium der Malereien, Roma sotterranea cristiana 6, Vatican City/Münster.Google Scholar
Delehaye, H. (1933) Les origines du culte des martyrs (2nd. rev. edn.), Brussels.Google Scholar
Duchesne, L. (1955) Le Liber pontificalis: texte, introduction et commentaire, 3 vols. (1st edn. 1886), Paris.Google Scholar
Duchesne, L. (1923) ‘La “Memoria Apostolorum” de la via Appia’, in Atti della pontificia Accademia romana di Archeologia, Memorie Serie 3.1, 1–22 = (1973) Scripta minora: études de topographie romaine et de géographie ecclésiastique, Collection de l'École Française de Rome 13, Rome, 361–406.Google Scholar
Fasola, U. M. (1978) ‘Lavori nelle catacombe’, RAC 54, 7–13.Google Scholar
Felle, A. E. (1997) Inscriptiones christianae urbis Romae, Bari.Google Scholar
Finney, P. C. (1980) ‘Did Gnostics make pictures?’, in Layton, , 434–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Finney, P. C. (1994) The invisible God: the earliest Christians on art, New York and Oxford.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fischer, B., Fiala, V. (eds.) (1952) Colligere fragmenta: Festschrift Alban Dold zum 70 Geburtstag, Beuron.Google Scholar
Guarducci, M. (1973) ‘Valentiniani a Roma: ricerche epigrafiche ed archeologiche’, MR 80, 169–89.Google Scholar
Guidobaldi, F., Guidobaldi, A. G. (eds.) (2002) Ecclesiae Urbis: Atti del Congresso internazionale di studi sidle Chiese di Roma (IV – X secolo), Roma 4–10 settembre 2000, Studi di Antichità Cristiana 59, 3 vols., Vatican City.Google Scholar
Gwatkin, H. M. (1958) Selections from early Christian writers, London.Google Scholar
Jastrzębowska, E. (1981) Untersuchungen zum christlichen Totenmahl aufgrund der Monumente des 3. und 4. Jahrhunderts unter der Basilika des Hl. Sebastian in Rom, Frankfurt.Google Scholar
Jastrzębowska, E. (2002) ‘S. Sebastiano, la più antica basilica cristiana di Roma’, in Guidobaldi, and Guidobaldi, , 2. 1141–55.Google Scholar
Holloway, R. R. (2004) Constantine and Rome, New Haven/London.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jensen, R. M. (2000) Understanding early Christian art, London/New York.Google Scholar
Kjaergaard, J. (1984) ‘From “Memoria Apostolorum” to Basilica Apostolorum: on the early Christian cultcentre on the via Appia’, Analecta Romana Instituti Danici 13, 59–76.Google Scholar
Klauser, T. (1961) ‘Studien zur Entstehung der christlichen Kunst IV’, JbAC 4, 128–36.Google Scholar
Krautheimer, R. (1937) Corpus basilicarum christianarum Romae: le basiliche cristiane antiche di Roma (Sec. IV–IX) vol. 1, Vatican City.Google Scholar
Krautheimer, R., Corbett, S., Frankel, W. (eds.) (1970) Corpus basilicarum christianarum Romae: le basiliche cristiane antiche di Roma (Sec. IV–IX) vol. 4, Vatican City.Google Scholar
Lampe, P. (2003) From Paul to Valentinus: Christians at Rome in the first two centuries, London.Google Scholar
La Piana, G. (1921) ‘The tombs of Peter and Paul ad Catacumbas’, HTR 14, 53–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
La Rocca, E. (2002) ‘Le basiliche cristiane ‘a deambulatorio' e la sopravvivenza del culto eroico’, in Guidobaldi, and Guidobaldi, , 2. 1109–40.Google Scholar
Layton, B. (ed.) (1980) The rediscovery of Gnosticism, vol. 1, The school of Valentinus, Leiden.Google Scholar
Lietzmann, H. (1923) ‘The tomb of the Apostles ad Catacumbas’, HTR 16, 147–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lietzmann, H. (1927) Petrus und Paulus in Rom (2nd. edn.), Leipzig/Berlin.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Logan, A. H. B. (2006) The Gnostics: identifying an early Christian cult, London.Google Scholar
Mancini, G. (1923) ‘Scavi sotto la basilica di S. Sebastiano sull'Appia antica’, Notizie degli scavi di antichità 20, 3–79.Google Scholar
Marichal, R. (1953) ‘Les dates des graffiti de Saint-Sebastien’, Académie des Inscriptions et Belles Lettres: Comptes rendus, 60–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marucchi, O. (1921) ‘Di una iscrizione storica che può attribuirsi alla Basilica Apostolorum sulla via Appia’, Nuovo Bullettino di Archeologia Cristiana 27, 61–9.Google Scholar
Mohlberg, L. K. (1952) ‘Historische-kritische Bemerkungen zum Ursprung der sogennanten “Memoria Apostolorum” an der Appischen Strasse’, in Fischer, and Fiala, , 52–74.Google Scholar
Morisani, O. (1962) Gli affreschi di S. Angelo in Formis, Naples.Google Scholar
Nicolai, V. Fiocchi (2002) ‘Basilica Marci, Coemeterium Marci, Basilica Coemeterium Balbinue. A proposito della nuova basilica circiforme della via Ardeatina e della funzione funeraria delle chiese “a deambulatorio” del suburbio romano’, in Guidobaldi, and Guidobaldi, , 2. 1175–1201.Google Scholar
O'Connor, D. W. (1969) Peter in Rome. The literary, liturgical and archeological evidence, New York/London.Google Scholar
Owen, E. C. E. (ed.) (1933) Some authentic Acts of early martyrs, Oxford.Google Scholar
Prandi, A. (1936) La Memoria Apostolorum in Catacumbas 1: illustrazione del relievo e studio architettonico del complesso, Vatican City.Google Scholar
Scholten, C. (1988) ‘Gibt es Quellen zur Sozialgeschichte der Valentinianer Roms?’, ZNW 79, 244–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schumacher, W. N. (1987) ‘Die konstantinischen Exedra-Basiliken’, in Deckers, et al. , 132–86.Google Scholar
Snyder, G. F. (2003) Ante pacem: archaeological evidence of Church life before Constantine (rev. edn.), Macon.Google Scholar
Stevenson, J. (1978) The catacombs: rediscovered monuments of early Christianity, London.Google Scholar
Stevenson, J. (ed.) (1987) A new Eusebius (rev. edn.), London.Google Scholar
Styger, P. (1917) ‘Il monumento apostolico della via Appia’, Dissertazioni della pontificia Accademia romana di Archeologia, Serie 2, 13, Rome, 3–115.Google Scholar
Styger, P. (1927) Die altchristliche Grabeskunst: ein Versuch der einheitlichen Auslegung, Munich.Google Scholar
Styger, P. (1933) Die römische Katakomben: archäologischen Forschungen überden Ursprung und die Bedeutung der altchristlichen Grabstätten, Berlin.Google Scholar
Styger, P. (1935) Römische Märtyrergrüfte, 2 vols., Berlin.Google Scholar
Testini, P. (1954) ‘Noterelle sulla “Memoria Apostolorum in Catacumbas”’, RAC 30, 209–31.Google Scholar
Tolotti, F. (1953) Memorie degli apostoli in catacumbas: rilievo critico della memoria e della Basilica Apostolorum, Vatican City.Google Scholar
Tolotti, F. (1982) ‘Le basiliche cimiteriali con deambulatorio del suburbio romano: una questione ancora aperta’, MR 89, 153–211.Google Scholar
Tolotti, F. (1984) ‘Sguardo d'insiemeal monumento sotto S. Sebastiano e nuovo tentativo di interpretarlo’, RAC 60, 124–61.Google Scholar
Torp, H. (1953) ‘The Vatican excavations and the cult of Saint Peter’, Acta Archaeologica 24, 27–66.Google Scholar
Toynbee, J. M. C. (1971) Death and burial in the Roman world, London.Google Scholar
Toynbee, J. M. C., Ward, Perkins J. B. (1958) The shrine of St Peter and the Vatican excavations (2nd. edn), London.Google Scholar
von Gerkan, A. (1927) ‘Die MaJereien des Grabes X’, Beilage II, in Lietzmann, (1927) 301f.Google Scholar
von Gerkan, A. (1962) ‘Petrus in Vaticano et in Catacumbas’, JbAC 5, 23–42.Google Scholar
Wilpert, J. (1903) Die Malereien der Katakomben Roms, Freiburg im Breisgau.Google Scholar
Wilpert, J. (1917) Die römische Mosaiken und Malereien der kirchlichen Bauten vom IV bis XIII Jahrhundert, 4 vols., Freiburg im Breisgau.Google Scholar
Wilpert, J. (1924) ‘Le pitture dell'ipogeo di Aurelio Felicissimo presso il vialeManzoni in Roma’, Atti della pontificia Accademia romana di Archeologia, Memorie 3.1.2, Rome.Google Scholar
Wilpert, J. (1929–1932) I sarcofagi cristiani antichi, 5 vols., Rome.Google Scholar
Wirth, F. (1934) Römische Wandmalerei vom Untergang Pompejis bis zum Ende des 3. Jahrhundert, Berlin.Google Scholar