Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T21:22:46.896Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

CASTING A NEW CANON: COLLECTING AND TREATING CASTS OF GREEK AND ROMAN SCULPTURE, 1850–1939

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 August 2019

Emma M. Payne
Emma M. Payne*
Affiliation:
King's College London, UK
*
*[email protected].
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

From the mid-nineteenth century, it became de rigueur for Classics Departments to acquire casts of Greek and Roman sculpture to form reference and experimental collections. Recent scholarship has revived such casts, investigating their role as instruments of teaching and research, and their wavering popularity. This paper further examines the aims of those responsible for collecting casts, and discusses how these objectives influenced their materiality and treatment, as well as showing how the de facto creation of a new canon of casts through their repetition across the collections of different institutions contributed to the decline in their perceived importance.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Cambridge Classical Journal , Volume 65 , December 2019 , pp. 113 - 149
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2019. Published by Cambridge University Press 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

Research for this paper was conducted during a PhD funded by the AHRC at the Institute of Archaeology, UCL (2013–17). Writing up was completed in part during a research associateship at the Institute of Classical Studies, London and in part as a Leverhulme Early Career Fellow at KCL.

References

Works cited

Ashmole, B. (1994). Bernard Ashmole: an Autobiography, Oxford.Google Scholar
Badde, A. (2009). ‘Dust on busts: dust on plaster surfaces. Focussing on the portrait busts in the Rococo Hall of the Duchess Amalia Library in Weimar’, unpublished MA thesis, Northumbria University, Newcastle.Google Scholar
Baedeker, K. F. (1903) Italy: handbook for travellers. Part iii: Southern Italy and Sicily, with excursions to the Lipari Islands, Malta, Sardinia, Tunis, and Corfu, Leipzig.Google Scholar
Baker, M. (2007 [1982]) The history of the cast courts, V&A Masterpieces series, available at: www.vam.ac.uk/content/articles/t/the-cast-courts/, accessed 8 April 2019.Google Scholar
Barr, S. M. (2009) Making something out of next to nothing: Bartolomeo Cavaceppi and the major restorations of Myron's Discobolus, Faculty of the School of Art. ProQuest LLC, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Basile, J. (2014) Facsimile and originality: changing views of classical casts in arts education and art history, The International Journal of the Arts in Society: Annual Review 8, 11–30.Google Scholar
Beard, M. (1993) Casts and cast-offs: the origins of the Museum of Classical Archaeology, Proceedings of the Cambridge Philological Society 39, 1–29.Google Scholar
Beard, M. (2012) ‘Cambridge's “Shrine of the Muses”’, Journal of the History of Collections 24.3, 289–308.Google Scholar
Bilbey, D. and Trusted, M. (2010) ‘The question of casts – collecting and later reassessment of the cast collections at South Kensington, in Frederiksen and Marchand (2010) 465–84.Google Scholar
Borbein, A. H. (2000) ‘Zur Geschichte der Wertschätzung und Verwendung von Gisabgüssen antiker Skulpturen (insbesondere in Deutschland und in Berlin)’, in Lavagne, H. Queyrel, F. (eds.), Les moulages de sculptures antiques et l'histoire de l'archéologie. Actes du colloque international Paris, 24 Octobre 1997, Paris, Geneva, 29–43, available at: www.digitalsculpture.org/casts/borbein/index.html, accessed 8 April 2019.Google Scholar
Born, P. (2002) The canon is cast: plaster casts in American museum and university collections. Art Documentation, Journal of the Art Libraries Society of North America 21.2, 8–13.Google Scholar
Brannt, W. T. and Wahl, W. H. (1919) The techno-chemical receipt book, New York.Google Scholar
Brinkmann, V. and Wünsche, R. (eds.) (2007) Gods in color: painted sculpture of classical antiquity, exhibition at the Arthur M. Sackler Museum, Harvard University Art Museums in cooperation with Staatliche Antikensammlungen and Glyptothek Munich, Stiftung Archäologie Munich. 22 September 2007–20 January 2008, Munich.Google Scholar
Byatt, A. S. (1994) The virgin in the garden, London.Google Scholar
Caproni, P. P. and Brother (1911) Catalogue of Caproni casts: subjects for drawing and modeling classes, Boston, MA.Google Scholar
Caproni, P. P. and Brother (1913) Catalogue of plaster reproductions from antique, medieval and modern sculpture: subjects suitable for schools, libraries, and homes, Boston.Google Scholar
Casson, S. (1921) Catalogue of the Acropolis Museum. Volume ii: Sculpture and architectural fragments, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Cavaceppi, B. (1768–72) Raccolta d'antiche statue, busti, testi cognate, 3 vols., Rome.Google Scholar
Challis, D. (2009) ‘Charles Newton and the British Museum: articulating a science of ancient art in the nineteenth century’, in Adlam, C. and Simpson, J. (eds.), Critical exchange: art criticism of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries in Russia and Western Europe, Bern, 153–66.Google Scholar
Chicago, Art Institute of (1896) Catalogue of Objects in the Museum. Part i: Sculpture and painting, Chicago.Google Scholar
Chiurazzi, J. and Fils (1900) J. Chiurazzi et Fils, fournisseurs de cours et musées, Naples.Google Scholar
Coltman, V. (2009) Classical sculpture and the culture of collecting in Britain since 1760, New York.Google Scholar
Connor, P. (1989) ‘Cast-collecting in the nineteenth century: scholarship, aesthetics, connoisseurship’, in Clarke, G. W. (ed.), Rediscovering Hellenism: the Hellenic inheritance and the English imagination, Cambridge, 187–236.Google Scholar
Cormier, B. (2018) Copy culture: sharing in the age of digital reproduction, London.Google Scholar
Current Art Events (1905) The international studio: an illustrated magazine of fine and applied art, New York.Google Scholar
de Clarac, C. O. F. J.-B. (1826–53) Musée de sculpture antique et moderne, Paris.Google Scholar
D'Este, A. (1999 [1864]) Memorie della vita di Antonio Canova, Bassano del Grappa.Google Scholar
Dyson, S. L. (2010) ‘Cast collecting in the United States’, in Frederiksen and Marchand (2010) 557–76.Google Scholar
Elsner, J. (1998) Imperial Rome and Christian triump:. the art of the Roman Empire AD 100–450, Oxford and New York.Google Scholar
Frederick, F. F. (1899) Plaster casts and how they are made, New York.Google Scholar
Frederiksen, R. and Marchand, E. (eds.) (2010) Plaster casts: making, collecting and displaying from classical antiquity to the present, Transformationen der Antike, Berlin and New York.Google Scholar
Friedland, E., Grunow Sobocinski, M. and Gazda, E. (eds.) (2015) The Oxford handbook of Roman sculpture, New York.Google Scholar
Friedman, T. and Clifford, T. (1974) The man at Hyde Park corner: sculpture by John Cheere 1709–1787, Leeds.Google Scholar
Frieze, H. S. (1876) ‘Art museums and their connection with public libraries’, in US Bureau of Education (ed.), Public libraries in the UnitedSstates of America: their history, condition, and management. Special report. Part i, Washington, DC, 434–44.Google Scholar
Frischer, B. (2009) Digital sculpture project: Laocoön. An annotated chronology of the ‘Laocoön’ statue group, available at: www.digitalsculpture.org/laocoon/chronology, accessed 8 April 2019.Google Scholar
Furtwängler, A. (1895 [1893]) Masterpieces of Greek sculpture: a series of essays on the history of art, London.Google Scholar
Gardner, E. A. (1896) A handbook of Greek sculpture, London.Google Scholar
Gardner, P. (2010 [1887]) Classical archaeology: introductory letter (1887). Montana, USA.Google Scholar
Gazda, E. (1995) Roman sculpture and the ethos of emulation: reconsidering repetition, HSPh 97, 121–56.Google Scholar
Grand-Clément, A. (2005) ‘Couleur et esthétique classique au xixème siècle: l'art grec antique pouvait-il être polychrome?’, Ítaca: Quaderns Catalans de Cultura Clàssica. Societat Catalana d'Estudis Clàssics 21, 139–60.Google Scholar
Grossman, J. B., Podany, J. and True, M. (eds.) (2003) History of restoration of ancient stone sculptures: papers delivered at a symposium organized by the Departments of Antiquities and Antiquities Conservation of the J. Paul Getty Museum and held at the museum, 25–27 October 2001, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Habetzeder, J. (2012) ‘The impact of restoration: the example of the dancing satyr in the Uffizi’, Opuscula: Annual of the Swedish Institutes at Athens and Rome 5, 133–63.Google Scholar
Hägele, H. (2013) Colour in sculpture: a survey from ancient Mesopotamia to the present, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Hagen, B. (2007) ‘The cast collection at the Academy of Fine Arts in Vienna’, Visual Resources: An International Journal of Documentation 23.1–2, 7–19.Google Scholar
Hamilton, W. R. (1842) ‘Report of the committee appointed to examine the Elgin Marbles, in order to ascertain whether any evidence remains as to the employment of color in the decoration of the architecture or sculpture. Read by W. R. Hamilton, Esq. Honorary Fellow, at the closing Meeting of the Session 1836–7, held Monday, 24th July, 1837’, Transactions of the Royal Institute of British Architects of London. Volume i, Part ii, London, 102–8.Google Scholar
Haskell, F. and Penny, N. (1981) Taste and the antique: the lure of classical sculpture 1500–1900, New Haven and London.Google Scholar
Hennecke (1889) Hennecke's art studies, Chicago and Milwaukee.Google Scholar
Herz, N. and Waelkens, M. (eds.) (1988) Classical marble: geochemistry, technology, trade, Dordrecht.Google Scholar
Howard, S. (1992) ‘Fakes, intention, proofs and impulsion to know: the case for Cavaceppi and clones’, in Jones (1992) 51–62.Google Scholar
Jenkins, I. (1990) ‘Acquisition and supply of casts of the Parthenon sculptures by the British Museum’, The Annual of the British School at Athens 85, 89–114.Google Scholar
Jenkins, I. (1991) ‘Casts and the drawing school of the Royal Academy and British Museum’, Journal of the History of Collections 3.2, 293–4.Google Scholar
Jenkins, I. (1992) Archaeologists and aesthetes in the sculpture galleries of the British Museum, 1800–1939, London.Google Scholar
Jenkins, I. and Middleton, A. (1988) ‘Paint on the Parthenon sculptures’, ABSA 83, 183–207.Google Scholar
Jones, M. (ed.) (1990) Fake? The art of deception. London.Google Scholar
Jones, M. (1992) Why fakes matter: essays on problems of authenticity, LondonGoogle Scholar
Jones, O. (1854) An apology for the colouring of the Greek Court at the Crystal Palace, London.Google Scholar
Kenworthy-Browne, J. (2006) Plaster casts for the Crystal Palace, Sydenham, Sculpture Journal 15.2, 173–98.Google Scholar
Kurtz, D. (2000a) The reception of classical art in Britain: an Oxford story of plaster casts from the Antique, Oxford.Google Scholar
Kurtz, D. (2000b) ‘John Boardman's curatorship of the cast gallery, Ashmolean Museum 1978–1994’, in Tsetskhladze, G. R., Prag, A. J. N. W. and Snodgrass, A. M. (eds.), Periplous: papers on classical art and archaeology presented to Sir John Boardman, London, 178–89.Google Scholar
Mallampati, H. (2010) ‘Acquiring antiquity: the classical collections at the University of Michigan and the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, ca. 1850–1925’, PhD thesis, University of Michigan.Google Scholar
Mallampati Gleason, H. (2015) ‘Collecting in early America’, in Friedland, Grunow Sobocinski and Gazda (2015), 44–58.Google Scholar
Mallouchou-Tufano, F. (2007) ‘The vicissitudes of the Athenian Acropolis in the 19th century: from castle to monument’, in Valavanis (2007) 36–57.Google Scholar
Martellotti, G. (2003) ‘Reconstructive restorations of Roman sculptures: three case studies’, in Grossman, Podany and True (2003) 179–90.Google Scholar
Marvin, M. (2003) ‘Possessions of princes: the Ludovisi Collection’, in Grossman, Podany and True (2003) 225–38.Google Scholar
Marvin, M. (2008) The language of the muses: the dialogue between Roman and Greek Sculpture, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Mattusch, C. (2005) The Villa dei Papiri at Herculaneum: life and afterlife of a sculpture collection, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Mattusch, C. (2013) ‘Appearances can be deceiving: the presentation of bronzes from Herculaneum and Pompeii’, in Risser and Saunders (2013a) 30–40.Google Scholar
Melfi, M. (2010) ‘Old meets new: the Oxford University collection of casts from the antique and the new Ashmolean Museum’, in Marcinkowski, W. and Zaucha, T. (eds.), Plaster casts of the works of art: history of collections, conservation, exhibition practice. Materials from the conference in the National Museum in Krakow, Krakow, 23–36.Google Scholar
Metropolitan Museum of Art (1891) Tentative lists of objects desirable for a collection of casts, sculptural and architectural, intended to illustrate the history of plastic art for private circulation among those whose advice is sought in the preparation of final lists, to enable them the more readily to make suggestions to the Special Committee on Casts, New York.Google Scholar
Michaelis, A. (1882) Ancient marbles in Great Britain, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Milanese, A. (2013) ‘Exhibition and experiment: a history of the Real Museo Borbonico’, in Risser and Saunders (2013a) 13–29.Google Scholar
Mitchell, L. M. (1885) ‘Plaster in sculpture: its value as a medium for copying the old masters’, The New York Times, 20 April 1885.Google Scholar
Moltesen, M. (2003) ‘De-restoring and re-restoring: fifty years of restoration work in the Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek’, in Grossman, Podany and True (2003) 207–24.Google Scholar
Mulliez, D. (2007a) ‘Delos: the excavation of the sacred island of Apollo’, in Valavanis (2007) 78–99.Google Scholar
Mulliez, D. (2007b) Delphi: the excavation of the Great Oracular Centre (1892)’, in Valavanis (2007) 134–57.Google Scholar
Newby, Z. (2016) Greek myths in Roman art and culture: imagery, values and identity in Italy, 50 BC – AD 250, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Newton, C. T. (1880) Essay on art and archaeology, London.Google Scholar
Nichols, K. (2015) Greece and Rome at the Crystal Palace: classical sculpture and Modern Britain, 1854–1936, Oxford.Google Scholar
Nichols, K., Wade, R. and Williams, G. (eds.) (2016) Art versus industry? New perspectives on visual and industrial cultures in nineteenth-century Britain, Manchester.Google Scholar
Payne, E. M. (2019) ‘The conservation of plaster casts in the nineteenth century’, Studies in Conservation, DOI: 10.1080/00393630.2019.1610845.Google Scholar
Payne, E. M. (forthcoming a) ‘From pillar to post: classical casts at the British Museum’, in Alexandridis, A. and Winkler-Horaçek, L. (eds.), Destroy the copy: Transformationen der Antike, Berlin.Google Scholar
Payne, E. M. (forthcoming b) ‘3D imaging of the Parthenon sculptures: assessing the archaeological value of 19th century plaster casts’, Antiquity.Google Scholar
Perry, E. (2005) The aesthetics of emulation in the visual arts of ancient Rome, New York.Google Scholar
Perry, W. C. (1887) A descriptive catalogue of the collection of casts from the antique in the South Kensington Museum, London.Google Scholar
Pinelli, O. R. (1996) ‘The surgery of memory: ancient sculpture and historical restorations’, in Stanley-Price, N., Talley, M. K. J. and Vaccaro, A. M. (eds.), Historical and philosophical issues in the conservation of cultural heritage, Los Angeles, 288–306.Google Scholar
Pinelli, O. R. (2003) ‘From the need for completion to the cult of fragment: how tastes, scholarship, and museum curators’ choices changed our view of ancient sculpture’, in Grossman, Podany and True (2003) 61–74.Google Scholar
Podany, J. (2003) ‘Lessons from the past’, in Grossman, Podany and True (2003) 13–24.Google Scholar
Podany, J. (2015) ‘Conservation and restoration’, in Friedland, Grunow Sobocinski and Gazda (2015) 27–43.Google Scholar
Potts, A. (1998) ‘The impossible ideal: Romantic conceptions of the Parthenon sculptures in early nineteenth-century Britain and Germany’, in Hemingway, A. and Vaughan, W. (eds.), Art in bourgeois society, 1790–1850, Cambridge, 101–22.Google Scholar
Pryce, F. N. (1913) A guide to the collection of casts in the Department of Greek and Roman Antiquities in the British Museum, London.Google Scholar
Pye, E. (2001) Caring for the past: issues in conservation for archaeology and museums, London.Google Scholar
Quatremère de Quincy, A. C. (1815) Le Jupiter Olympien, ou l'art de la sculpture antique considéré sous un nouveau point de vue; ouvrage qui comprend un essai sur le gout de la sculpture polychrome, l'analyse explicative de la toreutique, et l'histoire de la statuaire en or et ivoire chez les Grecs et les Romains, avec la restitution des principaux monuments de cet art et la démonstration pratique ou le renouvellement de ses procédés mécaniques, Paris.Google Scholar
Ralph, J. (1734) A critical review of the publick buildings, statues and ornaments in, and about London and Westminster, London.Google Scholar
Reinach, S. (1897–1930) Répertoire de la statuaire grecque et romaine, Paris.Google Scholar
Ridgway, B. S. (1984) Roman copies of Greek sculpture, Ann Arbor.Google Scholar
Ridgway, B. S. (1990) Hellenistic sculpture i: The styles of ca. 331–200 bc, Wisconsin.Google Scholar
Riegl, A. (1996 [1903]) ‘The modern cult of monuments: its essence and its development’, in Stanley-Price, N., Kirby Talley, J. M. and Melucco Vaccaro, A. (eds.), Historical and philosophical issues in the conservation of cultural heritage, Los Angeles, 69–83.Google Scholar
Risser, E. and Saunders, D. (eds.) (2013a) The restoration of ancient bronzes: Naples and beyond, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Risser, E. and Saunders, D. (2013b) ‘The restoration history of the bronze Apollo and Diana from Pompeii’, in Risser and Saunders (2013a) 41–56.Google Scholar
Robinson, D. M. (1917) ‘On reproductions for the college museum and art gallery’, The Bulletin of the College Art Association of America 1.3, 15–21.Google Scholar
Robinson, E. (1887) Descriptive catalogue of the casts from Greek and Roman sculpture, Boston.Google Scholar
Robinson, E. (1892) Catalogue of Casts. Parts i, ii and iii: Ancient Sculpture, Boston.Google Scholar
Rockwell, P. (2003) ‘The creative reuse of antiquity’, In Grossman, Podany and True (2003) 75–86.Google Scholar
Siapkas, J. and Sjögren, L. (2014). Displaying the ideals of antiquity: the petrified gaze. London and New York.Google Scholar
Smailes, H. E. (1991) ‘A history of the statue gallery at the Trustees’ Academy in Edinburgh’, Journal of the History of Collections 3.2, 125–43.Google Scholar
Smith, A. H. (1900) A catalogue of sculpture in the Department of Greek and Roman Antiquities, in the British Museum. Volume ii, London.Google Scholar
Smith, A. H. (1910) The sculptures of the Parthenon: British Museum, Department of Greek and Roman Antiquities, London.Google Scholar
Solís Parra, A., Gasca Miramón, G., Sánchez, S. V., and Luzón Nogué, J. M. (2010) ‘The restoration of two plaster casts acquired by Velázquez in the seventeenth century: the Hercules and Flore Farnese’, in Frederiksen and Marchand (2010) 385–402.Google Scholar
St Clair, W. (1967) Lord Elgin and the marbles: the controversial history of the Parthenon sculptures, Oxford.Google Scholar
Stewart, A. (2012) ‘Hellenistic freestanding sculpture from the Athenian agora. Part i: Aphrodite’, Hesperia: The Journal of the American School of Classical Studies at Athens 81.2, 267–342.Google Scholar
Stroszeck, J. (2007) ‘Kerameikos i: the discovery of the ancient cemetery (1863)’, in Valavanis (2007) 58–71.Google Scholar
Stuart, J. and Revett, N. (1762–94) The antiquities of Athens: measured and delineated, London.Google Scholar
Tietze, A. (1998) ‘Classical casts and colonial galleries: the life and afterlife of the 1908 Beit Gift to the National Gallery of Cape Town’, South African Historical Journal 39.1, 70–90.Google Scholar
True, M. (2003) ‘Changing approaches to conservation’, in Grossman, Podany and True (2003) 1–12.Google Scholar
Valavanis, P. (ed.) (2007) Great moments in Greek archaeology, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Vaughan, G. (1992) ‘The restoration of classical sculpture in the eighteenth century and the problem of authenticity’, in M. Jones (1992) 41–50.Google Scholar
Vaughan, G. (1997) ‘Some observations and reflections on the restoration of antique sculpture in the eighteenth century’, in Lindley, P. (ed.), Sculpture conservation: preservation or interference?, Brookfield, VT, 195–208.Google Scholar
Verri, G. (2009) ‘The spatially resolved characterisation of Egyptian blue, Han blue and Han purple by photo-induced luminescence digital imaging’, Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry 394, 1011–21.Google Scholar
Wade, R. (2018) Domenico Brucciani and the formatori of 19th-century Britain, London and New York.Google Scholar
Whitehill, W. M. (1970) Museum of Fine Arts, Boston: a centennial history, London.Google Scholar
Winckelmann, J. J. (2011 [1762, 1764]) Letter and report on the discoveries at Herculaneum, tr. Mattusch, C. C., Los Angeles.Google Scholar