Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-vdxz6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T20:45:25.207Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Memoirs, confessions and apologies: the last chapter of Byzantine autobiography

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 January 2016

Michael Angold
Michael Angold*
Affiliation:
Edinburgh
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Two issues are addressed here: the status of Byzantine autobiography and the state of Byzantine literary culture in its last years. Autobiographical information was mostly a device used at all levels of Byzantine literature for immediacy, emphasis and to suggest personal involvement. It continued to function in this way in the last years of Byzantium, but there was also a degree of experimentation, as it extended its range into satire and comedy and, in the hands of Theodore Agallianos evolved from the rhetoric of apologia into fully-fledged autobiography.

Type
Articles
Information
Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies , Volume 37 , Issue 2 , 2013 , pp. 208 - 225
Copyright
Copyright © The Centre for Byzantine, Ottoman and Modern Greek Studies, University of Birmingham 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Mathew, G., Byzantine Aesthetics (London 1963) 141 Google Scholar.

2 Mazaris’ Journey to Hades, ed. and trans. Smithies, A. et al. [Arethusa Monographs, 5] (Buffalo NY, 1975)Google Scholar (hereafter Mazaris).

3 Canivet, P. and Oikonomidès, N., (Jean Argyropoulos) La Comédie de Katablattas. Invective byzantine du XVe s (Athens 1982-83)Google Scholar (hereafter Katablattas).

4 Laurent, V., Les “Mémoires” de Sylvestre Syropoulos sur le concile de Florence (1438-1439) (Paris 1971)Google Scholar (hereafter Syropoulos).

5 Sfranze, Giorgio, Cronaca, ed. Malsano, R. [CFHB ser. Italica, 29] (Rome 1990)Google Scholar (hereafter Sphrantzes).

6 Patrinelis, K. G., ‘О Θέοδωρος Άγαλλιανός ταυτιζόμενος προς τον Θεοφάνην Μηδείας каі оі άνεκδοτοι λόγοι του> (Athens: privately printed, 1966)Google Scholar (hereafter Agallianos). For a list of his works, see now Blanches, M.-H. ‘Bilan des études sur Théodore Agallianos’, ‘O Έρανιστής 28 (2011) 25–48 Google Scholar.

7 Hinterberger, M., Autobiographische Traditionen in Byzanz [Wiener Byzantinische Studien, 22] (Vienna 1999)Google Scholar.

8 Kazhdan, A.P. and Epstein, A.W., Change in Byzantine Culture in the eleventh and twelfth centuries (Berkeley/Los Angeles/London 1985) 230 Google Scholar.

9 Macrides, R.J., ‘The historian in the History’, in ΦΙΛΕΛΛΗΝ. Studies in honour of Robert Browning, ed. Constantinides, C.N. et al. (Venice 1996) 205-24Google Scholar.

10 Kazhdan, A.P., ‘L’histoire de Cantucuzène en tant qu’oeuvre littéraire’, B 50 (1980) 279–335 Google Scholar; contra Nicol, D. M., The Reluctant Emperor: a biography of John Cantacuzene, Byzantine emperor and monk, c.1295-1383 (Cambridge 1996) 162, 167-9Google Scholar.

11 Mercati, G., Notizie di Procoro e Demetrio Cidone, Manuele Caleca e Teodoro Meliteniota ed altri appunti per la storia deUa teologia e della letteratura bizantina del secolo XIV [Studi e Testi 56] (Vatican 1931) 359-103Google Scholar; Kianka, F., ‘The Apology of Demetrius Kydones’, Byzantine Studies/Études Byzantines 7 (1980) 57–71 Google Scholar; Ryder, J.R., The Career and Writings of Demetrius Kydones: a study of fourteenth-century Byzantine politics, religion and society [Medieval Mediterranean, 85] (Leiden 2010) 13–15 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 44-6, 84-5, 197-205.

12 Angold, M.J., ‘Were Byzantine monastic typika literature?’, in Beaton, R. and Roueché, Ch., eds., The Making of Byzantine History: Studies dedicated to Donald M. Nicol (Aldershot 1993) 46–70 Google Scholar; Angold, M.J., ‘The autobiographical impulse in Byzantium’, DOP 52 (1998) 225-57Google Scholar.

13 Miklosich, F. and Müller, J., Acta et diplomata medii aevi sacra et profana (Vienna 1861) II, 224-30Google Scholar; Nicol, D. M., ‘The confessions of a bogus patriarch: Paul Tagaris Palaiologos, Orthodox patriarch of Jerusalem and Catholic patriarch of Constantinople in the fourteenth century’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History 21 (1970) 289-99CrossRefGoogle Scholar (repr. in Nicol, D.M., Byzantium: Ecclesiastical History and Relations with the Western World (London 1972) no. IX)Google Scholar; Hinterberger, Autobiographische Traditionen, 376-81.

14 Miklosich and Müller, II, 225.30-1.

15 Sphrantzes, 4.2-3

16 See Sphrantzes, 36-37.

17 Kugéas, S., ‘Notizbuch eines Beamten der Metropolis in Thessalonike aus dem Anfang des XV. Jahrhunderts’, BZ 23 (1914) 143-63Google Scholar.

18 Jones, P.J., ‘Florentine families and Florentine diaries in the fourteenth century’, Papers of the British School at Rome 24 (1956) 183–206 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Sphrantzes, XLI, 7: 170.1-8; XLII, 12: 176.7-10.

20 Sphrantzes, XXXIII, 2-3: 118-20.

21 Sphrantzes, XXXVI, 14: 142.9-14.

22 Sphrantzes, XXXV, 11-12: 134-6; XXXVII, 3: 144.5-9; XXXVII, 9: 146.7-9; XXXVII, 6: 144.27-32.

23 Sphrantzes, XXIII, 1-4: 80.1-29.

24 Sphrantzes, XXIII, 5-7: 82.1-26.

25 Gill, J., Personalities of the Council of Florence and other essays (Oxford 1964) 144-77Google Scholar.

26 Syropoulos, XII, 15:566.22-3.

27 Syropoulos, XII, 10: 556-559. Cf. Polites, N.G., “H μετάνοια τοΰ Σιλβέστρου Συροπούλου’, EEBS 39-40 (1972-73) 386–402 Google Scholar.

28 Gill, Personalities of the Council of Florence, 170-5.

29 Syropoulos, III, 11: 172.1-5.

30 Syropoulos, 41.

31 Syropoulos, II, 4: 104.12-15.

32 Mazaris, 66.9-10.

33 Mazaris, 74.33-76.1.

34 Only Baldwin, B., ‘The Mazaris. Reflections and reappraisal’, Illinois Classical Studies 18(1993) 345-58Google Scholar, does justice to the text’s literary qualities.

35 Katablattas, 31.50.

36 Katabiattas, 71-5.

37 Katabiattas, 8-9, 16, 18-20.

38 Ganchou, Th., ‘Iôannès Argyropoulos, Géôrgios Trapézountios et le patron crétois Géôrgios Maurikas’, Thesaurismata 38 (2008) 105–212 Google Scholar.

39 Doukas, , Historia Byzantina, ed. Becker, I. [CHSB] (Bonn 1834) 214.2Google Scholar

40 Mondrain, B., ‘Jean Argyropoulos professeur à Constantinople et ses auditeurs médecins, d’Andronic Éparque à Demetrios Angelos’, in Scholz, C. and Makris, G., eds., ΠΟΑΤΠΑΕΤΡΟΣΝΟΥΣ, Miscellanea für Peter Schreiner zu seinem 60. Geburtstag (Munich 2000) 223-50Google Scholar.

41 Woodhouse, C.M., Gemistos Plethon: the last of the Hellenes (Oxford 1986) 273-82Google Scholar.

42 Oeuvres completes de Gennade Scholarios, ed. Petit, L. et al, 8 vols. (Paris 1928-36) (hereafter Scholar-ios) IV, 476-89Google Scholar; Syropoulos, 537, n.8; Woodhouse, Gemistos Plethon, 271-2, 315-18; Blanchet, M.-H., Georges-Gennadios Scholarios (vers 1400-vers 1472): un intellectuel orthodoxe face à la disparition de l’empire byzantin [Archives de l’Orient Chrétien, 20] (Paris 2008) 182-3Google Scholar.

43 Scholarios, III, 111.3-15

44 Ganchou, ‘Ioannès Argyropoulos’, esp.136-41.

45 Blanchet, Scholarios, 217-20.

46 See Gill, J., Personalities of the Council of Florence and other Essays (Oxford 1964) 79–94 Google Scholar.

47 Blanchet, Scholarios, 419-26.

48 Scholarios, IV, 211-31; Blanchet, Scholarios, 496-99.

49 Scholarios, I, 283-94; Blanchet, Scholarios, 499-502.

50 Scholarios I, 288-90.

51 Scholarios IV, 226.9-35.

52 Scholarios IV, 224-25.

53 Scholarios I, 290.30-4.

54 Scholarios I, 293.8-18.

55 Scholarios I, 287.6-31.

56 Scholarios I, 287.31-4.

57 A.D. Angelou, ‘ “Who am I?” Scholarios’ answers and the Hellenic identity’, in ΦΪΛΕΛΛΗΝ, 1-19.

58 BLanchet, M.-H., ‘L’ambiguïté du statut juridique de Gennadios Scholarios après la chute de Constantinople (1453)’, in Muresan, D. and Odorico, P., eds., Le Patriarcat œcuménique de Constantinople aux XIVe-XVIe siècles: ruptures et continuité, [Dossiers byzantins, 7] (Paris 2007) 195–211 Google Scholar.

59 Patrinelis, K., “O Θεόδωρος Άγαλλιανος ταυτιζόμενος προς τον Θεοφάνην Μηδείας καί οί άνέκδοτοι λόγοι του’, Επετηρίς του Μεσαιωνικου Αρχείου 14 (1966) 97.218-20Google Scholar.

60 Agallianos, 98.258-61.

61 Agallianos, 91.25.

62 Agallianos, 129.1370.

63 Angold, M.J., ‘Theodore Agallianos: the last Byzantine Autobiography’, in Guirao, E. Matos et al., eds., Constantinopla: 550 años de su caída, ed. (Granada 2006) I, 1–11 Google Scholar.

64 Agallianos, 93-4.

65 Agallianos, 94-5.

66 Agallianos, 96.183-204.

67 Agallianos, 97.209-21. See now, Blanchet, M.-H., Théodore Agallianos, Dialogue avec un moine contre les Latins (1442) (Paris 2013)Google Scholar; eadem, ‘Image de l’Union et de la croisade dans le Dialogue avec un moine contre les Latins de Théodore Agallianos (1442)’, in Italy and Europe’s eastern border (1204-1669) (Frankfurt 2012) 31-44.

68 Agallianos, 97.225-227.

69 Agallianos, 97.236-41.

70 Agallianos, 97-8.

71 Agallianos, 98.247-57.

72 Runciman, S., The Great Church in Captivity: a study of the patriarchate of Constantinople from the eve of the Turkish Conquest to the Greek War of Independence (Cambridge 1968) 187 Google Scholar, 195-207.

73 Agallianos, 133.1521-8.

74 Agallianos, 110.690-5.

75 Agallianos, 107.586.

76 Agallianos, 103.442-7.