Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-05T08:06:51.712Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Historical Perspectives on Entrepreneurship and Philanthropy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 September 2019

Charles Harvey ,
Mairi Maclean  and
Roy Suddaby
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

We define philanthropy as voluntary giving by households or corporate bodies to promote charitable causes, projects, and organizations or, alternatively, as “voluntary action for the public good.” Entrepreneurial philanthropy refers specifically to “the pursuit by entrepreneurs on a not-for-profit basis of big social objectives through active investment of their economic, cultural, social and symbolic resources.” Government projects financed by taxation and interfamily resource transfers are never philanthropic. Gifts only qualify as philanthropic when the donor is under no compulsion to give, when the gift benefits people with whom the donor is not directly connected, when the gift is made from the donor's own resources, and when the donor receives no direct economic benefit as a consequence of making the gift. In other words, philanthropists invest their own resources in causes they believe will benefit others and that yield no direct benefit to themselves or their families.

Keywords

charitable givingentrepreneurshipfoundationshistorical organization studiesphilanthropy
Type
Research Article
Information
Business History Review , Volume 93 , Issue 3: Entrepreneurship and Philanthropy , Autumn 2019 , pp. 443 - 471
Copyright
Copyright © The President and Fellows of Harvard College 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Payton, Robert L. and Moody, Michael P., Understanding Philanthropy (Bloomington, IN, 2008), 28Google Scholar.

2 Harvey, Charles, Maclean, Mairi, Gordon, Jillian, and Shaw, Eleanor, “Andrew Carnegie and the Foundations of Contemporary Entrepreneurial Philanthropy,” Business History 53, no. 3 (2011): 425–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 428.

3 Bekkers, René and Wiepking, Pamela, “A Literature Review of Empirical Studies of Philanthropy: Eight Mechanisms That Drive Charitable Giving,” Nonprofit and Voluntary Quarterly 40, no. 5 (2011): 924–973CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Schervish, Paul G., “Major Donors, Major Motives: The People and Purposes behind Major Gifts,” New Directions for Philanthropic Fundraising 47 (2005): 49–87Google Scholar.

4 Maclean, Mairi, Harvey, Charles, Gordon, Jillian, and Shaw, Eleanor, “Identity, Storytelling and the Philanthropic Journey,” Human Relations 68, no. 10 (2015): 1623–52CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

5 Smith, Christian and Davidson, Hilary, “How Generosity Enhances Well-Being,” in The Philanthropy Reader, ed. Moody, Michael and Breeze, Beth (London, 2016), 60–62Google Scholar.

6 Hall, Peter D., “Religion, Philanthropy, Service and Civic Engagement in Twentieth Century America,” in Gifts of Time and Money in America's Communities, ed. Brooks, Arthur C. (Lanham, MD, 2005), 159–84Google Scholar.

7 Harvey, Maclean, Gordon, and Shaw, “Andrew Carnegie.”

8 Callahan, David, The Givers: Wealth, Power and Philanthropy in a New Gilded Age (New York, 2017)Google Scholar; Pevnick, Ryan, “Philanthropy and Democratic Ideals,” in Philanthropy in Democratic Societies, ed. Reich, Rob, Cordelli, Chiara, and Bernholz, Lucy (Chicago, 2016), 226–43Google Scholar.

9 Bishop, Matthew and Green, Michael, Philanthrocapitalism: How Giving Can Save the World (New York, 2008)Google Scholar.

10 Baumol, William J. and Strom, Robert J., “Entrepreneurship and Philanthropy: Protecting the Public,” in Handbook of Entrepreneurs’ Engagement in Philanthropy, ed. Taylor, Marilyn L., Strom, Robert J., and Renz, David O. (Cheltenham, U.K., 2014), 11–23Google Scholar.

11 Olivier Zunz, “Why Is the History of Philanthropy Not a Part of American History?,” in Reich, Cordelli, and Bernholz, Philanthropy in Democratic Societies, 44–63.

12 Hall, Peter D., Inventing the Nonprofit Sector and Other Essays on Philanthropy, Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations (Baltimore, 1992)Google Scholar; Zunz, Olivier, Philanthropy in America (Princeton, 2012)Google Scholar.

13 Boltanski, Luc and Chiapello, Eve, The New Spirit of Capitalism (London, 2007)Google Scholar; Piketty, Thomas, Capital in the Twenty-First Century (Cambridge, MA, 2014)CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

14 Friedman, Walter A. and Jones, Geoffrey, “Business History: Time for Debate,” Business History Review 85, no. 1 (2011): 1–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 North, Douglass C., Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance (Cambridge, U.K., 1990)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Suddaby, Roy, Foster, William M., and Mills, Albert J, “Historical Institutionalism,” in Organizations in Time: History, Theory, Methods, ed. Bucheli, Marcelo and Wadhwani, R. Daniel (Oxford, 2014), 100–23Google Scholar.

16 Atkinson, Anthony B., Inequality: What Can Be Done? (Cambridge, MA, 2015)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Piketty, Capital.

17 Hall, Inventing the Nonprofit Sector; Zunz, Philanthropy in America.

18 Lonneke Roza, Marjelle Vermeulen, Kellie Liket, and Lucas Meijs, “Contemporary European E2P: Towards an Understanding of European Philanthrepreneurs,” in Taylor, Strom, and Renz, Entrepreneurs’ Engagement in Philanthropy, 197–233.

19 David B. Audretsch and Joshua Hinger, “From Entrepreneur to Philanthropist: Two Sides of the Same Coin,” in Taylor, Strom, and Renz, Entrepreneurs’ Engagement in Philanthropy, 24–42.

20 Harvey, Maclean, Gordon, and Shaw, “Andrew Carnegie”; Shaw, Eleanor, Gordon, Jillian, Harvey, Charles, and Maclean, Mairi, “Exploring Contemporary Entrepreneurial Philanthropy,” International Small Business Journal 31, no. 5 (2013): 580–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Carnegie, Andrew, “The Gospel of Wealth,” in Andrew Carnegie: The Gospel of Wealth and Other Essays, ed. Nasaw, David (1889; New York, 2006), 1–12Google Scholar.

22 Bishop and Green, Philanthrocapitalism; Callahan, The Givers.

23 Paul G. Schervish, “Hyperagency and High-Tech Donors” (Social Welfare Research Institute, Boston College, 14 Nov. 2003).

24 Acs, Zoltan J. and Phillips, Ronnie J., “Entrepreneurship and Philanthropy in American Capitalism,” Small Business Economics 19, no. 3 (2002): 189–294CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Acs, Zoltan J., Why Philanthropy Matters: How the Wealthy Give, and What It Means for Our Well-Being (Princeton, 2013)Google Scholar.

25 Callahan, The Givers.

26 Harvey, Maclean, Gordon, and Shaw, “Andrew Carnegie.”

27 Maclean, Mairi, Harvey, Charles, and Kling, Gerhard, “Pathways to Power: Class, Hyper-Agency and the French Corporate Elite,” Organization Studies 35, no. 6 (2014): 825–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

28 Bekkers and Wiepking, “Literature Review”; Bosworth, David, “The Cultural Contradictions of Philanthrocapitalism,” Society 48, no. 5 (2011): 382–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Ostrower, Francie, Why the Wealthy Give: The Culture of Elite Philanthropy (Princeton, 1995)Google Scholar; Ostrower, , Trustees of Culture: Power, Wealth and Status on Elite Arts Boards (Chicago, 2002)Google Scholar; Villadsen, Kaspar, “The Emergence of ‘Neo-Philanthropy’: A New Discursive Space in Welfare Policy,” Acta Sociologica 50, no. 3 (2007): 309–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

29 Maclean, Harvey, Gordon, and Shaw, “Philanthropic Journey.”

30 Maryana P. Feldman and Alexandra Graddy-Reed, “Local Champions: Entrepreneurs’ Transition to Philanthropy and the Vibrancy of Place,” in Taylor, Strom, and Renz, Entrepreneurs’ Engagement in Philanthropy, 43–76; Dees, J. Gregory and Anderson, Beth B., “Framing a Theory of Social Entrepreneurship: Building on Two Schools of Practice and Thought,” in Research on Social Entrepreneurship: Understanding and Contributing to an Emerging Field, ed. Mosher-Williams, Rachel (Indianapolis, 2006), 39–66Google Scholar; Maclean, Mairi, Harvey, Charles, and Gordon, Jillian, “Social Innovation, Social Entrepreneurship and the Practice of Contemporary Entrepreneurial Philanthropy,” International Small Business Journal 31, no. 7 (2012): 747–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

31 Hay, Iain, “On Plutonomy: Economy, Power and the Wealthy Few in the Second Gilded Age,” in Handbook on Wealth and the Super-Rich, ed. Hay, Iain and Beaverstock, Jonathan V. (Cheltenham, U.K., 2016), 68–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Ilan Kapoor, “Billionaire Philanthropy: ‘Decaf Capitalism,’” in Hay and Beaverstock, Wealth and the Super-Rich, 113–31.

32 Henthorn, Thomas C., “Building a Moral Metropolis: Philanthropy and City Building in Houston, Texas,” Journal of Urban History 44, no. 3 (2015): 402–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

33 Clotfelter, Charles T. and Ehrlich, Thomas, eds., Philanthropy and the Nonprofit Sector in a Changing America (Bloomington, IN, 2001)Google Scholar.

34 Breeze, Beth and Lloyd, Theresa, Richer Lives: Why Rich People Give (London, 2013), 72–74Google Scholar.

35 Shaw, Gordon, Harvey, and Maclean, “Exploring Contemporary Entrepreneurial Philanthropy.”

36 Milton Friedman, “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Profits,” in Moody and Breeze, Philanthropy Reader, 355–59.

37 Thomas W. Dunfee, “The Legitimacy of Corporate Philanthropy,” in Moody and Breeze, Philanthropy Reader, 360–63; Moran, Michael and Branigan, Elizabeth, “The Contested Terrain of Corporate Philanthropy and Social Responsibility,” in The Routledge Companion to Philanthropy, ed. Jung, Tobias, Phillips, Susan D., and Harrow, Jenny (Abingdon, U.K., 2016), 375–90Google Scholar.

38 Hall, Peter D., “A Historical Overview of Philanthropy, Voluntary Associations, and Nonprofit Organizations in the US, 1600–2000,” in The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, ed. Powell, Walter W. and Steinberg, Richard (New Haven, 2006), 32–65Google Scholar.

39 Holcombe, Randall G., Writing Off Ideas: Taxation, Philanthropy and America's Non-profit Foundations (New York, 2000)Google Scholar.

40 Fleishman, Joel L., The Foundation: A Great American Secret (New York, 2007)Google Scholar; Dietlin, Lisa M., Transformational Philanthropy: Entrepreneurs and Nonprofits (Boston, 2010)Google Scholar.

41 Hammack, David C. and Anheier, Helmut K., A Versatile American Institution: The Changing Ideals and Realities of Philanthropic Foundations (Washington, DC, 2013)Google Scholar.

42 Jenny Harrow, Tobias Jung, and Susan D. Phillips, “Community Foundations: Agility in the Duality of Foundation and Community,” in Jung, Phillips, and Harrow, Routledge Companion to Philanthropy, 308–21.

43 Moran and Branigan, “Contested Terrain.”

44 Ray D. Madoff, “When Is Philanthropy? How the Tax Code's Answer to This Question Has Given Rise to the Growth of Donor Advised Funds,” in Reich, Cordelli, and Bernholz, Philanthropy in Democratic Societies, 158–77.

45 Anheier, Helmut K. and Daly, Siobhan, The Politics of Foundations: A Comparative Analysis (Abingdon, U.K., 2007)Google Scholar.

46 Hammack and Anheier, Versatile American Institution, 117–56.

47 Michael Rothschild, “Philanthropy and American Higher Education,” in Clotfelter and Ehrlich, Philanthropy and the Nonprofit Sector, 413–27.

48 Daniel Harari and Matthew Ward, “Regional and Country Economic Indicators” (Office of National Statistics, House of Commons Library Briefing Paper No. 06924, London, 2018).

49 Ben-Amos, Ilana Krausman, The Culture of Giving: Informal Support and Gift-Exchange in Early Modern England (Cambridge, U.K., 2008)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gray, Benjamin Kirkman, A History of English Philanthropy: From the Dissolution of the Monasteries to the Taking of the First Census (London, 1905)Google Scholar; Gray, , Philanthropy and the State, or Social Politics (London, 1908)Google Scholar; Jordan, Wilbur K., Philanthropy in England, 1480–1660: A Study of the Changing Patterns of English Social Aspirations (New York, 1959)Google Scholar; Owen, David E., English Philanthropy 1660–1960 (Cambridge, MA, 1965)Google Scholar; Prochaska, Frank, Women and Philanthropy in Nineteenth-Century England (Oxford, 1980)Google Scholar; Prochaska, , The Voluntary Impulse: Philanthropy in Modern Britain (London, 1988)Google Scholar.

50 Brand, John, The History and Antiquities of the Town and County of Newcastle upon Tyne (London, 1789)Google Scholar; Lomas, Richard, North East England in the Middle Ages (Edinburgh, 1992)Google Scholar; Lomas, , County of Conflict: Northumberland from Conquest to Civil War (East Linton, U.K., 1996)Google Scholar; Lomas, , An Encyclopaedia of North-East England (Edinburgh, 2009)Google Scholar; MacKenzie, Eneas, A Descriptive and Historical Account of the Town and County of Newcastle upon Tyne: Including the Borough of Gateshead (Newcastle upon Tyne, 1827)Google Scholar; McCord, Norman, North East England: An Economic and Social History (London, 1979)Google Scholar; McCord, Norman and Thompson, Richard, The Northern Counties from AD 1000 (London, 1998)Google Scholar; Parson, William and White, William, History, Directory and Gazetteer of the Counties of Durham and Northumberland: And the Towns and Counties of Newcastle upon Tyne and Berwick upon Tweed (Sheffield, U.K., 1828)Google Scholar; Purdue, A. William, Newcastle: The Biography (Chalford, U.K., 2011)Google Scholar; Rowe, David J., “The North-East,” in The Cambridge Social History of Britain 1750–1950, vol. 2, Regions and Communities, ed. Thompson, F. M. L. (Cambridge, U.K., 1990), 415–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

51 Broadberry, Stephen, Campbell, Bruce M. S., Klein, Alexander, Overton, Mark, and van Leeuwen, Bas, British Economic Growth, 1270–1870 (Cambridge, U.K., 2015)Google Scholar.

52 Lomas, North-East England, 1–31.

53 Broadberry, Campbell, Klein, Overton, and van Leeuwen, British Economic Growth, 25.

54 Lomas, North-East England, 125–46.

55 Lomas, County of Conflict, 38–44.

56 Bennett, Judith M., “Conviviality and Charity in Medieval and Early Modern England,” Past and Present 134, no. 1 (1992): 19–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

57 Wrightson, Keith, Earthly Necessities: Economic Lives in Early Modern Britain, 1470–1750 (London, 2002), 331Google Scholar.

58 Braddick, Michael J., State Formation in Early Modern England c. 1550–1700 (Cambridge, U.K., 2000)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

59 Jordan, Philanthropy in England; Ben-Amos, Culture of Giving, 379.

60 Cannon, John, Schooling in England, 1660 to 1850, vols. 1 and 2 (Kew, U.K., 2016)Google Scholar.

61 Broadberry, Campbell, Klein, Overton, and van Leeuwen, British Economic Growth, 25.

62 Rowe, “The North-East,” 418–33.

63 McCord, North East England, 69–105.

64 Owen, English Philanthropy, 97–133.

65 Prochaska, Frank, “Philanthropy,” in The Cambridge Social History of Britain, 1750–1950, vol. 3, Social Agencies and Institutions, ed. Thompson, F. M. L. (Cambridge, U.K., 1990), 357Google Scholar.

66 McCord, North East England, 215–41.

67 Broadberry, Stephen, The Productivity Race: British Manufacturing in International Perspective, 1850–1900 (Cambridge, U.K., 1997), 1–16CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

68 Tony Chapman and Jack Hunter, Third Sector Trends in the North, Institute of Public Policy Research (IPPR) North, Manchester, Mar. 2017.

69 Available at Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/.

70 “Bishop Hugh du Puiset,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/puiset-bishop-hugh-du; “Bishop Robert de Stichell,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/stichell-bishop-robert-de; ”Sherburn House Charity,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/beneficiaries/sherburn-house-charity.

71 McCord and Thompson, Northern Counties, 107–9.

72 ”Sir William Bertram II and Sir Roger Bertram,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/bertram-sir-william-ii-1157-1206-and-bertram-sir-roger-1195-1242-landowners.

73 “Sir Roger Mauduit,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/mauduit-sir-roger-1266-1347-landowner.

74 Lomas, County of Conflict, 112–13.

75 MacKenzie, Town and County of Newcastle upon Tyne, 235–362.

76 Jordan, Philanthropy in England; Owen, English Philanthropy.

77 Prochaska, Voluntary Impulse.

78 Davis, Rhodri, Public Good by Private Means: How Philanthropy Shapes Britain (London, 2015)Google Scholar.

79 “Lord Crewe's Charity,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/organisations/lord-crewes-charity; “Durham University,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/beneficiaries/durham-university; Whiting, Charles E., The University of Durham, 1832–1932 (London, 1932)Google Scholar; Whiting, , Nathaniel Lord Crewe: Bishop of Durham and His Diocese (London, 1940)Google Scholar.

80 Purdue, Newcastle, 103–73.

81 “Newcastle University,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/beneficiaries/newcastle-university.

82 McCord, North East England, 215–41.

83 Feldman and Graddy-Reed, “Local Champions.”

84 “Community Foundation Tyne & Wear and Northumberland,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/organisations/community-foundation-tyne-wear-and-northumberland.

85 “Sir Roger Thornton,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/thornton-roger.

86 “Thomas Horsley,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/horsley-thomas; “Dame Eleanor Allan,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/allan-dame-eleanor.

87 “Henry William Ferdinand Bolckow,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/bolckow-henry-william-ferdinand; “Baron William George Armstrong,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/armstrong-baron-william-george; “Sir Charles Palmer,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/palmer-sir-charles; “Joseph Constantine,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/constantine-joseph.

88 “Sir William Leech,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/leech-sir-william; “Wilfred Augustine Handley,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/handley-wilfred-augustine; “Reginald Mann,”, Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/mann-reginald; “Dr Alan Richard Reece,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/reece-dr-alan-richard; “Dame Margaret Barbour,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/barbour-dame-margaret.

89 Maclean, Harvey, and Gordon, “Social Innovation.”

90 Cannon, Schooling in England.

91 Maclean, Harvey, and Gordon, “Social Innovation.”

92 DiMaggio, Paul J. and Powell, Walter W., “The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields,” American Sociological Review 48, no. 2 (1983): 147–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

93 Braudel, Fernand, On History (Chicago, 1980)Google Scholar.

94 “Dr John Sharp,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/sharp-dr-john.

95 Gray, History of English Philanthropy, 171–203.

96 Harvey, Charles and Maclean, Mairi, “Capital Theory and the Dynamics of Elite Business Networks in Britain and France,” Sociological Review 56, no. S1 (2008): 103–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

97 “Sir Peter Vardy,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/vardy-sir-peter.

98 “Robert Spence Watson,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/watson-robert-spence.

99 “Dr John Theodore Merz,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/merz-dr-john-theodore; “Teresa Merz,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/the-philanthropists/merz-teresa.

100 Bishop and Green, Philanthrocapitalism; Callahan, The Givers.

101 Owen, English Philanthropy, 91–210; Prochaska, Voluntary Impulse.

102 “Newcastle University,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/beneficiaries/newcastle-university.

103 Holden, Andrew, Funnell, Warwick, and Oldroyd, David, “Accounting and the Moral Economy of Illness in Victorian England: The Newcastle Infirmary,” Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal 22, no. 4 (2009): 525–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

104 Ostrower, Trustees of Culture.

105 “Tyne and Wear Archives and Museums,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/beneficiaries/tyne-and-wear-archives-and-museums.

106 “Bowes Museum,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/beneficiaries/bowes-museum.

107 Chapman and Hunter, Third Sector Trends.

108 “Lord Crewe's Charity,” Philanthropy North East, accessed 2 Aug. 2019, http://www.philanthropynortheast.com/organisations/lord-crewes-charity.

109 Maclean, Mairi, Harvey, Charles, and Clegg, Stewart R., “Conceptualizing Historical Organization Studies,” Academy of Management Review 41, no. 4 (2016): 609–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 609.

110 Maclean, Mairi, Harvey, Charles, and Clegg, Stewart R., “Organization Theory in Business and Management History: Present Status and Future Prospects,” Business History Review 91, no. 3 (2017): 457–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

111 Maclean, Harvey, and Gordon, “Social Innovation.”

112 Bourdieu, Pierre, Outline of a Theory of Practice (Cambridge, U.K., 1977)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

113 Harvey, Maclean, Gordon, and Shaw, “Andrew Carnegie.”

114 Maclean, Mairi and Harvey, Charles, “‘Give It Back, George’: Network Dynamics in the Philanthropic Field,” Organization Studies 37, no. 3 (2016): 399–423CrossRefGoogle Scholar.