Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7czq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-24T01:19:21.477Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Corporate Profit and Race in Central African Copper Mining, 1946–1958

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 February 2012

Ian Phimister
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The focus in the literature on the political outcomes of decolonization has resulted in neglect of the business activities that took place from the mid-1940s to the mid-1950s. Missing from existing accounts are the occasions when business turned impending political change to economic advantage. One such shift occurred in the central African copper-mining industry as, first, the promise of racial “partnership” during the short-lived Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasaland and then the prospect of African majority rule in Northern Rhodesia redefined the political context within which businesses operated. Rather than emphasizing the ethical considerations that influenced business attitudes, this study describes how corporate policies toward the job color bar were shaped by the copper industry's changing cost structure and profitability.

Type
Research Article
Information
Business History Review , Volume 85 , Issue 4 , Winter 2011 , pp. 749 - 774
Copyright
Copyright © The President and Fellows of Harvard College 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Hochschild, Harold K., “The Copper Mining Industry of Northern Rhodesia,” Overseas Business, Economic Development and the Cold War, Harvard Business School Association 50th Anniversary Conference, 5 Sept. 1958, 17–18, 15, 16Google Scholar. For Hochschild himself, see especially Hochschild, Adam, Half the Way Home: A Memoir of Father and Son (New York, 1986)Google Scholar.

2 Tignor, Robert, Capitalism and Nationalism at the End of Empire: State and Business in Decolonizing Egypt, Nigeria, and Kenya, 1945–1963 (Princeton, 1998)Google Scholar. Among others, see especially Misra, Maria, Business, Race and Politics in British India, c.1850–1960 (Oxford, 1999)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Stockwell, Sarah, The Business of Decolonization: British Business Strategies in the Gold Coast (Oxford, 2000)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and White, Nicholas, “The Business and Politics of Decolonisation: The British Experience in the Twentieth Century,” Economic History Review 53 (2000): 544–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 For the former perspective, see Sklar, Richard, Corporate Power in an African State: The Political Impact of Multinational Mining Companies in Zambia (Berkeley, 1975), 105–6Google Scholar. See also Berger, Elena, Labour, Race, and Colonial Rule: The Copperbelt from 1924 to Independence (Oxford, 1974), 232Google Scholar; Mhone, Guy, The Political Economy of a Dual Labor Market in Africa: The Copper Industry and Dependency in Zambia, 1929–1969 (East Brunswick, 1982), 141Google Scholar; Cunningham, Simon, The Copper Industry in Zambia: Foreign Mining Companies in a Developing Country (New York, 1981), 84Google Scholar; and Butler, L. J., Copper Empire: Mining and the Colonial State in Northern Rhodesia, c.1930–1964 (Basingstoke, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Harold K. Hochschild to Henry de Witt Smith, Tsumeb Corporation, New York, 2 Nov. 1949, H. K. Hochschild correspondence, file 1, 1940–1949, box 1, RP [Ronald Prain] collection, American Metal Company, American Heritage Center, University of Wyoming (hereafter, RP collection).

5 Holleman, Johan F. and Biesheuvel, Simeon, White Mine Workers in Northern Rhodesia, 1959–60 (Leiden, 1973), 11Google Scholar.

6 Figures derived from Roberts, Andrew, “Notes towards a Financial History of Copper Mining in Northern Rhodesia,” Canadian Journal of African Studies 19 (1982): 355–56Google Scholar; Economist, 27 Oct. 1951; and Barber, William, The Economy of British Central Africa: A Case Study of Economic Development in a Dualistic Society (London, 1961), 110Google Scholar.

7 Paragraph based on Northern Rhodesia Chamber of Mines Year Book, 1958 (Kitwe, 1959), 80, 90Google Scholar; Northern Rhodesia Chamber of Mines Year Book, 1960 (Kitwe, 1961), 64, 66, 72, 74Google Scholar; Prain, Ronald, “Rhodesian Selection Trust Group of Companies: Its Place in the World Copper Industry,” Selected Papers, vol. 2: 1958–1960 (London, 1961), 124Google Scholar; and Roberts, Andrew, History of Zambia (London, 1976), 214Google Scholar. For the Rand, see Frankel, S. Herbert, Investment and the Return to Equity Capital in the South African Gold Mining Industry, 1887–1965: An International Comparison (Cambridge, Mass., 1967)Google Scholar.

8 Sklar, , Corporate Power in an African State, 51, 40Google Scholar. See also, Navin, Thomas R., Copper Mining and Management (Tucson, 1978), 273–84, 347–56Google Scholar.

9 Prain, , “Rhodesian Selection Trust Group of Companies,” 120Google Scholar.

10 Prain to Hochschild, 30 Apr. 1948, H. K. Hochschild correspondence, file 1, 1940–1949, box 1, RP collection. See also Coleman, Francis L., The Northern Rhodesia Copperbelt, 1899–1962: Technological Development Up to the End of the Central African Federation (Manchester, 1971), 144Google Scholar.

11 Confidential memorandum, “Visit to the Rhodesias,” Nairobi, 22 Oct. 1949Google Scholar, unnumbered file, misc. 1949–62, box 1, RP collection.

12 Hochschild to de Witt Smith, 2 Nov. 1949.

13 Philips, John, “Roan Antelope: Big Business in Central Africa, 1890–1953,” PhD diss., University of Cambridge, 2000, 302, 363, 365, 368Google Scholar; and Baldwin, Robert, Economic Development and Export Growth: A Study of Northern Rhodesia, 1920–1960 (Berkeley, 1966), 91Google Scholar.

14 Prain to Hochschild, 26 Apr. 1950 and 17 Oct. 1951, H. K. Hochschild correspondence, file 2, 1950–51, box 1, RP collection.

15 Economist, 5 Dec. 1953.

16 Baldwin, , Economic Development and Export Growth, 100Google Scholar.

17 Perrings, Charles, “A Moment in the ‘Proletarianisation’ of the New Middle Class: Race, Value and the Division of Labour in the Copperbelt, 1946–1966,” Journal of Southern African Studies 6 (1980): 192–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Northern Rhodesia Chamber of Mines Year Book, 1956 (Kitwe, 1957), 76Google Scholar.

18 Burawoy, Michael, The Colour of Class on the Copper Mines: From African Advancement to Zambianization (Lusaka, 1972), 98Google Scholar.

19 Paragraph based on Mhone, , Political Economy of a Dual Labor Market in Africa, 162–63Google Scholar; Baldwin, , Economic Development and Export Growth, 94–95, 99Google Scholar; and Perrings, “‘Proletarianisation’ of the New Middle Class,” 191–92.

20 Coleman, , Northern Rhodesia Copperbelt, 162Google Scholar. See esp., Wilkie, Norman and Holt, Walter, “A Description of Open Pit Mining at Nchanga Consolidated Copper Mines Limited, Northern Rhodesia,” in Technical Proceedings of the Northern Rhodesia Section Seventh Commonwealth Mining and Metallurgical Congress, 1961, ed. Watts, William (Kitwe, 1962), 191–215Google Scholar.

21 Nelems, Hendrik, “Open Pit Mining at Nchanga,” Optima 5 (1955): 6–14Google Scholar.

22 Baldwin, , Economic Development and Export Growth, 95Google Scholar.

23 Ibid., 95–96, 91.

24 Mhone, , Political Economy, 172, 166–67Google Scholar.

25 Baldwin, , Economic Development and Export Growth, 91Google Scholar.

26 Berger, , Labour, Race, and Colonial Rule, 124, 64Google Scholar. For the origins of the white miners' union generally, and the 1941 “closed shop” agreement in particular, see Henderson, Ian, “Labour and Politics in Northern Rhodesia, 1900–1953: A Study in the Limits of Colonial Power,” PhD diss., University of Edinburgh, 1972Google Scholar.

27 Prain, Ronald, “The Problem of African Advancement on the Copperbelt of Northern Rhodesia,” African Affairs 53 (1954): 101CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

28 Gregory, Theodor Emanuel, Ernest Oppenheimer and the Economic Development of Southern Africa (Cape Town, 1962), 477Google Scholar.

29 Ronald Prain, “Notes on the Advancement Situation,” 1 Apr. 1954, African advancement file, box 2, RP collection.

30 Prain, Ronald, Reflections on an Era: Fifty Years of Mining in Changing Africa (Worcester Park, 1981), 110Google Scholar.

31 For Hochschild, , see his “Labor Relations in Northern Rhodesia,” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 305 (1956): 46–47Google Scholar; and for Prain, see his “The Problem of African Advancement,” 100–101, from which the quotation comes.

32 Richard Hagart to Frank Searls, 8 Feb. 1954, and attached correspondence, and Prain to Hochschild, 19 Mar. 1954, file 3, AmCo–H. K. Hochschild, 1952–54, box 1, RP collection.

33 Cunningham, , The Copper Industry in Zambia, 105Google Scholar.

34 Prain, , Reflections on an Era, 110Google Scholar.

35 Ibid.; and Berger, , Labour, Race and Colonial Rule, 144–46Google Scholar.

36 Parpart, Jane L., Labor and Capital on the African Copperbelt (Philadelphia, 1983), 140–41Google Scholar.

37 Confidential memorandum, “Visit to the Rhodesias,” unnumbered file, misc. 1949–1962, box 1, RP collection.

38 Hochschild to Prain, 8 May 1950 and 13 June 1950, file 2, AmCo–H. K. Hochschild, 1950–51, box 1, RP collection.

39 Confidential memorandum, “Visit to the Rhodesias”; and Hochschild to Prain, 7 May 1954, file 3, AmCo–H. K. Hochschild, 1952–54, box 1, RP collection.

40 Berger, , Labour, Race and Colonial Rule, 128Google Scholar.

41 Rhodesia Herald, 21 Apr. 1955.

42 Murphy, Philip, Party Politics and Decolonization: The Conservative Party and British Colonial Policy in Tropical Africa, 1951–1964 (Oxford, 1995), 74CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Sir Roy Welensky to Ronald Prain, 23 Apr. 1955, file “Correspondence Sir Roy Welensky 1951–1959,” box 2, RP collection. See esp. Richard, J.Wood, T., The Welensky Papers: A History of the Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasaland (Durban, 1983), 431–32Google Scholar.

43 Berger, , Labour, Race and Colonial Rule, 129Google Scholar; and Gregory, , Ernest Oppenheimer, 484Google Scholar.

44 Ronald Prain to Alan Lennox-Boyd, 3 Mar. 1955 and 11 July 1955, file “Misc. Correspondence with Harold Macmillan, Alan Lennox-Boyd, and Ian Macleod,” box 2, RP collection.

45 Prain, , Reflections on an Era, 111–13Google Scholar. For one of several different accounts, see Clegg, Edward, Race and Politics: Partnership in the Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasaland (London, 1960), 198–201Google Scholar.

46 Economist, 17 Sept. 1955; Prain, , Reflections on an Era, 122Google Scholar. See Hochschild, “Labor Relations in Northern Rhodesia,” 48–49; and esp. his “Copper Mining Industry of Northern Rhodesia,” 16–17.

47 Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Mining Industry of Zambia, 1966 [Brown Report] (Lusaka, 1966), 6–7Google Scholar; and Northern Rhodesia Chamber of Mines Year Book, 1956, 8.

48 Times, 3 Jan. 1956.

49 His Royal Highness the Duke of Edinburgh's Study Conference on the Human Problems of Industrial Communities Within the Commonwealth and Empire, 9–27 July 1956, 2 vols. (London, 1957), 2: 56Google Scholar.

50 Prain to Sir Ernest Oppenheimer, 22 May 1956, file misc. correspondence, box 2, RP collection.

51 Ibid.

52 Prain to Hochschild, 10 Aug. 1955, file 4, AmCo–H. K. Hochschild, 1955–56, box 1, RP collection.

53 Mhone, , Political Economy, 167Google Scholar.

54 Northern Rhodesia Chamber of Mines Year Book, 1956, 19. For RST's attempts to introduce a “fixed price” for copper, see esp. Metal Bulletin, 21 Feb. 1956. See also Ronald Prain, , Copper: The Anatomy of an Industry (London, 1975), 94–112Google Scholar.

55 Cunningham, , Copper Industry in Zambia, 106Google Scholar. Rothschilds had initially advised RST that “there should be no difficulty under present conditions in placing £7.5m. of unsecured loan stock 1977 to 1983 at 6%.” See Ronald Prain to Walter Hochschild, 10 Apr. 1957, file 1, AmCo–W. Hochschild 1947/57, Amax, W. Hochschild, 1958, RP collection.

56 Cunningham, , Copper Industry in Zambia, 109Google Scholar.

57 Prain to Hochschild, 5 Nov 1956, file 4, AmCo–H. K. Hochschild, 1955–56, box 1, RP collection.

58 Mhone, , Political Economy, 184–85Google Scholar.

59 Prain, , Reflections on an Era, 115Google Scholar.

60 Berger, , Labour, Race and Colonial Rule, 183, 178Google Scholar; and Holleman, and Biesheuval, , White Mine Workers, 21–22Google Scholar.

61 Prain, , Reflections on an Era, 115Google Scholar.

62 Ibid.

63 Baldwin, , Economic Development and Export Growth, 103Google Scholar.

64 Ernest Bromwich, “Problems of Arresting Cost Increases in Our Mines,” Lusaka, 1959, unpublished, as cited in Baldwin, , Economic Development and Export Growth, 102Google Scholar.

65 Butler, , Copper Empire, 236Google Scholar.

66 Mhone, , Political Economy, 209, 212Google Scholar.

67 Hochschild, “Labor Relations in Northern Rhodesia,” 47.

68 See note 3 above. Skeptical views include Baldwin, Economic Development and Export Growth; Burawoy, The Colour of Class on the Copper Mines; and Parpart, Labor and Capital on the African Copperbelt.

69 For example, the differing interpretations in Butler, Larry J., “Business and British Decolonisation: Sir Ronald Prain, the Mining Industry and the Central African Federation,” Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 35 (2007): 459–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Cohen, Andrew, “Business and Decolonisation in Central Africa Reconsidered,” Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 36 (2008): 641–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

70 Williams, Ronald, “Trade Unions in Africa,” African Affairs 54 (1955): 269CrossRefGoogle Scholar.