Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T07:43:06.406Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Centralization and Incremental Change in France: The Case of the Haby Educational Reform

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 January 2009

Roger Duclaud-Williams
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

A concern with the relationships between different levels of centralization and the management of change is long-standing in many of the social sciences. The French educational system has always stood in the minds of many as a monument to over-centralization and red tape. In her recent magisterial study, The Social Origins of Educational Systems, Archer has examined the consequences for educational change of different levels of centralization in the educational system in a variety of national settings. In her book she argues with great care and a wealth of historical example that it is possible to establish certain broad generalizations which describe the manner in which educational change is produced, and that sharp distinctions in this regard must be made between the centralized systems and the more decentralized systems. Her study covers the period up to 1974. Since then there have been very important changes in the French educational system. These changes and the political conflict which surrounded them, particularly between 1974 and 1978, are of considerable interest in their own right, to students of both comparative public policy and French politics. The principal purpose of this discussion, however, is to examine Archer's propositions about the modes of change typical of centralized systems in the light of the reforms introduced in these years. My concern is therefore with the administrative and political consequences of centralization and this inquiry leads in turn to some discussion of the role of pressure groups in the Fifth French Republic.

Type
Articles
Information
British Journal of Political Science , Volume 13 , Issue 1 , January 1983 , pp. 71 - 91
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1983

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Archer, Margaret Scotford, Social Origins of Educational Systems (London: Sage, 1979).Google Scholar

2 Crozier, Michel, The Bureaucratic Phenomenon (London: Tavistock Publications, 1964)Google Scholar. Hoffman, Stanley, Decline or Renewal? France since the 1930s (New York: Viking Press, 1974)Google Scholar. For a less empirical critique of Crozier's conclusions see Duclaud-Williams, Roger, ‘Change in French Society: A Critical Analysis of Crozier's Bureaucratic Model’, West European Politics, IV (1981), pp. 235–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

3 Archer, , Social Origins of Educational Systems, pp. 618–28, especially p. 628.Google Scholar

4 Archer, , Social Origins of Educational Systems, pp. 184–208Google Scholar. ‘Systematization and unification remain the predominant pair of characteristics as specialization and differentiation are accommodated to them’ (p. 207). ‘The fact that the political elite curtails specialization in turn reduces the diversity of parts and hence the problems of dovetailing them’ (p. 207–8).

5 Archer, , Social Origins of Educational Systems, p. 271Google Scholar: ‘Political manipulation is the main process through which educational change is pursued and produced in the centralized system’.

6 Archer, , Social Origins of Educational Systems, p. 369.Google Scholar

7 Haby, René, Combat pour les jeunes Français (Paris, Julliard, 1981), p. 67.Google Scholar

8 Haby, , Combat pour les jeunes Français, p. 84.Google Scholar

9 Stream i was thought of as equivalent to the teaching carried on traditionally in the lycées. Stream 2 was intended to cater for less academically able pupils who before 1963 had been accommodated in a separate establishment, similar in conception to the English secondary modern school. These schools were called ‘collèges d'enseignement général’. Stream 3, also generally housed after 1963 within the lower secondary school (Collèges d'Enseignement Secondaire or CES) contained the least able 20 per cent of pupils.

10 Le Monde, 21 06 1974.Google Scholar

11 Le Monde, 9 07 1974 and 25 07 1974.Google Scholar

12 Haby, , Combat pour les jeunes Français, p. 191.Google Scholar

13 Le Monde, 25 07 1974.Google Scholar

14 Haby, René, Pour une modernisation du système éducatif (Paris: La Documentation Française, 02 1975).Google Scholar

15 Haby, , Pour une modernisation du système éducatif, p. 18.Google Scholar

16 Haby, , Pour une modernisation du système éducatif, pp. 15–18.Google Scholar

17 Le Monde, 18 02 1976, 12 03 1976 and 7 04 1976.Google Scholar

18 Haby, , Pour une modernisation du système éducatif, Chap. 3.Google Scholar

19 Haby, , Combat pour les jeunes Français, p. 191.Google Scholar

20 Haby, , Pour une modernisation du système éducatif, Chaps. 2 and 3.Google Scholar

21 For the union's initial mixed reaction see L'Ecole Libératrice, 21 02 1975, p. 778 and 14 03 1975, p. 958Google Scholar and following. For later illegal defiance see Le Figaro, 12 02 1977.Google Scholar

22 For the Communist position see l'Humanité, 28 02 1975Google Scholar. The full text of a motion adopted by the comité directeur of the Socialist party can be found in Unité, 14 03 1975.Google Scholar

23 On this point see Le Monde, 28 02 1975Google Scholar. For the opposition of the Centre Démocrate see Le Monde, 24 03 1975Google Scholar. For opposition from many prominent philosophers and the Association des Professeurs de Philosophie de l'Enseignement Public, see Le Monde, 18 02 1975Google Scholar. For opposition from within the Majority (Jacques Chirac and André Rossi) see Le Monde, 11 04 1975.Google Scholar

24 Senior civil servant directly concerned.

25 Haby, , Combat pour les jeunes Français, p. 109.Google Scholar

26 Le Monde, 24 03 1975.Google Scholar

27 Le Monde, 28 04 1975.Google Scholar

28 Le Monde, 31 10 1979.Google Scholar

29 Le Monde, 20 02 1975.Google Scholar

30 Haby, , Combat pour les jeunes Français, p. 131.Google Scholar

31 PEGC: ‘Professeurs d'enseignement général des collèges’.

32 L'Express, 30 01 1978.Google Scholar

33 Haby, , Combat pour les jeunes Français, p. 75.Google Scholar

34 Haby, , Combat pour les jeunes Français, p. 196 and following.Google Scholar

35 Haby, , Combat pour les jeunes Français, p. 33.Google Scholar

36 Senior civil servant directly concerned.

37 Gaullist politician with previous service as civil servant in the Ministry of Education.