Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-dh8gc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-02T21:46:38.488Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Crises of the Welfare State

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 January 2009

Michael Moran
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

‘The essence of the welfare state’, wrote Wilensky in a classic study, ‘is government-protected minimum standards of income, nutrition, health, housing, and education, assured to every citizen’. This innocent definition is, we shall see, highly contestable, but it has the merit of putting into a few words the most important characteristics of modern welfare states: that they necessarily involve some model of citizenship; that they provide a stream of services for people called citizens; and that they use public power to raise the resources for those services and to organize their provision. If there is a crisis of the welfare state it has to involve, in other words, a crisis of citizenship, or a crisis in the capacity of states to raise resources and to transform those resources into services.

Type
Review Articles
Information
British Journal of Political Science , Volume 18 , Issue 3 , July 1988 , pp. 397 - 414
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1988

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Wilensky, Harold, The Welfare State and Equality: Structural and Ideological Roots of Public Expenditure (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1975), p. 1.Google Scholar

2 Offe, Claus, ‘The Divergent Rationalities of Administrative Action’ in his Disorganised Capitalism: Contemporary Transformation of Work and Politics (Cambridge: Polity Press, 1985, edited by Keane, John), pp. 300–16, at p. 315.Google Scholar

3 Habermas, Jürgen, Legitimation Crisis (London: Heinemann, 1976, translated by McCarthy, Thomas), p. 2.Google Scholar

4 Offe, Claus, ‘Legitimacy Versus Efficiency’ in his Contradictions of the Welfare State (London: Hutchinson, 1984, edited by Keane, John), pp. 130–46.Google Scholar

5 Marshall, T. H., ‘Citizenship and Social Class’ in his Sociology at the Crossroads (London: Heinemann, 1963), pp. 67–127.Google Scholar

6 Marshall, , ‘Citizenship and Social Class’.Google Scholar

7 Murie, Alan, ‘Housing’ in Wilding, Paul, ed., In Defence of the Welfare Slate (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1986), pp. 53–80.Google Scholar

8 Mann, Kirk, ‘Incorporation, Exclusion, Underclasses and the Unemployed’, in Harrison, M. L., ed., Corporatism and the Welfare State (Aldershot, Hants: Gower, 1984), pp. 41–60.Google Scholar

9 Dale, Jennifer and Foster, Peggy, Feminists and State Welfare (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1986)Google Scholar, especially Part II. In addition to the literature examined by Dale and Foster, this critique of citizenship is also in Vogel-Polsky, Eliane, ‘New Social Needs: The Problems of Women’ in Vandamme, Jacques, ed., New Dimensions In European Social Policy (London: Croom Helm, 1985), pp. 95–114Google Scholar: and is one theme of Lewis, Jane, ‘Work, Women and Welfare’ in Klein, Rudolf and O'Higgins, Michael, eds, The Future of Welfare (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1985), pp. 216–22.Google Scholar

10 Land, Hilary and Rose, Hilary, ‘Compulsory Altruism for Some or an Altruistic Society for All’ in Bean, Philip, Ferris, John and Whynes, David, eds, In Defence of Welfare (London: Tavistock Publications, 1985), pp. 74–96.Google Scholar

11 Bindman, Geoffrey and Carrier, John, ‘A Multi-Racial Society’Google Scholar and David, Miriam and Land, Hilary, ‘Sex and Social Policy’, both in , Howard Glennerster, ed., The Future of the Welfare State: Remaking Social Policy (Aldershot, Hants: Gower, 1985), pp. 124–56.Google Scholar This book was originally published for the Fabian Society in 1983. Doyal, Len and Cough's, Ian paper, ‘A Theory of Human Needs’ is in Critical Social Policy, 10 (1984), 6–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

12 For instance, Ferris, John, ‘Citizenship and the Crisis of the Welfare State’Google Scholar, in Bean, et al. , eds, In Defence of Welfare, pp. 46–73Google Scholar; Seldon, Arthur, ‘The Idea of the Welfare State and its Consequences’ in Eisenstadt, S. N. and Ahimeir, O., eds, The Welfare State And Its Aftermath (London: Croom Helm, 1985), pp. 59–73.Google Scholar

13 For instance, Townsend, Peter, Poverty in the United Kingdom (Harmondsworth, Middx: Penguin, 1979).Google Scholar

14 The Black Report was first published in a limited, typescript edition as Department of Health and Social Security, Inequalities in Health: Report of a Research Working Group (London: HMSO, 1980).Google Scholar

15 Grand, Julian Le, The Strategy of Equality: Redistribution and the Social Services (London: Allen & Unwin, 1982)Google Scholar, Chaps 3–6 and 8. See also Goodin, Robert and Grand, Julian Le, Not Only the Poor: The Middle Class and the Welfare State (London: Allen & Unwin, 1987).Google Scholar

16 Evidence of distributive effects for other countries similar to those identified by Le Grand is reported in, for instance, Debreck, Herman, ‘Social Expenditure and the Efficiency of Social Policies in Europe’Google Scholar in Vandamme, , ed., New Dimensions In European Social Policy, pp. 39–74.Google Scholar

17 Grand, Julian Le, ‘Making Redistribution Work: The Social Services’Google Scholar in Glennerster, , ed., Future of The Welfare State, pp. 74–87.Google Scholar

18 George, Vic and Wilding, Paul, The Impact of Social Policy (London: Routledge, 1984), pp. 111–12.Google Scholar

19 Wilding, , ed., In Defence of the Welfare State.Google Scholar The only sustained defence is in Wilding, 's ‘Conclusion’, pp. 127–49.Google Scholar

20 The rhetoric of ‘ordinary’ people oppressed by the welfare state is used with characteristic polemical skill in, for instance, Seldon, , ‘The Idea of the Welfare State and its Consequences’.Google Scholar

21 O'Higgins, Michael, ‘Welfare, Redistribution, and Equality – Disillusion, Illusion and Reality’Google Scholar in Bean, et al. , eds, In Defence of Welfare, pp. 162–79.Google Scholar The quoted passages are pp. 166, 167, 168–9.

22 Klein, Rudolf, ‘The Welfare State: A Self-Inflicted Crisis?’, Political Quarterly, 51 (1980), 24–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

23 Hood, Christopher and Wright, Maurice, eds, Big Government In Hard Times (Oxford: Martin Robertson, 1981).Google Scholar

24 This literature is well described, sympathetically, by Offe in Contradictions of the Welfare State.

25 O'Connor, James, The Fiscal Crisis of the State (New York: St Martin's Press)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Brittan, Samuel, ‘The Economic Contradictions of Democracy’ in King, Anthony, ed., Why Is Britain Becoming Harder to Govern? (London: BBC, 1976), pp. 96–137.Google Scholar O'Connor has more recently reapplied his arguments to the United States in Accumulation Crisis (New York: Blackwell, 1984).Google Scholar

26 Wolfe, Alan, The Limits of Legitimacy: Political Contradictions of Contemporary Capitalism (New York: Free Press, 1977).Google Scholar

27 Offe, , Contradictions of the Welfare State, p. 153.Google Scholar

28 Brittan, , ‘Economic Contradictions’.Google Scholar

29 Pressman, Jeffrey and Wildavsky, Aaron, Implementation (London: University of California Press, 1973)Google Scholar; Hood, Christopher, The Limits of Administration (London: Wiley, 1976)Google Scholar; Hall, Peter, Great Planning Disasters (Harmondsworth, Middx: Penguin, 1981).Google Scholar

30 This literature is discussed in Wilding, Paul, Professional Power and Social Welfare (London: Routledge, 1982), pp. 85–128.Google Scholar

31 Weale, Albert, ‘Why Are We Waiting? The Problem of Unresponsiveness in the Public Social Services’Google Scholar in Klein, and O'Higgins, , eds, The Future of Welfare, pp. 150–65.Google Scholar

32 King, Anthony, ‘The Problem of Overload’Google Scholar, in King, , ed., Why is Britain Becoming Harder to Govern?, pp. 8–30.Google Scholar

33 Habermas, , Legitimation Crisis, p. 47.Google Scholar

34 Dunleavy, Patrick, The Politics of Mass Housing 1945–75 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1981).Google Scholar

35 For example, Teubner, G., ‘Substantive and Reflexive Elements in Modern Law’, Law and Society Review, 17 (1983), 239–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Kettler, David, ‘Legal Reconstitution of the Welfare State: A Latent Social Democratic Legacy’, Law and Society Review, 21 (1987), 9–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

36 George, and Wilding, , The Impact of Social Policy, pp. 151–86.Google Scholar

37 Rein, Marfin, ‘Women, Employment and Social Welfare’Google Scholar in Klein, and O'Higgins, , eds, Future of Welfare, pp. 37–58Google Scholar, and his ‘The Social Welfare Labour Market’ in Eisenstadt, and Ahimeir, , eds, The Welfare State and Its Aftermath, pp. 109–31.Google Scholar

38 Cameron, David, ‘Public Expenditure and Economic Performance’Google Scholar in Klein, and O'Higgins, , eds, The Future of Welfare, pp. 8–21. (The quotation is from p. 21.)Google Scholar

39 Schmidt, Manfred, ‘The Welfare State and the Economy in Periods of Economic Crisis: A Comparative Study of Twenty-Three OECD Nations’, European Journal of Political Research, 11 (1983), 1–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

40 Rose, Richard, Understanding Big Government: The Programme Approach (London: Sage, 1984).Google Scholar The quotation is from p. 11, the statistics from p. 195.

41 Flora, Peter, ‘On the History and Current Problems of the Welfare State’Google Scholar; and Johansen, Lars Nørby and Kolberg, Jon Eivind, ‘Welfare State Regression in Scandinavia? The Development of the Scandinavian Welfare States from 1970 to 1980’Google Scholar, both in Eisenstadt, and Ahimeir, , eds, The Welfare Slate and its Aftermath, pp. 11–30 and 143–76.Google Scholar

42 Gillion, Colin and Hemming, Richard, ‘Social Expenditure in the United Kingdom in a Comparative Context: Trends, Explanations and Projections’Google Scholar in Klein, and O'Higgins, , The future of Welfare, pp. 22–36. The quotation is on p. 36.Google Scholar

43 O'Higgins, Michael, ‘Social Policy Needs and Resources: The Prospects for the 1990s’, in Berthoud, Richard, ed., Challenges to Social Policy (Aldershot, Hants: Gower, 1985), pp. 24–45.Google Scholar

44 Vedel-Peterson, Jacob, ‘The Experience of the Danish Welfare State’Google Scholar in Eisenstadt, and Ahimeir, , eds, The Welfare State and Its Aftermath, pp. 229–36. The statistics are on p. 232.Google Scholar

45 Mishra, Ramesh, The Welfare State in Crisis (Brighton, Sussex: Wheatsheaf, 1984), pp. 1–25.Google Scholar

46 Habermas, , Legitimation Crisis, p. 76.Google Scholar

41 Offe, , Contradictions of the Welfare State, pp. 99 and 249.Google Scholar

48 Hirsch, Fred, Social Limits to Growth (London: Routledge, 1977).Google Scholar

49 Crozier, Michel, Huntington, Samuel and Watanuki, Joji, The Crisis of Democracy (New York: New York State University Press, 1975), especially pp. 3–9, 25–33 and 161–8.Google Scholar

50 Rose, Richard and Peters, Guy, Can Government Go Bankrupt? (London: Macmillan, 1979), especially pp. 3–41.Google Scholar

51 Alt, James, The Politics of Economic Decline (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979).Google Scholar

52 Taylor-Gooby, Peter, Public Opinion, Ideology and State Welfare (London: Routledge, 1985).Google Scholar

53 Taylor-Gooby, , Public Opinion, pp. 32 ff.Google Scholar

54 Taylor-Gooby, , Public Opinion, pp. 28–32.Google Scholar

55 Taylor-Gooby, , Public Opinion, pp. 33.Google Scholar

56 Taylor-Gooby, , Public Opinion, p. 115.Google Scholar

51 Taylor-Gooby, , Public Opinion, pp. 93–6.Google Scholar

58 Plant, Raymond, ‘The Very Idea of a Welfare State’Google Scholar in Bean, et al. , eds, In Defence of Welfare, pp. 3–30Google Scholar; Plant, , ‘Welfare and the Value of Liberty’, Government and Opposition, 20 (1985), 297–314CrossRefGoogle Scholar (special issue, ed., Parry, Geraint, on ‘Welfare State and Welfare Society’).Google Scholar

59 Habermas, Jürgen, ‘Legitimation Problems in the Modern State’ in his Communication and the Evolution of Society (London: Heinemann, 1979).Google Scholar

60 Jones, Catherine, ‘Types of Welfare Capitalism’, Government and Opposition, 20 (1985), 328–42, at p. 332.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

61 Jones, , ‘Welfare Capitalism’, p. 335.Google Scholar

62 Eisenstadt, and Ahimeir, , eds, Welfare State and Its Aftermath, Part Five.Google Scholar

63 Flora, Peter, ed., Growth to Limits: The Western European Welfare States Since World War II (Berlin/New York: de Gruyter, 1986)Google Scholar; Volume 1: Sweden, Norway, Finland, Denmark; Volume 2: Germany, United Kingdom, Ireland, Italy.

64 Flora, , ed., Growth to Limits, p. xviGoogle Scholar (the same introduction by Flora prefaces both volumes).

65 Rose, Richard, ‘Common Goals but Different Roles: The State's Contribution to the Welfare Mix’ in Rose, and Shiratori, Rei, eds, The Welfare State East and West (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986), pp. 13–39.Google Scholar

66 Maruo, Naomi, ‘The Development of the Welfare Mix in Japan’Google Scholar in Rose, and Shiratori, , eds, Welfare State East and West, pp. 64–79, at p. 68.Google Scholar