Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-l7hp2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-27T13:53:58.689Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Medical lecturing in Georgian London

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 January 2009

Roy Porter
Roy Porter
Affiliation:
Wellcome Institute for the History of Medicine, 183 Euston Road, London NW1 2BE.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Viewed in the light of the discussions of scientific lecturing in eighteenth-century London contained in this issue, the case of medicine may be said to be both more of the same but also something different.

Type
Research Article
Information
The British Journal for the History of Science , Volume 28 , Issue 1 , March 1995 , pp. 91 - 99
Copyright
Copyright © British Society for the History of Science 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 For the classic account, see Altick, R. D., The Shows of London: A Panoramic History of Exhibitions, 1600–1862, Cambridge, Mass., 1978Google Scholar; see also Boulton, William Biggs, The Amusements of Old London: Being a Survey of the Sports and Pastimes, Tea Gardens and Parks, Playhouses and Other Diversions of the People of London from the 17th to the Beginning of the 19th Century, London, 1901Google Scholar. A helpful evaluation of scientific lecturing as spectacle is offered in Schaffer, Simon, ‘The consuming flame: electrical showmen and Tory mystics in the world of goods’, in Consumption and the World of Goods (ed. Brewer, John and Porter, Roy), London and New York, 1993, 489–526.Google Scholar

2 Porter, Roy, ‘The sexual politics of James Graham’, British Journal for Eighteenth Century Studies (1982), 5, 201–6Google Scholar; idem., ‘Sex and the singular man: the seminal ideas of James Graham’, Studies on Voltaire and the Eighteenth Century (1984), 228, 3–24Google Scholar; and more generally on contemporary quacks, Porter, Roy, Health for Sale: Quackery in England 1650–1850, Manchester, 1989.Google Scholar

3 Hyde, Ralph, Panoramania! The Art and Entertainment of the ‘All-Embracing’ View, London, 1988.Google Scholar

4 See Porter, Roy, ‘John Hunter Showman’, Transactions of the Hunterian Society (1995), 20, in press.Google Scholar

5 Burney, Susan, quoted in Altick, , op. cit. (1), 29Google Scholar. On John Hunter as a collector, see Allen, Elizabeth, Hunterian Museum, London, 1974Google Scholar; see also Jacyna, L. S., ‘Images of John Hunter in the nineteenth century’, History of Science (1983), 21, 85–108.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

6 Jay, Ricky, Learned Pigs and Fireproof Women, New York: Warner Books, 1986, 277–8.Google Scholar

7 Bynum, W. F. and Porter, Roy (eds.), William Hunter and the Eighteenth Century Medical World, Cambridge, 1985.Google Scholar

8 Porter, Roy, ‘“Under the influence”: mesmerism in England’, History Today (1985), 35, 22–9Google Scholar; Miller, Jonathan, ‘Mesmerism’, The Listener, 22 11 1973, 685–90Google Scholar; Winter, Alison, ‘Mesmerism and popular culture in early Victorian England’, History of Science (1994), 32, 317–43.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed

9 Rosner, Lisa, Medical Education in the Age of Improvement: Edinburgh Students and Apprentices, 1760–1826, Edinburgh, 1990Google Scholar; Risse, Guenter B., ‘Clinical instruction in hospitals: the Boerhaavian tradition in Leyden, Edinburgh, Vienna, and Pavia’, Clio Medica (1989), 21, 1–19Google Scholar; idem., Hospital Life in Enlightenment Scotland: Care and Teaching at the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, Cambridge, 1986.Google Scholar

10 Beddoes, Thomas, A Letter to the Right Honourable Sir Joseph Banks…on the Causes and Removal of the Prevailing Discontents, Imperfections, and Abuses, in Medicine, London, 1808, 55.Google Scholar

11 Beddoes, , op. cit. (10), 41Google Scholar. See also Porter, Roy, Doctor of Society: Thomas Beddoes and the Sick Trade in Late Enlightenment England, London, 1991, 148Google Scholar; Lawrence, C. J., ‘Medicine as Culture: Edinburgh and the Scottish Enlightenment’, Ph.D. thesis, University of London, 1984Google Scholar, and his ‘The Edinburgh Medical School and the end of the Old Thing’, History of Universities (1988), 7, 259–86Google Scholar; and, more generally, Lawrence, Susan C., ‘Medical education’, in Companion Encyclopedia of the History of Medicine (ed. Bynum, W. F. and Porter, Roy), London, 1993, 1144–72.Google Scholar

12 Holloway, S. W. F., ‘Medical education in England, 1830–1858: a sociological analysis’, History (1964), 49, 299–324CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Newman, Charles, The Evolution of Medical Education in the Nineteenth Century, London, 1957Google Scholar; Lawrence, Susan C., ‘Private enterprise and public interests: medical education and the Apothecaries Act, 1780–1825’, in British Medicine in an Age of Reform (ed. French, Roger and Wear, Andrew), London, 1992, 45–73Google Scholar; Lawrence, Susan C., ‘Educating the senses: students, teachers and medical rhetoric in eighteenth-century London’, in Medicine and the Five Senses (ed. Bynum, W. F. and Porter, Roy), Cambridge, 1993, 154–78.Google Scholar

13 For midwifery lectures, see Wilson, Adrian, The Making of Man Midwifery, London, 1995.Google Scholar

14 Foucault, M., Naissance de la clinique: Une archéologie du regard medical (tr. Smith, A. M. Sheridan), Paris, 1963Google Scholar; idem., The Birth of the Clinic, London, 1973Google Scholar. For evaluation, see Osborne, Thomas, ‘On anti-medicine and clinical reason’, in Reassessing Foucault: Power, Medicine and the Body (ed. Jones, Colin and Porter, Roy), London, 1994, 28–47.Google Scholar

15 Quoted in Gelfand, Toby, ‘“Invite the Philosopher, As Well As the Charitable”: hospital teaching as private enterprise in Hunterian London’Google Scholar, in Bynum, and Porter, , op. cit. (7), 129–52, on 138Google Scholar; see also Porter, Roy, ‘Medical education in England before the teaching hospital: some recent revisions’, in The Professional Teacher (ed. Wilkes, John), Leicester, 1986, 29–44.Google Scholar

16 For information, see Lawrence, Susan C., ‘Entrepreneurs and private enterprise: the development of medical lecturing in London, 1775–1820’, Bulletin of the History of Medicine (1988), 57, 171–92Google Scholar; ‘Anatomy and address: creating medical gentlemen in London, 1720–1820’, in History of Medical Education in Britain (ed. Nutton, Vivian and Porter, Roy), forthcomingGoogle Scholar; and her ‘Science and Medicine at the London Hospitals: The Development of Teaching and Research 1750–1815’, Ph.D. thesis, University of Toronto, 1985Google Scholar; also, Porter, Roy, ‘William Hunter: a surgeon and a gentleman’Google Scholar, in Bynum, and Porter, , op. cit. (7), 7–34.Google Scholar

17 There is valuable information in Darlington, C. A., ‘The Teaching of Anatomical Instruction at the Royal Academy of Arts and the Cultural Consequences of Art-Anatomy Practices, circa 1768–1782’, Ph.D. thesis, University of London, 1991.Google Scholar

18 Johnstone, R. W., William Smeltie, the Master of British Midwifery, Edinburgh, 1952.Google Scholar

19 Campbell, Robert, The London Tradesman, Newton Abbot, 1969 (1st edn, 1747), 50.Google Scholar

20 Richardson, Ruth, Death, Dissection and the Destitute: A Political History of the Human Corpse, London, 1987Google Scholar; Linebaugh, P., ‘The Tyburn riot against the surgeons’, in Albion's fatal Tree (ed. Thompson, E. P., Hay, Douglas, Linebaugh, Peter, Rule, John E. and Winslow, Cal), London, 1975, 65–118Google Scholar; Cole, H., Things for the Surgeon: A History of the Resurrection Men, London, 1964.Google Scholar

21 Quoted in Porter, , op. cit. (16), 7–34.Google Scholar

22 Lawrence, C. J., ‘Alexander Monro Primus and the Edinburgh manner of anatomy’, Bulletin of the History of Medicine (1988), 62, 193–214.Google Scholar

23 See Darlington, , op. cit. (17).Google Scholar

24 See Rosner, , op. cit. (9).Google Scholar

25 Brockbank, W. and Kenworthy, F. (eds.), The Diary of Richard Kay (1716–51) of Baldingstone, near Bury, Manchester, 1968Google Scholar; Lane, Joan, ‘The role of apprenticeship in eighteenth-century medical education in England’Google Scholar, in Bynum, and Porter, , op. cit. (7), 57–104.Google Scholar

26 Wilson, , op. cit. (13).Google Scholar

27 For these arguments developed in greater detail, see Porter, , op. cit. (16), 7–34.Google Scholar

28 See Keel, Othmar, ‘The politics of health and the institutionalisation of clinical practices in Europe in the second half of the eighteenth century’Google Scholar, in Bynum, and Porter, , op. cit. (7), 207–56Google Scholar; see also Risse, , Hospital Life, op. cit. (9).Google Scholar

29 Gelfand, Toby, ‘Gestation of the clinic’, Medical History (1981), 25, 169–80CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; and his Professionalizing Modern Medicine: Paris Surgeons and Medical Science and Institutions in the 18th Century, Westport, CT, 1980Google Scholar. See also Gelfand, , op. cit. (15).Google Scholar

30 Lesky, Erna, The Vienna Medical School of the Nineteenth Century (tr. Williams, L. and Levis, I. S.), Baltimore, 1976.Google Scholar

31 Quoted in Keel, , op. cit. (28), 240.Google Scholar

32 Risse, , Hospital Life, op. cit. (9).Google Scholar

33 Quoted in Howie, W. B., ‘Medical education in eighteenth century hospitals’, Scottish Society for the History of Medicine Report of Proceedings (1969–1970), 27–46, on 41–2.Google Scholar

34 Woodward, J., To Do the Sick No Harm. A Study of the British Voluntary Hospital System to 1875, London, 1974Google Scholar; Porter, Roy, ‘The gift relation: philanthropy and provincial hospitals in eighteenth-century England’, in The Hospital in History (ed. Porter, R. and Granshaw, L.), London, 1989, 149–78.Google Scholar

35 Quoted in SirCope, Zachary, William Cheselden, Edinburgh, 1955, 35.Google Scholar

36 See Porter, , op. cit. (15), 29–44.Google Scholar

37 For Hunter, see Qvist, George, John Hunter, 1728–1793, London, 1981.Google Scholar

38 Quoted in Gelfand, , op. cit. (15), 146Google Scholar. See the discussion in Kirkpatrick, R. L., ‘Nature's Schools: The Hunterian Revolution in London Hospital Medicine, 1780–1825’, Ph.D. thesis, Cambridge University, 1989.Google Scholar

39 Wilde, Joseph, The Hospital. A Poem in Three Books written in the Devon and Exeter Hospital 1809, Norwich, 1810, 17Google Scholar, discussed in Porter, , op. cit. (34), 169.Google Scholar

40 See the discussion in Hunter, Richard and Macalpine, Ida, Three Hundred Years of Psychiatry: 1535–1860, London, 1963, 402.Google Scholar

41 Beddoes, , op. cit. (10), 77.Google Scholar

42 Desmond, Adrian, The Politics of Evolution: Morphology, Medicine and Reform in Radical London, Chicago, 1989.Google Scholar