Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T01:53:35.476Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Claudius, Elephants and Britain: Making Sense of Cassius Dio 60.21.2

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 December 2022

Michael B. Charles  and
Michael Singleton
Michael B. Charles
Affiliation:
Southern Cross University [email protected]
Michael Singleton
Affiliation:
Ewingsdale, Australia [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Narratives of the Claudian invasion of Britain in a.d. 43 have regularly referred to elephants being part of Claudius’ force, with some accounts even suggesting that Claudius paraded the beasts through Colchester (Camulodunum), or even rode on top of one. This study investigates these claims, which derive solely from a somewhat ambiguous reference in Cassius Dio's (60.21.2) description of the invasion. Temporal and logistical constraints, together with military and iconographic considerations, however, make it highly unlikely that the animals, even if they had been assembled on the Channel, made their way across to Britain. Overall, the study shows that Dio's testimony should be treated with extreme caution, and should be accorded only parenthetical importance in treatments of the Claudian invasion.

Keywords

ElephantsBritaininvasionClaudiusCassius Dio
Type
Articles
Information
Britannia , Volume 53 , November 2022 , pp. 173 - 184
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

BMCRE = British Museum Catalogue of Coins of the Roman Empire 1, ed. Mattingly, J. (London, 1976)Google Scholar
RIC = The Roman Imperial Coinage 1 (rev. edn), ed. Sutherland, C.H.V. (London, 1984)Google Scholar
Aldhouse-Green, M. 2006: Boudica Britannia: Rebel, War-leader and Queen, HarlowGoogle Scholar
Anon. 1826: ‘Review of J. Ranking: Historical researches on the wars and sports of the Monguls and Romans’, Monthly Review n.s. 2, May–August’, 131–9Google Scholar
Barrett, A.A. 1998: ‘The date of Claudius’ British campaign and the mint of Alexandria’, Classical Quarterly 48, 574–7CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bird, D.G. 2000: ‘The Claudian invasion campaign reconsidered’, Oxford Journal of Archaeology 19.1, 91–104CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bird, D.G. 2002: ‘The events of a.d. 43: further reflections’, Britannia 33, 257–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Black, E.W. 2001: ‘The first-century historians of Roman Britain’, Oxford Journal of Archaeology 20.4, 415–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Charles, M.B. 2007: ‘The rise of the Sassanian elephant corps: elephants and the later Roman empire’, Iranica Antiqua 42, 301–46Google Scholar
Charles, M.B. 2008a: ‘African forest elephants and turrets in the ancient world’, Phoenix 62, 338–62.Google Scholar
Charles, M.B. 2008b: ‘Alexander, elephants and Gaugamela’, Mouseion 3rd series 8: 9–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Charles, M.B. 2014: ‘Elephants at Rome: provenance, use and fate’, Athenaeum 102, 25–46Google Scholar
Charles, M.B. 2016: ‘Elephant size in antiquity: DNA evidence and the battle of Raphia’, Historia 65, 53–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Charles, M.B. 2020: ‘The African elephants of antiquity revisited: habitat and representational evidence’, Historia 69, 392–407CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Creighton, J. 2006: Britannia: The Creation of a Roman Province, London and New YorkGoogle Scholar
De la Bédoyère, G. 2013: Roman Britain: A New History (rev. edn), LondonGoogle Scholar
Durry, M. 1939: Les cohortes prétoriennes, ParisGoogle Scholar
Edmondson, J. 1992: Dio: The Julio-Claudians. Selections from Books 58–63 of the Roman History of Cassius Dio, Lactor 16, LondonGoogle Scholar
Erim, K.T. 1982: ‘A new relief showing Claudius and Britannia from Aphrodisias’, Britannia 13, 277–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frere, S.S., and Fulford, M. 2001: ‘The Roman invasion of a.d. 43’, Britannia 32, 445–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grainge, G. 2005: The Roman Invasions of Britain, StroudGoogle Scholar
Graves, R, 1934. Claudius the God, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Hind, J.G.F. 1989: ‘The Roman invasion of a.d. 43 – an alternative strategy for A. Plautius’, Britannia 20, 1–21Google Scholar
Hind, J.G.F. 2007: ‘Plautius’ campaign in Britain: an alternative reading of the narrative in Cassius Dio (60.19.5–21.2)’, Britannia 38, 93–106CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hoffmann, B. 2019: The Roman Invasion of Britain: Archaeology Versus History, BarnsleyGoogle Scholar
Koeppel, G.M. 1983: ‘Two reliefs from the Arch of Claudius in Rome’, Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts, Römische Abteilung 90, 103–9Google Scholar
Levick, B. 1978: ‘Antiquarian or revolutionary? Claudius Caesar's conception of his principate’, American Journal of Philology 99.1, 79–105CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lister, A., and Bahn, P. 2007: Mammoths: Giants of the Ice Age (rev. edn), LondonGoogle Scholar
Manley, J. 2002: AD 43 – The Roman Invasion of Britain. A Reassessment, StroudGoogle Scholar
Manley, J., and Rudkin, D. 2005: ‘A pre-a.d. 43 ditch at Fishbourne Roman palace, Chichester’, Britannia 36, 55–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Millar, F. 1964: A Study of Cassius Dio, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Nossov, K. 2008: War Elephants, Osprey New Vanguard Series 150, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Nousek, D.L. 2008: ‘Turning points in Roman history: the case of Caesar's elephant denarius’, Phoenix 62, 290–307Google Scholar
Peddie, J. 2005: Conquest: The Roman Invasion of Britain (rev. edn), StroudGoogle Scholar
Rance, P. 2003: ‘Elephants in warfare in late antiquity’, Acta Antiqua Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae 43, 355–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rankov, B. 1994: The Praetorian Guard, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Salway, P. 1981: Roman Britain, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Salway, P. 1997: A History of Roman Britain, LondonGoogle Scholar
Sauer, E. 2002: ‘The Roman invasion of Britain (AD 43) in imperial perspective: a response to Frere and Fulford’, Oxford Journal of Archaeology 21.4, 333–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Scullard, H.H. 1974: The Elephant in the Greek and Roman World, LondonGoogle Scholar
Smith, R.R.R. 1987: ‘The imperial reliefs from the Sebasteion at Aphrodisias’, Journal of Roman Studies 77, 88–138Google Scholar
Southern, P. 2011: Roman Britain: A New History 55 BC–AD 450, StroudGoogle Scholar
Stevens, C.E. 1959: ‘Julius Caesar's elephant’, History Today September, 626–7Google Scholar
Sydenham, E.A. 1952: The Coinage of the Roman Republic (rev. Haines, G.C., eds Forrer, L. and Hersh, C.A.), LondonGoogle Scholar
Thackery, H.St.J. (tr.) 1927: Josephus. The Jewish War Books III–IV, LCL 487, Cambridge, MA and LondonGoogle Scholar
Thornhill, P. 1976: ‘A lower Thames ford and the campaigns of 55 b.c. and a.d. 43’, Archaeologia Cantiana 92, 119–28Google Scholar
Webster, G. 1993: The Roman Invasion of Britain (rev. edn), LondonGoogle Scholar
Wightman, E.M. 1975: ‘Priscae Gallorum memoriae: some comments on sources for a history of Gaul’, in Levick, B. (ed.), The Ancient Historian and His Materials: Essays in Honour of C.E. Stevens on his Seventieth Birthday, Farnborough, 93–107Google Scholar