Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-fscjk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T19:11:22.186Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Soldiers' Burials at Camelon, Stirlingshire, 1922 and 1975

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2011

David J. Breeze ,
Joanna Close-Brooks ,
J. N. Graham Ritchie ,
Ian R. Scott ,
A. Young  and
Archibald Young
David J. Breeze
Affiliation:
Edinburgh
Joanna Close-Brooks
Affiliation:
Edinburgh
J. N. Graham Ritchie
Affiliation:
Edinburgh
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

On 11 January 1975 a stone cist containing two inhumation burials and a series of iron objects was found in gravel-working at the Cairnmuirs Gravel Pit, west of the Roman fort at Camelon, Stirlingshire, now in the Falkirk district of the Central Region of Scotland (NS 860810). The two boys who made the initial discovery, David Vause and Wallace Wright, took a collection of bones and ironwork home, and their parents informed Camelon constabulary. The police took the matter up with Mr. J. M. Sanderson of Falkirk Museum and he asked the National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland and the Ancient Monuments Inspectorate of the Department of the Environment for assistance in excavating the grave. Because of the risk of sandfalls, the excavation of what turned out to be the burial of two soldiers accompanied by their weapons was undertaken the following day by Dr. J. Close-Brooks, National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland, Dr. D. J. Breeze, Department of the Environment, and Dr. J. N. G. Ritchie, Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland. Under Scottish law, objects of archaeological importance (not necessarily of precious metal) may be claimed as Treasure Trove, and the finders appropriately rewarded; accordingly the Queen's and Lord Treasurer's Remembrancer claimed the weapons for the Crown and Mr. Vause and Mr. Wright have been rewarded for their prompt reporting of the cist. A second sword found by a bulldozer driver in the gravelworkings at a rather earlier date was handed over at the same time, and also claimed by the Crown. Two other deposits, one of them in a cist, were found at Camelon in 1922 on the south-east side of the site, and the opportunity has been taken here to publish new illustrations of these finds. This report comprises a discussion of the known history of the fort, a description of the excavation of the most recent cist and of the deposits found in 1922, a discussion of the mode of burial, the status of the soldiers and of the weapons, and finally a detailed description of the individual objects.

Type
Articles
Information
Britannia , Volume 7 , November 1976 , pp. 73 - 95
Copyright
Copyright © David J. Breeze, Joanna Close-Brooks and J. N. Graham 1976. Exclusive Licence to Publish: The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Discovery and Excavation in Scotland 1961, 54–5.

2 Ibid. 1962, 45.

3 RCAHMS, Stirlingshire (1962), 107–12, No. 122.

4 It has been suggested that there was sufficient accommodation in the Antonine fort for an ala quingenaria; ibid., 110. The length of the barrack-blocks (51.8 m) implies, however, that the garrison may have been part or all of a cohors milliaria; cf. Arch. Aeliana1 xlvii (1969), 27–30.Google Scholar

5 Britannia iii (1972), 13, 38–9.Google Scholar

6 Buchanan, M. and Callander, J. G., PSAS lvii (1922–1923), 243–50.Google Scholar

7 Ibid., 246.

8 Wilson, D., Prehistoric Annals of Scotland (second edition, 1863), i, 474.Google Scholar

9 PSAS xxxviii (1903–1904), 427–45.Google Scholar

10 PSAS xx (1885–1886), 136–41Google Scholar; Arch. Aeliana4 xxxvii (1959), 44Google Scholar; Britannia i (1970), 212, Table vii.Google Scholar

11 PSAS lxxxv (1950–1951), 92–117; R. B. K. Stevenson in A. L. F. Rivet (ed.), The Iron Age in Northern Britain (1966), 35.Google Scholar

12 PSAS lviii (1923–1924), 143–60.Google Scholar

13 Stead, I. M., The La Tène Cultures of Eastern Yorkshire (1965), 67–70Google Scholar; PPS xxxiv (1968), 166–78.Google Scholar

14 PSAS v (1862–1864), 341.Google Scholar

15 Welfare, H. G., Iron Age and Native Burial in North Britain. M.Phil, thesis, University of Newcastle upon Tyne (1974).Google Scholar

16 Germania 51 (1973), 121–33.Google Scholar

17 B. Cunliffe, Iron Age Communities in Britain (1974), 287–95.

18 Antiq. Journ. xlviii (1968), 25–7.Google Scholar

19 Zeit. Schweiz. Arch. Kunst. 15 (1954–1955), 220–2.Google Scholar

20 L. P. Wenham, The Romano-British Cemetery at Trentholme Drive, York (1968), 4.

21 Annals of Archaeology and Anthropology 6 (1914), 123; 7 (1921), 49.Google Scholar

22 Wenham, op. cit. (note 20), 42–4.

23 Med. Arch. 5 (1961), 1–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Antiq. Journ. 1 (1970), 295–7, 313Google Scholar

24 Wenham, op. cit. (note 20), 38.

25 Saalburg Jahrb. 12 (1953), 53–6; 17 (1958), 65; 20 (1962), 54–61; 21 (1963/4), 20–31. We are grateful to Dr. D. Baatz for bringing these references to our attention.Google Scholar

26 Saalburg Jahrb. 12 (1953), No. 10; 21 (1963/4), No. II.Google Scholar

27 Cf. CIL xiii 5708 and appendix.Google Scholar

28 PPS xvi (1950), 3–16.Google Scholar

29 Loc. cit.

30 Germania 51 (1973), 129–31Google Scholar; PPS xvi (1950), 12–14.Google Scholar

31 PSAS ciii (1970–1971), 242, No. 19, fig. 1.Google Scholar

32 C. Fox, A Find of the Early Iron Age from Llyn Cerrig Bach, Anglesey (1946), pi. XXXIII, 92.

33 Bull. Board Celtic Studies 19 (1960–1962), 85–9.Google Scholar

34 Vindonissa Museum, acc. no. 31: 1400.

35 Vindonissa Museum, acc. no. 1938 (Pompeii type).

36 J. Curie, A Roman Frontier Post and its People, The Fort of Newstead (1911), pl. xxxiv, 11 (hereinafter referred to as Newstead).

37 Newstead, pl. XXXIV, 13.

38 Unpublished, see below.

39 L. Jacobi, Römerkastell Saalburg (1897), 136, Taf. 23, 7.

40 Rheinisches Landesmuseum, Bonn, acc. no. 31783.

41 From the Wallbrook, 1954; Guildhall Museum, acc. no. 18154.

42 Saalburg Jahrb. 26 (1969), 131–3, Abb. 2.Google Scholar

43 We are grateful to Mr. G. Jobey for information on this find in advance of publication.

44 Newstead, 185–6, pl. XXXIV, 8 and 10; pL. xxxv, 11 and 12.

45 PSAS lxxiii (1938–1939), 146, pl. LX, 1.Google Scholar

46 Déchelette, J., Manuel d'Archéologie, ii, 3 (1914), figs. 435, 2 and 3; 441, 6; 443, e–h; 444, 1; 478 and 479; P. Vouga, La Tène (1923), pls. X–XIV.Google Scholar

47 Brailsford, J., Hod Hill i (1962), pls. V and VIGoogle Scholar; PSAS lxxxix (1955–1956), 201–2, Nos. 384–98.Google Scholar

48 C. Fox, A Find of the Early Iron Age from Llyn Cerrig Bach, Anglesey (1946), pl. XIX, spear 96; pL. xxxv, spears 14, 15 and 16; PSAS lxxxix (1955–1956), 202, No. 395.Google Scholar

49 PSAS lxiii (1928–1929), 559–60, fig. 121, 1.Google Scholar

50 PSAS lxiv (1929–1930), 118, fig. 5, No. 36.Google Scholar

51 Britannia i (1970), 207, Table 1.Google Scholar

52 Arch. Journ. 93 (1937), pls. VA and XIII, 4–6Google Scholar; PSAS liv (1919–1920), 83, fig. 15, 2.Google Scholar

53 Scottish Archaeological Forum 1 (1969), 31–40.Google Scholar

54 PSAS lxxxvii (1952–1953), 37 (C 38), 47 (B 30); lxxxix (1955–6), 200, No. 382.Google Scholar

55 Britannia iii (1972), 224–50.Google Scholar

56 M. I. Rostovtzeff, F. E. Brown and C. B. Welles (eds), The Excavations at Dura-Europos, 1933–4 and 1934–5 (1939), 326–69, pis. XLI, XLII, XLIV–VI.

57 RIB 2030.

58 C. Cichorius, Die Reliefs die Traianssaule (1896 and 1900), Tafs. XVIII, XIX, XLIX, LXVIII and LXIX.

59 ORL VII B, 73 (Das Kastell Pfunz), Taf. XV, 14–16 and 18; ORL II 2 B, 16 (Das Kastell Arnsburg), Taf. VI, 11 and 12.

60 Newstead, pl. XXXIV, 3.

61 Newstead, pl. XXXVI, 6 and 7.

62 C. F. C. Hawkes and M. R. Hull, Camulodunum: First Report on the Excavations at Colchester, 1938–39 (1947), pl. CIV, Nos. 3–6.

63 See above p. 83.

64 Lindenschmit, L., Die Altertumer … von der Direktion des Römisch-Germanischen Central-museums in Mainz, v (1911), Taf. 64, Nos. 1186 and 1187.Google Scholar

65 Newstead, pl. XXXVI, 6.

66 E. Ritterling, Das Frührömische Lager bei Hofheim im Taunus (1913), Taf, XVII.

67 Britannia iv (1973), 198.Google Scholar

68 Tacitus, Agricola, 13.

69 Tacitus, Annals, xii, 31.

70 RCAHMS, Stirlingshire (1962), 112, No. 122.

71 G. Forni, Il reclutamento delle legioni da Augusto a Diocleziano (1953), 135–41.

72 The wood structure is too crushed to be identifiable.

73 The Stanwick scabbard was also of ash, a wood particularly suitable for making scabbards; R. E. M. Wheeler, The Stanwick Fortifications (1954), 47.

74 PSAS xcvii (1963–1964), 172, 178–9.Google Scholar

75 Newstead, 183–4, pl. XXXIV, 6, 7.

76 A similar but well-preserved shoulder-piece of bone was found at Newstead; Newstead, pl. LXXIV, 4.

77 Woodcuts: Pitt-Rivers, A. H., Excavations in Cranbourne Chase i (1887), 617, pls. XIX–XXIGoogle Scholar. Richborough and Dunapentele: Bushe-Fox, J. P., Richborough iv (1949), 142, pls. XLVII, XLVIIIGoogle Scholar. Strasbourg: Forrer, R., Strasbourg-Argentorate ii (1927), 324, pl. XXXIX, 15.Google Scholar

78 Newstead, pl. LXXXIII, 8, 12.

79 In Frere, S. S., Verulamium Excavations i (1972), 180.Google Scholar

80 vi, 39.

81 Tacitus, Annals, i, 17.

82 P. Gen. Lat. 1 recto, part 1 = R. O. Fink, Roman Military Records on Papyrus (1971), 68.

83 Bonner Jahrb. 169 (1969), 224.Google Scholar

84 P. Mich. 467 and 468.

85 P. Fouad 45.

86 P. Fay. 105 ii, 2 and 18 = Fink 73 (see note 82).

87 P. Col. inv 325; cf. Bonner Jahrb. 167 (1967), 233–43.Google Scholar

88 CPL 221.

89 American J. Archaeol. 64 (1960), 23–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

90 Helinium 10 (1970), 3, 242–9; n (1971), I, 34–47.Google Scholar

91 CIL xiii 5708.Google Scholar