Published online by Cambridge University Press: 09 November 2011
This paper will present an analysis of one of the most common legionary fortress building types – the centurions' quarters, in an attempt to understand their usage and organisation, and the degree to which they were standardised. After looking briefly at centurions themselves, and especially their social backgrounds, to see what they might have expected of their houses, the paper will study the buildings' size and position within a fortress, and analyse their common features, internal structure, and the distribution of find types within them, in an attempt to identify different areas of use. Finally, an historical overview will be offered to show how the design of the buildings evolved over time, whilst comparisons with other structures will be used to see how they fit into the wider Roman building tradition.
1 L.J.F. Keppie, The Making of the Roman Army (1984) and P.J. Casey, The Legions of the Later Roman Empire (1984).
2 Dobson, B., ‘Legionary centurion or equestrian officer? A comparison of pay and prospects’, Ancient Society iii (1972), 203.Google Scholar
3 Birley, E., ‘A Roman altar from Old Kilpatrick and interim commanders of auxiliary units’, Latomus xlii (1983), 73–83.Google Scholar
4 M.C. Bishop, ‘The distribution of military equipment within forts of the first century A.D.’, in Chr. Unz, Studien zu den Militärgrenzen Roms 111. 13. Internationaler Limeskongress Aälen 1980 (1988), 717ff.
5 e.g. P. Crummy, Excavations at Culver Street, the Gilberd School and Other Sites in Colchester 1971–1985 (1992)
6 e.g. M.R. Cagnat, Les deux camps de légion IIIe Auguste á Lambèse d'après les fouilles recentes (1908).
7 Breeze, D.J., ‘Pay grades and ranks below the centurionate’, JRS lxi (1971), 134 and A. von Domazewski, Die Rangordnung des römischen Heeres. 2. Durchgesehene Auflage. Einführung, Berichtigungen und Nachträge von B. Dobson (1967), 28ff.Google Scholar
8 B. Dobson, ‘The significance of the centurion and primipilaris in the Roman army and administration,' in H. Temporini (ed.), Aufstieg und Niedergang der Römischen Welt II.I (1974), 403.
9 E. Birley, ‘The origins of legionary centurions’, in E. Birley, The Roman Army Papers 1929–1986 (1988), 204.
10 CIL VIII.217 with p. 2353 = ILS 2658; Birley, E., ‘Promotions and transfers in the Roman army. II: the centurionate’, Carnuntum Jb. viii (1965), 23.Google Scholar
11 Dobson, op. cit. (note 8), 403.
12 idem.
13 Summerly, J.R., Studies in the Legionary Centurionate (unpub. Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Durham, 1990), 227.Google Scholar
14 Dobson, op. cit. (note 2), 204.
15 ibid., 205.
16 ibid., 194.
17 Birley, E., ‘Some legionary centurions’, Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik lxxix (1989), 115.Google Scholar
18 Dobson, op. cit. (note 2), 205.
19 Dobson, op. cit. (note 2), 204.
20 Summerly, op. cit. (note 13), 226.
21 B. Dobson, Die primipilares. Entwicklung und Bedeutung, Laufbahnen und Persönlichkeiten eines römischen Offiziersranges (1978), 114.
22 Dobson, op. cit. (note 2), 203.
23 See Table 1, based on L. Wierschowski, Heer und Wirtschaft. Das römische Heer der Prinzipatszeit als Wirtschaftsfaktor (1984), 39.
24 Campbell, B., ‘The marriage of soldiers under the empire’, JRS lxviii (1978), 1663–6.Google Scholar
25 Y. Le Bohec, La Troisième Légion Auguste (1989), lists all the known inscriptions from Lambaesis and thereby presents a convenient update to the material published in CIL III.
26 Digest XXIII.2.63ff., Tab. Vindol. 11.291, and a number of epigraphic records. It may be worth noting, that a number of primipilares had marriage links with other equestrian and even senatorial families (B. Dobson, ‘The centurionate and social mobility during the principate’, in Nicolet (ed.), Recherches sur les structures sociales dans l'antiquité classique (1970), 110f.).
27 H. von Petrikovits, Die Innenbauten römischer Legionslager während der Prinzipatszeit (1975), 62 and 134.
28 Sander, E.G., ‘Das Recht des römischen Soldaten’, Rheinisches Museum für Philologie N.F. ci (1958), 153.Google Scholar
29 A.R. Birley, “Vindolanda: neue Ausgrabungen 1985–1986’, in H. Vetter and M. Kandler (eds), Akten des XIV. Internationalen Limeskongresses 1986 in Carnuntum (1990), 330.
30 C. van Driel-Murray, paper delivered to 1992 Roman Military Equipment Conference in Newcastle.
31 L. Wierschowski, Heer und Wirtschaft. Das römische Heer der Prinzipatszeit als Wirtschaftsfaktor (1984), 70.
32 Saller, R.P. and Shaw, B.D., ‘Tombstones and family relations in the principate: civilians, soldiers and slaves’, JRS lxxiv (1984), 124–56.Google Scholar
33 Breeze, op. cit. (note 7), 133f.
34 von Petrikovits, op. cit. (note 27), 59ff.
35 Fellmann, D.R., ‘Die Ausgrabungen im Legionslager Vindonissa im Jahre 1953’, Jahresbericht der Gesellschaft Pro Vindonissa 1953/4 (1956). 45ff.Google Scholar
36 Lehner, H., ‘Bericht über die Tätigkeit des Provinzialmuseums in Bonn in der Zeit vom 1.4.1929 bis 31.3.1930.1. Die Ausgrabung auf dem Fürstenberg bei Xanten’, Bonner Jb. cxxxv (1935), fig. 3.Google Scholar
37 Davison, D.P., The Barracks of the Roman Army from the First to Third Centuries AD. A Comprehensive Study of Barracks from Fortresses, Forts and Fortlets with an Analysis of Building Types and Construction, Stabling and Garrison, BAR Int. Ser. 742 (1989), 619ff and table ix.Google Scholar
38 ibid., 627ff. and table x.
39 von Domazewski, op. cit. (note 7), 90ff.
40 B. Dobson in von Domazewski, op. cit. (note 7), xxiiiff.
41 Davison, op. cit. (note 37), 622, gives wider variations but the published plans of the site (Das im Auftrag des Rheinischen Provinzialverbandes vom Bonner Provinzialmuseum 1887-1900 ausgegrabene Legionslager, Tafeln, and Koenen, C., ‘Beschreibung von Novaesium’, Bonner Jb. cxi/cxii (1904)) show only the two sizes quoted.Google Scholar
42 von Petrikovits, op. cit. (note 27), 110 and fig. 33.
43 ibid., 106.
44 The drain is shown on Groller's plan of 1900 (Groller (1901), Taf. XI fig. 11), but was not found when Nowotny re-examined the site ten years later (Nowotny (1914), Taf. III). It should be noted that most of the structures shown in the Carnuntum plans are probably Diocletianic (von Petrikovits, op. cit. (note 27), 30) and show other features not found in earlier barracks.
45 The drains of Carnuntum Geb. XXVIId (Groller (1903), 80f. and figs 41–2) were initially interpreted as heating ducts.
46 Groller, M. von, ‘Das Lager Carnuntum’, in Wissenschaften, Kaiserliche Akademie der (ed.), Der römische Limes in Österreich VI (1905), 83f.Google Scholar
47 P. Ottaway, ‘Excavations and observations on and adjacent to the fortress defences, 1971–90’, The Archaeology of York 3.3 (forthcoming), 4.
48 Jakobi, H., ‘Die Beund Entwaesserung unserer Limeskastelle’, Saalburg Jb. lxxxix (1934), 51ff.Google Scholar
49 Chr. Ebeling, unpub. M.A. thesis, Universität Freiburg.
50 F.G. Simpson, Watermills and Military Works on Hadrian's Wall (ed. G. Simpson, 1976), pls 53–5.
51 e.g. Ostia III, VII, 3–5 and Herculaneum IV, 3, 4 (J.E. Packer, The Insulae of Imperial Ostia (1971), plan 22 and 53).
52 Jakobi, op. cit. (note 48), 56.
53 Packer, op. cit. (note 51), 290.
54 Simpson, op. cit. (note 50), pl. 53.
55 The term ‘hydraulic concrete’ is used here for the typical Roman concrete used in the linings of basins. Frequent analysis has shown that it differs from normal concrete by the addition of pozzuolana earths or substances with similar characteristics.
56 Chr. Simonett, ‘Grabungen der Gesellschaft Pro Vindonissa im Jahre 1938’, Zeitschrift für Schweizerische Archaeologie und Kunstgeschichte 1,2. (1939), 89.
57 Fox, A., ‘The legionary fortress at Caerleon, Monmouthshire. Excavations at Myrtle Cottage Orchard 1939’, Arch. Camb. xcv (1940), 115.Google Scholar
58 Albrecht, Chr., Das Römerlager in Oberaden und das Uferkastell in Beckinghausen an der Lippe I (1938), 19.Google Scholar
59 Crummy, op. cit. (note 5).
60 Packer, op. cit. (note 51), plan 20f.
61 von Petrikovits, op. cit. (note 27), 30.
62 K. Parlasca, Die römischen Mosaiken in Deutschland (1959), 85f. and Hagen, J., ‘Bonn. (Zimmer mit Mosaikfussboden im Legionslager)’, Korrespondenzblatt der Westdeutschen Zeitung für Geschichte und Kunst 7–8, 23 (1904), 136.Google Scholar
63 My thanks to Dr M. Gechter for drawing my attention to these features.
64 H. Th. Fischer and S. Rieckhoff-Pauli, Von den Römern zu den Bajuwaren – Stadtarchaeologie in Regensburg (1982), 44–52.
65 The example at Carnuntum Bau XXVId which was originally interpreted as a drain (Groller, op. cit. (note 46), 80f. and figs 41–2) has been included here as it is similar to other hypocausts that have since been found linked to praefurnia.
66 P.J. Casey and B. Hoffmann, ‘Excavations at Alstone Cottage, Caerleon, 1970’, above, p. 72.
67 An example of just what could have been created in these rooms can be seen in the reconstructed wall-painting from Echzell, which was found in the quarters of an auxiliary officer, probably a decurion (M. Schleiermacher, ‘Die Wand- und Deckenmalereien aus dem Kastell Echzell’, in H. Vetter and M. Kandler (eds), Akten des XIV. Intemationalen Limeskongresses 1986 in Carnuntum (1990), 431ff.
68 Theoretically a door might be equally possible, but this seems unlikely in view of the evidence presented below.
69 Packer, op. cit. (note 51), and R. Meiggs, Roman Ostia (1960), 242.
70 Meiggs, op. cit. (note 69), 244.
71 See Nowotny, E., ‘Ausgrabungen im Lager Carnuntum’, in Wissenschaften, Kaiserliche Akademie der (ed.), Der romische Limes in Österreich 12 (1994), 1–222 for the enlarging and interlinking of structures in the retentura. The suite type is found in Gebäude B, C?, XIII, XVIII, XXIV?, XXVI, XXVII, XXXI, XXXIV, 1 Ost, 4 Ost, 5 Ost, 6 and 7 Ost.Google Scholar
72 H. Lehner, ‘Ausgrabung- und Fundberichte des Provinzialmuseums in Bonn vom I. August 1901 bis 30. April 1903 (mit Beiträgen von C. Koenen, F.G.V. Papen, P. Steiner)’, Banner Jb. cx (1903), 122ff.Google Scholar
73 Fingerlin, G., ‘Dangstetten, ein augusteisches Legionslager am Hochrhein. Vorbericht über die Grabungen 1967–1969,’ Berichte der Römisch-Germanischen Kommission 51/52 (1992), Beilage 28.Google Scholar
74 Bogaers, J.E. and Haalebos, J.K., ‘Opgravingen in de Romeinse Legionensvestingen te Nijmegen’, Oudheidkindige Medelingen van het Rijksmuseum te Leiden lvii (1977), fig. 4.Google Scholar
75 Luedin, O., ‘Ausgrabungen Königsfelden-Breite 1966. Bericht des Grabungsleiters’, Jahresberichte der Gesellschaft Pro Vindonissa 1966 (1967), Beilage 3.Google Scholar
76 L.F. Pitts and J.K. St. Joseph, Inchtuthil. The Roman Legionary Fortress, Excavations 1952–65 (1985), fig. 40.
77 Das im Auftrag des Rheinischen Provinzialverbandes vom Bonner Provinzialmuseum 1887–1990 ausgegrabene Legionslager (1904), Taf. 3.
78 Packer, op. cit. (note 51), pls 6, 7, 20f., 29f. et al.
79 Nash-Williams, V.E., ‘The Roman legionary fortress at Caerleon in Monmouthshire. Report on the excavations carried out in the Prysg Field. Part II. The finds’, Arch. Camb. lxxxvii (1932), 48–104Google Scholar and Nash-Williams, V.E., ‘The Roman legionary fortress at Caerleon in Monmouthshire. Report on the excavations carried out in the Prysg Field. Part III. The finds of pottery,’ Arch. Camb. lxxxvii (1932), 265–349.Google Scholar
80 Droop, J.P. and Newstead, R., ‘Excavations in the Deanery Field, Chester, 1928. Part 1: the excavation,’ Annals Arch. Anth. Soc. University of Liverpool xviii (1931), 113ff.Google Scholar
81 Schnurbein, S. von, ‘Untersuchungen zur Geschichte der römischen Militärlager an der Lippe’, Berichte der Romisch-Germanischen Kommission lxii (1981), 17, 22.Google Scholar
82 Schnurbein, S. von, Bodenaltertümer Westfalens xiv (1974), 68Google Scholar and Morel, J.A.W., ‘Tents or Barracks?’ in Maxfield, V. and Dobson, M.J. (eds), Roman Frontier Studies 1989. Proceedings of the XVth International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies (1991), 384f., fig. 72.1 and 2.Google Scholar
83 von Schnurbein, op. cit. (note 82), 69.
84 von Schnurbein, op. cit. (note 81), 77f.
85 Crummy, op. cit. (note 5), 24.
86 S. Ward and T.J. Strickland, Chester Excavations, Northgate Brewery 1974. A Roman Centurion's Quarter and Barrack (1978), 22f.
87 Wiedemer, H., ‘Ausgrabung Königsfelden 1961. Organisation und Verlauf der Grabung’ Jahrbuch der Geselhchaft Pro Vindonissa 1961/1962 (1962), 26–8.Google Scholar
88 Such conservatism is also visible in other features such as the passages separating centurions' quarters from the contubernia (mentioned above), which can often be traced as vestigial features in much later rebuildings of barracks that originally contained them, e.g. Carnuntum Geb. XVIII, XXIV and possibly Bau 4 Ost.
89 von Petrikovits, op. cit. (note 27), 145.
90 Packer, op. cit. (note 51), 62 and Meiggs, op. cit. (note 69), 237f.
91 Trans. M.H. Morgan
92 Y. Le Bohec, La Troisième Légion Auguste (1989).