No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Theodor Herzl and Richard von Schaukal: Self-Styled Nobility and the Sources of Bourgeois Belligerence in Prewar Vienna
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 February 2009
Abstract
An abstract is not available for this content so a preview has been provided. Please use the Get access link above for information on how to access this content.
- Type
- Forum: New Views of Fin-de-Siècle Vienna
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Center for Austrian Studies, University of Minnesota 1997
References
1 Karpfen, Fritz, Literarisches Verbrecheralbum (Vienna, 1918), 14–15Google Scholar; Sonnleitner, Johann, “Eherne Sonette 1914. Richard von Schaukal und der Erste Weltkrieg,” in Österreich und der groβe Krieg. 1914–1918, ed. Amann, Klaus and Lengauer, Hubert (Vienna, 1989), 152–58.Google Scholar In addition to the much discussed work of Havel, see also Wojtyła, Karol, The Collected Plays and Writings on Theater, trans. Taborski, Boleslaw (Berkeley, Calif., 1987).Google Scholar
2 Herzl, Theodor, Briefe und Tagebücher, ed. Bein, Alex, Greive, Hermann, Schaerf, Moshe, and Schoeps, Julius H., 5 vols. (Berlin, 1983), 2:48.Google Scholar
3 Bein, Alex, Theodore Herzl, trans. Samuel, Maurice (Philadelphia, 1941), 335–36.Google Scholar
4 Zweig, Stefan, The World of Yesterday (New York, 1943), 106.Google Scholar
5 von Schaukal, Richard, “Herkunft und Anfänge. Kennzeichen,” in Beiträge zu einer Selbstdarstellung (1929; reprint Vienna, 1934), 45.Google Scholar
6 Schaukal, , Beiträge zu einer Selbstdarstellung, 55.Google Scholar
7 Goffman, Erving, The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life (New York, 1959), 36.Google Scholar
8 See Mayer, Arno J., The Persistence of the Old Regime (New York, 1981).Google Scholar
9 Sked, Alan, The Decline and Fall of the Habsburg Empire (London, 1989), 187.Google Scholar Sked makes the case against the thesis of the decline and “inevitable” fall of the Habsburg order. Despite its well-known weaknesses, he concludes, the empire dissolved because it lost World War I.
10 Trommler, Frank, “The Creation of a Culture of Sachlichkeit,” in Society, Culture, and the State in Germany, 1870–1930, ed. Eley, Geoff (Ann Arbor, Mich., 1996), 465–85Google Scholar; Trommler, , “Sachlichkeit statt Bürgerlichkeit,” in Von der Aufgabe der Freiheit. Politische Verantwortung und bürgerliche Gesellschaft im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert, ed. Jansen, Christian, Niethammer, Lutz, and Weisbrod, Bernd (Berlin, 1995), 63–46.Google Scholar
11 Bein, Alex, Theodor Herzl (Vienna, 1934), 81.Google Scholar
12 Schaukal, , Beiträge zu einer Selbstdarstellung, 18.Google Scholar
13 Schaukal, Richard, Intérieurs aus dem Leben der Zwanzigjährigen (Leipzig, 1901), 186.Google Scholar
14 Schaukal, Richard, Vom Geschmack. Zeitgemässe Laienpredigten über das Thema Kultur (Munich, 1910).Google Scholar
15 Schaukal, Richard and Schnitzler, Arthur, Briefwechsel (1900–1902)Google Scholar, ed. Urbach, Reinhard, Modern Austrian Literature 8, no. 3/4 (1975): 31.Google Scholar
16 Elster, Hanns Martin, “Richard Schaukal,” Xenien 11 (1909): 299.Google Scholar
17 The official proclamation for the ennoblement of Schaukal appeared in Wiener Zeitung, 05 28, 1918, 1.Google Scholar For Schaukal as the last high civil servant, consult Suchy, Viktor, “Die ‘österreichische Idee’ als konservative Staatsidee bei Hugo von Hofmannsthal, Richard von Schaukal und Anton Wildgans,” in Staat und Gesellschaft in der modernen österreichischen Literatur, ed. Aspetsberger, Friedbert (Vienna, 1977), 29.Google Scholar
18 Kraus, Karl, Die Fackel 521–530 (1920): 69.Google Scholar
19 “Allerhöchste Entschließung,” 05 18, 1918Google Scholar (Priora: 3934/ K.U.M.) Staatsarchiv (Vienna). The case of Schaukal numbered among the 712 elevations in rank performed during the two-year reign of Emperor Karl. For noble promotion during this period, see Wiesflecker, Peter, “Nobilitierungen Kaiser Karls I von Österreich. Studien zum Österreichischen Adel am Ende der Donaumonarchie” (D.Phil, diss., University of Vienna, 1992).Google Scholar
20 Goldinger, Walter, “Geschichte der Organisation des Handelsministeriums,” in 100 Jahre im Dienste der Wirtschaft, ed. Handel, Bundesministerium für und Wiederaufbau, (Vienna, 1961), 361.Google Scholar
21 Nadler, Josef, Literaturgeschichte Österreichs (Linz, 1948), 448.Google Scholar
22 Schaukal, Richard, Meine Gärten (Berlin, 1897), 123Google Scholar: “Above meadows and fog / Breaks sleepily the day. / No welcoming larksong, / Only the clashing of cavalry sabers / And the dragging of tired hooves / On a hard and broken road. / Legs and dreams sluggish … / Out of the distance, a prophecy of doom.”
23 Schaukal, Richard, “Ausfahrt,” in Das Buch der Tage und Träume, rev. ed. (1899; Leipzig, 1902), 7Google Scholar: “Farewell, you garden breezes, / suffused with the scent of violet and mild. / Our hair is without fragrance, / we have a sword on our hips: / sound the sword on the shield.”
24 Although his sample reaches beyond 1908—the year that brought the Expressionist breakthrough and, for most scholars, the close of the “fin de siècle”—Armin A. Wallas responds to some now conventional readings of the garden in “Ort des paradiesischen Lebens und Ort der Verwüstung. Das Bild des Gartens in der österreichischen Literatur der Jahrhundertwende,” Protokolle 1 (1991): 73–94.Google Scholar
25 Rilke, Rainer Maria, review of Ausgewählte GedichteGoogle Scholar, by Schaukal, Richard, Die Zukunft 51 (1905): 39–40.Google Scholar
26 Schaukal, Richard, Ausgewählte Gedichte (Leipzig, 1904), 93Google Scholar: “Mount my horse, test his / stride / along the covered path in the park next to the castle rid- / ing.” Some editions of Schaukal's poetry use a dot stop, rather than a comma, to indicate a clausal break. This practice has been reproduced here.
27 Ibid.: “Look, it pays attention / the animal knows that I am talking about it.”
28 Ibid.: “Look how proudly and happily it laughs / I rode the horse to much hunting / to many feuds.”
29 Hermand, Jost, “Gralsmotive um die Jahrhundertwende,” in Von Mainz nach Weimar (1793–1919) (Stuttgart, 1969), 269–97.Google Scholar
30 For the genesis of this work, see the three versions and documentation collected in Simon, Walter, Rainer Maria Rilke. Die Weise von Liebe und Tod. Texte und Dokumente (Frankfurt, 1974).Google Scholar On Rilke's noble self-understanding, see Simenauer, Erich, Rainer Maria Rilke. Legende und Mythos (Frankfurt, 1953), 383–414.Google Scholar
31 For the literary and cultural context of Der Gral, see Leroy, Robert, “Der Gral. Aus den Anfängen einer katholischen Literaturzeitschrift,” Tijdschrift voor Levende/Revue des Langues Vivantes 25, no. 1 (1979): 29–53.Google Scholar
32 McGrath, William J., Dionysian Art and Populist Politics in Austria (New Haven, Conn., 1974), 98–99.Google Scholar
33 Doppler, Bernhard, “‘Ich habe diesen Krieg immer sozusagen als meinen Krieg angesehen’. Der katholische Kulturkritiker Richard von Kralik (1852–1934)Google Scholar,” in Österreich und der groβe Krieg, ed. Amann and Lengauer, 97.Google Scholar
34 Schaukal, , Ausgewählte Gedichte, 40Google Scholar: “Higher workings silently disposed / Enemies frankly shown the colors / Noble goal in the distance. / Hold my eyes and heart open, / Lord, my God, and let me learn / From pain as from pleasure!”
35 Bourdieu, Pierre, The Logic of Practice, trans. Nice, Richard (Cambridge, Eng., 1990), 70.Google Scholar
36 See Mosse, George L., Nationalism and Sexuality: Respectability and Abnormal Sexuality in Modern Europe (Madison, 1985)Google Scholar, and Mosse, , The Image of Man: The Creation of Modern Masculinity, Studies in the History of Sexuality Series (New York, 1996).Google Scholar
37 Procházka, Arnošt, Literární siluety a Studie (1905; reprint, Prague, 1912), 93.Google Scholar
38 Schaukal, Richard, Sehnsucht (Munich, 1900), 17Google Scholar: “Armored I ride from you, locking behind me / the gates, / the morning heralds its red return. / Watches me from its distant gazing gallery, / the first arrows of the sun hit my naked shield.”
39 Schaukal, , Ausgewählte Gedichte, 83Google Scholar: “His helmet bears a smooth edge / his armor is of black steel / his horse has eyes like rubies / his look shot through me like a ray.”
40 Ibid., 80: “Oh, if only I were already riding in battle vestments / to win for myself a fair wife.”
41 Schaukal, Richard, Leben und Meinungen des Herrn Andreas von Balthesser eines Dandy und Dilettanten (Munich, 1907), 25, 98.Google Scholar
42 Herzog, Wilhelm, review of Leben und Meinungen des Herrn Andreas von BalthesserGoogle Scholar, by Schaukal, Richard, Neue Revue 1 (1908): 839–4.Google Scholar
43 Poppenberg, Felix, review of Leben und Meinungen des Herrn Andreas von BalthesserGoogle Scholar, by Schaukal, Richard, Neue Deutsche Rundschau 18 (1907): 1015.Google Scholar
44 Hegel, G. W. F., The Philosophy of Fine Art, trans. Osmaston, F. P. B., 4 vols. (1920; reprint, New York, 1975), 2:335; emphasis in original.Google Scholar
45 Blei, Franz, “Drei Briefe an einen jungen Mann,” Hyperion 1 (2 vols.) (1907), 2:88.Google Scholar
46 Schaukal, , Leben und Meinungen des Herrn Andreas von Balthesser, 143.Google Scholar
47 Pynsent, Robert B., Questions of Identity: Czech and Slovak Ideas of Nationality and Personality (London, 1994), 108.Google Scholar
48 Blei, , “Drei Briefe,” 88.Google Scholar
49 Quoted in Handler, Andrew, Dori: The Life and Times of Theodor Herzl in Budapest (1860–1878) (University, Ala., 1983), 42.Google Scholar For a study of Herzl suggesting that those talks on the street did not last long and that the sexuality of Herzl, in fact, had something in common with that of the woman-hating dandy, see Loewenberg, Peter, “Theodor Herzl: Nationalism and Politics,” in Decoding the Past (New York, 1983), 101–35.Google Scholar
50 Auernheimer, Raoul, “Beard of the Prophet,” Herzl Year Book 6 (1964–1965): 76.Google Scholar
51 Goldhammer, Leo, “Theodor Herzl and Sigmund Freud,” Theodor Herzl Jahrbuch (Vienna), 1937, 268.Google Scholar For a more recent perspective, see Falk, Avner, “Freud and Herzl,” Midstream 23, no. 1 (1977): 3–24.Google ScholarPubMed
52 Zweig, Stefan, “King of the Jews,” Herzl Year Book 3 (1960): 110.Google Scholar
53 Zweig, Arnold, “The Emergence of Theodor Herzl,” in Theodor Herzl: A Memorial, ed. Weisgal, Meyer W. (New York, 1929), 298.Google Scholar
54 See Berkowitz, Michael, Zionist Culture and West European Jewry before the First World War (Cambridge, Eng., 1993), 135.Google Scholar
55 Prestel, Claudia T., “Frauen und die Zionistische Bewegung (1897–1933). Tradition oder Revolution?” Historische Zeitschrift 258 (1994): 68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
56 Elon, Amos, Herzl (New York, 1975)Google Scholar; Pawel, Ernst, The Labyrinth of Exile: A Life of Theodor Herzl (New York, 1989)Google Scholar; Stewart, Desmond, Theodor Herzl: Artist and Politician (New York, 1974).Google Scholar
57 Herzl, , Briefe und Tagebücher, 1:159.Google Scholar
58 Beller, Steven, Herzl, Jewish Thinkers Series (New York, 1991), 10. See also 71–74.Google Scholar
59 Beller, Steven, Vienna and the Jews, 1867–1938: A Cultural History (Cambridge, Eng., 1989), 185–86.Google Scholar
60 The reception of Oscar Wilde in Austria is a complex one. For a view of “Wilde's iconographic role among the German-Jewish avant-garde as the essential outsider,” read Gilman, Sander, “Opera, Homosexuality, and Models of Disease: Richard Strauss's Salome in the Context of Images of Disease in the Fin de Siècle,” in Disease and Representation: Images of Illness from Madness to AIDS (Ithaca, N.Y., 1988), 155–81.Google Scholar
61 On the “neglected facet of the Jewish experience: assimilation with the upper classes, particularly the nobility,” see Godsey, William D. Jr., “The Nobility, Jewish Assimilation, and the Austro-Hungarian Foreign Service in the Late Imperial Era,” Austrian History Yearbook 27 (1996): 155–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
62 See McCagg, William O. Jr., Jewish Nobles and Geniuses in Modern Hungary (Boulder, Colo., 1972).Google Scholar
63 Recent research has credited the significant Jewish engagement in the uprisings of 1848 with the later rapid assimilation of Jews to Viennese modes of behavior; see McCagg, William O. Jr., A History of Habsburg Jews, 1670–1918 (Bloomington, Ind., 1989), 96–97Google Scholar; and Wistrich, Robert, The Jews of Vienna in the Age of Franz Joseph (Oxford, 1989), 29–37.Google Scholar
64 Wassermann, Jakob, Mein Weg als Deutscher und Jude (Berlin, 1921), 102–3.Google Scholar The translation is based on that of Brainin, S. N. (My Life as a German and Jew [New York, 1933], 186–87).Google Scholar
65 Kraus, Karl, “Eine Krone für Zion,” Frühe Schriften, ed. Braakenburg, Joh. J., 2 vols. (Munich, 1979), 2:312.Google Scholar
66 On Kraus's “unconditional belief in assimilation,” see Wistrich, Robert, “Karl Kraus: Jewish Prophet or Renegade?” European Judaism 9, no. 2 (1975): 34.Google Scholar For a recent restatement, see Rider, Jacques Le, Modernity and Crises of Identity: Culture and Society in Fin-de-Siècle Vienna, trans. Morris, Rosemary (Cambridge, Eng., 1993), 254.Google Scholar
67 Kraus, Karl, Die Fackel 1 (1899): 32.Google Scholar
68 Rossbacher, Karlheinz, Literatur und Liberalismus. Zur Kultur der Ringstraβenzeit in Wien (Vienna, 1992), 135–36, 417–18.Google Scholar
69 On the role of the aristocracy in Schnitzler, see Schwarz, Egon, “Arthur Schnitzler und die Aristokratie,” in Arthur Schnitzler in neuer Sicht, ed. Scheible, Hartmut (Munich, 1981), 54–70.Google Scholar
70 Schnitzler, Arthur, Der Weg ins Freie, vol. 4 of Das erzählerische Werk (Frankfurt, 1978), 14–16.Google Scholar
71 Herzl, Theodor, Der Judenstaat. Theodor Herzl oder der Moses des Fin de Siècle, ed. Dethloff, Klaus (Vienna, 1986), 186–259.Google Scholar
72 Herzl, , Briefe und Tagebücher, 2: 225.Google Scholar
73 Kurrein, Adolf, Dr. Herd's Grab. Nachruf, gehalten von Dr. Ad. Kurrein (Brünn, 1904?); emphasis in original.Google Scholar
74 Herzl, , Briefe und Tagebücher, 2:70, 128.Google Scholar
75 Gilman, Sander, Jewish Self-Hatred (Ithaca, N.Y., 1986), 239.Google Scholar
76 Herzl, , Briefe und Tagebücher, 2:77; see also 94.Google Scholar
77 Boyer, John W., Political Radicalism in Late Imperial Vienna (Chicago, 1981), 235.Google Scholar
78 Beller, , Herzl, 36Google Scholar; see also Herzl, , Briefe und Tagebücher, 2:92.Google Scholar
79 Schorske, Carl E., Fin-de-Siècle Vienna: Politics and Culture (New York, 1981), 148.Google Scholar
80 See Gilman, , Jewish Self-HatredGoogle Scholar; see also Robertson, Ritchie, “The Problem of ‘Jewish Self-Hatred’ in Herzl, Kraus and Kafka,” Oxford German Studies 16 (1985): 86–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
81 Quoted in Gaisbauer, Adolf, Davidstern und Doppeladler. Zionismus und jüdischer Nationalismus in Österreich 1882–1918 (Vienna, 1988), 424–25.Google Scholar
82 von Doderer, Heimito, Die Strudlhofstiege oder Melzer und die Tiefe der Jahre (1951; reprint, Vienna, 1993), 260–61Google Scholar: “Sie haben etwas sehr Stoßkräftiges, diese Genicke, sie erinnern durch ihre rasierte Glätte an ein Knie, in der Funktion dem bewußten Ellenbogen nicht unverwandt.… Mitunter geschieht das jedoch erst, wenn sie einem den Rücken drehen (was sie gut können), und da erkennt man's erst recht, mit wem man es zu tun hatte—wenn man das Genick sieht: ach so, aha.… Aber hierin liegt eben der Kniff und Trick jener Genickler: man sieht ihr eigentliches Gesicht erst, wenn sie sich abgewandt haben, also zu spät, jedenfalls beim ersten Zusammentreffen viel zu spät und wenn es schon vorbei ist. Sie tragen ihr Gesicht rückwärts.”
83 Herzl, , Briefe und Tagebücher, 2:539.Google Scholar For a perspective on this episode that emphasizes Herzl's state-building aspirations, see Beller, Steven, “Herzl's Tannhäuser: The Redemption of Artist as Politician,” in Austrians and Jews in the Twentieth Century: From Franz Joseph to Waldheim, ed. Wistrich, Robert S. (New York, 1992), 38–57.Google Scholar
84 Schaukal, , Vom Geschmack, 171.Google Scholar
85 The relationship between the conceptual pair “aesthetic culture” and “aristocratic culture” is in dire need of mediation and investigation in the work of Carl Schorske. Aristocratic behavior seems to be synonymous with a mostly vague kind of aesthetic refinement, yet, in the case of Schaukal and Herzl here, refinement is precisely an energetic and forceful response; Schorske, , Fin-de-Siècle Vienna.Google Scholar
86 Barea, Ilsa, Vienna (New York, 1966), 321.Google Scholar
87 Redlich, Josef, Schicksalsjahre Österreichs 1908–1919. Das politische Tagebuch Josef Redlichs, ed. Fellner, Fritz, 2 vols. (Graz, 1953), 2:27.Google Scholar
88 It should be noted that Herzl did, at times, profess admiration for the figure of the Prussian nobleman. That the fiercely self-reliant, rural, and pious Junker embodied the practical aspirations of the cosmopolitan Herzl is, however, doubtful. Indeed, as Max Weber used to argue, it was precisely due to Junker forms of socialibility that, in contrast to their German-Austrian neighbors, Germans had never been fully formed as aristocrats. Weber, Max, Gesamtausgabe, vol. 15Google Scholar: Zur Politik im Weltkrieg. Schriften und Reden 1914–1918, ed. Mommsen, Wolfgang J. (Tübingen, 1984), pt. 1, 347–96.Google Scholar For more on Herzl's understanding of the aristocrat, see the important recent work of Kornberg, Jacques, Theodor Herzl: From Assimilation to Zionism (Bloomington, Ind., 1993).Google Scholar
89 Herzl, Theodor, Das neue GhettoGoogle Scholar, in Der Judenstaat, ed. Dethloff, 94–155. See also Herzl, Theodor, “Compagniearbeit. Lustspiel in einem Act,” Wallishausser'scher Theater-Katalog 10 (1880): 26.Google Scholar
90 Mosse, , The Image of Man, 63.Google Scholar