Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-15T07:25:56.221Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Strategic Use of Human Rights Treaties in Hong Kong’s Cage-Home Crisis: No Way Out?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 February 2016

Luke MARSH
Luke MARSH*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Law, Chinese University of Hong Kong
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Using a socioeconomic rights framework, this article will evaluate government policy relating to housing welfare in Hong Kong. In particular, it will explore the alarming plight of cage tenants in Hong Kong, a highly marginalized group estimated to be as many as 200,000 in number, who live day to day in cramped, dank dwellings averaging 15 square feet in size. It will argue that current government policies are incompatible with the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). It will further look at strategies for domesticating these international human rights treaties. In doing so, this article will contribute to the ongoing debate concerning the legal nature of socioeconomic rights.

Keywords

ICESCRICCPRright to housinginhumane and degrading treatmentcage-homes
Type
Research Article
Information
Asian Journal of Law and Society , Volume 3 , Issue 1 , May 2016 , pp. 159 - 188
Copyright
© Cambridge University Press and KoGuan Law School, Shanghai Jiao Tong University 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

Assistant Professor, Faculty of Law, Chinese University of Hong Kong and Associate Director (Social Justice Programme), Centre for Rights and Justice. I am grateful to Professor Margaret Bedggood and the anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments on an earlier draft of this article, to which the usual disclaimers apply. Correspondence to Luke Marsh, Room 528, Faculty of Law, 5/F, Lee Shau Kee Building, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Sha Tin, NT, Hong Kong SAR. E-mail address: [email protected].

References

REFERENCES

Akandji-Kombe, Jean-Francois (2007) “Positive Obligations under the ECHR,” Human Rights Handbook No. 7, online <http://www.echr.coe.int/LibraryDocs/DG2/HRHAND/DG2-EN-HRHAND-07%282007%29.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Altman, Irwin (1975) The Environment and Social Behaviour, Monterey, CA: Wadsworth.Google Scholar
Amos, Merris (2014) Human Rights Law, 2nd edn, Oxford: Hart.Google Scholar
CESCR (2001a) “Concluding Observations of the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (Hong Kong) China.” UN Doc. E/C.12/1/Add.58, 21 May.Google Scholar
CESCR (2001b) “Statement on Poverty and the ICESCR.” UN Doc. E/C.12/2001/10, 4 May.Google Scholar
CESCR (2004) “Concluding Observations of the CESCR: Denmark.” UN Doc. E/C.12/1/Add.102, 14 December.Google Scholar
CESCR (2014) “Concluding Observations on the 2nd Periodic Report of China, including Hong Kong, China, & Macao, China.” UN Doc. E/C.12/CHN/CO/2, 13 June.Google Scholar
CESCR General Comment No. 4 (1992) “The Right to Adequate Housing (Art 11(1) of the Covenant).” E.1992/23, 13 December 1991.Google Scholar
CESCR General Comment No. 3 (1994) “The Nature of States Parties Obligations (Art. 2, para. 1).” E/1991/23, 14 December 1990; 1–1 IHRR 6.Google Scholar
CESCR General Comment No. 7 (1997) E/1996/22, 20 May.Google Scholar
CESCR General Comment No. 19 (2008) “The Right to Social Security (Art 9).” E/C.12/GC/19, (04/02/2008); 15 IHRR 605.Google Scholar
CESCR General Comment No. 9 (2009) “The Domestic Application of the Covenant.” E/C12/1998/24, 3 December 1998; 6 IHRR 289.Google Scholar
Chan, Cora (2010) “Judicial Deference at Work: Some Reflections on Chan Kin Sum and Kong Yun Ming.” 40 Hong Kong Law Journal 1–14.Google Scholar
Chen, Albert (2014) ““A Stroke of Genius” in Kong Yunming.” 44 Hong Kong Law Journal 17–24.Google Scholar
Cheung, Siu-keung (2000) “Speaking Out: Days in the Lives of Three Hong Kong Cage Dwellers.” East Asia Cultures Critique, 8 Duke University Press 1 Spring 235–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chief Executive’s Spokesman (2013) Government Information Service, 30 January.Google Scholar
Chinese University of Hong Kong (2014) Hong Kong Quality of Life Index, Hong Kong Institute of Asia-Pacific Studies, Centre for Quality of Life, August, online <http://www.cuhk.edu.hk/hkiaps/qol/eventdoc/QoL%20report/QoL%202013%20report_eng.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Chun-yuen, Barry Cheung (2010–11) “Urban Renewal Authority: New Strategy New Focus for Urban Renewal. Annual Report,” online <http://www.ura.org.hk/media/578181/ura_annual_report_2010-2011_english_edition_low_resolution.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Clements, Luke, & Simmons, Alan (2008) “European Court of Human Rights,” in M. Langford, ed., Social Rights Jurisprudence: Emerging Trends in International and Comparative Law, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 409–427.Google Scholar
Crawford, James (2012) Brownlie’s Principles of Public International Law, 8th edn, Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Demographia (2015) “11th Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey,” online <http://www.demographia.com/dhi.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Dwan, Daniel, Sawicki, Meghan& Wong, Jeffrey (2013) Subdivided Housing Issues of Hong Kong: Causes and Solutions, Hong Kong: Hong Kong Institute of Education, online <https://www.wpi.edu/Pubs/E-project/Available/E-project-022713-213142/unrestricted/Subdivided_Housing_Issues_of_Hong_Kong_Causes_and_Solutions.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
FlorCruz, Michelle (2012) “Hong Kong’s ‘Shoebox’ Apartments: Slums, but More Expensive than New York.” 5 International Business Times 16–18.Google Scholar
Freeman, Johnathon (1975) Crowding and Behaviour, San Francisco, CA: W.H. Freeman.Google Scholar
Fuller, Lon (1978) “The Forms and Limits of Adjudication.” 92 Harvard Law Review 353–409.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goodstadt, Leo (2013) Poverty in the Midst of Affluence: How Hong Kong Mismanaged Its Prosperity, Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
HKSAR Government (2003) “Second Report of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People’s Republic of China in the Light of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights,” online <http://www.cmab.gov.hk/en/issues/culturalrights_report.htm> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
HKSAR Government (2015a) “2015 Policy Address by Chief Executive,” online <http://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201501/14/P201501140485.htm> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
HKSAR Government (2015b) “CSSA Rent Allowance (Annex),” online <http://gia.info.gov.hk/general/201501/29/P201501290330_0330_141364.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
HKSAR Government, Development Bureau (2010) “Legislative Council Panel on Development Subcommittee on Building Safety and Related Issues: Measures to Enhance Building Safety in Hong Kong,” Annex: “Legislative Council Brief Measures to Enhance Building Safety in Hong Kong. File Ref: DEVB (PL-CR) 12/2010,” CB(1)681/10–11(01), December.Google Scholar
HKSAR Government, Economy (2012) “Half Yearly Economic Report 2012,” online <http://www.hkeconomy.gov.hk/en/pdf/box-12q2-5-2.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
HKSAR Government, Financial Secretary’s Office (2013) “Hong Kong Poverty Situation Report 2012.” Census and Statistics Department, Economic Analysis Division, Economic Analysis and Business Facilitation Unit, September.Google Scholar
HKSAR Government, Housing Authority (2015) “Housing in Figures - 2015,” online, <https://www.housingauthority.gov.hk/en/common/pdf/about-us/publications-and-statistics/HIF.pdf> (last accessed 24 January 2016).+(last+accessed+24+January+2016).>Google Scholar
HKSAR Government, Housing Department (2015) “Allocation Status,” online <http://www.housingauthority.gov.hk/en/flat-application/allocation-status> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
HKSAR Government, Labour and Welfare Bureau (2009) “Legislative Council Panel on Welfare Services: Definition of Poverty.” CB(2)179/09–10(07), November.Google Scholar
HKSAR Government, Social Welfare Department (2015) “Comprehensive Social Security Assistance (CSSA) Scheme,” online <http://www.swd.gov.hk/en/index/site_pubsvc/page_socsecu/sub_comprehens/> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
HKSAR Government, Transport and Housing Bureau (2014) “Long Term Housing Strategy December 2014,” online <http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr14-15/english/panels/hg/papers/hg20150105cb1-352-1-e.pdf> (last accessed 24 January 2015).+(last+accessed+24+January+2015).>Google Scholar
Hodgson Impey Cheng, (2015) “Hong Kong Budget Summary 2015/16,” online <http://www.hic.com.hk/eBulletin/tax/budget2015-16/budget.html> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Hohmann, Jessie (2013) The Right to Housing: Law, Concepts, Possibilities, Oxford: Hart.Google Scholar
Hong Kong Committee on Children’s Rights (2012) “NGO Report of HKSAR under the Convention on the Rights of the Child.” Hong Kong, November.Google Scholar
Hong Kong Council of Social Service (2012) “Poverty—Recommendations,” online <http://www.hkcss.org.hk/e/cont_detail.asp?type_id=10&content_id=228> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Jain, Uday (1987) The Psychological Consequences of Crowding, London: Sage.Google Scholar
Kenna, Padraic (2010) “International Instruments on Housing Rights.” 2 Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction 11–20.Google Scholar
Koch, Ida Elizabeth (2009) Human Rights as Indivisible Rights: The Protection of Socio-Economic Demands under the European Convention on Human Rights, International Studies in Human Rights, Volume 101, Leiden, NLD: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.Google Scholar
Kong, Karen (2012) “Adjudicating Social Welfare Rights in Hong Kong.” 10 International Journal of Constitutional Law 588–599.Google Scholar
Kong, Karen (2014) “Kong Yunming v Director of Social Welfare: Implications for Law and Policy.” 44 Hong Kong Law Journal 67–82.Google Scholar
Kong, Karen (2015) “Refugees’ Right to Work in Hong Kong—or Lack Thereof: GA v Director of Immigration.” 14 Oxford University Commonwealth Law Journal 337–348.Google Scholar
Kong, Karen, & Hong Kong Bar Association (2014) “Top Issues of Concerns of Hong Kong SAR NGOs,” 7 May, online <http://www.hkhrm.org.hk/resource/NGO_Top_Issues_ICESCR_7MAY2014.docx> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Lai, Ying-kit (2014) “CY Leung Says He ‘Regrets’ Controversial Remarks about Low-Income Voters,” South China Morning Post, 28 October.Google Scholar
Langford, Malcolm, & King, Jeff (2008) “Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Past, Present and Future,” in M. Langford, ed., Social Rights Jurisprudence: Emerging Trends in International and Comparative Law, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 477–516.Google Scholar
Legislative Council (2008) “Report on the Subcommittee on Review of the Comprehensive Social Security Assistance Scheme to Panel on Welfare Services Meeting on 14 January 2008,” LP Paper No. CB(2)778/07–08, online <http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr07-08/english/panels/ws/ws_cssa/reports/ws_cssacb2-778-e.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Legislative Council (2013–14) “Paper No CB(2)217/13–14(03),” (in Chinese) online <http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr13-14/chinese/panels/ws/papers/ws1111cb2-217-3-c.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Legislative Council (2014–15) “Paper No CB(2)213/14–15(07),” (in Chinese) online <http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr14-15/chinese/panels/ws/papers/ws20141110cb2-213-7-c.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Legislative Council Panel on Welfare Services (1999) “Report on Housing Standards of Private Dwellings,” LC Paper No. CB(2) 1430/13–14(03), 29 June.Google Scholar
Legislative Council Secretariat (2012–13) “Sub-Divided Flats in Hong Kong,” online <http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr12-13/english/sec/library/1213in22-e.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Lehmann, Karin (2006) “In Defense of the Constitutional Court: Litigating Socio-Economic Rights and the Myth of the Minimum Core.” 22 American University International Law Review 163–197.Google Scholar
Leung, Chun-ying (2012) Government Information Service, 19 June.Google Scholar
Leung, Chun-ying (2013) “Chief Executive’s 2013 Policy Address,” online <http://www.policyaddress.gov.hk/2013/eng/pdf/PA2013.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Li, Joseph (2015) “Hong Kong Prepares for an Aging Society,” China Daily, 2 February.Google Scholar
Limburg Principles (1997) “The Limburg Principles on the Implementation of the International Covenant on Economic Social, and Cultural Rights.” E/CN.4.1987/17/17, 8 January.Google Scholar
LSE (2011) “Hong Kong’s Housing Shame,” in Cities, Health and Well-Being, London: London School of Economics, November, online <http://lsecities.net/files/2011/11/2011_chw_5010_SoCO.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Mason, Sir Anthony (2007) “The Place of Comparative Law in Developing the Jurisprudence on the Rule of Law and Human Rights in Hong Kong.” 37 Hong Kong Law Journal 299–317.Google Scholar
Minkler, Lanse, & Sweeney, Shawna (2011) “On the Indivisibility and Interdependence of Basic Rights in Developing Countries.” 33 Human Rights Quarterly 351–396.Google Scholar
Müller, Amrei (2013) The Relationship between Economic Social and Cultural Rights and International Humanitarian Law, an Analysis of Health-Related Issues in Non-International Armed Conflict, Nottingham: Nottingham Studies on Human Rights.Google Scholar
Ngo, Jennifer (2015) “One in Three Elderly Hongkongers Living in Poverty Despite Slight Overall Drop in Number of Poor,” South China Morning Post, 10 October.Google Scholar
Ngo, Jennifer, & Cheung, Simpson (2012) “Welfare Recipient Bids for Judicial Review over ‘Inadequate’ Rent Subsidy,” South China Morning Post, 8 September.Google Scholar
Oxfam (2014) Study on the Basic Cost of Living and the Poverty Line, Hong Kong: Oxfam, June.Google Scholar
Petersen, Carole (2007) “Embracing Universal Standards? The Role of International Human Rights Treaties in Hong Kong’s Constitutional Jurisprudence,” in F. Hualing, L. Harris, & S. Young, eds., Interpreting Hong Kong’s Basic Law: The Struggle for Coherence, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 33–53.Google Scholar
Policy 21 Limited (2013) “Survey on Subdivided Units in Hong Kong,” online <http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr12-13/english/panels/hg/hg_lths/papers/hg_lths0626cb1-1371-3-e.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Ramsden, Michael (2010) “Using the ICESCR in Hong Kong Courts.” 42 Hong Kong Law Journal 839–864.Google Scholar
Ramsden, Michael, & Marsh, Luke (2013) “The ‘Right to Work’ of Refugees in Hong Kong: MA v Director of Immigration.” 25 International Journal of Refugee Law 574–596.Google Scholar
Ramsden, Michael, & Marsh, Luke (2014a) “Paper for Special Meeting of the Legislative Council Panel on Welfare Services on 13 January 2014,” online <http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr13-14/english/panels/ws/papers/ws0113cb2-663-1-e.pdf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Ramsden, Michael, & Marsh, Luke (2014b) Refugees in Hong Kong: Developing the Legal Framework for Socio-Economic Rights Protection.” 14 Human Rights Law Review 267–299.Google Scholar
Ramsden, Michael, & Hargreaves, Stuart (2015) The Hong Kong Basic Law Handbook, Hong Kong: Sweet & Maxwell.Google Scholar
Salomon, Margot (2013) “Deprivation, Causation and the Law of International Cooperation,” in M. Langford, W. Vandenhole, M. Scheinin, & W. Van Genugten, eds., Global Justice, State Duties, New York: Cambridge University Press, 259–296.Google Scholar
Saul, Ben, Kinley, David& Mowbray, Jacqueline (2014) The ICESCR, Commentary, Cases and Materials, Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Saunders, Peter, Wong, Hung& Pin Wong, Wo (2014) “Deprivation and Poverty in Hong Kong.” 48 Social Policy & Administration 556–575.Google Scholar
Shue, Henry (1996) Basic Rights: Subsistence, Affluence and US Foreign Policy, 2nd edn, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Society of Community Organisation (SoCO) (2013) “Research Report on Cage Homes, Cubicles, and Sub-Divided Flats 2012–13.” Hong Kong, 1 September.Google Scholar
Tsang, Donald (2001) Government Information Service, 3 September.Google Scholar
Tsang, Donald (2001, 2005, 2006, 2009) Hong Kong Hansard, 24 October; 27 June; 12 January; 14 October 2009.Google Scholar
Tung, Chee-hwa (1997) Government Information Service, 12 September.Google Scholar
Tung, Chee-hwa (2004) Hong Kong Hansard, 7 January.Google Scholar
United Nations (2010) “Human Development Report.” UN Development Programme.Google Scholar
United Nations OHCR (2008) “Markets Alone Cannot Ensure Housing for All, UN Expert Says,” online <http://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=8464&LangID=E#sthash.Bp78qNe0.dpuf> (last accessed 17 November 2015).+(last+accessed+17+November+2015).>Google Scholar
Waldron, Jeremy (2010) “Inhuman and Degrading Treatment: The Words Themselves.” 23 Canadian Journal of Law & Jurisprudence 269–286.Google Scholar
Wassener, Bettina, & Tsoi, Grace (2013) “Stacked in Hovels out of Hong Kong Light,” International Herald Tribune, 27 September.Google Scholar
Xie, Andy (2014) “Stability Will Only Return when Hong Kong Ends Its Property Tyranny,” South China Morning Post, 14 October.Google Scholar
Young, Katherine (2008) “The Minimum Core of Economic and Social Rights: A Concept in Search of Content.” 32 Yale Journal of International Law 113–175.Google Scholar
Yung, Betty, & Lee, Fung-Ping (2012) “Right to Housing in Hong Kong: Perspectives from the Hong Kong Community.” 1 Housing, Theory and Society 401–419.Google Scholar

CASE-LAW

Hong KongGoogle Scholar
Chan Mei Yee v. Director of Immigrati on (unrep., HCAL 77 and 99/1999, [2000] HKEC 788).Google Scholar
Chan To Foon and Others v. Director of Immigration and Another HCAL 58 [1998].Google Scholar
GA v. Director of Immigration [2014] 17 HKCFAR 60.Google Scholar
Ho Choi Wan v. Hong Kong Housing Authority [2005] 4 HKLRD 706.Google Scholar
Kong Yunming v. Director of Social Welfare [2012] 4 HKC 180.Google Scholar
Kong Yunming v. Director of Social Welfare [2013] HKCU 2878.Google Scholar
MA v. Director of Immigration [2011] 2 HKLRD F6.Google Scholar
MA v. Director of Immigration [2012] HKCA; HKEC 1624.Google Scholar
Mok Chi Hung v. Director of Immigration HCAL No. 371 [2000].Google Scholar
Suen Mo Joel v. Director of Social Welfare HCAL 117/2012.Google Scholar
Ubamaka v. Director of Immigration [2011] 1 HKLRD 359.Google Scholar
Ubamaka v. Secretary for Security [2013] 2 HKC 75.Google Scholar
InternationalGoogle Scholar
East African Asians v. UK (1973) 3 EHRR 76.Google Scholar
Francine Van Volsem v. Belgium Application no. 14641/89.Google Scholar
Gezer v. Secretary for State for the Home Department [2004] EWCA Civ 1730; [2005] HRLR 7.Google Scholar
Grant v. Ministry of Justice [2011] EWHC 3379 (QB).Google Scholar
In re E (a child) [2008] UKHL 66, [2009] 1 AC 536.Google Scholar
Ireland v. UK Application no. 5310/71.Google Scholar
Khosa v. Minister of Social Development [2004] 6 SA 505 (CC).Google Scholar
Kay v. Lambeth London Borough Council [2006] UKHL 10; [2006] 2 AC 465.Google Scholar
Larioshina v. Russia Application no. 5686900.Google Scholar
Lee v. Leeds City Council [2002] EWCA Civ 6; [2002] 1 WLR 1488.Google Scholar
Lorse v. Netherlands (2003) 37 EHRR 3.Google Scholar
O’Rourke v. United Kingdom (2001)).Google Scholar
Pancenco v. Latvia 28 October 1999 (inadmissibility decision).Google Scholar
Pretty v. United Kingdom (2002) 35 EHRR 1.Google Scholar
R (Adam) v. Secretary of State for the Home Department [2004]; [2005] 3 All ER 29.Google Scholar
R (B) v. Responsible Medical Officer, Broadmoor Hospital [2005] EWHC (Admin) 1936.Google Scholar
R (Limbuela) v. Secretary of State for the Home Department [2006] 1 AC 396.Google Scholar
R (M) v. Secretary of State for the Home Department [2010] EWHC 3541 (Admin).Google Scholar
R (on the application of Bernard) v. London Borough of Enfield [2002] EWHC (Admin) 2282; [2003] HRLR 4.Google Scholar
R (Pretty) v. Director of Public Prosecutions [2001] UKHL 61; [2001] 3 WLR 1598.Google Scholar
R (Q) v. Secretary of State for the Home Department [2003] EWCA Civ 364; [2004] QB 36, 60 (Q [2003]).Google Scholar
R (Q) v. Secretary of State for the Home Department [2003] 2 All ER 905; [2004] QB 36.Google Scholar
R (T) v. Secretary of State for the Home Department [2003] EWCA Civ 1285; [2003] UKHRR 1321; [2004] HLR 254.Google Scholar
R v. Drew [2003] UKHL 25; [2003] 1 WLR 1213.Google Scholar
R v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Adam [2006] 1 AC 396.Google Scholar
Republic of South Africa v. Grootboom and Others 2000 (11) BCLR 1169 (CC).Google Scholar
Soering v. UK Application no. 14038/88, 7 July 1989.Google Scholar
Tyrer v. United Kingdom Judgment of 25 April 1978.Google Scholar