Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7fkt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T22:19:56.830Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Sculpture, Dates and Patrons: Dating the Herefordshire School of Sculpture

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 April 2011

John Hunt
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The origins of the Herefordshire School of Sculpture have traditionally been associated with Shobdon Priory, although both Leominster Priory and Kilpeck Church have also been suggested. This paper proposes that the origins of the Herefordshire School should be sought elsewhere, most probably in Hereford Cathedral. Recent studies tend to date the activity of the Herefordshire School earlier than was previously supposed, but it is here argued that these principal monuments of the School are actually later in date than the revisions suggest and that the Herefordshire School of Sculpture was active for around thirty years, into the early 1160s. The importance of lay patronage is confirmed, but scope for the influence of churchmen in the promotion of the School is also proposed. Some of the schemes adopted may have served to convey messages intended to help the church protect itself and its possessions in the turbulent times of the Anarchy.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 84 , September 2004 , pp. 185 - 222
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2004

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alexander, J J G 1993. ‘Ideological representation of military combat in Anglo-Norman art’, Anglo-Norman Stud, 15 (1992), 1–24Google Scholar
Barrow, J (ed) 1993. English Episcopal Ada VII. Hereford 1079–1234, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Besson, F M 1987. ‘À armes égales: une répresentation de la violence en France et en Espagne au XIIe siècle’, Gesta, 26/2113–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blair, J (ed) 1988. Minsters and Parish Churches. The Local Church in Transition 950–1200, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Brown, D L and Wilson, D 1994. ‘Leominster Old Priory: recording of standing buildings and excavations 1979–80’, Archaeol J, 151, 307–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Capes, W W (ed) 1908. Charters and Records of Hereford Cathedral, Cantilupe Society, 20, HerefordGoogle Scholar
Chibnall, M (ed) 1972. The Ecclesiastical History of Orderic Vitalis, III, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Chibnall, M (ed) 1978. The Ecclesiastical History of Orderic Vitalis, VI, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Chwojko, E and Thurlby, M 1997. ‘Gloucester and the Herefordshire School’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 150, 17–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Colvin, H M (ed) 1963. The History of the King's Works. Vol II: The Middle Ages, LondonGoogle Scholar
Coplestone-Crow, B 1979–1981. ‘The Baskervilles of Herefordshire, 1086–1300’, Trans Woolhope Natur Fld Club, 43, 18–39Google Scholar
Coplestone-Crow, B 1995. ‘The Herefordshire School’, The Worcester Area: Proceedings of the 151st Summer Meeting of the Royal Archaeological Institute (ed Pounds, N J G), 12–14, LondonGoogle Scholar
Cownie, E 1998. Religious Patronage in Anglo-Norman England 1066–1135, LondonGoogle Scholar
Crouch, D 1986. The Beaumont Twins. The Roots and Branches of Power in the Twelfth Century, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crouch, D 1990. William Marshal. Court, Career and Chivalry in the Angevin Empire 1147–1219, LondonGoogle Scholar
Crouch, D 1992. The Image of Aristocracy in Britain 1000–1300, LondonGoogle Scholar
Davis, R H C 1962. ‘Treaty between William Earl of Gloucester and Roger Earl of Hereford’, in A Medieval Miscellany for Doris Mary Stenton (eds Barnes, P M and Slade, C F), Pipe Roll Society, new ser, 36, 139–46, LondonGoogle Scholar
Dickinson, J C and Ricketts, P T (eds) 1969. ‘The Anglo-Norman chronicle of Wigmore Abbey’, Trans Woolhope Natur Fld Club, 39, 413–46Google Scholar
Douglas, D C and Greenaway, G W (eds) 1981. English Historical Documents. Vol II: 1042–1189, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Dugdale, W 1849. Monasticon Anglicanum, LondonGoogle Scholar
Durliat, M 1986. Roussillon Roman, La Pierre-qui-VireGoogle Scholar
Galbraith, V H and Tait, J (eds) 1950. Herefordshire Domesday c.1160–1170, Pipe Roll Society, new ser, 25, LondonGoogle Scholar
Garmonsway, G N (ed) 1953. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, LondonGoogle Scholar
Geese, U 1997. ‘Romanesque sculpture’, in Romanesque (ed Toman, R), 256–345, CologneGoogle Scholar
Gem, R 1986. ‘The Bishop's Chapel at Hereford: the roles of patron and craftsman’, in Art and Patronage in the English Romanesque (eds Macready, S and Thompson, F H), Soc Antiq London Occas Pap 8, 87–96, LondonGoogle Scholar
Gensbeitel, C 1998. ‘Saint-Pierre-de-l'Isle; Eglise Saint-Pierre’, in La Sculpture Romane en Saintonge. L'imaginaire et lafoi (ed Lacoste, J), 288–90, SaintesGoogle Scholar
Gough, R (ed) 1806. Britannia: or a Chorographical Description of the Flourishing Kingdoms of England, Scotland and Ireland, and the Islands Adjacent; from the Earliest Antiquity, by William Camden, 4 vols, LondonGoogle Scholar
Greenway, D (ed) 1996. Henry, Archdeacon of Huntingdon. Historia Anglorum. The History of the English People, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Grivot, D and Zarnecki, G 1985. Gislebertus. Sculptor of Autun, New YorkGoogle Scholar
Grivot, D 1990. Twelfth Century Sculpture in the Cathedral of Autun, IngersheimGoogle Scholar
Hall, H (ed) 1896. Red Book of the Exchequer, 2 vols, LondonGoogle Scholar
Hamer, E R 1992. ‘Patronage and iconography in Romanesque England: the Herefordshire School in context’, unpublished PhD thesis, University of ChicagoGoogle Scholar
Harper-Bill, C 1979. ‘The piety of the Anglo-Norman knightly class’, Proc Battle Conf, 2, 62–77Google Scholar
Hart, W H (ed) 1863–1867. Historia et Cartularium: Monasterii Sancti Petri Gloucestriae, 3 vols, LondonGoogle Scholar
Hawley, Lt Col W, Montgomerie, D H and St John Hope, W H 1913. ‘Excavations at Old Sarum’, Proc Soc Antiq, 25, 93–104Google Scholar
Hawley, Lt Col W, Montgomerie, D H, and St John Hope, W H 1914. ‘Excavations at Old Sarum’, Proc Soc Antiq, 26, 100–19Google Scholar
Heslop, T A 1986. ‘Brief in words but heavy in the weight of its mysteries’, Art Hist, 9/1, 1–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hillaby, J and Boulton, R 1993. The Sculptured Capitals of Leominster Priory, LeominsterGoogle Scholar
Holdsworth, C 1994. ‘The Church’, in The Anarchy of King Stephen's Reign (ed King, E), 207–29, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hollister, C W 2001. Henry I, New Haven and LondonGoogle Scholar
Hunt, J 1994. ‘Piety, prestige or politics? The House of Leofric and the foundation and patronage of Coventry Priory’, in Coventry's First Cathedral. The Cathedral and Priory of St Mary. Papers from the 1993 Anniversary Symposium (ed Demidowicz, G), 97–117, StamfordGoogle Scholar
Hunt, J 1997. Lordship and the Landscape. A Documentary and Archaeological Study of the Honor of Dudley c 1066–1322, BAR, Brit Ser 264, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Hunt, J and Stokes, M A 1997. ‘Sculpture and patronage in a Shropshire manor: a group of 12th-century sculptures from Alveley’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 150, 27–47Google Scholar
Impey, E 1997. ‘The buildings on the motte at Kilpeck Castle, Herefordshire’, Archaeol Cambrensis, 146, 101–8Google Scholar
James, B S 1998. The Letters of St Bernard of Clairvaux, StroudGoogle Scholar
Jónsdóttir, S 1950. ‘The portal of Kilpeck Church: its place in English Romanesque sculpture’, Art Bull, 32, no. 3, 171–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kahn, D 1997. ‘La Chanson de Roland dans le décor des églises du Xlle siècle’, Cahiers de Civilisation medievale, 40, 337–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kauffman, M 1984. ‘Cambridge, Pembroke College MS 120; New Testament’, in Zarnecki et al. 1984, 97, no. 21Google Scholar
Keats-Rohan, K S B 1999. Domesday People. A Prosopography of Persons occurring in English Documents, 1066–1166. Vol I: Domesday Book, WoodbridgeGoogle Scholar
Kemp, B R 1968. ‘The monastic dean of Leominster’, Eng Hist Rev, 83, 505–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kemp, B R 1980. ‘Monastic possession of parish churches in England in the twelfth century’, J Eccl Hist, 31, 133–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kemp, B R (ed) 1986. Reading Abbey Cartularies, 2 vols, LondonGoogle Scholar
Kemp, B R 1988. ‘Some aspects of the parochia of Leominster in the twelfth century’, in Blair, (ed) 1988, 83–95Google Scholar
King, E 1799–1805. Munimenta antiqua; or, Observations on ancient castles. Including remarks on the whole progress of architecture, ecclesiastical, as well as military, in Great Britain, vol IV (1805), LondonGoogle Scholar
King, E 1984. ‘The anarchy of King Stephen's reign’, Trans Roy Hist Soc, 34, 133–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar
King, E and Potter, K R (eds) 1998. William of Malmesbury. Historia Novella. The Contemporary History, OxfordGoogle Scholar
King, J F 1990. ‘The Old Sarum master: a twelfth-century sculptor in south-west England’, Wiltshire Archaeol Natur Hist Mag, 83, 70–95Google Scholar
King, J F 1995. ‘The parish church at Kilpeck reassessed’, in Whitehead, (ed) 1995, 82–91Google Scholar
Maguire, H P 1970. ‘A twelfth-century workshop in Northampton’, Gesta, 9/1, 11–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McGurk, P (ed) 1998. The Chronicle of John of Worcester, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Morey, A and Brooke, C N L (eds) 1967. The Letters and Charters of Gilbert Foliot, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Mortimer, R 1986. ‘Land and service: the tenants of the Honor of Clare’, Anglo-Norman Stud, 8, 177–97Google Scholar
Patterson, R B (ed) 1973. Earldom of Gloucester Charters. The Charters and Scribes of the Earls and Countesses of Gloucester to AD 1217, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Petzold, A 1995. Romanesque Art, LondonGoogle Scholar
Pevsner, N 1963. Herefordshire, The Buildings of England, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Potter, K R (ed). 1955. The Historia Novella by William of Malmesbury, LondonGoogle Scholar
Potter, K R (ed) 1976. Gesta Stephani, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Preest, D (ed) 2002. William of Malmesbury. The Deeds of the Bishops of England (Gesta Pontificum Anglorum), WoodbridgeGoogle Scholar
RCHME 1939. ‘The parish church of St Mary, Iffley’, in City of Oxford, Roy Comm Hist Monuments Engl Inventories, 151–4, LondonGoogle Scholar
RCHME 1980. City of Salisbury, Vol 1, Roy Comm Hist Monuments Engl Inventories, LondonGoogle Scholar
Reeves, N C (ed) 1997. The 1675 Thomas Blount Manuscript History of Herefordshire, HerefordGoogle Scholar
Round, J H (ed) 1899. Calendar of Documents in France, Illustrative of the History of Great Britain and Ireland, LondonGoogle Scholar
Sanders, I J 1960. English Baronies. A Study of their Origins and Descent 1086–1327, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Seidel, L 1981. Songs of Glory. The Romanesque Facades of Aquitaine, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
Shoesmith, R (ed) 1992. ‘Excavations at Kilpeck, Herefordshire’, Trans Woolhope Natur Fid Club, 47, Part II, 162–209Google Scholar
Simpson, G G 1985. ‘The familia of Roger de Quincy, Earl of Winchester and Constable of Scotland’, in Essays on the Nobility of Medieval Scotland (ed Stringer, K J), 102–23, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Stalley, R A 1971. ‘A twelfth-century patron of architecture: a study of the buildings erected by Roger, Bishop of Salisbury 1102–1139’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 3rd ser, 34, 62–83CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stalley, R A 1981 ‘Three Irish buildings with West Country origins’, Medieval Art and Architecture at Wells and Glastonbury, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, IV (eds Coldstream, N and Draper, P), 62–80, London and LeedsGoogle Scholar
Stenton, F M 1932. The First Century of English Feudalism, 1066–1166, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Stokes, M A, Baxter, R, Gardiner, H, Hunt, J and Thurlby, M 1999. ‘The Herefordshire School of sculpture. Summary of papers given at a day school held in the University of Birmingham, Saturday May 22nd, 1999’, West Midlands Archaeol, 42, 11–18Google Scholar
Stone, L 1972. Sculpture in Britain. The Middle Ages, 2nd edn, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Stringer, K J 1985. Earl David of Huntingdon, 1152–1219, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Stubbs, W (ed) 1889. Willelmi Malmesbiriensis Monachi De Gestis Regum Anglorum, II, Rolls Series, XC, LondonGoogle Scholar
Taylor, H M and Taylor, J 1965. Anglo-Saxon Architecture, 2 vols, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
Tcherikover, A 1990. ‘Aulnay de Saintonge and High Romanesque figure sculpture in Aquitaine’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 143, 77–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thurlby, M 1986. ‘The north transept doorway of Lichfield Cathedral: problems of style’, Revue d'Art Canadienne/Canadian Art Review, 13/2, 121–30Google Scholar
Thurlby, M 1995a. ‘Hereford Cathedral: the Romanesque fabric’, in Whitehead, (ed) 1995, 15–28Google Scholar
Thurlby, M 1995b. ‘The Lady Chapel of Glastonbury Abbey’, Antiq J, 75, 107–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thurlby, M 1999. The Herefordshire School of Romanesque Sculpture, LogastonGoogle Scholar
Thurlby, M 2000. ‘Aspects of Romanesque ecclesiastical architecture in Dorset: Wimborne Minster, Sherborne Abbey, Forde Abbey Chapter House, and St Mary's, Maiden Newton’, Proc Dorset Natur Hist Archaeol Soc, 122, 1–19Google Scholar
Thurlby, M 2001. ‘The place of St Albans in regional sculpture and architecture in the second half of the twelfth century’, in Alban Architecture, Art and Archaeology, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, XXIV (eds Henig, M and Lindley, P), 162–75, LeedsGoogle Scholar
Walker, D 1964. ‘Charters of the earldom of Hereford 1095–1201’, Camden Miscellany, 23, 1–75Google Scholar
Weaver, J R H (ed) 1908. The Chronicle of John of Worcester 1118–1140, OxfordGoogle Scholar
West, J K 1988. ‘Architectural sculpture in parish churches in the nth- and 12th-century west Midlands: some problems in assessing the evidence’, in Blair, (ed) 1988, 159–64Google Scholar
Whitehead, D 1995. ‘The mid-nineteenth-century restoration of Hereford Cathedral by Lewis Knockalls Cottingham, 1842–1850’, in Whitehead, (ed) 1995, 176–86Google Scholar
Whitehead, D (ed) 1995. Medieval Art, Architecture and Archaeology at Hereford, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, XV, London and LeedsGoogle Scholar
Wightman, W E 1966. The Lacy Family in England and Normandy, 1066–1195, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Williamson, P 1984. ‘Corbel, Victoria and Albert Museum, London’, in Zarnecki, et al. 1984, 177, no. 136Google Scholar
Wilson, C 1985. ‘Abbot Serlo's church at Gloucester (1089–1100): its place in Romanesque architecture’, Medieval Art and Architecture at Gloucester and Tewkesbury, Brit Archaeol Ass Conference Trans, VII (eds Heslop, T A and Sekules, V A), 52–83, London and LeedsGoogle Scholar
Wood, R 1994. ‘The Romanesque doorways of Yorkshire, with special reference to that at St Mary's Church, Riccall’, Yorkshire Archaeol J, 66, 59–90Google Scholar
Wood, R 2000. ‘The Romanesque doorway at Fishlake’, Yorkshire Archaeol J, 72, 17–39Google Scholar
Zarnecki, G 1951. ‘Regional schools of English sculpture in the twelfth century. The Southern School and the Herefordshire School’, unpublished PhD thesis, University of LondonGoogle Scholar
Zarnecki, G 1953. Later English Romanesque Sculpture, 1140–1210, LondonGoogle Scholar
Zarnecki, G 1993. ‘The future of the Shobdon Arches’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 146, 87–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zarnecki, G 1998. ‘The Romanesque sculpture of the Welsh Marches’, in Medieval Art: Recent Perspectives. A Memorial Tribute to C. R. Dodwell (eds Owen-Crocker, G R and Graham, T), 60–88, ManchesterGoogle Scholar
Zarnecki, G, Holt, J and Holland, T (eds) 1984. English Romanesque Art 1066–1200, LondonGoogle Scholar