Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T18:27:45.015Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Royal and Lordly Residence in Scotland c 1050 to c 1250: an Historiographical Review and Critical Revision

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2008

Richard D Oram
Richard D Oram
Affiliation:
Centre for Environmental History and Policy, Department of History, University of Stirling, Stirling FK9 4LA, UK. E-mail: .
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Academic study of eleventh- to thirteenth-century high-status residence in Scotland has been largely bypassed by English debates over origin, function and symbolism. Archaeologists have also been slow to engage with three decades of historical revision of the traditional socioeconomic, cultural and political models upon which their interpretations of royal and lordly residence have drawn. Scottish castle studies concerned with the pre-1250 era continue to be framed by a ‘military architecture’ historio graphical tradition and a view of the castle as an alien artefact imposed on the land by foreign adventurers and a ‘modernizing’ monarchy and native Gaelic nobility. Knowledge and understanding of pre-twelfth-century native high-status sites is rudimentary and derived primarily from often inappropriate analogy with English examples. Discussion of native responses to the imported castle-building culture is founded upon retrospective projection of inappropriate later medieval social and economic models and anachronistic perceptions of military colonialism. Cultural and socio-economic difference is rarely recognized in archaeological modelling and cultural determinism has distorted perceptions of structural form, social status and material values. A programme of interdisciplinary studies focused on specific sites is necessary to provide a corrective to this current situation.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 88 , September 2008 , pp. 165 - 189
Copyright
Copyright © The Society of Antiquaries of London 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

ABBREVIATION AND BIBLIOGRAPHY

RCAHMS Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of ScotlandGoogle Scholar
Anderson, A O (ed) 1908. Scottish Annals from English Chroniclers, LondonGoogle Scholar
Anderson, A O (ed) 1922. Early Sources of Scottish History AD 500–1286, 2 vols, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Anderson, A O, Anderson, M O and Dickinson, W C (eds) 1936. The Chronicle of Melrose, LondonGoogle Scholar
Barbour, J 1997. The Bruce (ed and trans Duncan, A A M), EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Barrow, G W S (ed) 1960. The Acts of Malcolm IV, King of Scots, 1155–65, Regesta Regum Scottorum 1153–1424 I, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Barrow, G W S (ed) 1971. The Acts of William I, King of Scots, 1165–1214, Regesta Regum Scottorum 1153–1424 II, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Barrow, G W S (ed) 1999. The Charters of David I: the written Acts of David I King of Scots, 1124–53, and of his son Henry, Earl of Northumberland, 1139–52, WoodbridgeGoogle Scholar
Bogdan, N Q 1979. ‘Some aspects of early castle building in Scotland’, unpublished MPhil thesis, 2 vols, University of St AndrewsGoogle Scholar
Bower, W 1994. Scotichronicon (general ed Watt, D E R), IV, AberdeenGoogle Scholar
Innes, C (ed) 1832. Registrum Monasterii de Passelet, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
McGurk, F (ed) 1976. Calendar of Papal Letters to Scotland of Benedict XIII of Avignon 1394–1419, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Myln, A 1831. Vitae Dunkeldensis Episcoporum, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Pálsson, H and Edwards, P (trans) 1978. Orkneyinga Saga, HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
Stuart, J and Burnett, G (eds) 1878. ‘The Exchequer Rolls of Scotland, I, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
‘Stirling Castle Archaeological Survey and Investigation: excavations in Stirling Castle 1992–97’ nd. Unpublished report prepared for Historic Scotland by Headland ArchaeologyGoogle Scholar
Airlie, S 1994. ‘The view from Maastricht’, in Scotland in Dark Age Europe (ed Crawford, B E), 33–46, St AndrewsGoogle Scholar
Aitchison, N 2006. Forteviot: a Pictish and Scottish royal centre, StroudGoogle Scholar
Alcock, L 1981. ‘Early historic fortifications in Scotland’, in Hill-Fort Studies (ed Guilbert, G), 150–81, LeicesterGoogle ScholarPubMed
Alcock, L 1988. ‘The activities of potentates in Celtic Britain, AD 500–800: a positivist approach’, in Power and Politics in Early Medieval Britain and Ireland (eds Driscoll, S T and Nieke, M R), 22–46, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Alcock, L and Alcock, E A 1990. ‘Reconnaissance excavations on Early Historic fortifications and other royal sites in Scotland, 1974–84, 4: Excavations at Alt Glut, Clyde Rock, Strathclyde, 1974–75’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 120, 95–150Google Scholar
Alcock, L and Alcock, E A 1992. ‘Reconnaissance excavations on Early Historic fortifications and other royal sites in Scotland, 1974–84, 5A: Excavations and other fieldwork at Forteviot, Perthshire, 1981; 5B: Excavations at Urquhart Castle, Inverness-shire, 1983; 5C: Excavations at Dunnottar, Kincardineshire, 1984’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 122, 215–87Google Scholar
Alcock, A, Alcock, E A and Driscoll, S 1989. ‘Reconnaissance excavations on Early Historic fortifications and other royal sites in Scotland, 1974–84, 3: Excavations at Dundurn, Strathearn, Perthshire, 1976–77’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 119, 189–226Google Scholar
Barrow, G W S 1981a. The Anglo-Norman Era in Scottish History, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Barrow, G W S 1981b. Kingship and Unity: Scotland 1000–1306, Ist edn, LondonGoogle Scholar
Barrow, G W S 2003. The Kingdom of the Scots: government, church and society from the eleventh to the fourteenth century, 2nd edn, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Beresford, G 1987. Goltho: the development of an early medieval manor c 850–1150, LondonGoogle Scholar
Bowler, D and Perry, D 2004. ‘The medieval and early modern town’, in Perth: the archaeology and development of a Scottish burgh (ed Bowler, D), 21–34, PerthGoogle Scholar
Bridgland, N 2005. Urquhart Castle and the Great Glen, LondonGoogle Scholar
Brotherstone, T and Ditchburn, D (eds) 2000. Freedom and Authority: Scotland, c 1050 –c 1650: historical and historiographical essays presented to Grant G Simpson, East LintonGoogle Scholar
Brown, R A 1954. English Medieval Castles, LondonGoogle Scholar
Brown, R A 1976. English Castles, LondonGoogle Scholar
Caldwell, D H and Ruckley, N A 2005. ‘Domestic architecture in the Lordship of the Isles’, in Oram and Stell (eds) 2005, 96–121Google Scholar
Coles, F R 1890–1891. ‘The motes, forts and doons of the Stewartry of Kirkcudbright’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 25, 352–96Google Scholar
Coles, F R 1891–1892. ‘The motes, forts and doons of the Stewartry of Kirkcudbright’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 26, 117–70Google Scholar
Coles, F R 1892–1893. ‘The motes, forts and doons of the east and west divisions of the Stewartry of Kirkcudbright’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 27, 98–182Google Scholar
Corser, P 2005. ‘The Bruce lordship of Annandale, 1124–1296’, in Oram and Stell (eds) 2005, 44–59Google Scholar
Coulson, C 1979. ‘Structural symbolism in medieval castle architecture’, J Brit Archaeol Ass, 132, 73–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coulson, C 1996. ‘The state of research: cultural realities and reappraisals in English castle-study’, J Medieval Hist, 22 (2), 171–208CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Creighton, O H 2002. Castles and Landscapes: power, community and fortification in medieval England, LondonGoogle Scholar
Crone, A and Watson, F 2003. ‘Sufficiency to scarcity: medieval Scotland, 500–1600’, in People and Woods in Scotland: a history (ed Smout, T C), 60–81, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Cruden, S 1981. The Scottish Castle, 2nd edn, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Dennison, E P and Coleman, R 2000. Historic Forfar: the archaeological implications of development, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Driscoll, S T 1991. ‘The archaeology of state formation in Scotland’, in Scottish Archaeology: new perceptions (eds Hanson, W S and Slater, E A), 81–111, AberdeenGoogle Scholar
Driscoll, S T 1998. ‘Formalising the mechanisms of state power: early Scottish lordship from the ninth to the thirteenth centuries’, in Scottish Power Centres from the Early Middle Ages to the Twentieth Century (eds Foster, S, Macinnes, A and MacInnes, R), 32–58, GlasgowGoogle Scholar
Driscoll, S T and Yeoman, P A 1997. Excavations within Edinburgh Castle, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Dunbar, J 1981. ‘The medieval architecture of the Scottish Highlands’, in The Middle Ages in the Highlands (ed Maclean, L), 38–70, InvernessGoogle Scholar
Dunbar, J 1999. Scottish Royal Palaces, East LintonGoogle Scholar
Duncan, A A M 1975. Scotland: the making of the kingdom, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Duncan, A A M and Dunbar, J G 1971. ‘Tarbert Castle: a contribution to the history of Argyll’, Scott Hist Rev, 50, 1–17Google Scholar
Ewart, G 1985. Cruggleton Castle: report of excavations 1978–1981, DumfriesGoogle Scholar
Ewart, G and Triscott, J 1996. ‘Archaeological investigations at Castle Sween, Knapdale, Argyll and Bute, 1989–90’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 126, 517–58Google Scholar
Fernie, E 1986. ‘Early church architecture in Scotland’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 116, 393–411Google Scholar
Fisher, I 2005. ‘The heirs of Somerled’, in Oram and Stell (eds) 2005, 85–96Google Scholar
Gifford, J 1992. The Buildings of Scotland: Highlands and Islands, LondonGoogle Scholar
Gilbert, J M 1979. Hunting and Hunting Reserves in Medieval Scotland, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Grant, A 1993. ‘Thanes and thanages from the eleventh to the fourteenth centuries’, in Grant and Stringer (eds) 1993, 39–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grant, A and Stringer, K J (eds) 1993. Medieval Scotland: crown, lordship and community, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Greig, M K and Greig, C 1989. ‘Remains of a 12th-century structure and other medieval features on the knoll of Castle Point, Troup (Cullykhan), Banff and Buchan’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 119, 279–96Google Scholar
Haggarty, G and Tabraham, C J 1982. ‘Excavations of a motte near Roberton, Clydesdale, 1979’, Trans Dumfriesshire Galloway Natur Hist Antiq Soc, 57, 51–64Google Scholar
Hall, D W, MacDonald, A D, Perry, S and Terry, J 1998. ‘The archaeology of Elgin: excavations on Ladyhill and in the High Street, with an overview of the archaeology of the burgh’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 128, 753–829Google Scholar
Higham, R and Barker, P 2004. Timber Castles, 2nd edn, ExeterGoogle Scholar
Hope-Taylor, B 1977. Yeavering: an Anglo British centre of early Northumbria, LondonGoogle Scholar
Hope-Taylor, B 1980. ‘Balbridie… and Doon Hill’, Curr Archaeol, 7 (i), 8–19Google Scholar
Lamb, A C 1895. Dundee: its quaint and historic buildings, DundeeGoogle Scholar
Lane, A and Campbell, E 2000. Dunadd: an early Dalriadic capital, OxfordGoogle Scholar
Lang, J T 1972–1974. ‘Hogback monuments in Scotland’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 105, 206–35Google Scholar
Lewis, J 1996. ‘Dunstaffnage Castle, Argyll and Bute: excavations in the north tower and east range, 1987–94’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 126, 559–603Google Scholar
Lewis, J and Smith, H 1998. ‘Excavations at Inverlochy Castle, Inverness-shire, 1983–95’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 128, 619–44Google Scholar
MacGibbon, D and Ross, T 1887. The Castellated and Domestic Architecture of Scotland from the Twelfth to the Eighteenth Centuries, I, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
McDonald, R A 1997. The Kingdom of the Isles: Scotland's western seaboard c II00 – c 1336, East LintonGoogle Scholar
McKean, C A 1990. Banff and Buchan: an illustrated architectural guide, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
McNeill, T 1997. Castles in Ireland: feudal power in a Gaelic world, LondonGoogle Scholar
Miket, R and Roberts, D L 2007. The Medieval Castles of Skye and Lochalsh, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Morris, C D 1989. The Birsay Bay Project, I: Coastal sites beside the Brough Road, Birsay, Orkney: excavations 1976–82, Univ Durham Dept Archaeol Monogr Ser i, DurhamGoogle Scholar
Morris, C D 1996. The Birsay Bay Project, 2: Sites in Birsay village and on the Brough of Birsay, Orkney, Univ Durham Dept of Archaeol Monogr Ser 2, DurhamGoogle Scholar
Morrison, A 1974. ‘Some prehistoric sites in Scotland with medieval occupation’, Scott Archaeol Forum, 6, 66–74Google Scholar
Murray, H and Ewart, G 1978–1980. ‘Two early medieval timber buildings from Castle Hill, Peebles’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 110, 519–27Google Scholar
Murray, H K and Murray, J C 1993. ‘Excavations at Rattray, Aberdeenshire: a Scottish deserted burgh’, Medieval Archaeol, 37, 109–218CrossRefGoogle Scholar
O'Conor, K 2005. ‘Gaelic lordly settlement in 13th- and 14th-century Ireland’, in ‘Utmark’. The Outfield as Industry and Ideology in the Iron Age and the Middle Ages (eds Holm, I, Innselet, S and Øye, I), Univ Bergen Archaeol Int Ser i, 209–21, BergenGoogle Scholar
Oram, R D 2000. The Lordship of Galloway, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Oram, R D 2003. ‘Continuity, adaptation and integration: the earls and earldom of Mar’, in The Exercise of Power in Medieval Scotland, c 1200–1500 (eds Boardman, S and Ross, A), 46–66, DublinGoogle Scholar
Oram, R D 2005. ‘Prelatical builders: a preliminary study, c 1124–e 1500’, in Oram and Stell (eds) 2005, 1–25Google Scholar
Oram, R D 2006. ‘Castles and colonists in twelfth- and thirteenth-century Scotland: the case of Moray’, Château Gaillard, 22, 289–98Google Scholar
Oram, R D 2007. ‘Capital tales or Burghead bull?’, in A Grey Eye Looks Back: essays in honour of Colm O'Baoill (eds Arbuthnot, S and Hollo, K), 241–62, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Oram, R D and Stell, G P (eds) 2005. Lordship and Architecture in Medieval and Renaissance Scotland, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Platt, C 2007. ‘Revisionism in castle studies: a caution’, Medieval Archaeol, 51, 83–102CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Platt, C 2007–2008. ‘Understanding licences to crenellate’, J Castle Stud Group, 21, 203–7Google Scholar
Pringle, D 1989. Linlithgow Palace: a historical guide to the royal palace and peel, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
RCAHMS 1920. Inventory of Ancient Monuments and Historic Constructions in the County of Dumfries, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
RCAHMS 1933. Eleventh Report with Inventory of Monuments and Constructions in the Counties of Fife, Kinross, and Clackmannan, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
RCAHMS 1957. An Inventory of the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Selkirkshire, with the Fifteenth Report of the Commission, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
RCAHMS 1967. Peeblesshire: an inventory of the ancient monuments, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
RCAHMS 1982. South Kincardine: Kincardine and Deeside District, Grampian Region, Archaeological Sites and Monuments of Scotland XV, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Richardson, J S, Root, M E and Taylor, A N 1980. Balvenie Castle, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Sibbald, R 1803. The History, Ancient and Modern, of the Sheriffdoms of Fife and Kinross with a Description of Both, and of the Firths of Forth and Tay and the Islands in them; in which there is an account of the royal seats and castles; and of the royal burghs and ports; and of the religious houses and schools; and of the most remarkable houses of the nobility and gentry, with an account of the natural products of the land and waters, new edn, CuparGoogle Scholar
Simpson, G G and Webster, B 1985. ‘Charter evidence and the distribution of mottes’, in Essays on the Nobility of Medieval Scotland (ed Stringer, K J), 1–24, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Simpson, W D 1924. The Scottish Castle, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Smith, I M 1991. ‘Sprouston, Roxburghshire: an early Anglian centre of the eastern Tweed basin’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 121, 261–94Google Scholar
Stell, G 2006. [Castle Tioram report] <http://www.historic-scotland.gov.uk/index/news/indepth/castletioram/castletioram-docu-ments.htm> (4 06 2008)+(4+062008)>Google Scholar
‘Strathearn environs and royal Forteviot’, <http://www.gla.ac.uk/departments/archaeology/research/projects/serf> (7 04 2008)+(7+042008)>Google Scholar
Stringer, K J 1993. ‘Periphery and core in thirteenth-century Scotland: Alan son of Roland, Lord of Galloway and Constable of Scotland’, in Grant and Stringer (eds) 1993, 82–113CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stringer, K J 2000. ‘Acts of Lordship: the records of the lords of Galloway to 1234’, in Brotherstone and Ditchburn (eds) 2000, 203–34Google Scholar
Tabraham, C 1977–1978. ‘Norman settlement in upper Clydesdale: recent archaeological fieldwork’, Trans Dumfriesshire Galloway Natur Hist Antiq Soc, 53, 114–28Google Scholar
Tabraham, C 1984. ‘Norman settlement in Galloway: recent fieldwork in the Stewartry’, in Studies in Scottish Antiquity Presented to Stewart Cruden (ed Breeze, D), 87–124, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Tabraham, C 1997. Scotland's Castles, LondonGoogle Scholar
Talbot, E J 1974. ‘Early Scottish castles of earth and timber: recent fieldwork and excavation’, Scott Archaeol Forum, 6, 48–57Google Scholar
Talbot, E J 1976–1977. ‘Castlehill, Caithness: a Viking fortification?’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 108, 378–9Google Scholar
Talbot, E J 1981. ‘The defences of earth and timber castles’, in Scottish Weapons and Fortifications 1100–1800 (ed Caldwell, D H), 1–9, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
Toorians, L 1996. ‘Twelfth-century Flemish settlement in Scotland’, in Scotland and the Low Countries 1124–1994 (ed Simpson, G G), 1–14, East LintonGoogle Scholar
Watson, F J 2005. ‘Adapting tradition? The earldom of Strathearn, 1114–1296’, in Oram and Stell (eds) 2005, 26–43Google Scholar
Yeoman, P 1984. ‘Excavations at Castlehill of Strachan, 1980–81’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 114, 315–64Google Scholar
Yeoman, P 1988. ‘Mottes in northeast Scotland’, Scott Archaeol Rev, 5, 125–33Google Scholar
Yeoman, P 1995. Medieval Scotland, LondonGoogle Scholar