Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T07:15:22.391Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘CLUMSY AND ILLOGICAL’? RECONSIDERING THE WEST KIRBY HOGBACK

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 November 2016

Howard Williams
Howard Williams*
Affiliation:
Department of History and Archaeology, University of Chester, Parkgate Road, Chester CH1 4BJ, UK. Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper presents a fresh reading of a significant early medieval recumbent stone monument from West Kirby, Merseyside (formerly Cheshire). Rather than being a single-phased hogback, later subject to damage, it is argued that West Kirby 4 might have been carved in successive phases, possibly by different hands. It is suggested that the carvers had different abilities and/or adapted their work in response to the time pressures of a funeral or a shift in the location or function of the stone. While a single explanation for the character of the West Kirby monument remains elusive, the article proposes that, rather than ‘clumsy and illogical’, the stone was more likely a coherent but experimental, distinctive and asymmetrical, multi-phased and/or multi-authored creation. Through a review of the monument’s historiography and a reappraisal of the details and parallels of its form, ornament and material composition, the paper reconsiders the commemorative significance of this recumbent stone monument for the locality, region and understanding of Viking Age sculpture across the British Isles. As a result, West Kirby’s importance as an ecclesiastical locale in the Viking Age is reappraised.

Type
Papers
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 96 , September 2016 , pp. 69 - 100
Copyright
© The Society of Antiquaries of London 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abrams, L 2012. ‘Diaspora and identity in the Viking Age’, Early Medieval Europe, 20 (1), 17–38 Google Scholar
Allen, J R and Anderson, J 1903. The Early Christian Monuments of Scotland, Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, Edinburgh (facsimile edn published 1993, Pinkfoot Press, Balgavies)Google Scholar
Ashby, S 2015. ‘What really caused the Viking Age? The social content of raiding and exploration’, Archaeol Dialogues, 22 (1), 89–106 Google Scholar
Back Danielsson, I-M 2015. ‘Walking down memory lane: rune-stones as mnemonic agents in the landscapes of late Viking-Age Scandinavia’, in Williams et al 2015a, 62–86Google Scholar
Bailey, R 1980. Viking Age Sculpture in Northern England, Collins, London Google Scholar
Bailey, R 1994. ‘Govan and Irish Sea sculpture’, in A Ritchie (ed), Govan and its Early Medieval Sculpture, 113–121, Sutton, Stroud Google Scholar
Bailey, R 2010. Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture. Volume IX: Cheshire and Lancashire, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Bailey, R and Cramp, R 1988. Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture. Volume II: Cumberland, Westmorland and Lancashire North-of-the-Sands, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Bailey, R and Whalley, J 2006. ‘A miniature Viking-Age hogback from the Wirral’, Antiq J, 86, 345–356 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Biddle, M and Kjølbye-Biddle, B 2001. ‘Repton and the “great heathen army”, 873–4’, in J Graham-Campbell, R Hall, J Jesch and D N Parsons (eds), Vikings and the Danelaw, 45–96, Oxbow, Oxford Google Scholar
Bristow, C R 2010. ‘Regional geology’, in Bailey 2010, 11–18Google Scholar
Browne, G F 1887. ‘Brief precis of the description of the early sculpted stones of Cheshire’, Archaeol J, 44, 146–156 Google Scholar
Bu’Lock, J D 2000. ‘Pre-Norman crosses of West Cheshire and the Norse settlements around the Irish Sea’, in Cavill et al 2000, 70–83Google Scholar
Carroll, J, Harrison, S H and Williams, G (eds) 2014. The Vikings in Britain and Ireland, Thames & Hudson, London Google Scholar
Carver, M 2001. ‘Why that? Why there? Why then? The politics of early medieval monumentality’, in H Hamerow and A MacGregor (eds), Image and Power in the Archaeology of Early Medieval Britain, 1–22, Oxbow, Oxford Google Scholar
Cavill, P 2000. ‘Major place-names of the Wirral: a gazetteer’, in Cavill et al 2000, 125–47Google Scholar
Cavill, P, Harding, S and Jesch, J (eds) 2000. Wirral and its Viking Heritage, English Place-Name Society, Nottingham Google Scholar
Coatsworth, E 2008. Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture. Volume VIII: Western Yorkshire, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Collingwood, W G 1927. Northumbrian Crosses of the Pre-Norman Age, Faber & Faber, London Google Scholar
Collingwood, W G 1928. ‘Early monuments of West Kirby’, in J Brownbill (ed), West Kirby and Hilbre: a parochial history, 14–26, Henry Young, Liverpool (reprinted in Cavill et al 2000, 84–97, from which page references are given)Google Scholar
Cramp, R 1984. Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture. Volume I: County Durham and Northumberland, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Driscoll, S, O’Grady, O and Forsyth, K 2005. ‘The Govan school revisited: searching for meaning in the early medieval sculpture of Strathclyde’, in S Foster and M Cross (eds), Able Minds and Practised Hands: Scotland’s early medieval sculpture in the 21st century, 135–158, Maney, Leeds Google Scholar
Edwards, N 1999. ‘Viking-influenced sculpture in North Wales, its ornament and context’, Church Archaeol, 3, 5–16 Google Scholar
Edwards, N 2009. ‘Rethinking the Pillar of Eliseg’, Antiq J, 89, 143–177 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Edwards, N 2013. A Corpus of Early Medieval Inscribed Stones and Stone Sculpture in Wales. Volume III: North Wales, University of Wales Press, Cardiff Google Scholar
Everson, P and Stocker, D 2015. ‘Erratics and enterprise: Lincolnshire grave-covers in Norwich and Thetford and some implications for urban development in the 10th century’, in T A Heslop and H E Lunnon (eds), Norwich: medieval and early modern art, architecture and archaeology, British Archaeol Ass Conference Trans xxxviii, 23–43, Maney, Leeds Google Scholar
Everson, P and Stocker, D 2016. ‘Transactions on the Dee: the “exceptional” collection of early sculpture at St John’s, Chester’, in E Cambridge and J Hawkes (eds), Crossing Boundaries: interdisciplinary approaches to the art, material culture, language and literature of the early medieval world, Oxbow Books, Oxford Google Scholar
Foster, S 2015. ‘Circulating agency: the V&A, Scotland and the multiplication of plaster coasts of “Celtic crosses”’, J Hist Coll, 27 (1), 73–96 Google Scholar
Gondek, M 2010. ‘Constructing sacred space – soil, stone, water and symbols: early medieval carved stone monuments from Tillytarmot, Aberdeenshire’, in A George, D Hawley, G Nash, J Swann and L White (eds), Early Medieval Enquiries: the Proceedings of the Clifton Antiquarian Club, 9, 318–333, Clifton Antiquarian Club, Bristol Google Scholar
Graham-Campbell, J 2013. Viking Art, Thames & Hudson, London Google Scholar
Griffiths, D 1996. ‘The maritime economy of the Chester region in the Anglo-Saxon period’, in P Carrington (ed), ‘Where Deva Spreads Her Wizard Stream’. Trade and the Port of Chester. Papers from a Seminar Held at Chester, November 1995, Chester Archaeology Occas Pap No. 3, 49–60, Chester Archaeological Society, Chester Google Scholar
Griffiths, D 2006. ‘Maen Achwyfan and the context of Viking settlement in north-east Wales’, Archaeol Camb, 155, 143–162 Google Scholar
Griffiths, D 2010. Vikings of the Irish Sea, The History Press, Stroud Google Scholar
Griffiths, D 2015. ‘A brief history and archaeology of Viking activity in north-west England’, in Harding et al 2015, 33–49Google Scholar
Griffiths, D and Harding, S 2015. ‘Interdisciplinary approaches to the Scandinavian heritage of north-west England’, in Harding et al 2015, 1–31Google Scholar
Hadley, D 2008. ‘Warriors, heroes and companions: negotiating masculinity in Viking-Age England’, in S Crawford and H Hamerow (eds), Anglo-Saxon Stud Archaeol Hist, 15, 270–284 Google Scholar
Hall, M 2015a. ‘The Meigle Stones: a biographical overview’, Northern Stud, 46, 15–46 Google Scholar
Hall, M 2015b. ‘Lifeways in stone: memories and matter-reality in early medieval sculpture from Scotland’, in Williams et al 2015a, 182–215Google Scholar
Harding, S 2002. Viking Mersey: Scandinavian Wirral, West Lancashire and Chester, Countywise, Birkenhead Google Scholar
Harding, S, Griffiths, D and Royles, E (eds) 2015. In Search of Vikings: interdisciplinary approaches to the Scandinavian heritage of north-west England, CRC, London Google Scholar
Hawkes, J 2003. ‘Reading stone’, in C E Karkov and F Orton (eds), Theorizing Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture, 5–30, West Virginia University Press, Morgantown, WV Google Scholar
Hayes, L and Malim, T 2008. ‘The date and nature of Wat’s Dyke: a reassessment in the light of recent investigations at Gobowen, Shropshire’, in S Crawford and H Hamerow (eds), Anglo-Saxon Stud Archaeol Hist, 15, 147–179 Google Scholar
Jesch, J 2000. ‘Scandinavian Wirral’, in Cavill et al 2000, 1–10Google Scholar
Jesch, J 2015. The Viking Diaspora, Routledge, London Google Scholar
Kermode, P M C 1907. Manx Crosses, Bemrose & Sons, London (facsimile edn published 1994, Pinkfoot Press, Balgavies)Google Scholar
Kirton, J 2015. ‘Locating the Cleulow cross: materiality, place and landscape’, in Williams et al 2015a, 35–61Google Scholar
Kirton, J 2016. ‘The contextualisation of Cheshire’s early medieval sculptural corpus: an in-depth exploration of the key relationship between carved monuments and their location’, unpublished PhD thesis, University of ChesterGoogle Scholar
Kopár, L 2012. Gods and Settlers: the iconography of Norse mythology in Anglo-Scandinavian sculpture, Brepols, Turnhout Google Scholar
Lang, J 1972–4. ‘Hogback monuments in Scotland’, Proc Soc Antiq Scotl, 105, 206–235 Google Scholar
Lang, J 1984. ‘The hogback: a Viking colonial monument’, Anglo-Saxon Stud Archaeol Hist, 3, 83–176 Google Scholar
Lang, J 1991. Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture. Volume III: York and Eastern Yorkshire, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Lang, J 1994. ‘The Govan hogbacks: a reappraisal’, in A Ritchie (ed), Govan and its Early Medieval Sculpture, 123–131, Sutton, Stroud Google Scholar
Lang, J 2001. Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture. Volume VI: Northern Yorkshire, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Mason, D 2007. Chester AD 400–1066, Tempus, Stroud Google Scholar
Nash, G 2010. ‘Death and memorial in an early medieval ecclesiastical landscape in north-west England: an appraisal of St Patrick’s Chapel and St Peter’s Church, Heysham, Lancashire’, in A George, D Hawley, G Nash, J Swann and L White (eds), Early Medieval Enquiries: the Proceedings of the Clifton Antiquarian Club, 9, 299–317, Clifton Antiquarian Club, Bristol Google Scholar
Orton, F 2003. ‘Rethinking the Ruthwell and Bewcastle monuments: some deprecation of style; some consideration of form and ideology’, in C E Karkov and G H Brown (eds), Anglo-Saxon Styles, 31–68, State University of New York Press, Albany, NY Google Scholar
Price, N 2010. ‘Passing into poetry: Viking-Age mortuary drama and the origins of Norse Mythology’, Medieval Archaeol, 54, 123–156 Google Scholar
Stocker, D 2000. ‘Monuments and merchants: irregularities in the distribution of stone sculpture in Lincolnshire and Yorkshire in the tenth century’, in D M Hadley and J D Richards (eds), Cultures in Contact: Scandinavian settlement in England in the ninth and tenth centuries, 179–212, Brepols, Turnhout Google Scholar
Thompson, V forthcoming. Bodystones and Guardian Beasts: the early medieval recumbent grave-stones of middle Britain, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Wawn, A 2000. ‘The Vikings and Victorian Merseyside’, in Cavill et al 2000, 125–47Google Scholar
White, R 2013. ‘Resolving the carving: application of laser scanning in reconstructing a Viking cross from Neston, Cheshire’, in E Ch’ng, V L Gaffney and H Chapman (eds), Visual Heritage in the Digital Age, 33–41, Springer, London Google Scholar
White, R 2015. ‘Figuring it out: further work on the Neston cross fragments, Cheshire’, in Harding et al 2015, 179–88Google Scholar
Williams, H 2006. Death and Memory in Early Medieval Britain, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Google Scholar
Williams, H 2011. ‘Remembering elites: early medieval stone crosses as commemorative technologies’, in L Boye, P Ethelberg, L Heidemann Lutz, S Kleingärtner, P Kruse, L Matthes and A B Sørensen (eds), Arkæologi i Slesvig/Archäologie in Schleswig. Sonderband ‘Det 61. Internationale Sachsensymposion 2010’ Haderslev, Denmark, 13–32, Wachholtz, Neumünster Google Scholar
Williams, H 2014. ‘Memory through monuments: movement and temporality in Skamby’s boat graves’, in H Alexandersson, A Andreeff and A Bünz (eds), Med hjärta och hjärna. En vänbok till professor Elisabeth Arwill-Nordbladh, GOTARC Series A, Gothenburg Archaeol Stud, 5, 397–414, Göteborgs Universitet, Institutionen för historiska studier, Gothenburg Google Scholar
Williams, H 2015. ‘Hogbacks: the materiality of solid spaces’, in Williams et al 2015a, 241–68Google Scholar
Williams, H 2016. ‘Citations in stone: the material world of hogbacks’, European J Archaeol, 19 (3), 497–518Google Scholar
Williams, H, Kirton, J and Gondek, M (eds) 2015a. Early Medieval Stone Monuments: materiality, biography and landscape, Boydell & Brewer, Woodbridge Google Scholar
Williams, H, Kirton, J and Gondek, M 2015b. ‘Introduction: stones in substance, space and time’, in Williams et al 2015a, 1–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar