Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T20:40:34.773Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Oxford University/British Institute of Archaeology at Ankara Survey of Medieval Castles of Anatolia (1992) Mastaura Kalesi: a Preliminary Report

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 December 2013

Hugh Barnes  and
Mark Whittow
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

1992 was the first season of the Oxford University/British Institute of Archaeology at Ankara Survey of Medieval Castles of Anatolia. Over the next five years it is planned to survey and record in as much detail as practicable five Byzantine castles in the area of the Büyük and Küçük Menderes river systems in western Turkey. The five castles will eventually be published in a single monograph where they can be discussed as a group and placed in their historical and geographical context. An annual preliminary report will appear in Anatolian Studies, which we hope will serve as a forum to test ideas, raise problems, and encourage other historians and archaeologists to suggest further ways of obtaining the most from these sites.

The five sites—indicated on Fig. 1—are Mastaura kalesi (near Bozyurt, in Aydın ili, Nazilli ilçesi, merkez bucağı); Yılanlı kalesi (on the side of the Boz dağ near Kemer in İzmir ili, Ödemiş. ilçesi, Birgi bucağı); Çardak kalesi (near Çardak in Denizli ili, Çardak ilçesi, merkez bucağı); Yöre kalesi (near Yöre köy in Aydın ili, Kuyucak ilçesi, Pamukören bucağı); and Ulubey kalesi (on the Kazancı deresi near Ulubey in Uşak ili, Ulubey ilçesi). None has received more than brief notice before; none has been planned or studied in any detail. They have been chosen to cover the whole period of Byzantine rule in the area from the seventh century to the early fourteenth, and a variety of the different types and functions of Byzantine castles. Yılanlı is possibly a late seventh-century fortress, built in the context of the Arab attempts to take Constantinople and the consequent struggle to control the western coastlands of Asia Minor. Çardak appears to have been built between the seventh and the ninth century principally to act as a look-out point in the Byzantine defensive system against Arab raids.

Type
Research Article
Information
Anatolian Studies , Volume 43 , December 1993 , pp. 117 - 135
Copyright
Copyright © The British Institute at Ankara 1993

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Yılanlı kalesi has been briefly discussed by Foss: Foss, C., “Explorations in Mount Tmolos”, California Studies in Classical Antiquity, 11 (1978) 45–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 Foss, C., “Late Byzantine Fortifications in Lydia”, Jahrbuch der Österreichischen Byzantinistik, 28 (1979) 297–320Google Scholar; idem., “The Defenses of Asia Minor against the Turks”, Greek Orthodox Theological Review, 27 (1982); idem., Survey of Medieval Castles of Anatolia I: Kütahya (BAR International Series 261, Oxford 1985); idem, “Strobilos and Related Sites”, AnatSt, 38 (1988) 147–74; idem., “Byzantine Malagina and the Lower Sangarius”, AnatSt, 40 (1990) 161–83; Foss, C., Winfield, D., Byzantine Fortifications: An Introduction (Pretoria 1986)Google Scholar.

3 Hamilton, W. J., Researches in Asia Minor, Pontus and Armenia (London 1842) I.537Google Scholar.

4 von Diest, W., Nysa ad Maeandrum nach Forschungen und Aufnahmen in den Jahren 1907 und 1909 (Jahrbuch des Kaiserlich Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts X, Berlin 1913) 18–20Google Scholar; Kourouniotes, K., “Μάσταυρα”, Αρχαιολογικόν Δϵλτίον, 7 (1921–1922) 247–57Google Scholar. Von Diest only spent a day at Mastaura from which he produced a very brief description and a rather misleading map; Kourouniotes was there for a longer period during the autumn and winter of 1921 but he was in danger from local guerilla attacks and had to leave with the Greek army. His work which includes some important photographs represents a considerable improvement on that of von Diest but he did not visit the castle hill and he produced no site plan. Mastaura was also visited by Hamilton in October 1836. He did climb to the castle but thought the remains were those of the ancient acropolis: Hamilton, W. J., Researches in Asia Minor, I.531Google Scholar, and see n. 9 below. All three were only concerned with the medieval remains in so far as they shed light on the ancient city.

5 Cribwork: see Foss, C., Winfield, D., Byzantine Fortification, 28–9Google Scholar; Wilcox, R. P., Timber and Iron Reinforcement in Early Buildings (Society of Antiquaries, Occasional Paper, New Series II, London 1981) 1–21Google Scholar.

6 Adam, J. P., La construction romaine, 2nd edn. (Paris 1989) 153–6Google Scholar.

7 von Diest, W., Nysa 20Google Scholar, reports that the northernmost cistern on the Castle Top, which now stands to a depth of 3 m., was 4 m. deep in 1909. But since he also gives the dimensions of this cistern as 3 × 6 m. (whereas it actually measures 4·3 × 6.3 m.) his evidence cannot be relied upon.

8 Scranton, R. L., Medieval Architecture in the Central Area of Corinth (Corinth XVI, Princeton 1957) 131Google Scholar.

9 It therefore seems most unlikely that the castle hill ever served as an acropolis to the ancient city: von Diest, W., Nysa 20Google Scholar; Kourouniotes, K., “Μάσταυρα”, 255–6Google Scholar; Hamilton, W. J., Researches in Asia Minor, I.531Google Scholar.

10 This tentative suggestion is based on unpublished field work on cisterns and the water supply in the Kerak plateau of Jordan being carried out as part of the Faris Project (see Johns, J., McQuitty, A., Falkner, R. et al. , “The Fâris Project: Preliminary Report upon the 1986 and 1988 Seasons”, Levant, 21 (1989) 63–95Google Scholar) and the advice of William Lancaster, (Director of the British Institute at Amman for Archaeology and History), Dr. Jeremy Johns and that of a number of local Turkish farmers—for all of which we are very grateful. The cisterns at Rougiers, a small fortified hilltop settlement in Provence, built in the late twelfth century, use a very similar pink mortar lining to that at Mastaura. Two of the cisterns were abandoned after less than a century, but one, serving the castle lodgings, was kept clean and in use for over 150 years without needing to be replastered: d'Archimbaud, G. Demains, Les Fouilles de Rougiers (Paris 1980) 114–15, 208–11, 121Google Scholar.

11 See in addition to the works cited in n. 2 above, Müller-Wiener, W., “Mittelalterliche Befestigungen im südlichen Jonien”, IstMitt, 11 (1961) 5–122Google Scholar; Rheidt, K., Die byzantinische Wohnstadt (Altertümer von Pergamon XV/2, Berlin 1991) 219–23Google Scholar.

12 Foss, C., Winfield, D., Byzantine Fortification, 56–9, 76Google Scholar; Foss, C., Kütahya, 68–71, 83–4Google Scholar.

13 Foss, C., Winfield, D., Byzantine Fortification, 59, 76, 103–5, 114, 120Google Scholar.

14 Waagé, F. O., “The Roman and Byzantine Pottery”, Hesperia, 2 (1933) 313–17CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Morgan, C. H., The Byzantine Pottery (Corinth XI, Cambridge, Mass. 1942) 146, 158–9Google Scholar; Scott, J. A., Kamilli, C. D., “Late Byzantine Glazed Pottery from Sardis”, Actes du XVe congrès international des études byzantines (Athens 1981) II b.683Google Scholar.

15 Jones, A. H. M., Cities of the Eastern Roman Provinces, 2nd edn. (Oxford 1971) 78Google Scholar; Head, B. V., Historia Numorum, 2nd edn. (Oxford, 1911) 653Google Scholar; Pococke, R., A Description of the East and Some other Countries (London, 1745) II.67–8Google Scholar: “The town of Naslee being near, and the hills being so sandy, without any stones for building, seems to be the reason why there is so little to be seen of [ancient Mastaura]”.

16 Hierokles, , Synekdemos (ed) Honigmann, E. (Brussels 1939) 659.8Google Scholar; Schwartz, E. (ed), Acta Conciliorum Oecumenicorum (Berlin 1925–)Google Scholar Ephesos (431): I, i/2.5; Chalcedon (451): II, i/2.154; Constantinople III (680–81): ser. II, ii/2.788–9; Mansi, J. D. (ed), Sacrorum Concilium nova et amplissima collectio (Florence/Venice 1759–1798) Nicaea II (787): XIII.994Google Scholar; J. Darrouzès, Notitiae episcopatuum Ecclesiae Constantinopolitanae (Paris 1981)Google Scholar not. 1.87, not. 2.102, not. 3.111, not. 4.96, not. 7.127, not. 9.19, not. 10.18, not. 13.20; Vita Theodori Studitorum (Patrologia cursus completus, Series graeca, ed. Migne, J.-P., XCIX) 289–92Google Scholar.

17 Zacos, G., Veglery, A., Byzantine Lead Seals (Basel 1972) I/2.1169Google Scholar, no. 2105: Leo, dioiketes of Mastaura. The editors date the seal on stylistic grounds to 750–850.

18 Mann, J., The Jews in Egypt and in Palestine under the Fatimid Caliphs (Oxford 1920–1922) II.94Google Scholar; Reinach, T., “Un contrat de mariage du temps de Basile le Bulgaroctone”, in Mélanges offerts à M. Gustave Schlumberger, II.123Google Scholar; Starr, J., The Jews in the Byzantine Empire (Athens 1939) 188Google Scholar.

19 Stephen of Byzantium in his sixth-century compendium of geographical tradition reports that the river Chrysaoras ran through the middle of Mastaura: Stephen of Byzantium, Ethnicorum quae supersunt (ed) Meineke, A. (Berlin 1849) 436Google Scholar.

20 Kourouniotes, K., “Μάσταυρα”, 251Google Scholar.

21 Odo of Deuil, De profectione Ludovici VII in orientem ed. Berry, V. G. (New York 1948) 108–14Google Scholar.

22 Choniates, Niketas, Historia, ed. van Dieten, J.L. (CFHB 11, Berlin 1975) 150Google Scholar; Foss, C., “The Defenses of Asia Minor”, 151–2Google Scholar.

23 Pachymeres, George, Chronikon III.21Google Scholar, IV.27, VI.20 (ed. Failler, A., Relations historiques, CFHB 24, Paris 1984, I.289–91, II.403, 591Google Scholar).

24 Smith, T., Remarks upon the Manners, Religion and Government of the Turks (London 1678) 254Google Scholar; Pococke, R., A Description of the East, II.67–8Google Scholar; Arundell, F. V. J., A Visit to the Seven Churches of Asia (London 1828) 69Google Scholar; Hamilton, W. J., Researches in Asia Minor, I.530–32Google Scholar; Taeschner, F., Das anatolische Wegentz nach osmanischen Quellen (Türkische Bibliothek 22, Leipzig 1924) I.170Google Scholar, II.40.

25 , II ed. Nystazopoulou-Pelekidou, M. (Athens 1980) 53, 58–9Google Scholar.

26 Foss, C., Ephesus after Antiquity (Cambridge 1979) 116–37Google Scholar; Rheidt, K., Die byzantinische Wohnstadt 197–200, 209–11, 237–9, 246–51Google Scholar.

27 , II.58Google Scholar.

28 Martin, J. -M., Noyé, G., “Les villes de l'ltalie byzantine (IXe–XIe siècle)”, in Kravari, V., Lefort, J., Morrisson, C. (ed) Hommes et richesses dans l'Empire byzantin II (Paris 1991) 37–8Google Scholar.

29 Ibid., 38–41.

30 Ibid., 41–2.

31 Pergamon: Rheidt, K., Die byzantinische Wohnstadt, 197–8, fig. 47 and general site plan in endpaperGoogle Scholar; Sardis: Foss, C., Byzantine and Turkish Sardis (Cambridge, Mass. 1976) 76–84, 180CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kütahya: Foss, C., Kütahya, 14, 205 (general site plan)Google Scholar; Dunn, A. W., “The Survey of Khrysoupolis and Byzantine Fortifications in the Lower Strymon Valley”, Jahrbuch der Österreichischen Byzantinistik, 32/4 (1982) 608, 610Google Scholar; Ariassos: Mitchell, S., “Ariassos 1990”, AnatSt 41 (1991) 160Google Scholar.

32 Bryer, A., “The Structure of the Late Byzantine Town: Dioikismos and Mesoi”, in Bryer, A., Lowry, H. (ed) Continuity and Change in Late Byzantine and Early Ottoman Society (Birmingham 1986) 275Google Scholar.

33 Rheidt, K., Die byzantinische Wohnstadt, 22–6Google Scholar. Note also the very slight traces of similar houses of the tenth to early eleventh century to have survived at Nichoria: McDonald, W. A., Coulson, W. D. E., Rosser, J. (ed), Excavations at Nichoria III: Dark Age and Byzantine Occupation (Minneapolis 1983) 354, 358Google Scholar.

34 Bakirtzes, Ch., , 39, Athens 1989) 111–21Google Scholar; Rheidt, K., Die byzantinische Wohnstadt, 215Google Scholar; Scranton, R. L., Medieval Architecture in the Central Area of Corinth, 37, 42, 73–7, 79, 82, 131Google Scholar. In general on grain storage in these flask-shaped cisterns see the papers by Mauny, R., Bresc, H., Polge, H., Triantafyllidou-Baladie, Y. and Gast, M. in Gast, M., Sigaut, F. (ed), Les techniques de conservation des grains à long terme (Paris 1979) 48–53, 113–16, 144–9, 150–8Google Scholar (esp. 155 for a peasant from Kattavià on Rhodes' description of building such a silo), 200 and 204 fig.6. For comparable examples from the western Mediterranean see Bazzana, A., Maisons d'Andalus (Madrid 1992) I.122–5Google Scholar; II, xliv pls. 66–8.

35 Rheidt, K., “Byzantinische Wohnhäuser des 11. bis 14. Jahrhunderts in Pergamon”, Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 44 (1990) 198–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar.