Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 December 2013
In 1968–69, three Phrygian tumuli in the vicinity of Ankara were excavated under the auspices of the Middle East Technical University and under the general supervision of Professor Ekrem Akurgal. The evidence from these tombs was initially examined from a purely archaeological standpoint. Recently, however, some of the metal findings were subjected to study through the application of physical and chemical analyses. The results have led to a re-examination of original conclusions drawn from the archaeological evidence.
In this paper, we present some of the results which have been obtained through these metallurgical analyses. But first, we would like to provide some general background information about the artifacts and about the locations at which they were found.
During the eighth and seventh centuries B.C. Ankara appears to have been the second most important Phrygian city after Gordion. Explorations in Ankara have revealed approximately twenty tumuli, dating from the eighth century to the middle of the sixth century B.C.
2 Buluç, S., Ankara Frig Nekropolünden üç Tümülüs Buluntuları, Ankara (dissertation, 1979)Google Scholar.
3 T. Makridy, Ankara Höyüklerindeki Hafriyata Dair Rapor, Maarif Vek. Mecmuası no. 6 (1926), 38–45; Koşay, H. Z., “Ankara Gazi Orman Fidanlıginda bulunan Eserler”, TTAED. I (1933), 5–20Google Scholar; Özgüç, T., “Anadolu'da Arkeoloji Arastırmaları” Belleten X/40 (1946), 585Google Scholar, Özgüç, T., Akok, M., “Anıt-Kabir Alanında Yapılan Tümülüs Kazıları” Belleten XI/41 (1947), 27–56Google Scholar.
4 S. Buluç., op. cit., 17, pl. 1.
5 S. Buluç, op. cit., 132–5.
6 For Mykonos bowls see Barnett, R. D., “The Nimrud Bowls in the British Museum” Rivista di Studi Fenici, II (1974), 20, pls. V, VIGoogle Scholar. For Olympia Bowls see Furtwangler, A., Olympia IV (1890), 141Google Scholar, no. 883, pl. 52; Kunze, E., “Ausgrabungen in Olympia, 1963/4”, Deltion 19 (1964), 168Google Scholar, pl. 172; Culican, W. “Coupes à decor phénicien provenants d'Iran”, Syria 47 (1970), 70CrossRefGoogle Scholar, fig. 2. For Iranian bowls see W. Culican, op. cit., pl. VIII, 2 and fig. 5; Porada, E. “Facets of Iranian Art”, Archaeology 17 (1964), 203Google Scholar; R. D. Barnett, op. cit., 20, n. 80.
7 R. D. Barnett, op. cit., Pl. III, p. 20 n. 80.
8 Nicholls, R. V. “Recent Acquisitions by the Fitzwilliam Museum”, Archaeological Reports for 1970–71 (BSA, 1971), 74–5, fig. 2Google Scholar; R. D. Barnett, op. cit., pl. VII, fig. 4.
9 Bissing, F. W. “Untersuchungen über die Phoinikischen Metallschalen”. JDAI 38–9 (1923–1924)Google Scholar; Gjerstad, E., “Decorated Metal Bowls from Cyprus” Opuscula arch. IV (1946), 1–18Google Scholar, Barnett, R. D., “Layard's Nimrud Bronzes and Their Inscriptions”, Eretz Israel 8 (1966–1967), 1*–6*Google Scholar.
10 Mallowan, M. E., Nimrud and Its Remains (1966), 428–9, Fig. 357Google Scholar. Taşyürek, O. A., “Adana ve Gaziantep Müzelerindeki Urartu Heykelcik ve Madeni Kapları”, T A D. 23.2 (1976), 113Google Scholar, Fig. 6.
11 Postgate, J. N., Iraq 35 (1973), 22–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Mellink, M. J., “Midas in Tyana” Florilegium Anatolicum, 255–7Google Scholar.
12 Goetze, A., Kleinasien (1933), 182–5Google Scholar.
13 Young, R., “Gordion on the Royal Road”, PAPS. 107 (1963), 357, n. 26Google Scholar; Young, R. “The Phrygian Contribution”, Xth International Congress of Classical Archaeology, 1973 (1978), 22Google Scholar.
14 Samples for testing were taken from the body and the intersection of mouldings and the body of fibulae.
15 Young, R., “The Phrygian Contribution”, Xth Int. Cong. Class. Arch. (1978), 20Google Scholar.
16 Muscarella, O. W., Phrygian Fibulae from Gordion (1967), 48Google Scholar.
17 Knudsen, A., A study of the Relation between Phrygian Metalwork, University of Pennsylvania (Ph.D. thesis, 1961), 81–4Google Scholar; O. W. Muscarella, op. cit., 50.
18 Young, R., “The Gordion Campaign of 1957”, AJA 62 (1958), p. 151CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Young, R., “Bronzes from Gordion's Royal Tomb”, Archaeology, 11 (1958), 228Google Scholar. A. Knudsen, op. cit., 45, 60.
19 The results of this analysis will be published in a book entitled Gordion Tombs by the Pennsylvania Museum. For this information we are grateful to Dr. Ellen Kohler of Pennsylvania Museum.