Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-30T15:08:23.017Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The apse decoration of the Akhiza cathedral: documents and materials in the museums of Georgia

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 February 2012

Zaza Skhirtladze
Zaza Skhirtladze
Affiliation:
Tbilisi State University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The meagre evidence, based on reports in sources and the material gleaned in the course of surveys by several researchers, of the fortress of Akhiza (northeast Turkey), which was renovated in the reign of King Vakhtang Gorgasali (446–522), and on the Episcopal See set up there, may be supplemented by archival material preserved at the Sh. Amiranashvili Museum of Art, as well as by recourse to the artefacts deposited at the S. Janashia Museum of Georgia, both in Tbilisi. In particular, a letter of A. Florenski, a collaborator with the Caucasian Museum in Tbilisi, written early in the 20th century to D. Gordeev (1889–1964) makes it clear that, at that time, a mosaic image of the Virgin Orans existed in the chancel of the ruined cathedral. According to Florenski, the mosaic was destroyed by a resident of Ardanuch, Usta-Gevork, at the beginning of the 20th century. Some of the material collected by Florenski from Akhiza (including a finger-ring with a cameo bearing the image of the Archangel Michael and distinguished for its high artistic features) found its way to St Petersburg, while two antefixes with representations of leaved crosses and deer, as well as up to three dozen mosaic tesserae are kept in the S. Janashia Museum of Georgia. At the time of the creation of the mosaic, it is worth noting that, after the Arab conquests (in the 730s), Akhiza, with its cathedral, must have ceased to exist as an Episcopal See. In this connection, the antefixes supply additional dating evidence, the artistic peculiarities of the images adorning them clearly pointing to the fifth to sixth century.

Özet

Kral Vakhtang Gorgasali (446–522) döneminde yenilenmiş ve piskoposlar tarafından idare olunan Akhiza Kalesi (kuzeydoğu Türkiye) hakkında hem yazılı kaynaklarda çok kısıtlı bilgi vardır, hem de yüzey araştırmaları sırasında sabırla toplanmış olan buluntular az sayıdadır. Bu kısıtlı bilgilerin her ikisin de Tiblis'de bulunan Sh. Amiranashvili Museum of Art daki arşiv belgeleri ve S. Janashia Museum of Georgia da bulunan fiziksel malzeme ile desteklenebileceğini düşünmekteyim. Tiblis'de bulunan Caucasian Museum üyesi, A. Florenski tarafından 20. yüzyılın başlarında D. Gordeev'e (1889–1964) yazılan bir mektup, mektubun yazıldığı dönemde yıkık durumdaki katedralin mihrap yerinde Virgin Orans a ait bir mozaiğin bulunduğunu ortaya koymaktadır. Florenski'ye göre mozaik Usta-Gevork isimli bir Ardanuch'lu tarafından 20. yüzyılın başında tahrip edilmiştir. Florenski tarafından Akhiza'dan toplanmış olan malzeme (kabartmasına Archangel Michael'ın bir resmi hakedilmiş olan kıymetli bir yüzük dahil olmak üzere) bir şekilde St Petersburg'a gitmiştir. Üzerinde yapraklarla sarılı haçlar ve geyikler bulunan iki antefix ile üç düzine mozaik ise S. Janashia Museum of Georgia tarafından sahiplenilmiştir. Mozaiğin yapıldığı tarihlerdeki şu durumun göz önüne alınması gereklidir. 730'lu yıllardaki Arap istilasının ardından Akhiza'nın piskoposlar tarafından idare ediliyor olması mümkün değildir. Bu bağlamda, antefixler bize daha doğru tarihleme yapabileceğimiz bilgiler sunmaktadır. Bu süslemeler çok net bir şekilde 5. ve 6. yüzyılları işaret eder.

Type
Research Article
Information
Anatolian Studies , Volume 59 , December 2009 , pp. 139 - 146
Copyright
Copyright © The British Institute at Ankara 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Aladashvili, N. 1983: ‘Altarkonchen-Kompositionen in den Kirchen Svanetiens’ in Beridze, V. (ed.), IV International Symposium on Georgian Art. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Aladashvili, N., Alibegashvili, G., Volskaja, A. 1983: Zhivopisnaja shkola Svaneti [School of the Mural Painting of Svaneti]. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Amiranashvili, Sh. 1925: ‘Kartuli kedlis mkhatvrobis dasuratebuli dednis fragmentebi’ [‘Fragments of the illuminated stencils of Georgian wall painting’] in Arili. Ferstschrift Dedicated to Ivane Javakhishvili. Tbilisi: 25–44Google Scholar
Baumgartner, B. 1996: Studien zur historischen Geographie von Tao-Klarjeti. PhD thesis, University of ViennaGoogle Scholar
Beridze, V. 1983: Arkhitektura Tao-Klardzeti [Architecture of Tao-Klarjeti]. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Chubinashvili, G. 1969: Tsromi. Iz istorii gruzinskoi arkhitektury pervoi treti VII veka [Tsromi. From the History of Georgian Architecture of the First Third of the Seventh Century]. MoscowGoogle Scholar
Chubinashvili, N. 1972: Khandisi. Problema rel'efa na primere odnoi gruppy gruzinskikh stel poslednei chetverti V veka, VI i pervoi poloviny VII veka [Khandisi. The Aspects of the Reliefs According to One Group of Stelae of the Fifth, Sixth and First Half of the Seventh Centuries]. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Djobadze, W. 1992: Early Medieval Georgian Monasteries in Historic Tao, Klarjeti and Šavšeti. StuttgartGoogle Scholar
Edwards, R. 1986: ‘The fortifications of Artvin: a second preliminary report on the marchlands of northeast Turkey’ Dumbarton Oaks Papers 40: 165–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gaprindashvili, G. 1976: ‘1089 tslis tsartsera mitsidzvris shesakheb garejis tsamebulis udabnos kharitonis kuabidan’ [‘The 1089 inscription on the earthquake from Khariton cave in the Tsamebuli monastery in the Gareja desert’] Proceedings of the Georgian Academy of Sciences, Series of History, Archaeology and Art 1976/2: 177–86Google Scholar
Merchule, Giorgi 1963: ‘Shromai da moghuatsebai ghirsad ckhorebisai tsmidisa da netarisa mamisa chuenisa grigolisi arkimandritisai khandztisa da shatberdisa aghmashenebelisai, da mis tana khsenebai mravalta mamata netartai’ [‘Life and labour and worthy activities of our holy and blessed father Grigol Archimandrite builder of Khandzta and Shatberdi, and the commemoration of many blessed fathers’] in Abuladze, I. (ed.), Dzveli kartuli agiograpiuli literaturis dzeglebi [Monuments of Ancient Georgian Hagiographic Literature] I. Tbilisi: 248–319Google Scholar
Gordeev, D. 1919: ‘Kratkii otchet o komandirovkakh v Kakhiju i Goriiski Uezd letom 1917 g.’ [‘Brief report on the mission to Kakheti and Gori districts in the summer of 1917’] Izvestija kavkazskogo otdelenija Moskovskogo Arkheologicheskogo Obshchestva 5: 1–26Google Scholar
Gordeev, D. 1923: ‘Otchet o poezdke v Akhaltsikhskij uezd v 1917 godu. Rospisi v Chule, Sapare i Zarzme’ [‘Report on travel in 1917 to the district of Akhaltsikhe; the murals of Ch'ule, Sapara and Zarzma’] Izvestija Kavkazskogo Istoriko-Arkheologicheskogo Instituta 1: 1–95Google Scholar
Gordeev, D. 1924: ‘Predvaritel'noe opisanie rospisi Khonskoi Georgievskoi baziliki’ [‘Preliminary description of the Church of St George at Khoni’] Saistorio moambe [Historical Bulletin] 2: 221–28Google Scholar
Gordeev, D. 1927: ‘K stilisticheskoi kharakteristike Martvilskoi Rospisi’ [‘Towards the stylistic analysis of Martvili murals’] in Naukovi Zapiski Naukovi Doslidchoi Katedri Istorii Ukrainskoi Kulturi. Kharkov: 357–64Google Scholar
Gordeev, D. 1928: ‘K voprosy o razgrupirovke emalei Khakhul'skogo skladnja’ [‘Concerning the distribution of the enamels of the Khakhuli tryptich’] Zbornik Kharkivskoi sektsii naukovo-doslidchoi katedri mistetstvoznatstva 1: 147–65Google Scholar
Gordeev, D. 1930: ‘Predvaritel'noe soobshchenie o Kintsvisskoi rospisi’ [‘Preliminary note on the murals of Kintsvisi’] in Naukovi Zapiski Naukovi Doslidchoi Katedri Istorii Ukrainskoi Kulturi. Kharkov: 711–16Google Scholar
Grabar, A. 1946: Martyrium. Recherches sur le culte des reliques et l'art chrétien antique II. ParisGoogle Scholar
Ihm, Ch. 1992: Die Programme der christlichen Apsismalerei vom 4. Jahrhundert bis zur Mitte des 8. Jahrhunderts. 2. durchgesehene und durch Zusatze erweiterte Auflage. StuttgartGoogle Scholar
Ingoroq'va, P. 1954: Giorgi Merchule. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Izvestija Kavkazskogo Muzeja [Proceedings of the Caucasian Museum] 1915: 4/1–2Google Scholar
Japaridze, V. 1982: Adreuli shua saukuneebis arkeologiuri dzeglebi kvemo kartlidan [Early Medieval Archaeological Monuments from Lower Kartli]. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Juansher, , Tskhovrebai Vakhtang Gorgasalisa [The Life of Vakhtang Gorgasali]: Qaukhchishvili, S. (ed.), Kartlis Tskhovreba [The Life of Georgia/Georgian Chronicle]. Tbilisi 1955: I, 139–244Google Scholar
Kakabadze, S. 1924: ‘Kartuli sakhelmtsipoebriobis genezisis sakitkhebi’ [‘Aspects of the genesis of Georgian statehood’] Saistorio Moambe [Historical Bulletin] 1: 1–120Google Scholar
Kekelidze, K. 1957: ‘Kanonikuri tsq'obileba dzvel sakartveloshi’ [‘Canonical system in old Georgia’], in Etiudebi dzveli kartuli literaturis istoriidan [Studies in Old Georgian Literature] IV. Tbilisi: 326–57Google Scholar
Khoshtaria, D. 2005: Klarjetis eklesiebi da monastrebi [Churches and Monasteries in Klarjeti]. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Koch, K. 1846: Wanderungen im Oriente wahrend der Jahre 1843–1844 II. WeimarGoogle Scholar
Kondakov, N. 1914: Ikonografija Bogomateri [Iconography of the Virgin] I. St PetersburgGoogle Scholar
Lafontaine-Dosogne, J. 1972: ‘L'église rupestre dite Eski Baka Kilisesi et la place de la Vierge dans les absides cappadociennes’ Jahrbuch der Österreichischen Byzantinistik 21: 163–70Google Scholar
Rapp, S. 2003: Studies in Medieval Georgian Historiography: Early Texts and Eurasian Contexts (Corpus Scriptorum Christianorum Orientalium 601, Subsidia 113). LouvainGoogle Scholar
Sheviakova, T. 1959: ‘K datirovke rospisi tserkvi Nesgun’ [‘Concerning the dating of Nesguni church wall painting’] Bulletin of the Georgian Academy of Sciences 23/1: 115–20Google Scholar
Sheviakova, T. 1983: Monumental'naja zhivopis’ rannego srednevekov'ja Gruzii [Early Medieval Georgian Wall Painting]. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Skhirtladze, Z. 1985: Sabereebis preskuli tsartserebi [The Mural Inscriptions of Sabereebi]. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Skhirtladze, Z. 1991: ‘A propos du decor absidal de C'romi’ Revue des études géorgiennes et caucasiennes 6–7: 163–83Google Scholar
Skhirtladze, Z. 1997: ‘Early medieval Georgian monumental painting: establishment of the system of church decoration’ Oriens Christianus 81: 169–206Google Scholar
Skhirtladze, Z. 1999: ‘Under the sign of the triumph of holy cross: Telovani church original decoration and its iconographic programme’ Cahiers Archéologiques 47: 101–18Google Scholar
Skhirtladze, Z. 2001: ‘Newly discovered early paintings in the Gareja Desert’ in Eastmond, A. (ed.), Eastern Approaches to Byzantium (Society for the Promotion of Byzantine Studies Publications 9). Aldershot: 149–67Google Scholar
Smirnov, Ja. 1935: Tsromskaja mozaika [The Mosaic of Tsromi]. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
dze, Sumbat Davitis, Tskhovreba da utsq'eba Bagrationta [Life and History of the Bagrationis]: Qaukhchishvili, S. (ed.), Kartlis Tskhovreba [The Life of Georgia/Georgian Chronicle]. Tbilisi 1955: I, 372–86Google Scholar
Thierry, M. 1989: ‘Topographie et état actuel des monuments Géorgiens en Turquie orientale’ Revue des études géorgiennes et caucasiennes 5: 129–67Google Scholar
Thomson, R.W. 1996: Rewriting Caucasian History: The Medieval Armenian Adaptation of the Georgian Chronicles. OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tsamebai da ghuatsli tsmidata da didebulta motsameta Davit da Konstantinesi [The Martyrdom and Acts of Holy and Glorious Martyrs David and Constantine]: Abuladze, I. (ed.), Dzveli Kartuli agiograpiuli literaturis dzeglebi [Monuments of Ancient Georgian Hagiographic Literature]. Tbilisi 1971: III, 248–64Google Scholar
Tsamebai tsmidisa da didebulisa motsamisa Archilisi, romeli-ese iq'o mepe Kartls [Martyrdom of the Holy and Glorious Martyr Archil, Who was a King in Kartli]: Qaukhchishvili, S. (ed.), Kartlis Tskhovreba [The Life of Georgia/Georgian Chronicle]. Tbilisi 1955: I, 245–48Google Scholar
Tshubinaschwili, G. 1921: Untersuchungen zur Geschichte der georgischen Baukunst. Bd. I, Hf. 1: Die Kirche des Heiligen Kreuzes von Mzcheta. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Tshubinaschwili, G. 1948: Pamjatniki tipa Djvari [Monuments of the Type of Jvari]. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Volskaja, A. 1988: ‘Rospisi peshchernykh monastyrei David-Garedji’ [‘Paintings in the rock-cut monasteries of David Gareja’] in Pitskhelauri, K. (ed.), Gareji. Proceedings of the Kakheti Archaeological Expedition VIII. Tbilisi: 130–55Google Scholar
Volskaja, A. 1983: ‘Peintures anciennes de Gareja’ in Beridze, V., Proceedings of the IV International Symposium on Georgian Art. TbilisiGoogle Scholar
Volskaja, A. 1991: ‘Izobrazhenie Bogomateri “Umilenije” v gruzinskom srednevekovom iskusstve (X – nach. XIII vv.)’ [‘Image of the Virgin ’Eleousa” in medieval Georgian Art (10th to beginning of the 13th century)’] Ars Georgica 10: 165–70Google Scholar