Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T08:03:41.645Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Historical Contingencies, Issues of Scale, and Flightless Hypotheses: A Response to Hildebrandt et al.

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

Terry L. Jones  and
Brian F. Codding
Terry L. Jones
Affiliation:
Department of Social Sciences, California Polytechnic State University San Luis Obispo, CA 93407 ([email protected])
Brian F. Codding
Affiliation:
Department of Anthropology, Stanford University, 450 Serra Mall, Building 50, Stanford, CA 94305-2034 ([email protected])
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Hildebrandt et al. offer this rather vitriolic challenge to our conclusions on the Diablo Canyon fauna in order to recast the data in favor of their view that major diachronic trends in western North American prehistory are the product of an increase in men's prestige hunting over time. Here we respond, first by discussing our view of the relationship between historical contingencies and behavioral ecological models, second by showing that the patterns they find in a regional faunal dataset result only from inappropriate aggregation of bone counts, third by questioning the potential prestige value of highly vulnerable species, and finally by making the case that standard behavioral ecological models, punctuated by historical contingencies, provide more parsimonious, albeit less fanciful, explanations for patterning in the western North American faunal record. We conclude by suggesting that when practitioners attempt to explain away empirical variability in order to support a favored hypothesis, it might be time to acknowledge that the hypothesis has failed to take flight.

Resumen

Resumen

Hildebrandt y colegas ofrecen este desafío bastante mordaz a nuestras conclusiones en la fauna de Cañón de Diablo para refundir los datos a favor de su vista que tendencias diacrónicas mayores en la prehistoria norteamericana occidental son el producto de un aumento en el prestigio de hombres que caza con el tiempo. Aquí respondemos, primero discutiendo nuestra vista de la relación entre contingencias y modelos históricas ecológicos conductistas, segundo mostrando que las pautas ellos encuentran en un resultado regional de dataset de faunal sólo de agregado inadecuada de condes de hueso, el tercero preguntando el valor potencial de prestigio de la especie sumamente vulnerable, y por último haciendo el caso que modelos ecológicos, conductistas y estándar, puntuado por contingencias históricas, proporciona más parco, aunque menos imaginario, Las explicaciones para modelar en el registro norteamericano occidental de faunal. Concluimos sugiriendo cuándo facultativos procuran justificar la variabilidad empírica para apoyar una hipótesis favorecida, quizás sea tiempo de reconocer que la hipótesis ha fallado de huir.

Type
Comments
Information
American Antiquity , Volume 75 , Issue 3 , July 2010 , pp. 689 - 699
Copyright
Copyright © Society for American Archaeology 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References Cited

Basgall, Mark E. 2006 Eligibility Assessments for Eight Prehistoric Archaeological Sites at Camp Roberts an Camp San Luis Obispo, San Luis Obispo and Monterey Counties, California. Copies available from the California Historic Resources Information System, Central Coast Information Center, University of California, Santa Barbara.Google Scholar
Binford, Lewis 1980 Willow’s Smoke and Dog’s Tails: Hunter-gatherer settlement systems and archaeological site formation. American Antiquity 45:4–20.Google Scholar
Bird, Douglas W., and O’Connell, James F. 2006 Human Behavioral Ecology and Archaeology. Journal of Archaeological Research 14:143–18.Google Scholar
Bird, Douglas W., Bliege Bird, Rebecca, and Codding, Brian F. 2009 In Pursuit of Mobile Prey: Martu Hunting Strategies and Archaeofaunal Interpretation. American Antiquity 74:3–29.Google Scholar
Bliege Bird, Rebecca, and Bird, Douglas W. 2008 Why Women Hunt: Risk And Contemporary Foraging in a Western Desert Aboriginal Community. Current Anthropology 49:655–693.Google Scholar
Bliege Bird, Rebecca, and Bird, Douglas W. 1997 Delayed Reciprocity and Tolerated Theft: The Behavioral Ecology Of Food Sharing Strategies. Current Anthropology 38:49–78.Google Scholar
Broughton, Jack M., and Bayham, Frank E. 2003 Showing Off, Foraging Models, and the Ascendance of Large-Game Hunting in the California Middle Archaic. American Antiquity 68:783–789.Google Scholar
Broughton, Jack M., Byers, David A., Bryson, Reid A., Eckerle, William, and Madsen, David B. 2008 Did Climatic Seasonality Control Late Quaternary Artiodactyl Densities in Western North America? Quaternary Science Reviews 27:1916–1937.Google Scholar
Byers, David A., and Broughton, Jack M. 2004 Holocene Environmental Change, Artiodactyl Abundances, and Human Hunting Strategies in the Great Basin. American Antiquity 69:235–256.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Byers, David A., Smith, C. S., and Broughton, Jack M. 2005 Holocene Artiodactyl Population Histories and Large Game Hunting in the Wyoming Basin, USA. Journal of Archaeological Science 32:125–142.Google Scholar
Cannon, Michael D. 2000 Large Mammal Relative Abundance in Pithouse and Pueblo Period Archaeofaunas from Southwestern New Mexico: Resource Depression among the Mimbres-Mogollon? Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 19:317–347.Google Scholar
Cannon, Michael D. 2001 Archaeofaunal Relative Abundance, Sample Size, and Statistical Methods. Journal of Archaeological Science 28:185–195.Google Scholar
Carpenter, D., Nicholson, D., and Zeanah, D. W. 2007 Archaeological Evaluations of Twelve Prehistoric Properties on Camp San Luis Obispo and Camp Roberts, San Luis Obispo County, California. Archaeological Research Center, Department of Anthropology, California State University, Sacramento. MS available from California’s Historic Resources Information System, Central Coast Information Center, University of California, Santa Barbara.Google Scholar
Codding, Brian E, and Jones, Terry L. 2007a Man the Showoff? Or the Ascendance of a Just-So Story: A Comment on Recent Applications of Costly Signaling in American Archaeology. American Antiquity 72:39–357.Google Scholar
Codding, Brian E, and Jones, Terry L. 2007b History and Behavioral Ecology during the Middle-Late Transition on the Central California Coast: Findings from the Coon Creek Site (CA-SLO-9), San Luis Obispo County. Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology 27:23–49.Google Scholar
Diamond, Jared 2005 Collapse. Penguin Books, New York.Google Scholar
Garlinghouse, Thomas S., and Farquhar, Jennifer M. 2005 Archaeological Evaluations of Four Sites at Camp Roberts, Monterey and San Luis Obispo Counties, California. MS available from the California Historic Resources Information System, Central Coast Information Center, University of California, Santa Barbara.Google Scholar
Gurven, Michael, and Hill, Kim 2009 Why do Men Hunt? A Reevaluation of “Man the Hunter” and the Sexual Division of Labor. CurrentAnthropology 50:51–74.Google Scholar
Harro, Douglas R., Lebow, Clayton G., McKim, Rebecca L., Ryan, Christopher, and Denardo, Carole 2000 Eligibility Testing at CA SBA 935, -2321, and -2345 for El Niño Related Road Repairs, Vandenberg Air Force Base, California. Applied Earthworks, Inc., Fresno, California, for Tetra Tech, Inc., Santa Barbara, California. Submitted to 30 CES/CEV, Vandenberg Air Force Base, California, US AF Contract No. F04684-95-C-0045, Work Request No. 33.Google Scholar
Heizer, Robert F. 1978 Trade and Trails. In California, edited by R. F. Heizer, pp. 690–693. Handbook of North American Indians, Vol. 8, William C. Sturtevant, general editor, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. Google Scholar
Hildebrandt, William R., and McGuire, Kelly R. 2002 The Ascendance of Hunting during the California Middle Archaic: an Evolutionary Perspective. American Antiquity 67:231–256.Google Scholar
Hildebrandt, William R., and McGuire, Kelly R. 2003 Large-Game Hunting, Gender-Differentiated Work Organization, and the Role of Evolutionary Ecology in California and Great Basin Prehistory: A Reply to Broughton and Bayham. American Antiquity 68:790–792.Google Scholar
Hockett, Bryan 2005 Middle and Late Holocene Hunting in the Great Basin: A Critical Review of the Debate and Future Prospects. American Antiquity 70:713–731.Google Scholar
Jones, Terry L. 1993 Big Sur: A Keystone in Central California Culture History. Pacific Coast Archaeological Society Quarterly 29:1–78.Google Scholar
Jones, Terry L. 2003 Prehistoric Human Ecology of the Big Sur Coast, California. Berkeley: Contributions of the University of California Archaeological Research Facility No. 61.Google Scholar
Jones, Terry L., and Ferneau, Jennifer A. 2002 Prehistory at San Simeon Reef: Archaeological Data Recovery at CA-SLO-179 and -267, San Luis Obispo County, California. San Luis Obispo County Archaeological Society Occasional Papers no. 16.Google Scholar
Jones, Terry L., Porcasi, Judith F., Gaeta, Jereme, and Codding, Brian F. 2008 Diablo Canyon Fauna: A Coarse-grained Record of Trans-Holocene Foraging from the Central California Mainland Coast. American Antiquity 73:289–316.Google Scholar
Jones, T.L., Porcasi, J. F., Erlandson, J. M., Dallas, H. Jr., Wake, T. A., Schwaderer, R. 2008 The Protracted Holocene Extinction of California’s Flightless Sea Duck (Chendytes lawi) and its Implications for the Pleistocene Overkill Hypothesis. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 105:4105–4108.Google Scholar
Jones, Terry L., Stevens, Nathan E., Jones, Deborah A., Fitzgerald, Richard T., and Hylkema, Mark G. 2007 The Central Coast: A Mid-Latitude Milieu. In California Prehistory: Colonization, Culture, and Complexity, edited by Terry L. Jones and Kathryn A. Klar, pp. 125–146. Altamira Press, Walnut Creek, California.Google Scholar
Jones, Terry L., Brown, Gary M., Mark Raab, L., McVickar, Janet L., W. Geoff., Spaulding, Kennett, Douglas J., York, Andrew, and Walker, Phillip L. 1999 Environmental Imperatives Reconsidered, Demographic Crises in Western North America during the Medieval Climatic Anomaly. Current Anthropology 40:137–170.Google Scholar
Kennett, Douglas J. 2005 The Island Chumash: Behavioral Ecology of a Maritime Society. University of California Press, Berkeley.Google Scholar
Kenyon, Karl W. 1981 Sea Otter—Enhydra lutris. In Handbook of Marine Mammals, edited by Sam H. Ridgway and Richard J. Harrison F.R.S., pp. 209–223. Academic Press, San Francisco.Google Scholar
Lebow, Clayton G., McKim, Rebecca L., Harro, Douglas R., Munns, Ann M., and Denardo, Carole 2007 Littoral Adaptations throughout the Holocene: Archaeological Investigations at the Honda Beach Site (CA-SBA-530). MS on file at the California Historic Resources Information System, Central Coast Information Center, University of California, Santa Barbara.Google Scholar
Lebow, Clayton G., McKim, Rebecca L., Harro, Douglas R., and Munns, Ann M. 2006 Lithic Technology. In Prehistoric Land Use in the Casmalia Hills throughout the Holocene: Archaeological Investigations along CombarRoad, Vandenberg Air Force Base, Santa Barbara County, California. MS on file at the California Historic Resources Information System, Central Coast Information Center, University of California, Santa Barbara.Google Scholar
Lebow, Clayton G., Harro, Douglas R., McKim, R. L., Munns, A. M., Denardo, C., Onken, J. and Bury, R. 2005 The Archaeology and Rock Art of Swordfish Cave (CA-SBA-503), Vandenberg Air Force Base, SantaBarbara County, California. MS on file at the California Historic Resources Information System, Central Coast Information Center, University of California, Santa Barbara.Google Scholar
Lebow, Clayton G., McKim, Rebecca L., Harro, Douglas R., Hodges, C. M. and Munns, Ann M. 2005 Large Game Hunting and Other Paludal Adaptations at Barka Slough: Excavations at CA-SBA-1010, Vandenberg Air Force Base, Santa Barbara County, California. MS on file at the California Historic Resources Information System, Central Coast Information Center, University of California, Santa Barbara.Google Scholar
Levin, Simon A. 1992 The Problem of Pattern and Scale in Ecology: The Robert H. MacArthur Award Lecture. Ecology 73:1943–1967.Google Scholar
Lupo, Karen D. 2007 Evolutionary Foraging Models in Zooarchaeological Analysis: Recent Applications and Future Challenges. Journal of Archaeological Research 15:143–189.Google Scholar
Lyman, R. Lee 2003 The Influence of Time Averaging and Space Averaging on the Application of Foraging Theory in Zooarchaeology. Journal of Archaeological Science 30:595–610.Google Scholar
McGuire, Kelly R., and Hildebrandt, William R. 1994 The Possibilities of Women and Men: Gender and the California Millingstone Horizon. Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology 16:41–59.Google Scholar
McGuire, Kelly R., and Hildebrandt, William R. 2005 Re-Thinking Great Basin Foragers: Prestige Hunting and Costly Signaling during the Middle Archaic Period. American Antiquity 70:695–712.Google Scholar
McGuire, Kelly R., Hildebrandt, William R., and Carpenter, Kimberly L. 2007 Costly Signaling and the Ascendance of No-Can-Do Archaeology: A Reply to Codding and Jones. American Antiquity 27:349–358.Google Scholar
Ogden, A. 1941 The California Sea Otter Trade: 1784–1884. University of California Press, Los Angeles.Google Scholar
Robinson, W.S. 1950 Ecological Correlations and the Behavior of Individuals. American Sociological Review 15:351–357 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosenthal, Jeffery S. and Fitzgerald, Rick T. 2009 The Paleo-Archaic Transition in Western California. In On the Brink, Transformations in Human Organization and Adaptation at the Pleistocene-Holocene Boundary in North America, edited by B. Bousman and B. Vierra, Texas A&M University Press, College Station, in press. Google Scholar
Sanchez, Thomas 1973 Rabbit Boss. Knopf Press, New York.Google Scholar
Schneider, David C. 2001 The Rise of the Concept of Scale in Ecology. Bio-science 51:545–553.Google Scholar
Shennan, Stephen 1997 Quantifying Archaeology. 2nd ed. University of Iowa Press, Iowa City.Google Scholar
Steadman, David W. 1995 Prehistoric Extinctions of Pacific Island Birds: Biodiversity Meets Zooarchaeology Science 267:1123–1131.Google Scholar
Turner, Monica G., O’Neil, Robert V., Gardner, Robert H., and Milne, Bruce T. 1989 Effects of Changing Spatial Scale on the Analysis of Landscape Pattern. Landscape Ecology 3:153–162.Google Scholar
Whitaker, Adrian R. 2008 The Role of Human Predation in the Structuring of Prehistoric Prey Populations in Northwestern California. Unpublished PhD Dissertation. Department of Anthropology, University of California, Davis.Google Scholar
Whitaker, Adrian R. 2009 Are Deer Really Susceptible to Resource Depression? Modeling Deer (Odocoileus hemionus) Populations under Human Predation. California Archaeology 1:93–108.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wiessner, Polly 2002 Hunting, Healing, and Hxaro Exchange: A Long-Term Perspective on !Kung (Ju/’hoansi) Large-Game Hunting. Evolution and Human Behavior 23:407–436.Google Scholar
Zeanah, David W 2004 Sexual Division of Labor and Central Place Foraging: A Model for the Carson Desert of Western Nevada. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 23:1–32.Google Scholar