Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-02T21:00:40.623Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Deconstructing Characterizations of Rape, Marriage, and Custom in South Africa: Revisiting The Multi-Sectoral Campaign Against Ukuthwala

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 March 2020

Nyasha Karimakwenda Open the ORCID record for Nyasha Karimakwenda [Opens in a new window]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

A critique of multi-sectoral responses to the customary practice of ukuthwala (the isiXhosa term for abduction for purposes of marriage) in South Africa highlights attention to gendered tropes pertaining to marriage, custom, and sexual assault. Karimakwenda deconstructs how, in its inflexible framing of customary practice, the multi-sectoral campaign against violent forms of ukuthwala lacks historicization and silences women’s narratives. By obscuring historical and locally-embedded linkages between marriage practices and rape, the myopic campaign energizes collective anxieties around representations of violence within Black communities, and fuels misconceptions surrounding marital rape. This critique contributes to debates about gender, violence, and state power by offering a counter-narrative to simplified characterizations of sexual violence and custom.

Résumé

Résumé

une critique des réponses multisectorielles à la pratique coutumière de l'ukuthwala (le terme isiXhosa pour l'enlèvement à des fins de mariage) en Afrique du Sud met en évidence l'attention portée aux tropes sexospécifiques concernant le mariage, la coutume et l'agression sexuelle. Karimakwenda déconstruit comment, dans son cadre inflexible de la pratique coutumière, la campagne multisectorielle contre les formes violentes d’ukuthwala manque d’historicisation et réduit au silence les récits des femmes. En masquant les liens historiques et ancrés localement entre les pratiques matrimoniales et le viol, cette campagne à courte vue alimente les angoisses collectives autour des représentations de la violence au sein des communautés noires et alimente les idées fausses entourant le viol conjugal. Cette critique contribue aux débats sur le genre, la violence et le pouvoir de l'État en offrant un contre-récit à des caractérisations simplifiées de la violence sexuelle et de la coutume.

Resumo

Resumo

Análise crítica das respostas multissetoriais à prática comum da ukuthwala (palavra xossa para designar o rapto com fins de casamento), na África do Sul, Karimakwenda sublinha a sua relação com o casamento, a tradição e a violência sexual. A autora demonstra que, devido ao modo inflexível como enquadra as práticas tradicionais, a campanha multissetorial contra as formas violentas da ukuthwala é desprovida de contextualização histórica e silencia as narrativas femininas. Ao ignorar as profundas ligações históricas e locais entre práticas de casamento e violação, a visão limitada da campanha potencia a ansiedade coletiva em torno das representações de violência entre as comunidades negras, e suscita vários equívocos acerca da violação marital. Esta análise crítica contribui para os debates acerca das questões de género, da violência e do poder do Estado, propondo uma contranarrativa para as caracterizações simplistas da violência sexual e da tradição.

Keywords

rapecustomukuthwalamarriageSouth Africasexual violence
Type
Article
Information
African Studies Review , Volume 63 , Issue 4 , December 2020 , pp. 763 - 781
Copyright
© African Studies Association, 2020

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

African News Agency. “DA refers alleged racist remarks by Judge Mabel Jansen to JSC.” Mail and Guardian, May 9. http://mg.co.za/article/2016-05-09-da-refers-alleged-racist-remarks-by-judge-mabel-jansen-to-jsc.Google Scholar
Bennett, Tom. 1991. A Sourcebook of African Customary Law for Southern Africa. Cape Town: Juta.Google Scholar
Bennett, Tom. 2010. “The Cultural Defence and the Custom of Thwala in South African Law.” University of Botswana Law Journal 10: 3–26.Google Scholar
Boonzaier, Floretta. 2001. Woman Abuse: Exploring Women’s Narratives of Violence and Resistence in Mitchell’s Plain. MA. diss., University of Cape Town.Google Scholar
Bridger, Emily. 2018. “Soweto’s Female Comrades: Gender, Youth, and Violence in South Africa’s Township Uprisings, 1984–1990” Journal of Southern African Studies 44(4): 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bunting, Annie Lawrance, Benjamin, and Roberts, Richard, eds. 2016. Marriage by Force?: Contestation Over Consent and Coercion in Africa. Athens: Ohio University Press.Google Scholar
Chanock, Martin. 1991. “Law, State and Culture: Thinking About Customary Law after Apartheid.” Acta Juridica: 52–70.Google Scholar
Choma, Hlako. 2011. “Ukuthwala Custom in South Africa: A Constitutional Test.” US-China Law Review 8: 874–78.Google Scholar
Department of Justice and Constitutional Development (DoJCD). “Ukuthwala.” http://www.justice.gov.za/brochure/ukuthwala/ukuthwala.html.Google Scholar
Diala, Anthony. 2017. “The Concept of Living Customary Law: A Critique.” The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law 49(2): 143–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Engle Merry, Sally. 1998. “Law, Culture, and Cultural Appropriation.” Yale Journal of Law & the Humanities 10: 575–603.Google Scholar
George, Zine. 2018. “Eastern Cape’s Shame over Ukuthwala.” Dispatch Live, July 12. https://www.dispatchlive.co.za/news/2018-07-12-e-capes-shame-over-ukuthwala/.Google Scholar
Gobodo-Madikizela, Pumla. 2000. Legacies of Violence: An In-Depth Analysis of Two Case Studies Based on Interviews with Perpetrators of a “Necklace” Murder and with Eugene de Kock. Ph.D. diss., University of Cape Town.Google Scholar
Gqola, Pumla. 2007. “How the ‘Cult of Femininity’and Violent Masculinities Support Endemic Gender Based Violence in Contemporary South Africa.” African Identities 5(1): 111–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hodgson, Dorothy. 2017. “Africa From the Margins.” African Studies Review 60(2): 37–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jezile v. the State and Others (A 127/2014) 2015 ZAWCHC.Google Scholar
Judge, Melanie. 2018. Blackwashing homophobia: Violence and the Politics of Gender, Sexuality and Race. Oxford: Routledge.Google Scholar
Karimakwenda, Nyasha. 2013. “‘Today It Would Be Called Rape’: A Historical and Contextual Examination of Forced Marriage and Violence in the Eastern Cape.” In Marriage, Land and Custom: Essays on Law and Social Change in South Africa, edited by Claassens, Aninka and Smythe, Dee, 339–56. Claremont: Juta.Google Scholar
Kottler, Sharon. 1998. Wives’ Subjective Definitions of and Attitudes Towards Wife Rape. MA. diss., UNISA.Google Scholar
Koyana, Digby, and Bekker, Jan. 2007. “The Indomitable Ukuthwala Custom.” De Jure 40: 139–44.Google Scholar
Mabasa, Diana. 2015. “Ukuthwala: Is It All Culturally Relative?” De Rebus 555: 28–30.Google Scholar
Maduna, Lizeka. 2017. “Ukuthwala: The Sex Trafficking Scandal Devastating Rural South Africa.” Mail and Guardian, November 29. https://mg.co.za/article/2017-11-29-ukuthwala-the-sex-trafficking-scandal-devastating-rural-south-africa.Google Scholar
Magaziner, Daniel. 2010. The Law and the Prophets: Black Consciousness in South Africa, 1968–1977. Athens: Ohio University Press.Google Scholar
Mager, Anne. 1999. Gender and the Making of a South African Bantustan: A Social History of the Ciskei, 1945–1959. Oxford: James Currey.Google Scholar
Malan, Mia. 2011. “Abduction a Perversion of the Past.” Mail and Guardian, December 15. https://bhekisisa.org/article/2011-12-15-abduction-a-perversion-of-the-past.Google Scholar
Maluleke, Joyce. 2012. “Culture, Tradition, Custom, Law and Gender Equality.” Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal/Potchefstroomse Elektroniese Regsblad 15(1): 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mfono, Zanele. 2000. “The Custom of Bride Abduction Holds Its Own against Time.” Agenda 45: 76–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mgidlana, Roberta. 2017. “Should South Africa Criminalise Ukuthwala Leading to Forced and Child Marriages?” Paper presented at Centre for Social Science Research Seminar, University of Cape Town, May 23.Google Scholar
Mitchell, Don. 1995. “There's No Such Thing as Culture: Towards a Reconceptualization of the Idea of Culture in Geography.” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers: 102–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mnisi-Weeks, Sindiso. 2010. The Interface between Living Customary Law(s) of Succession and South African State Law. DPhil diss., University of Oxford.Google Scholar
Moffett, Helen. 2006. “‘These Women, They Force Us to Rape Them’: Rape as Narrative of Social Control in Post-Apartheid South Africa.” Journal of Southern African Studies 32(1): 129–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Monyane, Chelete. 2013. “Is Ukuthwala Another Form of ‘Forced Marriage’?” South African Review of Sociology 44(3): 64–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moore, Elena. 2019. “‘My Husband Has to Stop Beating Me and I Shouldn’t Go to the Police’: Family Meetings, Patriarchal Bargains, and Marital Violence in the Eastern Cape Province, South Africa.” Violence Against Women: 1–22.Google Scholar
Motsemme, Nthabiseng 2004. “The Mute Always Speak: On Women’s Silences at the Truth and Reconciliation Commission.” Current Sociology 52(5): 909–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mubangizi, John Cantius. 2012. “A South African Perspective on the Clash between Culture and Human Rights, with Particular Reference to Gender-Related Cultural Practices and Traditions.” Journal of International Women's Studies 13(3): 33–48.Google Scholar
Mwambene, Lea, and Sloth-Nielsen, Julia. 2011. “Benign Accommodation? Ukuthwala, ‘Forced Marriage’ and the South African Children’s Act.” African Human Rights Law Journal 11(1): 1–22.Google Scholar
Mwambene, Lea, and Kruuse, Helen. 2017. “The Thin Edge of the Wedge: Ukuthwala, Alienation and Consent.” South African Journal on Human Rights 33(1): 25–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ndou, Clive. 2015. “Ukuthwala Still Rife in KZN.” The Citizen, June 11. https://citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/401096/ukuthwala-still-rife-in-kzn/.Google Scholar
Nkosi, Makho, and Wassermann, Johan. 2014. “A History of the Practice of Ukuthwala in the Natal/Kwazulu-Natal Region up to 1994.” New Contree 70: 131–46.Google Scholar
Odendal, Lesley. 2011. “Forcing the Issue.” Mail and Guardian, April 4. https://mg.co.za/article/2011-04-04-forcing-the-issue.Google Scholar
Peires, Jeff. 2014. “History Versus Customary Law: Commission on Traditional Leadership: Disputes and Claims.” South African Crime Quarterly 49: 7–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ratele, Kopano. 2013. “Masculinities without Tradition.” Politikon: South African Journal of Political Studies 40(1): 133–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Razack, Sherene. 2004. “Imperilled Muslim Women, Dangerous Muslim Men and Civilised Europeans: Legal and Social Responses to Forced Marriages.” Feminist Legal Studies 12(2): 129–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rice, Kate. 2014. “Ukuthwala in Rural South Africa: Abduction Marriage as a Site of Negotiation About Gender, Rights and Generational Authority among the Xhosa.” Journal of Southern African Studies 40(2): 381–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rice, Kate. 2018. “Understanding Ukuthwala: Bride Abduction in the Rural Eastern Cape, South Africa.” African Studies 77(3): 394–411.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shadle, Brett. 2008. “Rape in the Courts of Gusiiland, Kenya, 1940s–1960s.” African Studies Review 51(2): 27–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simons, Harold. 1968. African Women: Their Legal Status in South Africa. London: Hurst.Google Scholar
Singleton, Judith. 2012. “The South African Sexual Offences Act and Local Meanings of Coercion and Consent in Kwazulu Natal: Universal Human Rights?” African Studies Review 55(2): 59–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smit, W.J. 2016. “Rights, Violence and the Marriage of Confusion: Re-Emerging Bride Abduction in South Africa.” Anthropology Southern Africa 40(1): 56–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smit, W.J., and Notermans, Catrien. 2015. “Surviving Change by Changing Violently: Ukuthwala in South Africa's Eastern Cape Province.” Anthropology Southern Africa 38(1–2): 29–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Soga, J.H. 1931. The Ama-Xhosa: Life and Customs. Lovedale: Lovedale Press.Google Scholar
South African Law Reform Commission (SALRC). 2015. The Practice of Ukuthwala (Project 138) Discussion Paper 138.Google Scholar
Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. 1988. “Can the Subaltern Speak?” In Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture, edited by Nelson, Cary and Grossberg, Lawrence 271–313. Urbana: University of Illinois.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tamale, Sylvia. 2008. “The Right to Culture and the Culture of Rights: A Critical Perspective on Women’s Sexual Rights in Africa.” Feminist Legal Studies 16: 47–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thlabi, Redi. 2017. Khwezi. Cape Town: Jonathan Ball.Google Scholar
Thornberry, Elizabeth. 2011. Colonialism and Consent: Rape in South Africa’s Eastern Cape, 1847–1902. Ph.D. diss., Stanford University.Google Scholar
Thornberry, Elizabeth. 2016. “Ukuthwala, Forced Marriage, and the Idea of Custom in South Africa’s Eastern Cape.” In Marriage by Force?: Contestation over Consent and Coercion in Africa, edited by Bunting, Annie Lawrance, Benjamin, and Roberts, Richard 137–58. Athens: Ohio University Press.Google Scholar
Thornberry, Elizabeth. 2018. Colonizing Consent: Rape and Governance in South Africa’s Eastern Cape. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
van der Watt, Marcel, and Ovens, Michelle. 2012. “Contextualizing the Practice of Ukuthwala within South Africa.” Child Abuse Research in South Africa 13(1): 11–26.Google Scholar
van der Westhuizen, Christi. 2017. Sitting Pretty: White Afrikaans Women in Postapartheid South Africa. Pietermaritzburg: UKZN Press.Google Scholar
van Tromp, J. 1947. Xhosa Law of Persons: A Treatise on the Legal Principles of Family Relations among the Xhosa. Cape Town: Juta.Google Scholar
Volpp, Leti. 2000. “Blaming Culture for Bad Behavior.” Yale Journal of Law & the Humanities 12: 89–116.Google Scholar
Wadesango, Newman, Rembe, Symphorosa, and Chabaya, Owence. 2011. “Violation of Women’s Rights by Harmful Traditional Practices.” The Anthropologist 13(2): 121–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wilson, Monica. 1981. “Xhosa Marriage in Historical Perspective.” In Essays on African Marriage in Southern Africa, edited by Krige, Eileen and Comaroff, John, 133–47. Cape Town: Juta.Google Scholar
Wood, Kate. 2005. “Contextualizing Group Rape in Post‐Apartheid South Africa.” Culture, Health & Sexuality 7(4): 303–17.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Yllö, , , Kersti, and Torres, M. Gabriela. 2016. Marital Rape: Consent, Marriage, and Social Change in Global Context. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar