Hostname: page-component-669899f699-rg895 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-04-29T06:43:16.944Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Debating the Bascom controversy: revisiting the expropriation and repatriation of the Ifẹ̀ bronzes

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 May 2024

Tomos Llywelyn Evans
Tomos Llywelyn Evans*
Affiliation:
Dumbarton Oaks, Washington DC, USA College of William & Mary, Williamsburg, VA, USA
*
Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In 1937–38, the American doctoral candidate William R. Bascom conducted anthropological research in the sacred Yorùbá city of Ilé-Ifẹ̀, Nigeria. Bascom’s visit was a decisive moment in the history of African art, as, in 1938, he observed the chance discovery of unique copper and copper alloy heads, two of which he acquired and exported to the USA. Bascom’s actions in 1938, and his subsequent conflicts with British officials who demanded the return of the heads in the 1940s, have become matters of controversy and scholarly debate. Historian Robert Tignor and anthropologist Simon Ottenberg have presented contrasting arguments regarding the affair. This article draws on material from several archives to shed further light on this discussion, resolve remaining areas of dispute, and explore what the study of this controversy tells us about the nature and practice of anthropology, the impacts of Western exhibitions of African art, and early cultural preservation and repatriation efforts of the late colonial period. At a time when colonial-era collecting practices are facing increased critical re-examination, and with intensified calls for the repatriation of Nigerian cultural patrimony in Western museums, this article reflects on how the study of this controversy contributes to present restitution efforts.

Résumé

Résumé

En 1937–1938, le doctorant américain William R. Bascom mena des recherches anthropologiques dans la ville sacrée yorùbá d’Ilé-Ifẹ̀, au Nigeria. La visite de Bascom fut un moment décisif dans l’histoire de l’art africain, car il observa en 1938 la découverte fortuite de têtes uniques en cuivre et en alliage de cuivre, en acheta deux et les exporta aux États-Unis. Les actions de Bascom en 1938 et ses conflits ultérieurs avec les autorités britanniques qui exigèrent le retour des têtes dans les années 1940 sont devenus des sujets de controverse et de débat scientifique. L’historien Robert Tignor et l’anthropologue Simon Ottenberg ont présenté des arguments contrastés sur cette affaire. Cet article s’appuie sur des documents provenant de plusieurs archives pour apporter un éclairage supplémentaire sur cette discussion, résoudre les points de controverse subsistants et explorer ce que l’étude de cette controverse nous dit de la nature et de la pratique de l’anthropologie, de l’impact des expositions occidentales d’art africain et des premiers efforts de préservation culturelle et de rapatriement à la fin de la période coloniale. À une époque où les pratiques de collecte de l’ère coloniale font l’objet d’un réexamen critique croissant et où les appels à rapatrier le patrimoine culturel nigérian dans les musées occidentaux s’intensifient, cet article réfléchit à la manière dont l’étude de cette controverse contribue aux efforts de restitution actuels.

Resumo

Resumo

Em 1937–38, o doutorando americano William R. Bascom efectuou investigação antropológica na cidade sagrada Yorùbá de Ilé-Ifẹ̀, na Nigéria. A visita de Bascom foi um momento decisivo na história da arte africana, uma vez que, em 1938, observou a descoberta fortuita de cabeças únicas em cobre e liga de cobre, duas das quais adquiriu e exportou para os EUA. As acções de Bascom em 1938 e os seus conflitos subsequentes com as autoridades britânicas que exigiram a devolução das cabeças na década de 1940, tornaram-se assuntos de controvérsia e debate académico. O historiador Robert Tignor e o antropólogo Simon Ottenberg apresentaram argumentos contrastantes sobre o caso. Este artigo baseia-se em material de vários arquivos para lançar mais luz sobre esta discussão, resolver áreas de disputa remanescentes e explorar o que o estudo desta controvérsia nos diz sobre a natureza e a prática da antropologia, os impactos das exposições ocidentais de arte africana e os primeiros esforços de preservação e repatriamento cultural do período colonial tardio. Numa altura em que as práticas de colecionismo da era colonial enfrentam uma reavaliação crítica crescente e em que se intensificam os apelos ao repatriamento do património cultural nigeriano nos museus ocidentais, este artigo reflecte sobre a forma como o estudo desta controvérsia contribui para os actuais esforços de restituição.

Type
Debating the Bascom controversy
Information
Africa , Volume 94 , Issue 1 , February 2024 , pp. 186 - 214
Check for updates
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the International African Institute

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Achebe, C. (1978) ‘An image of Africa’, Research in African Literatures 9 (1): 1–15.Google Scholar
Aderemi, A. T. (1937) ‘Notes on the city of Ife’, Nigeria Magazine 12: 3–6.Google Scholar
Appiah, K. A. (2020) ‘The defender of differences: on Franz Boas and his critics’, New York Review of Books 67 (9).Google Scholar
Apter, A. (1993) ‘Atinga revisited: Yoruba witchcraft and the cocoa economy, 1950–1951’ in Comaroff, J. L. and Comaroff, J. (eds), Modernity and Its Malcontents. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Armstrong, R. P., Ames, D., Ames, B., Peek, P. M., Brody, J., Kopytoff, I., Lurie, N. O., Leis, P., Ricks, G. R., Greenberg, J. H., Watrous, B. and Moore, J. (1983) ‘William Bascom: in memoriam’, African Arts 16 (2): 26–93.Google Scholar
Asad, T. (ed.) (1973) Anthropology and the Colonial Encounter. New York NY: Humanities Press.Google Scholar
Bascom, W. R. (1938) ‘Brass portrait heads from Ile-Ife, Nigeria’, Man 38: 176.Google Scholar
Bascom, W. R. (1939) ‘The legacy of an unknown Nigerian “Donatello”’, Illustrated London News 194 (2): 592–4.Google Scholar
Bascom, W. R. (1951) ‘The Yoruba in Cuba’, Nigeria Magazine 37: 14–20.Google Scholar
Basu, P. (2014) ‘A museum for Sierra Leone? Amateur enthusiasms and colonial museum policy in British West Africa’ in Longair, S. and McAleer, J. (eds), Curating Empire: museums and the British imperial experience. Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
Basu, P. and Damodaran, V. (2015) ‘Colonial histories of heritage: legislative migrations and the politics of preservation’, Past and Present 226 (10): 240–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Biro, Y. (2013) ‘African Art, New York, and the avant-garde’, African Arts 46 (2): 88–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blier, S. P. (1988) ‘Melville J. Herskovits and the arts of ancient Dahomey’, RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics 16 (1): 125–42.Google Scholar
Bodenstein, F. (2022) ‘Getting the Benin bronzes back to Nigeria: the art market and the formation of national collections and concepts of heritage in Benin City and Lagos’ in Bodenstein, F., Oţoiu, D. and Troelenberg, E.-M. (eds), Contested Holdings: museum collections in political, epistemic and artistic processes of return. New York NY: Berghahn Books.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Braunholtz, H. J. (1940) ‘Bronze head from Ifé, Nigeria’, British Museum Quarterly 14 (4): 75–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bruchac, M. M. (2014) ‘My sisters will not speak: Boas, Hunt, and the ethnographic silencing of First Nations women’, Curator: The Museum Journal 57 (2): 153–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coombes, A. E. (1994) Reinventing Africa: museums, material culture, and popular imagination in late Victorian and Edwardian England. New Haven CT and London: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Crowther, M. (1982) ‘The outsider and African culture: the case of E. H. Duckworth and Nigeria Magazin e’ in July, R. and Benson, P. (eds), African Culture and Intellectual Leaders and the Development of the New African Nations. New York NY: Rockefeller.Google Scholar
Drake, S. C. (1980) ‘Anthropology and the black experience’, Black Scholar 11 (7): 2–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Duckworth, E. H. (1938a) ‘Recent archaeological discoveries in the ancient city of Ife’, Nigeria Magazine 14: 101–5.Google Scholar
Duckworth, E. H. (1938b) ‘Editorial’, Nigeria Magazine 16: 260–2.Google Scholar
Duckworth, E. H. (1939) ‘Editorial’, Nigeria Magazine 18: 99.Google Scholar
Duckworth, E. H. (1940) ‘Editorial’, Nigeria Magazine 20: 269–70.Google Scholar
Duckworth, E. H. (1951) ‘Ife bronzes’, Nigeria Magazine 37: 20–4.Google Scholar
Evans, T. L. (2023a) ‘A copper alloy head count: contextualising and accounting for the Wúnmọníjẹ̀ compound discoveries of Ilé-Ifẹ̀, Nigeria’, Afrique: Archéologie et Arts 19: 67–100.Google Scholar
Evans, T. L. (2023b) ‘Collecting copper alloy portrait heads: a history of the acquisition and export of the Wúnmọníjẹ̀ heads in late colonial Nigeria’, Journal of the History of Collections, fhad042.Google Scholar
Frobenius, L. (1913) The Voice of Africa: being an account of the travels of the German Inner African Exploration Expedition in the years 1910–1912, vol. 1. London: Hutchinson and Company.Google Scholar
Goucher, C. L., Teilhet, J. H., Wilson, K. R. and Chow, T. J. (1976) ‘Lead isotope studies of metal sources for ancient Nigerian “bronzes”’, Nature 262 (5564): 130–1.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gunsch, K. W. (2013) ‘Art and/or ethnographica?: The reception of Benin works from 1897–1935’, African Arts 46 (4): 22–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harrison, F. V. (ed.) (1991) Decolonizing Anthropology: moving further toward an anthropology for liberation. Washington DC: Association of Black Anthropologists and American Anthropological Association.Google Scholar
Harrison, I. E. and Harrison, F. V. (eds) (1999) African-American Pioneers in Anthropology. Urbana and Chicago IL: University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
Hellman, A. H. (2014) ‘The grounds for museological experiments: developing the colonial museum project in British Nigeria’, Journal of Curatorial Studies 3 (1): 74–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hellman, A. H. (2018) ‘Kenneth C. Murray and the founding of the Nigerian Museum, Lagos’ in Brusius, M. and Singh, K. (eds), Museum Storage and Meaning: tales from the crypt. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hellman, A. H. (2023) The Making of Museums in Nigeria: Kenneth C. Murray and heritage preservation in colonial West Africa. London: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
Heymer, K. (2007) ‘The art of Benin in German-speaking countries: notes on its reception history in the context of avant-garde art, 1910–1930’ in Plankensteiner, B. (ed.), Benin Kings and Rituals: court arts from Nigeria. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum, MVK and ÖTM.Google Scholar
Hicks, D. (2020) The Brutish Museums: the Benin bronzes, colonial violence and cultural restitution. London: Pluto Press.Google Scholar
Hymes, D. H. (ed.) (1972) Reinventing Anthropology. New York NY: Pantheon.Google Scholar
James, W. (1973) ‘The anthropologist as reluctant imperialist’ in Asad, T. (ed.), Anthropology and the Colonial Encounter. New York NY: Humanities Press.Google Scholar
Lundén, S. (2016) ‘Displaying loot: the Benin objects and the British Museum’. PhD thesis, Gothenburg University.Google Scholar
Mackenzie, S., Brodie, N., Yates, D. and Tsirogiannis, C. (2019) Trafficking Culture: new directions in researching the global market in illicit antiquities. Abingdon: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mafeje, A. (1976) ‘The problem of anthropology in historical perspective: an inquiry into the growth of the social sciences’, Canadian Journal of African Studies/La Revue Canadienne des Études Africaines 10 (2): 307–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mafeje, A. (1997) ‘Who are the makers and objects of anthropology? A critical comment on Sally Falk Moore’s “Anthropology and Africa”’, African Sociological Review/Revue Africaine de Sociologie 1 (1): 1–15.Google Scholar
Meyerowitz, H. and Meyerowitz, V. (1939) ‘Bronzes and terra-cottas from Ile-Ife’, Burlington Magazine for Connoisseurs 75 (439): 150–5.Google Scholar
Morton-Williams, P. (1956) ‘The Atinga cult among the south-western Yoruba: a sociological analysis of a witch-finding movement’, Bulletin de l’Institut Français d’Afrique Noire: Série B Sciences Humaines 18: 315–34.Google Scholar
Murray, K. C. (1941) ‘Nigerian bronzes: work from Ife’, Antiquity 15 (57): 71–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nevadomsky, J. and Osemweri, A. (2007) ‘Benin art in the twentieth century’ in Plankensteiner, B. (ed.), Benin Kings and Rituals: court arts from Nigeria. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum, MVK and ÖTM.Google Scholar
Nolte, I., Shear, K. and Yelvington, K. A. (2018) ‘From ethnographic knowledge to anthropological intelligence: an anthropologist in the office of strategic services in Second World War Africa’, History and Anthropology 29 (1): 52–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ntarangwi, M. (2019) ‘African participation in, and perspectives on, the politics of knowledge production in Africanist anthropology’ in Grinker, R. R., Lubkemann, S. C., Steiner, C. B. and Gonçalves, E. (eds), A Companion to the Anthropology of Africa. Hoboken NJ: Wiley.Google Scholar
Nyamnjoh, F. B. (2012) ‘Blinded by sight: divining the future of anthropology in Africa’, Africa Spectrum 47 (2–3): 63–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ochiagha, T. (2023) ‘The return of African antiquities and the ambiguity of the “romantic” colonial: Nigeria Magazine and the Benin and Ife bronzes’, Journal of Colonialism and Colonial History 24 (1).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ogundiran, A. (2020) The Yorùbá: a new history. Bloomington IN: Indiana University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ottenberg, S. (1994) ‘Further light on W. R. Bascom and the Ife bronzes’, Africa 64 (4): 561–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ottenberg, S. (2022) Anthropologists in America Take a First Look at Africa. La Vergne TN: Fulton Books.Google Scholar
Paudrat, J.-L. (2007) ‘Historiographic notes on the presence of the court art of Benin in France and the United States between 1930 and 1945’ in Plankensteiner, B. (ed.), Benin Kings and Rituals: court arts from Nigeria. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum, MVK and ÖTM.Google Scholar
Peraldi, A. (2017) ‘Oba Akenzua II’s restitution requests’, Kunst und Kontext 1: 23–33.Google Scholar
Phillips, B. (2022a) Loot: Britain and the Benin bronzes . Revised and updated edition. London: Oneworld Publications.Google Scholar
Phillips, B. (2022b) ‘Nigerian Ife head: why UK police are holding a priceless sculpture’, BBC News, 26 June <https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-61826273>..>Google Scholar
Plankensteiner, B. (2016) ‘The Benin treasures: difficult legacy and contested heritage’ in Hauser-Schäublin, B. and Prott, L. V. (eds), Cultural Property and Contested Ownership: the trafficking of artefacts and the quest for restitution. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Savoy, B. (2022) Africa’s Struggle for Its Art: history of a postcolonial defeat. Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Schmidt, P. R. and McIntosh, R. J. (eds) (1996) Plundering Africa’s Past. Bloomington IN: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Shaw, T. and MacDonald, K. C. (1995) ‘Out of Africa and out of context’, Antiquity 69 (266): 1036–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shyllon, F. (2017) ‘Benin Dialogue Group: perhaps no longer a dialogue with the deaf; University of Cambridge students to the rescue’, Art, Antiquity and Law 22: 299.Google Scholar
Shyllon, F. (2018) ‘Benin Dialogue Group: Benin Royal Museum – three steps forward, six steps back’, Art, Antiquity and Law 23: 341.Google Scholar
Sogbesan, O. Z. (2015) ‘The potential of digital representation: the changing meaning of the Ife “bronzes” from pre-colonial Ife to the post-colonial digital British Museum’. PhD thesis, City, University of London.Google Scholar
Steiner, C. B. (1994) African Art in Transit. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Stuckey, S. (1976) ‘“I want to be African”: Paul Robeson and the ends of nationalist theory and practice, 1914–1945’, Massachusetts Review 17 (1): 81–138.Google Scholar
Tignor, R. L. (1990) ‘W. R. Bascom and the Ife bronzes’, Africa 60 (3): 425–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Willett, F. (2004) The Art of Ife: a descriptive catalogue and database. CD-ROM. Glasgow: Hunterian Museum and Art Gallery.Google Scholar
Williams, V. J. (1995) ‘Franz Boas and the African American intelligentsia’, Western Journal of Black Studies 19 (2): 81–9.Google Scholar
Willis, W. S. (1972) ‘Skeletons in the anthropological closet’ in Hymes, D. H. (ed.), Reinventing Anthropology. New York NY: Pantheon.Google Scholar