Third-Party Punishment: Retribution

Morris B. Hoffman

doi:10.1017/CBO9781139811873.006

5 - Third-Party Punishment: Retribution

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 May 2014

Morris B. Hoffman

Show author details

Morris B. Hoffman: Affiliation:
University of Colorado Boulder

Book contents

Get access

Summary

God will punish the wicked. And before He does, we will.

John Green

The Punishing Animal

Ask anthropologists to list the things that make us most human – those special triggers of the human spark – and among the usual fare of language, consciousness, and of course the big social brains that make language and consciousness possible, will be an unlikely candidate: third-party punishment. We seem to be the only animal on Earth with a strong urge to punish wrongdoers when their wrongs cause harm to others but not to us.

Let’s go back to that bus stop (or cattle crossing or town square) from the previous chapter, and instead of us getting pushed and knocked over by the wrongdoer, let’s imagine that he pushes another innocent bystander. Through the miracle of empathy, remarkably similar feelings of fight or flight well up inside us, although admittedly not as sharp as when we are the victim. We get that same gnarl in our stomach, that same anxiousness about intervening, that same flash from our amygdalas telling us we are at risk, that same little dash of disgust from our insulas telling us this kind of aggression is intolerable. Just like when we are the victim, those instincts compete against a myriad of other inputs to produce a behavior.We might walk away, we might intervene, or we might pretend we don’t see anything. But an unavoidable part of our decision is the urge we instantly feel to punish the wrongdoer, even though we are not at risk of being injured by him.

Type: Chapter
Information: The Punisher's Brain
The Evolution of Judge and Jury
, pp. 150 - 187

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139811873.006 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2014

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Bingham, Paul M., Human uniqueness: a general theory, Q. Rev. Biol., 74(2), 133–169 (1999)

Flack, J. et al., Social structure, robustness, and policing cost in a cognitively sophisticated species, Am. Natur., 165(5), E126–E139 (May 2005)

Buckholtz, J. & Marois, R., The roots of modern justice: cognitive and neural foundations of social norms and their enforcement, Nature Neurosci., 15(5), 655–661 (2012)

Bendor, J. & Swistak, P., The evolution of norms, Am. J. Soc., 106, 1493–1545 (2001)

Nishida, T. et al., A within-group gang attack on a young adult male chimpanzee: ostracism of an ill-mannered member? Primates, 36(2), 207–211 (1995)

von Rohr, C. et al., Impartial third-party interventions in captive chimpanzees: a reflection of community concern. PLoS ONE 7(3) (2012)

Riedl, K. et al., No third-party punishment in chimpanzees, PNAS, 109(37), 14824–14829 (2012)

Hauser, M. & Marler, P., food-associated calls in rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta), Behav. Ecol., 4(3), 194–205 (1993)

Flack, J. et al., Policing stabilizes construction of social niches in primates, Nature, 493, 426–429 (January 26, 2006)

Reiter, J. et al., Northern elephant seal development: the transition from weaning to nutritional independence, Behav. Ecol. & Sociobiololgy, 3(4), 337–367 (1978)

Clutton-Brock, T. H. et al., The logical stag: adaptive aspects of fighting in red deer (Cervus elaphus L.), Animal Behav. 27(1), 211–225 (1979)

Clutton-Brock, T. H. & Parker, G. A., Punishment in animal societies, Nature, 373, 209–216 (1995)PubMed

Buckholtz, J. et al., The neural correlates of third-party punishment, Neuron, 60(5), 930–940 (2008)

Lancaster, Jane B., Primate Social Behavior and Ostracism, in Gruter, M. & Masters, R. (eds.), Ostracism: A Social and Biological Phenomenon 68 (Elsevier 1986)

Hoffman, M. & Goldsmith, T., The Biological Roots of Punishment, 1 Ohio St. J. Crim. L. 626 (2004)

Mirhady, David C., The Ritual Background of Athenian Ostracism, 11 Ancient Hist. Bull. 13 (1997)

Pettit, George A., Primitive Education in North America, 53 Cal. Publ. in Am. Anthro. 161 (1946)

Barnes, Harry E., The Story of Punishment 50 (2d ed. 1972), quoting Ephraim Emerton, Introduction to the Middle Ages (375–814) 87–90 (Ginn 1891)Google Scholar

Rosenblatt, Albert M., The Law's Evolution: Long Night's Journey into Day, 24 Cardozo L. Rev. 2119, 2127–2128 (2003)

Pirala, J. et al., Lifetime prevalence of psychotic and bipolar-I disorders in a general population, 64 Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 19 (2007)

Cima, M et al., Psychopaths know right from wrong but don't care, Soc. Cogn. & Affective Neurosci., 5(1), 59–67 (2010)

Casey, B. J. et al., The adolescent brain, Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sciences, 1124, 111–126 (2008)PubMed

Baird, A. & Fuselgang, J., The emergence of consequential thought: evidence from neuroscience, in Law and the Brain, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B, 359, 1797–1804 (Zeki, S. & Goodenough, O., eds. 2004)PubMed

Hoffman, Morris B. & Morse, Stephen J., The Insanity Defense Goes Back on Trial, New York Times, July 30, 2006

Morse, Stephen J. & Hoffman, Morris B., The Uneasy Entente between Insanity and Mens Rea: Beyond Clark v. Arizona, 97 J. Crim. L. & Criminology (Northwestern) 1071 (2007)