2 - The lies of the Fall, the tongues of Pentecost: typing and converting the deviant speaker

Summary

By claiming that post-Lateran pastoral texts on the Sins of the Tongue constituted a type of discourse to be reproduced in pastoral speech, I mean to convey several interwoven dimensions of the texts this chapter will explore. As I have established, these texts were produced by a powerful social group within an institution at a historical moment, and they mark out a position of knowledge and authority for the speaker: the priest as preacher, confessor, and all-around catechist. This position involves certain conceptions of the verbal sign and certain categories of analysis, insistently ethical, which together draw the boundaries between the salvific or normative in speech and the destructive or deviant. As they represent speech in sharply defined, value-laden ways, these texts also present a rhetoric which works to persuade the authoritative speaker and, through him, individuals in his cure to adopt these concepts, values, and categories – above all, to adopt the verbal practices dictated by these ways of framing speech. Thus, discourse on the Sins of the Tongue is an instrument of pastoral power as presented by Michel Foucault: it aims to insure the salvation of individuals by imposing on them a “law of truth” which they recognize as valid in their consciences.

THE WORD AS “MESSENGER OF REASON”: AN AUGUSTINIAN SEMIOTIC

Pastoral discourse on the Sins of the Tongue is shaped by the simple fact that its subject involves its medium: words.