Approaches to Comparative Analysis in Archaeology

doi:10.1017/CBO9781139022712.004

Chapter 2 - Approaches to Comparative Analysis in Archaeology

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 07 October 2011

Michael E. Smith and

Peter Peregrine

Edited by

Michael E. Smith

Show author details

Michael E. Smith: Affiliation:
Arizona State University

Book contents

Get access

Summary

Archaeology is inherently comparative. Comparison is necessary to understand the material record, for one cannot identify or understand an object never before seen without comparing it to a known object. Comparison is also necessary to understand variation over time and space, for one cannot identify or investigate variation unless one has examples spanning a range of variation, nor can one examine change without examples spanning a range of time. Comparative analysis is the only way to identify regularities in human behavior, and it is also the only way to identify unique features of human societies. Indeed, to Bruce G. Trigger the comparative nature of archaeological data and analysis places archaeology at the heart of the most important issues in the social sciences:

The most important issue confronting the social sciences is the extent to which human behavior is shaped by factors that operate cross-culturally as opposed to factors that are unique to particular cultures. (Trigger 2003:3)

In this chapter we outline the ways archaeologists have used comparison to understand the material record and to explore variation over time and space. After a brief history of comparative research on ancient societies, we review the variety of approaches used by the authors of this volume using seven dimensions of the comparative method in archaeology.

Type: Chapter
Information: The Comparative Archaeology of Complex Societies , pp. 4 - 20

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139022712.004 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Adams, Robert McC 1966 The Evolution of Urban Society: Early Mesopotamia and Prehispanic MexicoAldineChicagoGoogle Scholar

Allison, Penelope M. 1999 The Archaeology of Household ActivitiesRoutledgeNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Bailey, Geoff N. 2007 Time Perspectives, Palimpsests, and the Archaeology of TimeJournal of Anthropological Archaeology 26 198CrossRef Google Scholar

Bartolini, Stefano 1993 On Time and Comparative ResearchJournal of Theoretical Politics 5 131CrossRef Google Scholar

Blanton, Richard E.Fargher, Lane F. 2008 Collective Action in the Formation of Pre–Modern StatesSpringerNew YorkCrossRef Google Scholar

Blanton, Richard E.Kowalewski, Stephen A.Feinman, Gary M.Finsten, Laura 1993 Ancient Mesoamerica: A Comparison of Change in Three RegionsCambridge University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Briggs, Xavier de Souza 2004 Civilization in Color: The Multicultural City in Three MillenniaCity and Community 3 311CrossRef Google Scholar

Caramani, Daniele 2009 Introduction to the Comparative Method with Boolean Algebra. Quantitative Applications in the Social SciencesSageLos AngelesGoogle Scholar

Childe, V. Gordon 1950 The Urban RevolutionTown Planning Review 21 3CrossRef Google Scholar

Childe, V. Gordon 1951 Social EvolutionMeridian BooksNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Childs, Craig 2007 Phoenix Falling? Will Phoenix Continue to Boom…or Bust Entirely? The Answer May Lie in the Ancient Hohokam City Buried BeneathHigh Country News 37 10Google Scholar

Cutright, Robyn E.López–Hurtado, EnriqueMartin, Alexander J. 2010 Comparative Perspectives on the Archaeology of Coastal South America/Perspectivas comparativas sobre la arqueología de la costa SudamericanaArchaeology, PontificiaPittsburghLima and QuitoGoogle Scholar

Dal Lago, EnricoKatsari, Constantina 2008 Slave Systems, Ancient and ModernCambridge University PressNew YorkCrossRef Google Scholar

Drennan, Robert D.Peterson, Christian E. 2006 Patterned Variation in Prehistoric ChiefdomsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 103 3960CrossRef Google Scholar PubMed

Dunnell, Robert C. 1982 Science, Social Science, and Common Sense: The Agonizing Dilemma of Modern ArchaeologyJournal of Anthropological Research 38 1CrossRef Google Scholar

Earle, Timothy 1997 How Chiefs Come to Power: The Political Economy in PrehistoryStanford University PressStanfordGoogle Scholar

Earle, Timothy 2002 Bronze Age Economics: The Beginnings of Political EconomiesWestview PressBoulder, COGoogle Scholar

Eggan, Fred 1954 Social Anthropology and the Method of Controlled ComparisonAmerican Anthropologist 56 743CrossRef Google Scholar

Ember, Carol R. 2003 Cross-Cultural Research and its Relevance for Archaeological Inferencethe Santa Fe InstituteWorking Group on Language and PrehistorySanta Fe, NMGoogle Scholar

Ember, Carol R.Ember, Melvin 2001 Cross-Cultural Research MethodsAlta MiraWalnut Creek, CAGoogle Scholar

Ember, MelvinEmber, Carol R. 1995 Worldwide Cross-Cultural Studies and Their Relevance for ArchaeologyJournal of Archaeological Research 3 87CrossRef Google Scholar

Feinman, Gary M.Nicholas, Linda M. 2004 Archaeological Perspectives on Political EconomiesUniversity of Utah PressSalt Lake CityGoogle Scholar

Fried, Morton H. 1967 The Evolution of Political Society: An Essay in Political AnthropologyRandom HouseNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Giddens, Anthony 1984 The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of StructurationUniversity of California PressBerkeleyGoogle Scholar

Gingrich, AndreFox, Richard G. 2002 Anthropology, By ComparisonRoutledgeNew YorkCrossRef Google Scholar

Grew, Raymond 1980 The Case for Comparing HistoriesAmerican Historical Review 85 763CrossRef Google Scholar

Hallpike, Christopher R. 1986 The Principles of Social EvolutionClarendon PressOxfordGoogle Scholar

Harris, Marvin 1968 The Rise of Anthropological Theory: A History of Theories of CultureThomas Y. CrowellNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Haupt, Heinz-Gerhard 2001 Comparative HistoryInternational Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences2397PergamonOxfordCrossRef Google Scholar

Hodder, Ian 1986 Reading the Past: Current Approaches to Interpretation in ArchaeologyCambridge University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Holdaway, SimonWandsnider, LuAnn 2008 Time in Archaeology: Time Perspectivism RevisitedUniversity of Utah PressSalt Lake CityGoogle Scholar

Hunt, Robert C. 2007 Beyond Relativism: Comparability in Cultural AnthropologyAltamira PressLanhamGoogle Scholar

Kocka, Jürgen 2003 Comparison and BeyondHistory and Theory 42 39CrossRef Google Scholar

Mace, RuthPagel, Mark 1994 The Comparative Method in AnthropologyCurrent Anthropology 35 549CrossRef Google Scholar

Mahoney, James 2004 Comparative-Historical MethodologyAnnual Review of Sociology 30 81CrossRef Google Scholar

Maisels, Charles Keith 1999 Early Civilizations of the Old World: The Formative Histories of Egypt, the Levant, Mesopotamia, India, and ChinaRoutledgeNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Marcus, JoyceFlannery, Kent V. 1996 Zapotec Civilization: How Urban Society Evolved in Mexico’s Oaxaca ValleyThames and HudsonNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Martin, Paul S.Gregory, David A. 1973 Prehistoric and Contemporary ProblemsThe Archaeology of Arizona: A Study of the Southwest Region361DoubledayGarden CityGoogle Scholar

McNett, Charles W. 1979 The Cross-Cultural Method in ArchaeologyAdvances in Archaeological Method and Theory 2 39Google Scholar

Montelius, Oscar 1888 The Civilisation of Sweden in Heathen TimesMacmillanNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Moreland, John 2006 Archaeology and Texts: Subservience or EnlightenmentAnnual Review of Anthropology 35 135CrossRef Google Scholar

Morgan, Lewis Henry 1878 Ancient SocietyH. HoltNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Morris, IanScheidel, Walter 2009 The Dynamics of Ancient Empires: State Power from Assyria to ByzantiumOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar

Murdock, George P.White, Douglas R. 1969 Standard Cross-Cultural SampleEthnology 9 329CrossRef Google Scholar

Netting, Robert McCWilk, Richard R.Arnould, R. J. 1984 Households: Comparative and Historical Studies of the Domestic GroupUniversity of California PressBerkeleyGoogle Scholar

Nisbet, Robert A. 1969 Social Change and HistoryOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar

O’Brien, Michael J.Lee Lyman, R. 1999 Seriation, Stratigraphy, and Index Fossils: The Backbone of Archaeological DatingKluwerNorwell, MAGoogle Scholar

Odell, George H. 1998 Investigating Correlates of Sedentism and Domestication in Prehistoric North AmericaAmerican Anthropologist 90 335CrossRef Google Scholar

Parsons, Talcott 1966 Societies: Evolutionary and Comparative PerspectivesPrentice HallEnglewood CliffsGoogle Scholar

Pauketat, Timothy R. 2001 Practice and History in Archaeology: An Emerging ParadigmAnthropological Theory 1 73Google Scholar

Peregrine, Peter N. 2001 Outline of Cultural MaterialsHuman Relations Area FilesNew HavenGoogle Scholar

Peregrine, Peter N. 2003 Atlas of Cultural EvolutionWorld Cultures 14 2Google Scholar

Peregrine, Peter N. 2004 Cross-Cultural Approaches in Archaeology: Comparative Ethnology, Comparative Archaeology, and ArchaeoethnologyJournal of Archaeological Research 12 281CrossRef Google Scholar

Pugh, Cedric 2000 Squatter Settlements: Their Sustainability, Architectural Contributions, and Socioeconomic RolesCities 17 325CrossRef Google Scholar

Ragin, Charles C. 1987 The Comparative Method: Moving Beyond Qualitative and Quantitative StrategiesUniversity of California PressBerkeleyGoogle Scholar

Sanders, William T.Price, Barbara J. 1968 Mesoamerica: The Evolution of a CivilizationRandom HouseNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Sanderson, Stephen K. 1990 Social EvolutionismBlackwellOxfordGoogle Scholar

Sanderson, Stephen K. 1999 Social Transformations: A General Theory of Historical DevelopmentRowman and LittlefieldLanham, MDGoogle Scholar

Scheidel, Walter 2009 Rome and China: Comparative Perspectives on Ancient World EmpiresOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Service, Elman R. 1966 Primitive Social OrganizationRandom HouseNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Smelser, Neil J. 1976 Comparative Methods in the Social Sciences. Prentice Hall Methods of Social Science SeriesPrentice HallEnglewood Cliffs, NJGoogle Scholar

Smith, Adam T. 2003 The Political Landscape: Constellations of Authority in Early Complex PolitiesUniversity of California PressBerkeleyGoogle Scholar

Smith, Michael E. 1992 Braudel’s Temporal Rhythms and Chronology Theory in ArchaeologyAnnales, Archaeology, and Ethnohistory23Cambridge University PressNew YorkCrossRef Google Scholar

Smith, Michael E. 1992 Rhythms of Change in Postclassic Central Mexico: Archaeology, Ethnohistory, and the Braudellian ModelAnnales, Archaeology, and Ethnohistory51Cambridge University PressNew YorkCrossRef Google Scholar

Smith, Michael E. 2004 The Archaeology of Ancient State EconomiesAnnual Review of Anthropology 33 73CrossRef

Smith, Michael E. 2006 How Do Archaeologists Compare Early States? Book Review Essay on Bruce Trigger and Adam T. SmithReviews in Anthropology 35 5CrossRef Google Scholar

Smith, Michael E. 2010 Sprawl, Squatters, and Sustainable Cities: Can Archaeological Data Shed Light on Modern Urban IssuesCambridge Archaeological Journal 20 229CrossRef Google Scholar

Spencer, Herbert 1898 Principles of SociologyAppletonNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Storey, Glenn R. 1999 Archaeology and Roman Society: Integrating Textual and Archaeological DataJournal of Archaeological Research 7 203CrossRef Google Scholar

Thomas, Cyrus 1898 Report on Mound Explorations of the Bureau of American EthnologyAnnual Report of the Bureau of American Ethnology 12 3Google Scholar

Tilly, Charles 1984 Big Structures, Large Processes, and Huge ComparisonsRussell Sage FoundationNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Trigger, Bruce G. 1998 Sociocultural Evolution: Calculation and ContingencyBlackwellOxfordGoogle Scholar

Trigger, Bruce G. 2003 Understanding Early Civilizations: A Comparative StudyCambridge University PressNew YorkCrossRef Google Scholar

Trigger, Bruce G. 2006 A History of Archaeological ThoughtCambridge University PressNew YorkCrossRef Google Scholar

Tylor, Edward B. 1871 Primitive CultureJ. MurrayLondonGoogle Scholar

Ward, Kevin 2009 Towards a Relational Comparative Approach to the Study of CitiesProgress in Human Geography 33 1Google Scholar

Webster, Jane 2008 Less Beloved: Roman Archaeology, Slavery, and the Failure to CompareArchaeological Dialogues 15 103CrossRef Google Scholar

Westcoat, James L. 1994 Varieties of Geographic Comparison in the Earth TransformedAnnals of the Association of American Geographers 84 721CrossRef Google Scholar

White, Leslie A. 1959 The Evolution of Culture: The Development of Civilization to the Fall of RomeMcGraw-HillNew YorkGoogle Scholar

Whiting, John W.Ayres, B. 1968 Inferences from the Shape of DwellingsSettlement Archaeology117Yale University PressNew HavenGoogle Scholar

Yengoyan, Aram A. 2006 Modes of Comparison: Theory and PracticeUniversity of Michigan PressAnn ArborCrossRef Google Scholar

Yoffee, Norman 1993 Too Many Chiefs? (or, Safe Texts for the '90sArchaeological Theory: Who Sets the Agenda?60Cambridge University PressNew YorkCrossRef Google Scholar