Book contents
- Approaches and Frameworks for HCI Research
- Approaches and Frameworks for HCI Research
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Preface
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Approaches and Frameworks for HCI Research
- 2 Approaches to HCI Research
- 3 Frameworks for HCI Research
- 4 Innovation Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 5 Art Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 6 Craft Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 7 Applied Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 8 Science Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 9 Engineering Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 10 General Approach and General Framework for HCI Research
- 11 Validating General Approach and General Framework for HCI Research
- 12 Assessing General Framework against Other HCI Frameworks
- 13 Assessing General Framework against HCI Theories
- 14 Methodological Component for General Framework
- 15 Case Studies for General Framework
- 16 Approaches and Frameworks for HCI Research: Lessons Learned and Lessons Remaining
- Postscript
- References
- Index
12 - Assessing General Framework against Other HCI Frameworks
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 24 February 2021
- Approaches and Frameworks for HCI Research
- Approaches and Frameworks for HCI Research
- Copyright page
- Dedication
- Contents
- Preface
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Approaches and Frameworks for HCI Research
- 2 Approaches to HCI Research
- 3 Frameworks for HCI Research
- 4 Innovation Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 5 Art Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 6 Craft Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 7 Applied Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 8 Science Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 9 Engineering Approach and Framework for HCI Research
- 10 General Approach and General Framework for HCI Research
- 11 Validating General Approach and General Framework for HCI Research
- 12 Assessing General Framework against Other HCI Frameworks
- 13 Assessing General Framework against HCI Theories
- 14 Methodological Component for General Framework
- 15 Case Studies for General Framework
- 16 Approaches and Frameworks for HCI Research: Lessons Learned and Lessons Remaining
- Postscript
- References
- Index
Summary
The chapter assesses the General Framework for HCI research for completeness against other frameworks for HCI. The General Framework comprises concepts of discipline, general as common, general problem, particular scope, general research, general knowledge and general practices. These concepts are assessed for completeness against 10 individual other frameworks, which are in turn assessed for completeness against the General Framework. Overall, the General Framework is considered to be complete, although this depends much on the coherence of individual concepts. This assessment, however, does not constitute a validation of the General Framework. It is nevertheless indicative of its comparability with other HCI frameworks with respect to its completeness. The frameworks are further considered as concerns their dissemination in the HCI research literature. Dissemination is understood to include the framework’s disseminators, as well as the dissemination’s content, media and means. The General Framework is then assessed for its accommodation of the factors that appear to influence the success of framework dissemination.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Approaches and Frameworks for HCI Research , pp. 169 - 207Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2021