Journal of Fluid Mechanics, vol. 380 (1999), pp. 1–38
I am indebted to Professor Prosperetti and to Dr Ren for finding a significant error
in my detailed analysis of the temperature and pressure fluctuations in a pulsating
particle. As they point out, the error invalidates the results of that analysis for
the temperature fluctuations in gas bubbles. Those results are withdrawn. The error
also affects, although in a less significant manner, the results for the temperature
fluctuations in pulsating liquid drops with specific heat ratio significantly different
from 1. This includes the droplets chosen to illustrate the results, namely toluene
droplets. However, correct results for both bubbles and droplets may be easily obtained
and this is done here.
The error found by Prosperetti and Ren (see Prosperetti & Ren 2001) exists in both
the internal and external solutions, but because the external fluid is in both cases
a liquid having a very small value of (γf − 1), the error has no effect there. Thus,
fortuitously, the external solution is valid, provided the correct values of the interfacial
temperature and pressure fluctuations are used. In addition, the simple solution
presented in Appendix B, as well as the general expressions for derived quantities,
such as those for the energy dissipation rates and the attenuation coefficients, are
not affected by the error, provided, again, that the values of the temperature and
pressure ratios appearing in them are properly evaluated. This is done below for both
drops and bubbles by complementing the analysis of Appendix B with the polytropic
approximation. The required steps are straightforward.