We design the insurance contract when the insurer faces arson-type risks. We show that the optimal contract must be manipulation-proof. Therefore, it is continuous, has a bounded slope, and satisfies the no-sabotage condition when arson-type actions are free. Any contract that mixes a deductible, coinsurance, and an upper limit is manipulation-proof. A key feature of our models is that we provide a simple, general, and entirely elementary proof of manipulation-proofness that is easily adapted to different settings. We also show that the ability to perform arson-type actions reduces the insured’s welfare as less coverage is offered in equilibrium.