Recent models of impaired awareness in brain injury draw a distinction
between metacognitive knowledge of difficulties and online awareness of
errors (emergent and anticipatory). We examined performance of 31
Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) participants and 31 healthy controls using a
three-strand approach to assessing awareness. Metacognitive knowledge was
assessed with an awareness interview and discrepancy scores on three
questionnaires—Patient Competency Rating Scale, Frontal Systems
Behavioral Scale and the Cognitive Failures Questionnaire. Online Emergent
Awareness was assessed using an online error-monitoring task while
participants performed tasks of sustained attention. Online anticipatory
awareness was examined using prediction performance on two cognitive
tasks. Results indicated that the TBI Low Self-Awareness (SA) group and
High SA group did not differ in terms of severity, chronicity or standard
neuropsychological tasks but those with Low SA were more likely to exhibit
disinhibition, interpersonal problems and more difficulties in total
competency. Sustained attention abilities were associated with both types
of online awareness (emergent and anticipatory). There was a strong
relationship between online emergent and online anticipatory awareness.
Metacognitive knowledge did not correlate with the other two measures.
This study highlights the necessity in adopting a multidimensional
approach to assessing the multifaceted phenomenon of awareness of
deficits. (JINS, 2007, 13, 38–49.)