Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of figures
- List of tables
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Introduction: social comparison processes and levels of analysis
- Part 1 Cognition: comparison processes within and between individuals
- Part 2 Intergroup relations: comparison processes within and between groups
- 5 Predicting comparison choices in intergroup settings: a new look
- 6 The variable impact of upward and downward social comparisons on self-esteem: when the level of analysis matters
- 7 Attitudes toward redistributive social policies: the effects of social comparisons and policy experience
- 8 Social comparison and group-based emotions
- 9 The counter-intuitive effect of relative gratification on intergroup attitudes: ecological validity, moderators and mediators
- 10 Social comparison and the personal group discrimination discrepancy
- Part 3 Culture: comparison processes within and across cultures
- Author index
- Subject index
- References
5 - Predicting comparison choices in intergroup settings: a new look
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 27 October 2009
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of figures
- List of tables
- List of contributors
- Preface
- Introduction: social comparison processes and levels of analysis
- Part 1 Cognition: comparison processes within and between individuals
- Part 2 Intergroup relations: comparison processes within and between groups
- 5 Predicting comparison choices in intergroup settings: a new look
- 6 The variable impact of upward and downward social comparisons on self-esteem: when the level of analysis matters
- 7 Attitudes toward redistributive social policies: the effects of social comparisons and policy experience
- 8 Social comparison and group-based emotions
- 9 The counter-intuitive effect of relative gratification on intergroup attitudes: ecological validity, moderators and mediators
- 10 Social comparison and the personal group discrimination discrepancy
- Part 3 Culture: comparison processes within and across cultures
- Author index
- Subject index
- References
Summary
The question of which comparisons members of social groups make is a fascinating one, not least because a preference or aversion for certain types of comparisons will have a number of important implications. For example, comparison choices may determine whether people perceive existing discrimination, whether they feel deprived, and whether they are satisfied with their own or their group's outcomes. Comparison choices might also affect perceptions of entitlement and they might raise or lower people's aspirations. Not surprisingly, then, comparisons play a central role in several social psychological theories of intergroup relations, such as Social Identity Theory (Tajfel and Turner, 1986) and Relative Deprivation Theory (Runciman, 1966).
In this chapter, we will briefly review some predictions about comparison choices that can be derived from one of the most important theories of intergroup relations, namely Social Identity Theory (SIT). Then, we will discuss some other theories and research which suggest that some additional mechanisms are at play which are neglected in the original SIT conception. Synthesizing the insights from these two sections, the research questions can be summarized in four themes: the effect on comparison choices of (a) comparison motives, (b) status/deprivation relative to a target, (c) structural variables (stability, permeability, and legitimacy), and (d) identification. To address these four themes, we will review some empirical evidence we have obtained from three surveys among members of different ethnic groups and seven studies that used different methodologies and focussed on different intergroup contexts.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Social Comparison and Social PsychologyUnderstanding Cognition, Intergroup Relations, and Culture, pp. 99 - 126Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2005
References
- 4
- Cited by