1 - Is Conservation a Viable Land Usage? Issues Surrounding the Sale of Ivory by Southern African Countries

Summary

THE SYMBOL AND THE REALITY

The African elephant is a potent symbol of and for conservation efforts worldwide. However, the true value of wild animal species must be considered not as abstract symbols, but as essential components of their ecosystems. The elephant has been described as a “superkeystone” species. It is truly the landscape architect of the African bush and many physical and biological aspects of its habitat are dependent on its continued presence.

The argument goes even further. In Africa, animals have formed an integral part of the landscape. The res nullius of Roman Law finds an interesting expression in the law of property as it is applied in most African legal systems. Traditionally, neither land nor animals are capable of private ownership. Colonial systems of government and the laws that came with them changed this. No Eurasian system of land ownership has been successfully applied in Africa, except to the detriment of Africans. Refinements of the Eurasian- or European-influenced status quo probably would not go far enough in addressing questions of intra- and intergenerational equity – deeper reform is needed. Terms like investment and ecotourism have the ugly connotation of new colonialism, because new boundaries are created between the land and its people. Elephants are the gentle giants of the planet. Africa is the antithesis of the gentle giant, but it has the potential to represent a new order of coexistence of myriad cultures. Land represents a more complex emotional theme.