Book contents
Conclusion
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 31 October 2009
Summary
No-one has ever said it better than Gramsci … “you should have pessimism of the intellect and optimism of the will.”
(Chomsky, 1992b: 354)By any criterion Chomsky's achievement is vast. As the guiding spirit of the cognitive revolution, he has been instrumental in changing our view not just of language but of human nature. He has tamed the infinite complexity of language, and in doing so has given us a new appreciation of what we owe to the hand of nature and what we owe to the environment. He has done it through insight, through fanatical hard work and by devoting his efforts to problems rather than mysteries. The problems have come in different forms: some, like I-language, are amenable – when suitably dissected – to theoretical discussion; others, like politics, require not so much a theory as the dispassionate application of common sense in the scrutiny and presentation of the facts. Solving any of them requires dedication.
By contrast, there are mysteries where neither of these techniques appears to work. The creativity of genius, the everyday problem of free will, even the apparently banal Cartesian problem of what causes our particular use of language on given occasions, all seem still to lie beyond the reach of our intellect. Chomsky has had little to say on these areas, where agnosticism is the only rational position to adopt, but even here he has clarified the issues by drawing the relevant distinctions and by proposing a framework for the debate.
In some cases he has also raised the prospect of transferring particular phenomena from the status of “mysteries” to “problems.”
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- ChomskyIdeas and Ideals, pp. 214 - 215Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2004